Transcript Supplemental Figure 1

Evaluation of Final Paper
(Maximum of 100 points)
Authors' Names
Title
Row totals
No (0)
Yes (1)
No (0)
Yes (2)
Fair (1)
Good (2)
Excellent (3)
Fair (1)
Good (2)
Excellent (4)
No (0)
Yes (1)
Fair (1)
Good (2)
No (0)
Yes (1)
Fair (1)
Good (2)
Excellent (3)
Fair (1)
Good (1.5)
Excellent (2)
Fair (1)
Good (2)
Excellent (3)
No (0)
Yes (1)
No (0)
Yes (2)
Fair (1)
Good (2)
Excellent (3)
Many (0)
Few (2)
None (3)
Fair (1)
Good (2)
Excellent (3)
No (0)
Yes (1)
Is the title appropriate for the project?
Are the authors names and affiliations listed?
Abstract
Was an abstract included?
Did it summarize the objectives, methods, and results?
Introduction
Was the introduction clear?
Was sufficient background information given?
Were the research objectives stated?
Was information from current research literature included?
Methods
Was it present and appropriately titled?
Were methods for different experiments subdivided?
Excellent (4)
Were all materials and methods included?
Were the methods described clearly?
Were the methods described accurately?
Was enough detail included for one to repeat the experiment?
Results
Was it present and appropriately titled?
Were results for different experiments subdivided?
Did the text refer to each table/figure?
Were the tables and figures labeled adequately?
Transformation of yeast HS100-4A [IC4Y12] with high copy yeast
genomic library and 1st and 2nd screens for transformants for YAC
instability- content
Transformation of yeast HS100-4A [IC4Y12] with high copy yeast
genomic library and 1st and 2nd screens for transformants for YAC
instability- data presentation
Confirmation that high copy plasmids cause YAC instability (plasmid
isolation and retransformation into yeast and rescreening)- content
Confirmation that high copy plasmids cause YAC instability (plasmid
isolation and retransformation into yeast and rescreening)- data
presentation
Molecular genetics analysis of yeast DNAs responsible for the YAC
instability phenotype (PCR to determine size, gel digests)- content
Molecular genetics analysis of yeast DNAs responsible for the YAC
instability phenotype (PCR to determine size, gel digests)- data
presentation
Molecular genetics analysis of yeast DNAs responsible for the YAC
instability phenotype (sequence analysis)- content
Molecular genetics analysis of yeast DNAs responsible for the YAC
instability phenotype (sequence analysis)- data presentation
YAC loss rate experiment- content
YAC loss rate experiment- data presentation
Cell morphology in mitosis and meiosis- content
Cell morphology in mitosis and meiosis- data presentation
Independent experiment 1- content
Independent experiment 1- data presentation
Discussion
Were conclusions for each experiment stated and discussed?
Did the discussion appropriately/accurately reflect the conclusions?
Was the data discussed in the context of current research literature?
Were possible future experiments described?
References
Was a list of references included?
Were references cited appropriately in the text?
Overall
Organization- was the paper well organized with obvious sections?
Were there errors in grammar/spelling?
Was the writing clear?
Was the paper professional in appearance?
Total