Transcript Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) March 2000 doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0 Submission Title: [LB2 Results] Date Submitted: [6Mar00] Source: [Ian.

Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission Title: [LB2 Results]
Date Submitted: [6Mar00]
Source: [Ian Gifford] Company [M/A-COM, Inc.]
Address [1011 Pawtucket Boulevard Lowell, MA USA 01853-3295]
Voice:[+1 978 442 4650], FAX: [+1 978 442 5442], E-Mail:[[email protected]]
Re: []
Abstract: [The results of the Letter Ballot #2 held from 23Feb00 to 3Mar00.]
Purpose: [Provide TG1 with a detailed analysis of the LB2.]]
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for
discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this
document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right
to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE
and may be made publicly available by P802.15.
Submission
Slide 1
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
IEEE P802.15 Working Group for
Wireless Personal Area Networks
TG1 LB2 Report
March 2000, Albuquerque, NM
USA
Submission
Slide 2
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Contents
•
•
•
•
LB2 Summary
TG1 Ballot Roadmap
LB2 Background/Flowchart
LB2 Results
– Balloting
– Commenting
• Next Steps
Submission
Slide 3
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
LB2 Summary
• Opened 23Feb00 closed 3Mar00, noon to noon EST
• LB2 MOTION: “Submit the contents of -99/173r5
[99173r5P802-15_TG1-LB1-Comments-ResolutionWorksheet.xls] to the P802.15 WG for approval to
apply the TG1 Comment Resolutions to the current
P802.15.1 Draft Standard.”
• LB2 RESULT: Motion passed with 34/1/2 or 92% (99/173r5a)
• LB2 yielded 20 Reply Comments to be resolved
against –99/173r5a
Submission
Slide 4
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
TG1 Ballot Roadmap
Today
WG Balloting
Sponsor
Balloting
WG Letter
Ballot
#1
Sponsor Plan
WG
LB
#1
TG 1 Actual
Meetings/
Events
1999
8/99
CA
HI
9/99 10/99 11/99
Submission
Sponsor
Ballot
#1
Sponsor
Ballot
#2
IEEE
ETSI?
WG
LB #3
Option
WG
LB
#2
WG
LB
#1
TG 1 Plan
WG Letter
Ballot
#2
WG
LB
#2
IL
12/99
WG
LB
#(3)
NM
2/00
3/00
WA
4/00
5/00
Sponsor
LB
#1
CA
6/00
7/00
TN
8/00
9/00
FL
10/00 11/00
12/00...
2000
Slide 5
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart
Sponsor
IEEE802
Bluetooth
Special Interest Group
WG Chair
Program Management
(PM)
Bluetooth v1.0 A
Bluetooth v1.0 B
Bluetooth v1.1
Bluetooth v1.2?
Advisory Core
P802.15 WG
Software Working Group
Air Interface Working Group
Study Groups
n Working Groups
Task Groups
Committees
IEEE Editorial Working Group
Coexistence Study Group (SG)
High Rate Study Group (HRSG)
WG Chairman
Task Group 1 (TG1)
Marketing Committee (MC)
Sub Task Groups
Managment Entity
LLC Sublayer
MAC Sublayer
PHY Layer
This graphic is provided to indicate the chain of custody for the Specification to
Standard. The v1.0A was submitted 4Nov99, v1.0B was submitted on 1Dec99
And the v1.1 is expected in May00. V1.2 is just a place holder.
Submission
Slide 6
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 1
4Nov99
Draft Standard
Submission
V0.6 (v1.0A)
1Dec99
Draft Standard
Submission
(v1.0B)
Draft Standard
Submission
V0.6
11Nov99
Letter Ballot #1
comments are loaded into the database.
Any Bluetooth comments are also loaded.
Submission
{
23Dec99
*All
27Dec99
4Nov99
Letter Ballot #1
Comment DB
*Letter Ballot 1
Ballot Results &
Comment Prep.
Letter Ballot #1
Comment DB
Slide 7
27Dec99
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 2 (cont.)
27Dec99
Letter Ballot #1
Comment DB
Letter Ballot #1
Comment DB
27Dec99
P802.15 Interim Meeting 10-13Jan00
20Jan00
Bluetooth
Response
-99/173r5a
27Jan00
23Feb00
Letter Ballot #2
{
3Mar00
Submission
Slide 8
P802.15 Interim Meeting 6-10Mar00
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
May00
Submission
23Feb00
Letter Ballot #1
Comment DB
Letter Ballot #2
{
3Mar00
Letter Ballot #2
Comment DB
Letter Ballot #2
Ballot Results &
Comment Prep.
Bluetooth
Response
{
Bluetooth Errata Process
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 3 (cont.)
6Mar00
Letter Ballot #2
Comment DB
P802.15 Interim Meeting 8-12May00
Draft Standard
Submission
(v1.1)
Draft Standard
Submission
updated to V1.0
Slide 9
May00
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
= Resignation prior to the LB #1 Start
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
23Feb00 the P802.15 Working Group
was comprised of 43 voting members:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
Mr. Houman Alborzi
voter
Mr. Dimitri Alexandrou
voter
Mr. Simon Baatz (Simon)
voter
Mr. Edul Batliwala (Edul)
voter
Mr. Alan Bien (Alan)
voter
Dr. Chatschik Bisdikian
voter
Mr. Dave Carlson (Dave)
voter
Mr. Harshal Chhaya (Harshal) voter
Mr. Wm. Caldwell Crosswy
voter
Mr. William Cruz (Bill)
voter
Mr. Richard Ditch (Rich)
voter
Mr. Richard Eckard (Dick)
voter
Mr. Kurt Fischer (Kurt)
voter
Mr. Matthias Frank (Matthias) voter
Mr. Ian Gifford (Ian)
voter
Ms. Nada Golmie (Nada)
voter
Mr. Allen Heberling (Allen)
voter
Mr. Robert Heile (Bob)
voter
Mr. John Paul Jones (John) voter
Dr. Srinivas Kandala
voter
Dr. Parviz Kermani (Parviz) voter
Mr. Stuart Kerry (Stuart)
voter
Submission
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
Slide 10
Mr. Patrick Kinney (Pat)
Mr. Bruce P. Kraemer (Bruce)
Dr. Yunxin Li (Yunxin)
Mr. Daniel R. McGlynn
Mr. Michael D. McInnis (Mike)
Dr. Akira Miura (Akira)
Dr.Thomas Müller (Thomas)
Mr. Peter Murray (Peter)
Mr. Erwin R. Noble (Erwin)
Mr. Mike Paczonay (Mike)
Mr. Arto Palin (Arto)
Dr. Davis Pan (Davis)
Mr. Ivan Reede (Ivan)
Mr. Carlos A. Rios (Carlos)
Mr. Brian E. Roan (Brian)
Mr. Karlheinz Schwarz
Dr. Stephen J. Shellhammer
Mr. Thomas Siep (Tom)
Mr. Nick Stapleton (Nick)
Mr. Steve Torp (Steve)
Dr. Fujio Watanabe (Fujio)
Mr. Todor Cooklev (Todor)
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
Voter
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
23Feb00 the P802.15 Working Group
was comprised of 15 non members:
Nearly Voter
43 Mr. David Cypher (Dave)
44 Mr. Rajesh Jarang (Rajesh)
45 Mr. Kevin Marquess (Kevin)
46 Mr. Richard Wilson (Dick)
Submission
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Aspirant
47 Mr. Richard Alfvin (Rick)
48 Mr. James Allen (Jim)
49 Mr. Thomas Baker (Tom)
50 Dr. Victor Bahl (Vic)
51 Mr. William Bailey (Bill)
52 Mr. Timothy J. Blaney (Tim)
53 Mr. Masaki Hoshina (Masaki)
54 Mr. Gary McCoy (Gary)
55 Mr. Anand R. Prasad (Anand)
56 Mr. Matthew Sherman (Mat)
57 Mr. Hirohisa Wakai (Hirohisa)
Slide 11
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Voter
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
LB2 Results - Overview
• 43 Total Voting Members
• 37 Total Votes (34/1/2)
• 6 Total Failed to vote
YEAS
NEAS
ABSTAINS
Total
FAILED TO VOTE
TOTAL
Submission
34
1
2
37
6
43
Slide 12
92%
3%
5%
100%
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
LB2 Results - Detail
NO
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
Last name
Alborzi
Alexandrou
Baatz
Batliwala
Bien
Bisdikian
Chhaya
Cooklev
Crosswy
Ditch
Eckard
Fischer
Frank
Gifford
Golmie
Heberling
Heile
Jones
Kerry
Kinney
Kraemer
Li
Submission
First name
Mr. Houman (Houman)
Mr. Dimitri (Dimitri)
Mr. Simon (Simon)
Mr. Edul (Edul)
Mr. Alan (Alan)
Dr. Chatschik (Chatschik)
Mr. Harshal (Harshal)
Mr. Todor (Todor)
Mr. Wm. Caldwell (Caldwell)
Mr. Richard (Rich)
Mr. Richard (Dick)
Mr. Kurt (Kurt)
Mr. Matthias (Matthias)
Mr. Ian (Ian)
Ms. Nada (Nada)
Mr. Allen (Allen)
Mr. Robert (Bob)
Mr. John Paul (John)
Mr. Stuart (Stuart)
Mr. Patrick (Pat)
Mr. Bruce P. (Bruce)
Dr. Yunxin (Yunxin)
status
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
Slide 13
LB2
y
y
y
y
a
y/c
y
y
f
y
y
y
y
y
n
y/c
y
f
y
y
y
y
Yea
1
1
1
1
Yea w/c
Nea
Abs
Fail
Total
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
LB2 Results - Detail
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
McGlynn
McInnis
Miura
Mueller
Murray
Noble
Paczonay
Palin
Pan
Reede
Rios
Roan
Schwarz
Shellhammer
Siep
Stapleton
Torp
Watanabe
41 Carlson
42 Kandala
43 Kermani
Mr. Daniel R. (Dan)
Mr. Michael D. (Mike)
Dr. Akira (Akira)
Mr. Thomas (Tom)
Mr. Peter (Peter)
Mr. Erwin R. (Erwin)
Mr. Mike (Mike)
Mr. Arto (Arto)
Dr. Davis (Davis)
Mr. Ivan (Ivan)
Mr. Carlos A. (Carlos)
Mr. Brian E. (Brian)
Mr. Karlheinz (Karlheinz)
Dr. Stephen J. (Steve)
Mr. Thomas (Tom)
Mr. Nick (Nick)
Mr. Steve (Steve)
Dr. Fujio (Fujio)
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
voter
y
y
y
y
a
y
y
y/c
y
y
y
y
f
y
y
y
y
y/c
Mr. Dave Carlson (Dave)
Dr. Srinivas Kandala (Srinivas)
Dr. Parviz Kermani (Parviz)
voter
voter
voter
f
f
f
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
30
Submission
Slide 14
a = Abstain
n = Do Not Approve (Negative)
y = Approve (Affirmative)
/c = with Comments
w/o = with out Comments
y = failed to respond
Red = dropped from Membership
4
1
2
1
1
1
6
43
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
IEEE P802.15 Working Group for
Wireless Personal Area Networks
Sponsor Balloting Pool Status
Submission
Slide 15
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Sponsor Balloting Pool
as of 16Feb00
WG Membership
• 43 Voting
• 7 Nearly Voting
• 16 Aspirant
DATE
COUNT
15-Dec-99
38
6-Jan-00
48
16-Feb-00
54
P802.11
?
66
LAN/MAN
802.15
54?
P802.16
?
?
1579+9
?
Submission
Slide 16
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Sponsor Balloting Pool
as of 16Feb00 (cont.)
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Last Name
Aihara
Alborzi
Alspaugh
Andersson
Bell
Belvin
Bisdikian
Boer
Carter
Crosswy
Currivan
Ecclesine
Fischer
Fischer
Freedman
Gaucher
Gifford
Gilb
Godfrey
Harrison
Heberling
Heile
Hermann
Izadpanah
Kardach
Kerry
Khanna
Submission
FirstName
Toru
Houman
Matthew D
Daniel
Ernest
Stephen E
Chatschik
Jan
James S
William C
Bruce J
Peter
Kurt B
Michael A
Avraham
Brian P
Ian C
James P
Tim
Simon
Allen
Robert
Reto J
Hossein
Jim
Stuart J
Amarpal S
Phone
81-46-273-4905
301-405-7027
303-583-5255
46703242783
44-1442-438025
727-302-2296
914-784-7439
31-30-6097483
919-543-2436
281-514-2774
949-585-5460
408-527-0815
925-280-7779
210-614-4096
972-3-6959552
914-945-2596
978-442-4650
480-413-8421
913-897-0908
44-1753-661421
716-588-1939
617-873-4835
41-1-724-8479
310-317-5563
408-765-4469
408-267-4680
408-970-3108
EMailAlias
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
Slide 17
COMPANY
?
University of Maryland
SpectraLink
Celsius Test Systems AB
3Com Corporation
Raytheon
IBM Research
Lucent
IBM Corp
Compaq
Broadcom
CISCO Systems
Hyper Corp.
Intersil Corp.
InnoWave-ECI Ltd.
IBM TJ Watson Research
M/A-COM, Inc.
Motorola
Choice Microsystems
Madge
Eastman Kodak
GTE
IBM Research
HRL Laboratories
Intel
Consultant
Agilent Technologies
Voter
1
1
1
1
1
1
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Sponsor Balloting Pool
as of 16Feb00 (cont.)
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
Kiernam
Kinney
Langston
Marks
McInnis
Noble
O'Hara
Orzol
Paine
Pandanda
Park
Petry
Ralston
Rautenberg
Rohner
Roy
Sanders
Schott
Sherman
Shimura
Solomon
Srinivas
Thomas
Turner
Tzerefos
Valcourt
Zhang
Brian G
Patrick W
J Leland
Roger B
Michael D
Erwin
Robert
Roman
Richard H
Roger
Yunsang
Brian D
Margarete A
Peter
Christian
Jaideep
Ray W
Wolfgang
Matthew J
Akihiro
David
Kandala
Nicholas A
Edward
Polychronis D
Scott A
Wei
610-878-5637
319-369-3593
972-344-0795
(303) 497-3037
425-865-2840
281-719-1955
408-986-9596
856-222 7467
425-865-4921
619-839-3942
301-548-1291
858-674-8533
408-988-1112x117
49-2166-27-2778
41-1724-8703
973-793-5823
310-476-5063
41-1-724-8476
973-236-6925
81-44-798-7579
914-731-2259
360-817-7512
801-320-7533
44-1442-438586
44-411-265-793
603-862-4489
301-975-3443
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
InterDigital Comm Corp.
Intermec Inc.
Raytheon
NIST
Boeing
Telxon Corp.
Informed Technology, Inc.
Oki Data
Boeing
MCS Corp.
Hughes Network Sytems
3Com Corporation
Wytec Inc.
Alcatel Cabling Systems
IBM Research
Bear Sterns & Co.
CircuitPath
IBM Research Div.
AT&T
Canon
Fujitsu Network Communications
Sharp
3Com Corporation
3Com Corporation
University of Sheffield
University of New Hampshire
NIST
1
1
1
1
10
Submission
Slide 18
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Sponsor Balloting Pool
Planning Schedule - Overview
Preliminary Balloting Pool
(3 Months)
Sponsor Balloting Group
Working Group
LB1
43D
LB2
10D
Mar00
LB(3)
40D
May00
2000
•Invitation
•Balance
•Form Balloting Group
Jul00
2001
The LAN/MAN 802.15 Balloting Pool needs to filled before the
May00 Interim Meeting. We need to send requests to join in Mar00.
Submission
Slide 19
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Sponsor Balloting Pool
Planning Schedule - Detail
Submission
Slide 20
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Next Steps
• More Request to join via e-mails?
• The MC will craft a generic letter to help
promote and explain the Balloting Pool 00/056r0
• Contact?
– 802 Secretary to advertise
– P802.11, .16 Chairs to advertise
– Liaison Mailing List
• New Link on .15 Web Site?
• Other?
Submission
Slide 21
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.