Effects of Black Carbon on Clouds and Climate Mark Z. Jacobson Atmosphere/Energy Program Dept.

Download Report

Transcript Effects of Black Carbon on Clouds and Climate Mark Z. Jacobson Atmosphere/Energy Program Dept.

Effects of Black Carbon on Clouds and Climate
Mark Z. Jacobson
Atmosphere/Energy Program
Dept. of Civil & Environmental Engineering
Stanford University
Department of Meteorology, San Jose State University
February 1, 2012
Important Physical Processes Affecting BC
Climate Response
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Direct effect (dependent on evolution of mixing state)
Indirect effects I and II
Cloud absorption effects I and II
Semidirect effect
Effect on snow and sea ice albedo
Water evaporation effect
All processes involve nonlinear feedback and coupling must
be treated simutaneously. Effects cannot be linearly added.
Boomerang Curve
Indirect + Cloud Absorption+ Semidirect Effects
COD v. AOD Over Biomass Burning in Brazil Sept ‘06
Cloud optical depth (--)
11
MODIS
10
GATOR-GCMOM
Model
9
8
7
Model
6
5
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
Aerosol optical depth (--)
0.8
Ten Hoeve et al. ACP 11, 3021 (2011)
Smog Over Asia Decreasing Cloudiness
NASA/ORBIMAGE
Heating Rate Due to BC in Middle Cloud Inclusions, Interstitially
Between Cloud Particles, and in the Clear Sky
8
8
Cloud LWC
BC in cloud
BC in aerosol
7
6
Altitude (km)
Altitude (km)
6
5
4
3
5
4
3
2
2
1
1
0
0
0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1
1.2 1.4 1.6
3
c) Cloud LWC (g/kg) and BC (mg/m )
Cloud LWC and BC
In Cloud & Clear Sky
aerosol without cloud
aerosol in cloud between drops
aerosol in drops-DEMA-100nm
aerosol in drops-DEMA-200nm
aerosol in drops-CSA
7
0
0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12
d) Solar heating rate (K/hr)
COD=74.24
Column-integrated heating rate
of inclusions 2.8
CSA (c31) CAOD=0.0151;AOD=0.175;AAOD=0.00825
times that
of BC in clear
sky, 2.4 times that of
DEMA(D=200nm)
(c2) CAOD=0.0321;AOD=0.176;AAOD=0.00825
Interstitial
CAOD=0.000315;AOD=0.190;AAOD=0.0239
interstitialBkrd
BCBC, no(c7)
cld (c14) CAOD=0;AOD=0.168;AAOD=0.000864
10
10
8
8
Cloud IWC
BC in cloud
BC in aerosol
6
Altitude (km)
Altitude (km)
Heating Rate Due to BC in Contrail Inclusions, Interstitially Between
Contrail Particles, and in the Clear Sky
4
6
4
2
2
0
0.001
0
10-5
0.01
0.1
1
10
3
e) Cloud IWC (g/kg) and BC (mg/m )
Conrail IWC and BC In
Contrail & Clear Sky
aerosol without cloud
aerosol in cloud between drops
aerosol in drops-DEMA-100nm
aerosol in drops-DEMA-200nm
aerosol in drops-CSA
0.001
f) Solar heating rate (K/hr)
Heating rate of inclusions COD=53.27
30 times that of BC in
CSA (c31) CAOD=0.000284;AOD=0.0449;AAOD=0.0185
clear sky, 6 times
that of interstitial BC
DEMA(D=200nm)
(c2) CAOD=0.000253;AOD=0.0449;AAOD=0.0
Absorption efficiency
Cloud Absorption Should be Treated with DEMA
(Multiple BC Inclusions in Drops)
10
DEMA1
DEMA2
Brug
Core/shell
0
10
-1
10
-2
10
-3
10
-4
V=10
0.1
1
Wavelength (mm)
-5
10
Jacobson, J. Phys.
Chem. (2006)
Absorption Efficiency 12.6-Micron Cloud Drops
DEMA1,2=0.1-, 0.2-micron BC inclusions; Brug=Bruggeman (BC well-mixed); Core/shell=single BC core
Why Does Interstitial Cloud (IC) BC Heat More Than Clear-Sky
BC and In-Cloud-Drop BC Heat More Than IC BC?
1) BC between cloud drops (interstitial) heats more than aerosol BC
due to enhanced scattering of light between cloud drops thus more
photons hitting BC in the cloud than outside the cloud.
2) BC in cloud drops heats more than BC between cloud drops due
to optical focusing of enhanced scatter cloud light into drops and
multiple internal reflections of such light to BC inclusions.
Cloud Evolution With Versus Without Absorption by BC Inclusions
Without Absorption
With Absorption
4
4
Altitude (km)
3
5s
60 s
180 s
300 s
600 s
900 s
1500 s
3000 s
4500 s
2.5
2
1.5
3.5
3
Altitude (km)
3.5
900 s
1500 s
3000 s
4500 s
2.5
2
1.5
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
c) Cloud LWC (g/kg) with BC inclusion absorption
5s
60 s
180 s
300 s
600 s
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07
d) Cloud LWC (g/kg) no BC inclusion absorption
Absorption by BC inclusions speed up cloud dissipation, allowing more sunlight to reach surface in
positive feedback
Cloud Evolution With Versus Without Absorption by BC Inclusions
Irradiance (dots) and radiative forcing (solid) Temperature change due to BC
inclusions only and
due to BC inclusions (lower curves) and BC
inclusions+aerosol (accounting
inclusions + aerosol (upper curves)
for indirect effects)
Anti-correlation between
radiative forcing and
surface temperature
Ground surface temperature (K)
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
10
15
20
25
2
k) Total radiative forcing (W/m )
Instantaneous radiative forcing and surface temperature change are anti-correlated in the case of cloud
absorption
30
Models v. HIPPO BC Data Pacific
Schwartz et al. (2010) 14 Models vs. HIPPO
(“Models overpredict by factor of five”)
All Data
60 - 80N
All Data
60 - 80N
20 - 60N
20S - 20N
20 - 60N
20S - 20N
60 – 20S
67 - 60S
60 – 20S
GATOR-GCMOM vs HIPPO
(1.4% column diff. all data)
67 - 60S
Modeled
o
o
(4 x5 )
0.1
0.02
0.05
Aeronet AAOD
Model AAOD
0.018
0.08
Aeronet AAOD
Model AAOD
0.04
0.016
AAOD
AAOD
AAOD
0.012
0.04
0.01
2006.2
0.006
2006.4
2006.6
2006.8
2007
Year
0.004
2006
2006.2
2006.4
2006.6
2006.8
0
2006
2007
Year
0.05
Aeronet AAOD
Model AAOD
0.08
2006.8
2007
Aeronet AAOD
Model AAOD
Aeronet AAOD
Model AAOD
0.2
Station 245; 15.25 S, 23.15 E
Station 74; 20.44 S, 54.54 W
AAOD
0.06
0.15
Station 173; 8.32 N, 4.34 E
0.04
0.1
0.01
0.02
0.05
2006.2
2006.6
2006.4
0.25
0.02
0
2006
2006.2
Year
0.1
AAOD
0.03
Station 74; 20.44 S, 54.54 W
0.008
Station 27; 21.29 N; 106.22 E
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0.02
0
2006
Aeronet AAOD
Model AAOD
Station 97; 31.52 S, 64.46 W
0.014
0.06
AAOD
Versus AERONET AAOD
2006.4
2006.6
Year
2006.8
2007
0
2006
2006.2
2006.4
2006.6
Year
2006.8
2007
0
2006
2006.2
2006.4
2006.6
Year
2006.8
2007
Modeled vs. OMI and AERONET AAOD
a) Model v AERONET (dots) c-s 550-nm AAOD (ld:0.031;gb:0.014)
90
0.2
b) OMI 2006 clear-sky 500-nm AAOD (ld: 0.028; gb:nd)
90
0.15
0.15
0.1
0
0.1
0
0.05
0.05
0
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
0.2
0
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
Model (4ox5o resolution) calculates AAOD slightly higher than AERONET but
lower than OMI at AERONET sites. Model correlates better with AERONET and
OMI separately better than OMI correlates with AERONET
Modeled Mass Absorption Coefficients and
Enhancement
Factors
MAC of EM BC (Avg=6.7)
MAC of IM BC (Avg=16.2)
90
a) 550-nm MAC EM BC w/no shell (m 2/g) (6.72;ld:6.82;oc:6.67)
b) 550-nm MAC IM BC w/non-abs shell (m 2/g) (16.2;ld:16.2;oc:16.2)
7.2
90
18
7
6.8
0
17
0
16
6.6
15
6.4
-90
-180
90
14
-90
-90
0
90
180
-180
-90
0
90
180
c) 550-nm MAC ratio IM:EM (globe:2.41; land: 2.38; oc: 2.42)
2.8
2.6
0
2.4
2.2
2
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
Internal-mixing enhancement factor: IM:EM MAC
(Avg = 2.4 – highest where RH is high)
MAC of BC in Cloud Drop Inclusions
Average = 17.7, >9% higher than that of IM aerosol BC
650-nm HMAC of BC (m2 /g) (globe: 17.7; land:17.4; oc:17.8)
90
18
16
0
14
12
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
Modeled vs. Measured Annual Lightning Flash Rate
Modeled flash rate (flashes/km 2/yr) (2.9)
90
Observed flash rate (flashes/km2/yr) (2.9)
90
50
0
50
0
-90
0
-180
-90
0
90
180
-90
0
-180
-90
0
90
180
Data from NASA LIS/OTD Science Team
o
o
(4 x5
Model
resolution) calculates lightning by accounting for size-resolved
bounceoffs and charge separation in clouds. Results follow from new drop
breakup algorithms.
Modeled vs. Measured Precipitation
Baseline precipitation (mm/day) (2.62)
90
10
Observed precipitation 2006 (mm/day) (2.64)
90
10
8
0
5
6
0
4
2
-90
0
-180
-90
0
90
180
-90
0
-180
-90
0
90
180
Data from Huffman et al (2007)
Despite factor of 20 lower resolution than data, model predicts locations of
main features of observed precipitation and, with no flux adjustment, correctly
does not produce a double ITCZ
Modeled vs. Measured Paired in Space Monthly T/Td
Global domain
U.S. domain
Little numerical diffusion of water vapor or energy to stratosphere Data from FSL (2008)
Modeled vs. Measured Sea Ice Area
Arctic
25
20
Model
Data (1979-2007 avg)
15
10
5
0
2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Year from start of simulation
Arctic ice area (mil sq km)
Antarctic ice area (mil sq km)
Antarctic
25
20
Model
Data (1979-2007 avg)
15
10
5
0
2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Year from start of simulation
Model (at 4 x 5 degree resolution) predicts stable sea ice area
Data from NASA Team (2009)
Aerosol Size Distributions
Two distributions, each with multiple size bins and components per bin
Emitted fossil-fuel soot (EFFS)
Emission sources: fossil-fuel combustion
Internally-mixed (IM)
Emission sources: biofuel burning, biomass-burning, sea spray, soil dust, road
dust, volcanos, pollen, spores, bacteria
Homogeneous nucleation: H2SO4-HNO3-H2O into IM distribution
Coagulation:
EFFS + EFFS = EFFS
EFFS + IM = IM
IM + IM
= IM
Growth: Organic matter, H2SO4, HNO3, HCl, NH3 H2O grow on both EFFS & IM
Clouds: Both distributions activate size-resolved liquid, ice, graupel clouds
Imaginary refractive index
Imag. Ref. Indices Organic & Black Carbon
Black carbon
1
Tar balls
4-Nitrophenol anion
0.1
Nitrobenzene
2-Nitrophenol
4-Nitrophenol
0.3
0.5
0.6
Wavelength (mm)
0.01
0.4
0.7
0.8
BC: Bergstrom; nitrated & aromatics: Jacobson, 1999; Tar balls: Alexander et al., 2008 )
Black Carbon From Fossil- and Bio-fuel Soot
a.ii)
90
3
BC (IM) ( g/m ) w-w/o FSBSG (+0.16)
10
8
6
0
4
2
-90
0
-180
-90
0
90
180
BC from FF soot is about half that of BC from FF+BF soot
Black Carbon in Snow and Sea Ice
b.i)
90
BC in snow (mg/L) w-w/o FSBSG (+0.004)
0.3
0.2
0
0.1
0
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
Black Carbon Absorption in Clouds
g.i)
90
Cloud absorption opt. depth w-w/o FSBSG (+0.000036)
0.0006
0.0004
0
0.0002
0
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
COD Changes Due to FF+BF Soot + BF gases
and to FF Soot Alone
h.i)
90
Cloud optical depth w-w/o FSBSG (+0.29)
5
0
Cloud OD change due to
FF+BF soot + BF gases
Cloud OD change due
to FF soot
0
-5
h.ii)
90
Cloud optical depth w-w/o FS (-0.077)
4
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
2
0
0
-2
FF+BF soot +BF gases increased
COD; FF soot decreased COD
-4
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
Surface Air Temperature Changes Due FossilFuel Soot Plus Biofuel Soot and Gases
j.i)
90
Air temperature (K) w-w/o FSBSG (+0.69)
6
4
0
2
0
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
Cumulative D air temperature upon
eliminating emission and ambient
Fossil-Fuel Soot and Biofuel Soot & Gas Controls
may be Fastest Method of Slowing Global Warming
and Saving Arctic Ice
0.2
0
-0.2
Methane
Fossil-fuel soot
-0.4
-0.6
Fossil-fuel soot +
biofuel soot & gases
-0.8
-1
CO -30 yr
-1.2
CO -50 yr
2
-1.4
2000
2
2020
2040
2060
2080
2100
Year
www.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/controlfossilfuel.html
11.5% loss/decade
81,400 km2 loss/year
nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews
o
Temperature Change Since 1750 ( C)
Contributors to Global Warming
2
1
0
-1
Cooling
particles
Green- Fossil- Urban
house
fuel
heat
gases + biofuel island
soot
particles
Net
observed
global
warming
-2
Jacobson (2010, JGR 115, D14209)
Some Climate Response Estimates of BC
Ramanathan and Carmichael (2008) 0.5-1 K (all BC)
Chung and Seinfeld (2005) 0.37 K (all BC internally mixed)
Hansen et al. (2005) > 0.3 K (BC from fossil fuels)
Jacobson (2010) 0.4-0.7 K (BC, organic matter, and other
particle components from fossil fuels and biofuels)
Annual Deaths Due to Fossil-Fuel and Biofuel
Soot
o.iii) PM deaths/yr w-w/o FSBSG (+1.5 million)
2.5
90
100000
0
50000
0
-90
-180
-90
0
90
180
Deaths due to BF soot (1.5 million/yr) ~7 times those due to FF
soot (200,000/yr)
Effects of Rerouting Flights Around Arctic Circle
Reroute flights >500 mi, >50 seats, and origin+destination airports below Arctic Circle.
70,000
58,922
Annual Estimated Cross-Polar Flights
60,000
54,236
48,577
50,000
54,062
56,145
50,710
41,753
40,000
Number of cross-polar
flights 2004-2010
30,000
20,000
10,000
0
2004
2005
2006
2007
Year
2008
2009
2010
Rerouting One Flight (Frankfurt to Anchorage)
Cooper et al. (2011)
Rerouting 2006 Cross-Arctic Flights (40,399)
Before
After
Jacobson et al. (2011)
Global Modeled Temperature Change Due to
Rerouting Over 22 years
D Ground temperature (K)
0.05
0
-0.05
-0.1
-0.15
-0.2
-0.25
-0.3
-0.35
Reroute minus base AC
After 22 years
-80
-40
0
40
80
a) Latitude (degrees)
Jacobson et al. (2011)
Summary
FSBSG soot may be the second-leading cause of global warming
behind CO2 and ahead of CH4. FS causes 3 x the warming of BSG,
but BSG causes ~7x more deaths than FS.
Strong warming mainly due to cloud absorption effect, semidirect
effect, internal mixing of aerosol, snow absorption effect, and
feedback to water evaporation.
Net global warming (0.7-0.8 K) appears due to gross warming from
FF GHGs (2-2.4 K) and FSBSG (0.4-0.7 K) offset by cooling due to
non-FSBSG aerosol particles (-1.7 to -2.3 K). FS and FSBSG may
contribute to 13-16% and 17-23% of gross warming due to
atmospheric pollutants.
Control of FS, FSBSG is fastest method of reducing Arctic loss
www.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/VIII/controlfossilfuel.html