Transcript liaison-ieee802response-AEbwFDISScmts-0314.pptx

IEEE 802 Response to Submission comments
on IEEE 802.1AEbw
20 March 2014
Authors:
Name
Company
Phone
Slide 1
email
This presentation provides responses to comments
on IEEE 802.1AEbw during FDIS ballot
• The FDIS voting results on IEEE 802.1AEbw in N15858
– It passed 16 Approve,1 Disapprove (China NB voted negative)
– Comments were received from China NB
• This presentation provides the proposed responses from IEEE 802 to the
comments by China NB.
Slide 2
China NB comment CN1 on IEEE 802.1AEbw
China NB comment CN1 on IEEE 802.1AEbw
• Since the procedural and technical concerns China NB proposed in
6N15626 still haven’t been reasonably disposed in this FDIS text, and
referencing issues mentioned below exist in this text, so China NB has to
vote against on this FDIS ballot. If these issues could not be disposed
reasonably and this proposal would have been passing the FDIS ballot, it
is regretful for China to be obliged to lose the responsibility and
obligation of complying with and adopting the standard. Furthermore,
China NB wishes to state for the record.
Slide 3
China NB comment CN1 on IEEE 802.1AEbw
(continued)
Proposed IEEE 802 response to CN1 on IEEE 802.1AEbw
• IEEE 802 thanks the China NB for its carefully considered comments on
the 802.1AEbw submission ballot
• Per the agreement in 6N15606, China NB representatives are invited to
participate in the IEEE 802 comment resolution process.
• We have noted the comment that the China NB is “obliged to lose the
responsibility and obligation of complying with and adopting the
standard”. It is out of scope for IEEE 802 and therefore we will forward it
to ISO Central Secretariat.
Slide 4