Section 3.0 - Structural Design
Download
Report
Transcript Section 3.0 - Structural Design
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
3. Structural Design and Analysis
Martin Nordby
[email protected]
25 March 2003
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-1
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
3. LAT Structural Analysis (40 charts/75 min)
•
•
•
•
Introduction
– Structural block diagram
– LAT internal design changes since Delta PDR
– Interface design changes since Delta PDR
Design trade analyses performed and results
Structural analysis overview
Structural analysis modeling
– Requirements and compliance
– Analysis parameters and load case definitions
•
•
•
•
FEA model spec’s
Results are interface loads
Analysis update
– Modal analysis
– Static-equivalent analyses
– Failure analyses
Results and flow down (6 charts)
– Interface loads
– Environmental Spec. summary
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-2
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
LAT Structural Schematic Diagram
ACD
Structural
EMI/Grounding
Accommodation
Direction of arrow signifies
direction of reliance, or structural
support
TKR
Grid Base Ass’y
Rad
Mnt
Bkt
Radiator
EMI Skirt
Electronics
X-LAT Plate
Spacecraft
Htr Sw
Box
Radiator
Solar
Array
CAL
EMI Skirt
Htr Sw
Box
Rad
Mnt
Bkt
Solar
Array
LV Payload Attach Fitting
LAT Structural Schematic Diagram
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-3
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Internal Structural Design Changes Since Delta-PDR
•
•
•
•
Stiffened TKR flexure connection to Grid
– This was part of TKR bottom tray re-design
– Effect was to increase TKR first-mode natural frequency
Updated ACD model to reflect mass increase
– Added tile mass and BEA stiffness
Tuned Grid Wing and bottom flange designs
– Modified Grid Wing design to attenuate high local loads around SC mount
– Added full bottom flange around Grid perimeter to react localized loads
Moved Electronics Box structural mount to CAL back plate
– Boxes now hard-mounted to CAL plate by way of moment-bearing stand-offs
– Cleaner structural design simplifies analysis and test plans for CAL and Electronics
groups
– Forces on X-LAT Plate are reduced to just inertial loads of the plate
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-4
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
LAT Structural Interface Design Changes Since Delta-PDR
•
•
•
Increased Radiator area to 2.78 m2 and finalized dimensions
– Modified Radiator aspect ratio at request of Spectrum
– Agreed on final width, based on reduction in spacing between Radiators
– Agreed on final height, based on final positioning of LAT and PAF stay-clear agreements
with Boeing
Finalized Radiator mount location to SC
– Moved mount location down at request of Spectrum
– This reduced Radiator first-mode natural frequency, but margin to 50 Hz requirements is
still large
Modified LAT-SC mount region
– Bolt-on Wing accommodates interface bracket to accept Spectrum’s flexure
– This reduces local stress concentrations in the Grid, while improving integration access
for Spectrum
– Design is still in work—not yet finalized
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-5
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Trade Studies Since Delta PDR
•
•
•
Moved Electronics Box structural mount to CAL back plate
– Boxes now hard-mounted to CAL plate by way of moment-bearing stand-offs
– Cleaner structural design simplifies analysis and test plans for CAL and Electronics
groups
– Forces on X-LAT Plate are reduced to just inertial loads of the plate
Radiator panel top profile
– Modified panel to a stepped top profile
– Radiator area is maximized, while providing good access volume under the ACD
Acoustic test configuration
– Investigated acoustic testing without Radiators, to reduce complexity of STE and
potential risk to Radiators
– Decided to keep baseline test configuration as-is: with Radiators integrated. This
assures that coupling of acoustic energy into Grid is adequately tested
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-6
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Current State of Structural Model
•
•
LAT structural model moved to NASTRAN
– Changed FEA software from ANSYS to
NASTRAN to make it more compatible
with GLAST project office
– Re-built model to improve dynamic
analysis capabilities
– Model is used to generate system
structural response and interface limit
loads
Subsystem models updated
– New TKR model from Hytec—including
bottom tray and flexure design
modifications
– Updated ACD model from GSFC—with
new mass baseline
– Incorporated reduced CAL model from
NRL
– New Radiator model from LM—
including size and mount point
modifications
– Re-built electronics—new model based
on current E-Box and interface designs
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
LAT Finite Element Model
3-7
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Driving Structural Requirements
Parameter
LAT Configuration
LAT mass allocation
Structural, Loads
Fixed-base first-mode
TKR alignment during normal LAT operation
Capable of exposure to static-equivalent launch
loads
Capable of exposure to sinusoidal vibration
launch loads
Capable of exposure to acoustic launch loads
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
Requirement
Design
Margin
Comply
Ver.
Method
< 3000 kg
2679.4 kg
320.6 kg
Y
M
Y
T
Y
T, A
OK
Y
T, A
OK
Y
T
OK
P
T
> 50 Hz
56.4 Hz
6.4 Hz
< 7arc-sec 1s 4.1 arc-sec peak2.9 arc-sec + 5s
to-peak
radial
3-8
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
LAT FEA Model Boundary Conditions
•
•
•
Accelerations
– Used LAT center-of-mass accelerations
from LAT Environmental Spec. for
structural load cases
SC mounting
– X-Side SC mount: LAT restrained in the
Y- and Z-directions
– Y-Side SC mount: LAT restrained in the
X- and Z-directions
Radiator mounting
– Radiators mounted to Grid through
Radiator Mount Bracket beams
– SC boundary condition fixed in Ydirection (out-of-plane) only
Model Feature
Nodes
Total elements
Point elements
Shell elements
Beam elements
Number
56,458
64,091
448
47,819
15,160
LAT F.E.A. Model Metrics
LAT
Design
Unit
Lift-Off/
Launch Event
MECO
Airloads
Lateral
5.1
0.2
g
Axial (Z)
+4.1/-1.4 +6.8
g
LAT Static-Equivalent Design Accelerations
Source: LAT-SS-00778-01 “LAT Environmental
Specification,” March 2003
Subsystem
TKR
CAL
ACD
Radiators
Grid Box
Elec. Boxes
Total
LAT F.E.A.
Mass
Center of
(kg)
Gravity (m)
520.1
261.85
1375
-138.55
268
348.00
71.67
-1034.30
250.3
-231.00
199.6
-348.25
2685
-60.53
Current LAT Est.
Mass
Center of
(kg)
Gravity (m)
505
230.0
1376
-148.8
270
318.2
77
-1368.6
253
-218.0
199
-352.9
2679
-86.9
LAT F.E.A. Properties and Current LAT Estimates
Source: LAT-TD-00564-06 “LAT Mass Status Report, Mass Estimates for
Mar 2003,” 7 Mar 2003
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-9
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Structural Analysis Load Cases and Runs
•
•
•
Modal analysis
– Mode shape analysis of full model, supported with radially-compliant interface
– Includes analysis of any/all modes of subsystems, and coupling between subsystem and
LAT natural frequencies
Structural analysis methodology
– Analyzed 1g static-equivalent acceleration loading along X, Y, Z axes
– Combined results by linear super-position to produce LAT load cases
– Post-processed results to yield predicted loads and pre-loads at interface joints
– No dynamic analyses were performed C.L.A. provides this
Structural analysis runs
– Deflection
•
•
•
–
Thermal-mechanical
•
•
–
LAT distortions extracted from analysis results
Relative motions and deflections gleaned from results
These are for static-equivalent loading, only (no dynamic deflections)
LAT distortion due to transient changes to the LAT Control Temp
Transient thermo-mechanical analysis only
Interface Loads
•
Subsystem interface loads extracted from results
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-10
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Structural Load Case Definitions
Load Case
X
Y
Launch
Modal on SC Mount
Lift-Off/Airloads 1
+5.1g
0g
Lift-Off/Airloads 2
0g
+5.1g
Lift-Off/Airloads 3
+3.6 g
+3.6 g
MECO
+0.2 g
0g
Integration
Integration 1
0g
0g
Integration 2
+1 g
0g
Integration 3
0g
0g
Integration 4
0g
0g
Integration 5
+1 g
0g
Thermal
Cold Survival Soak -20C TKR, Grid, CAL
-60C Radiators
Hot Survival Soak +30C TKR, CAL, Grid
+20C Radiators
Thermal Transient +/- 3C/95 min period
Z (Thrust)
+4.1g
+4.1g
+4.1 g
+6.8g
+1 g
0g
-1 g
-1 g
0g
Comments
Supports fixed in Z and hoop, free radially
LAT is +X/-X symmetric
LAT is +Y/-Y symmetric
Diagonal lateral acceleration
Corner supports, in Integration Stand
Corner supports, rotated 90 deg in Int Stand
Corner supports, upside down in Int Stand
3-pt mid-side support, in Int Stand
3-pt mid-side support, rotated 90 deg in Int Stand
-40C ACD
Cold survival soak. Temp's imposed on
structural model
+TBD C ACD Hot survival soak. Temp's imposed on
structural model
Thermal stability of LAT
LAT Structural Analysis Load Cases
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-11
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Modal Analysis Results
•
•
10 modes below 75 Hz
– 1 significant LAT modes
– Multiple ACD panel, BEA vibration modes
– Multiple Radiator modes and mode combinations
LAT drumhead mode
– 65.9 Hz at 2679 kg estimate
– 63 Hz at 3000 kg allocation
Parameter
Req Design Margin Comply
LAT natural frequency > 50 Hz 56.4 Hz 6.4 Hz
Y
#
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Freq.
56.4
58.8
60.6
62.3
64.1
65.9
67.2
67.4
68.7
73.8
Effective Mass Fraction
9.4% UX, 5.4% UY
1% UZ
6.6% UX, 9.8% UY
0.1% UY
.16% UY
42% UZ, 26% RX, 26% RY
0.1% RZ
0.6% RX
0.2% UY
1% UX, 3% RY
Mode Description
ACD lateral mode
ACD mode
LAT lateral mode at 45 degrees
-Y side Radiator out-of-plane mode
+Y side Radiator out-of-plane mode
LAT drumhead mode
ACD anti-symmetric mode
-Y side Radiator asymmetric mode
+Y side Radiator asymmetric mode
X-axis LAT rocking mode
LAT Drumhead Mode
First 10 LAT Modes
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-12
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Deflections Due to Launch Loads
•
Grid Deflection
– 6.8 g thrust load at MECO
produces maximum Grid bowing
– Grid deflections
•
•
-0.41 mm at the center of the Grid
-0.09 mm at corner of the Grid
LAT Deflected Shape Plot
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-13
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
TKR Interface Load Recovery
•
•
TKR Flexure joint
– Flexures isolate the carbon-fiber TKR structure from thermal strains of the Grid
– All flexure normals point to the center of a TKR module
– The 8 flexures are not a kinematic mount
TKR Flexure force recovery
– Nodal forces are retrieved by isolating nodal forces at the TKR Flexure beam elements
– All forces are expressed in local cylindrical coordinates, with the module centerline the z
axis
– Shear forces in theta-increasing
direction have the same sign.
TKR-Grid Flexures
Design
Accept
Qual Unit
Lift-Off/
Shear forces sum to zero.
Launch Event
MECO
Transonic
– Design limit loads are the maxima
Mid-Side Flexures
of the TKR module loads
•
•
Limit loads identified for peak
compressive, tensile, and shear load
Peak loads all occur in corner bays
Shear
Tension/Compress.
Corner Flexures
Shear
Tension/Compress.
Source
2266
391
2061
291
2266
391
2832.5
489
N
N
1,003
1,277
(2)
80
1,193
(4)
1,003
1,277
1,254
1,596
N
N
Flexure Limit Loads
Delta PDR Analysis Model
Source: LAT-SS-00778-01 “LAT Environmental Specification,” March 2003
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-14
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
CAL Interface Load Recovery
•
•
CAL-Grid tab joint
– 1152 bolts (72 per CAL module)
– Joint allows CAL bottom plate to stiffen LAT by closing out bottom side of Grid
Load recovery
– Interface loads are backed out from the FEA model by resolving nodal forces at the
interface into shear and normal loads at the bolt locations
– New NASTRAN model will allow these interface loads to be pulled directly from beam
elements forces and moments
CAL
Tabs
F(x)
F(y)
F(z)
M(x)
M(y)
M(z)
Source
Scale
Notes:
Design Load Cases
Acceptance Test
Qualification Test
LC1 LC2 LC3 LC1 LC2 LC3 LC1 LC2 LC3
4373 1140 -3302 4373 1140 -3302 5467 1424 -4128
206 2994 1414
206 2994 1414
258 3742 1767
-195
-11
654 -195
-11
654 -244
-14
817
1.39 -0.05 -6.09 1.39 -0.05 -6.09 1.74 -0.06 -7.61
0.45 -1.28 0.22 0.45 -1.28 0.22 0.56 -1.60 0.27
20.98 4.58 -14.86 20.98 4.58 -14.86 26.22 5.73 -18.57
(6)
(6)
(6)
1
1
1
1.25 1.25 1.25
Unit Comments
N Across tab in plane of plate
N Along tab
N Out of plane of plate
N-m Around x-axis
N-m Around y-axis
N-m Around z-axis
Interface loads are for CAL tab thickness of 7 mm
Tab Limit Loads
Delta PDR Analysis Model
Source: LAT-SS-00778-01 “LAT Environmental Specification,” March 2003
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-15
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
ACD Interface Load Recovery
•
•
ACD Base Electronics Assembly (BEA) to Grid Joint
– Bolted connection at 4 corners of BEA carry z-direction (thrust) loads only
– Bolted and pinned connections at the center of each of the 4 sides
Interface load recovery
– Interface loads evaluated by retrieving nodal forces at rigid extension from Grid to BEA
– Loads shown are the maximum of predicts from ACD subsystem and LAT level analysis
ACD-Grid Mount
Corner Mounts
Shear
Tens/Compression
Mid-Side Mounts
Shear
Tens/Compression
Source
Design
Accept.
PFQ
Unit Comment
0
1787
0
1787
0
2234
N
N
RSS of X, Y max shear
Parallel to LAT Z-axis
4402
2223
4402
2223
5503
2779
N
N
RSS of X, Z shears in plane of Grid wall
Normal to Grid wall
ACD Limit Loads
Delta PDR Analysis Model
Source: LAT-SS-00778-01 “LAT Environmental Specification,” March 2003
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-16
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Electronics Interface Load Recovery
•
•
Electronics Box to CAL Joint
– Rigid stand-offs carry z-direction (thrust) loads, and lateral loads and moments
Interface load/deflection recovery
– Loads shown are based on trade study analysis of Electronics box loads through standoff
– CDR model will be used to update limit loads for this joint
E-Box Stand-Off
Tension
Compression
Shear
Bending Moment
Design Accept. Qual Unit
3,750
3,750 4,688 N
2,625
2,625 3,281 N
1,288
1,288 1,609 N
19.3
19.3
24.1 N-m
Electronic Box Limit Loads
Delta PDR Analysis Model
Source: LAT-SS-00778-01 “LAT Environmental Specification,” March 2003
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-17
GLAST LAT Project
Mechanical Design Integration Peer Review, March 2003
Summary and Further Work
•
•
Summary
– Subsystem structural models have been updated to reflect Peer Review designs
– First look at mode shapes and frequency show that the LAT has margin with respect to
its frequency requirement
– Structural model re-work is still in process
Further Work
– Verify subsystem model integration
– Complete all load cases with LAT CDR model
– Update subsystem interface loads, based on CDR model
– Deliver model to GLAST PO for next CLA cycle
– Incorporate acoustic analysis results into limit load analyses
– Revise “LAT Environmental Specification” with these results
– Start pre-test analysis runs
•
•
Dynamic analyses to size accelerometers
STE structural analyses
LAT-PR-01278 Section 3
3-18