Transcript NSF example scorecard

Judging Criteria
Presenter:
First Last Name
ERC Name, Project Title, 3-Level Diagram
Thrust
University:
Degree Program:
Advisor:
Date:
December xx, 2011
Problem
Statement
Expertise
Broader
Impact
Slide Design
Poise/Style
1
Did not clearly explain the
problem
Unfamiliar with the
information
Did not discuss benefits of
the technology
Content is unorganized and
difficult to digest
Lacks confidence and
enthusiasm
2
Problem explained, but no
connection to applications
Uncomfortable with the
information
Benefits described, but no fit
into ERC mission
Information takes some work
to extract
Mildly uncomfortable with
audience
3
Problem and connection to
application explained
Knowledgeable about the
subject
Benefits and fit into ERC
mission discussed
Information is complete and
well organized
Makes eye contact and
engages audience
4
Clearly described the
problem and application
Exhibits full knowledge of
the subject matter
Clearly explained benefits
and fit in ERC of work
Information clearly and
concisely presented
Feels comfortable and
engaging
Total
Points:
Comments
Strengths
Suggestions
Score