Limits to Aerosol Indirect Effects in marine low clouds Robert Wood, Atmospheric Sciences, University of Washington.
Download ReportTranscript Limits to Aerosol Indirect Effects in marine low clouds Robert Wood, Atmospheric Sciences, University of Washington.
Limits to Aerosol Indirect Effects in marine low clouds
Robert Wood, Atmospheric Sciences, University of Washington
Motivation
• Aerosols can potentially influence earth’s radiation budget both by direct interaction with sunlight (aerosol direct effect), and also by altering cloud radiative properties (aerosol indirect effects, AIEs) • Conceptually, it is useful to divide AIEs into two types: – primary or
quasi-instantaneous
dispersion effect); effects (e.g. Twomey effect, – effects that require an understanding of the system
feedbacks
on timescales comparable to or longer than the cloud element lifetime.
IPCC, 2007
Theoretical expression for AIE
• Response of cloud optical thickness t aerosol characteristic property A to change in some
primary feedback
• Generally, because AIEs must be dominated by warm clouds and ice clouds formed by homogeneous freezing, the property most relevant to the problem is the cloud condensation nucleus concentration (CCN).
• Aerosol size and composition effects can also play a role
Twomey’s hypothesis
• Increases in the number of aerosol particles will lead to increases in the concentration N droplets d of cloud • For a given LWC, greater N d implies smaller droplets ( since droplet radius r {LWC/N d } 1/3 ) • Greater N
N
d d
r
2 h, so t total surface area will increase (
N
d 1/3
h
5/3 ) and clouds reflect more t solar radiation • d(ln t )/d(lnN d ) = 1/3
Albrecht’s hypothesis (1989)
• A greater concentration of smaller drops (Twomey) suppresses precipitation because the coalescence efficiency of cloud droplets increases strongly with droplet size.
• Reduced precipitation leads to increased cloud thickness, liquid water content, coverage more reflective clouds
N
d [cm -3 ] from Wood (2005)
Twomey Albrecht
Significant aerosol-climate effects (IPCC 2007)
Model estimates of the two major aerosol indirect effects (AIEs)
• Pincus and Baker (1994) – 1 st and 2 nd AIEs comparable • GCMs (Lohmann and Feichter 2005) 1 st AIE: -0.5 to -1.9 W m -2 2 nd AIE: -0.3 to -1.4 W m -2
Limited investigation of factors that control the relative importance of the two AIEs
Shiptrack surprises!
3.7 m • Liquid water content in shiptracks is typically
reduced
compared with surrounding cloud • Clear refutation of Albrecht’s hypothesis courtesy Jim Coakley, see Coakley and Walsh (2002)
Drizzle suppression in shiptracks
• Drizzle is frequently found to be suppressed in shiptracks • So what’s wrong with Albrecht’s hypothesis?
cloud drizzle Ferek et al. 2000
LES results
• Impact of aerosols simulated by varying N
d
• Increased N
d
precipitation Reduced increased TKE increased entrainment w e • Changes in w e can sometimes result in cloud thinning (reduced LWP) • Also noted by Jiang et al. (2002)
Ackerman et al. (2004)
LWP [g m -2 ]
P
0 [mm d -1 ]
w
e [cm s -1 ] Cloud droplet concentration [cm -3 ]
Precipitation reduces TKE
Mixed layer model (MLM) approach
• Mixed layer model (Lilly 1968) – convective-radiative framework for understanding stratiform boundary layer clouds and their dependence upon meteorological forcings from Stevens et al. (2003)
Mixed layer model
• LW/SW radiation and bulk surface flux (LHF/SHF) parameterizations • Entrainment closure (Turton and Nicholls 1986) • Precipitation: For standard runs use formulation derived from shipborne radar observations in SE Pacific stratocumulus (Comstock et al. 2004). – cloud base precipitation P CB h 3.5
/N d 1.75
– treatment of evaporation below cloud to give surface precipitation
Indirect effect ratio
R
IE
1st AIE 2nd AIE For adiabatic cloud layers , t
N
d 1/3
LWP
5/6 Define
R
IE = 2 nd AIE / 1 st AIE Relative strength of the Albrecht effect compared with Twomey
Suite of simulations
see Wood (2007), J. Atmos. Sci., 64, 2657-2669.
• Surface divergence [10 -6 s -1 ]: { 2, 3, 4 } • Sea Surface Temp. [K]: { 288, 292, 296 } • Moisture above MBL [g kg -1 ]: { 1, 3, 6 } • 700 hPa potential temperature set to 312 K • No advective terms • MLM is run to equilibrium twice: – (control)
N
d =N d,control – (perturb)
N
d =1.05
N
d,control • R IE is calculated – examine dependence of R IE forcings and parameterizations upon
Base case, N
d,control
=100 cm
-3
• For most forcing conditions 2 nd AIE > 1 st AIE • R IE scales with surface precipitation in the control • Little dependence of scaling upon forcing conditions
Base case, N
d,control
=200 cm
-3
• Lower values of R IE because surface precip. is lower • Same R IE scaling with surface precip
Different drizzle parameterizations
BASE (Comstock) VanZanten et al. (2005)
Fixed entrainment
• Only surface moisture/energy budget important (Albrecht effect) • Entrainment important in determining the nature of the feedback response
Non-equilibrium response
• Timescale for 2 nd AIE is long – due to long z i adjustment timescale • On short timescales R IE can be
negative
(noted in Ackerman, 2004) • Important to understand timescales of aerosol evolution
Timescales
But what is the timescale t
N
for evolution of N d ?
t
N
=N d {dN d /dt} -1 – Coalescence scavenging (removal of CCN by coalescence of cloud/drizzle drops): t
N
(cloudbase precip rate) -1 ≈ 0.5-1 days • Advection timescale – typically 1-2 days
short timescales short timescales long timescales
Timescales
Short timescale cloud response
• Cloud base height determined by a balance between surface precipitation moistening (P) and entrainment drying (E) • Derive expression for cloud thickness change dh/dt ≈ - dz
CB
/dt using moisture and energy budgets for MBL is relative importance of entrainment drying compared with surface precipitation moistening
What determines
?
• Ackerman showed RH FT important • But
cloudbase height
dominates over wider range of phase space
Annual mean LCL 400-600 m over much of the subtropical and tropical oceans
cancellation of aerosol indirect effects?
SEP stratocumulus in GCMs
Poor representation of the vertical structure of stratocumulus-topped boundary layers – surface moisture budget is completely out to lunch Bretherton et al. 2004, BAMS
It’s not just drizzle….
Caldwell and Bretherton (2008), LES Ackerman et al. (2008), GCSS Case Study of 14 LES finds that including droplet sedimentation (reducing N d ) increases LWP in all cases
Analogies in trade cumulus clouds
• LES model of trade Cu • Both cloud fraction (CF) and LWP decrease with increasing CCN conc.
• Effect attributed to more rapid evaporation of smaller cloud droplets (higher N) during entrainment events resulting in more rapid cloud dissipation Xue and Feingold (2006) CF LWP aerosol concentration [cm -3 ]
Conclusions
• Relative strength of 2 nd AIE strongly dependent upon balance between precipitation suppression moistening and entrainment drying • R IE reduced by ~50% by changing drizzle parameterization need to understand climatology of precipitation and its dependency on LWP and N
d
• Over timescales comparable with aerosol lifetime in the MBL, 1 st and 2 nd AIEs may cancel – implications for sensitivity of low clouds to aerosols • Unlikely that current global models can capture the essential physics (evaporation/entrainment)
CloudSat observes drizzle
SE Pacific
Sensitive to size of drizzle drops
• Reducing mean radius of drizzle drops leads to more evaporation, and different ratio of surface moistening and entrainment drying • Representation of evaporation critical
r
driz =49 m
r
driz =65 m
The End
Low clouds in climate models change in low cloud amount for 2
CO 2
model number from Stephens (2005) GFDL CCM
Re-examination of Klein and Hartmann data
Change in LTS (K) Low cloud amount in an ensemble of 2xCO 2 -control GCM simulations is poorly estimated using LTS’ (for which a general increase is predicted) Much better agreement with change in saturated stability (≈EIS’)
Williams et al. (2006)
Precipitation parameterizations
Range typical in MBL clouds BASE: Comstock et al. (2004):
P
CB
h
3.5
/N d 1.75
Van Zanten et al. (2005):
P
CB
h
3 /N d
Weak temperature gradient
Minimalist approach
No entrainment drying/warming
• Entrainment only allowed to influence z i • leads to stronger LWP feedback
Doubling and halving entrainment efficiency
2 /2 Enhanced entrainment counteracts (by drying) the increased LWP caused by reduced precip. efficiency… ….but data fall on same curve
Cloud feedbacks remain the largest uncertainty in the prediction of future climate change
from Cess et al. 1989, 1996
Sensitivity of cloud optical depth
t
to increasing N
d
in the MLM
1 st AIE 2 nd AIE constant LWP feedback on LWP For the MLM, t
N
d 1/3
LWP
5/6
Indirect effect ratio
R
IE
1st AIE 2nd AIE Define
R
IE = 2 nd AIE / 1 st AIE Relative strength of the Albrecht effect compared with Twomey
• Relationship between LTS and EIS is not unique • For a given value of LTS, EIS decreases with surface (or 700 hPa) temperature
(2) Aerosols and low clouds
Chiquicamata, Chile Wood et al. (2006) Cloud droplet concentration
Primary effect (Twomey)
• Seminal papers in 1974, 1977 hypothesizing an important potential brightening of clouds subject to increased aerosol concentration • Importance of fixed cloud macrophysical properties (LWP) – difficult to test in practice
….first measurements (1967) + wind from land wind from sea
Aerosol-cloud microphysical observations
….recent measurements (1994) Predicted droplet concentration from aerosol spectrum [cm -3 ] From Twomey and Warner, J. Atmos. Sci., 24, 704-706, 1967 From Martin et al., J. Atmos. Sci., 51, 1823-1842, 1994 Aerosol concentration [cm -3 ]
Aerosol loading and cloud droplet radius….
….35 years on
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Aerosol index
from Breon et al. 2002, Science,
295, 834-838 6 8 10 12 14 Cloud droplet radius [micron]
Remote sensing estimates
IE = dlnr e /dln t a dln t /dlnN a = (dln t /dlnN d )(dlnN d /dlnN a ) (dlnN d /dlnN a ) 0.5 to 0.7
Expect IE =1/3 (0.5 to 0.7) 0.17 to 0.23
IE (Observations)
0.02-0.16 (Feingold et al.) 0.085 (Breon, ocean) 0.04 (Breon, land) 0.06 (Nakajima et al., ocean)
from Feingold et al. 2003, GRL