Transcript https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/09/11-09-1057-00-000v-conditional-approval-ec-report.ppt

September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
P802.11v Report to EC on Conditional
Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot
Date: 2009-09-23
Authors:
Name
Company
Dorothy Stanley
Aruba Networks
Bruce Kraemer
Marvell
Submission
Slide 1
Address
1322 Crossman Ave
Sunnyvale, CA 94089
5488 Marvell Lane,
Santa Clara, CA 95054
Phone
+1 (630)
363 1389
+1 (321)
427-4098
email
dstanley@arubanetworks.
com
[email protected]
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
Introduction
• This document contains the report to the IEEE 802
Executive Committee in support of a request for
conditional approval to send IEEE P802.11v to Sponsor
Ballot.
• This document (11-09/1057-00) was approved during
the closing plenary session of the 802.11 working group
on September 25, 2009.
– Passed in the Task Group x-y-z
– Passed in the Working Group x-y-z
Submission
Slide 2
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
Requirements Met for EC Conditional Approval
to advance P802.11v Draft 7.0 to Sponsor Ballot
a) Recirculation ballot is completed. Generally, the recirculation
ballot and resolution should occur in accordance with the schedule
presented at the time of conditional approval.
– Condition Met. Recirculation ballot 155 completed on 07 August
2009, according to the schedule presented in
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/09/11-09-0720-02-000v-tgv-sponsorballot-request-presentation.ppt
b) After resolution of the recirculation ballot is completed, the
approval percentage is at least 75% and there are no new valid
DISAPPROVE votes.
– Condition Met. The approval percentage is 92.19%. There were no new
valid DISAPPROVE votes.
c) No technical changes, as determined by the WG Chair, were made
as a result of the recirculation ballot.
– Condition Met. The comment resolutions in the last recirculation did not
approve any changes to the draft.
Submission
Slide 3
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
Requirements Met for EC Conditional Approval
to advance P802.11v Draft 7.0 to Sponsor Ballot
d. No new valid DISAPPROVE comments on new issues that are not
resolved to the satisfaction of the submitter from existing DISAPPROVE
voters.
– Condition Met. There are no DISAPPROVE comments from existing
DISAPPROVE voters. One existing DISAPPROVE voter submitted and
subsequently withdrew 3 submitted comments.
e. If the WG Chair determines that there is a new invalid DISAPPROVE
comment or vote, the WG Chair shall promptly provide details to the
Sponsor.
– Explanation: There are no required comments received that were determined to be
invalid. There are 2 not-required comments associated with DISAPPROVE votes
that were determined to be invalid. These were ruled invalid as they did not relate
to draft text changed, draft text affected by changed text or an existing unsatisfied
DISAPPROVE comment from a DISAPPROVE voter. LB155 comments are on
Slide 6.
f. The WG Chair shall immediately report the results of the ballot to the
Sponsor including: the date the ballot closed, vote tally and comments
associated with any remaining disapproves (valid and invalid), the WG
responses and the rationale for ruling any vote invalid.
– The ballot closed on: 7 August 2009
– The vote tally is: 177 Approve, 15 Disapprove, 38 Abstain
– The comments associated with remaining disapproves are on the next slide
Submission
Slide 4
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
Unsatisfied comments
• The composite of all unsatisfied comments and the
resolutions approved during working group ballot
may be found in document: 11-09-0676-06, a copy of
this is attached,
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/09/11-09-0676-06000v-lb-150-comments.xls .
– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.
• A copy of the unsatisfied comments presented using
MyBallot access database report format is attached.
– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.
Submission
Slide 5
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
LB155 comments
• The LB155 comments may be found in document: 1109-0929-04, a copy of this is attached, see
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/09/11-09-0929-04000v-lb155-comments.xls .
– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.
Submission
Slide 6
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
Post LB155 vote and comment changes
•
E-mail from Clint Chaplin, changing his vote to “Approve with comment”
–
–
–
•
E-mail from Qi Wang withdrawing LB 155 comments 10, 11, 12
–
–
–
–
–
–
•
Dorothy,
I withdraw LB155 CID_12 and will resubmit it during the upcoming 11v sponsor ballot.
Qi Wang
Dorothy,
I withdraw my LB155 comments with CID-10 and CID-11 (as indicated in 09/929r1) and will submit them
in the upcoming sponsor ballot.
Qi
E-mail from Nakjung Choi changing his comment to “T” to “TR”
–
–
–
–
•
Bruce,
This email is to officially change my vote status at this time on IEEE 802.11v to "Approve with Comments"
Clint (JOATMON) Chaplin
Hi, Dorothy.
Please change my LB155 comment from “TR” to “T”.
Thanks in advance.
Nakjung Choi
E-mail from Yongho Seok changing his comment to “T” from “TR”
–
–
–
Please change my LB155 comment from “TR” to “T”.
Regards,
Yongho
Submission
Slide 7
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
TGv draft text stability
375
350
4.0
5.0
6.07.0
# pages
325
300
AP MIB added
275
3.0
250
2.0
225
1.0
200
0
Jan-07
Submission
Slide 8
Jul-07
Jan-08
Jul-08
Jan-09
Jul-09
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
802.11 WG Letter Ballot Results – P802.11v
Ballot
ID
Ballot
Close
Date
140
19 Dec
2008
146
Title
Ballot Type
Pool
Return
%Return
Abstain
%
Abstain
Appr
ove
Disap
prove
%Appro
ve
Technical Letter
Ballot for Task
Group-v Draft 4.0
Technical
254
225
88.58
40
17.78
149
36
80.54
4 Apr
2009
Recirculation Letter
Ballot for Task
Group-v Draft 5.0
Recirculation
254
228
89.76
41
17.98
155
32
82.88
150
12 Jun
2009
Second
Recirculation Ballot
for Task Group-v
Draft 6.0
Recirculation
254
230
90.55
38
16.10
172
20
89.58
150.1
15 Jul
09
Second
Recirculation Ballot
for Draft 6.0 Post
ballot results
Recirculation
254
230
90.55
38
16.10
174
18
90.6
155
7 Aug
2009
Third Recirculation
for Task Group-v
Draft 7.0
Recirculation
254
230
90.55
38
16.10
176
16
91.6
155.1
23 Sept
2009
Recirculation
254
230
90.55
38
16.10
177
15
92.19
Third Recirculation
for Task Group-v
Draft 7.0 Post ballot
Submission results
Slide 9
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
802.11 WG Letter Ballot Comments – P802.11v
Ballot ID
Ballot Close
Date
Title
Ballot Type
Number of
Comments received
140
19 Dec 2008
Technical Letter Ballot for
Task Group-v Draft 4.0
Technical
586 (418T, 168E)
146
4 Apr 2009
Recirculation Letter Ballot
for Task Group-v Draft 5.0
Recirculation
321 (225T, 96E)
150
12 Jun 2009
Second Recirculation Ballot
for Task Group-v Draft 6.0
Recirculation
140 (93T, 47E)
155
7 Aug 2009
Third Recirculation Ballot
for Task Group-v Draft 7.0
Recirculation
24 (12T, 12E)
Submission
Slide 10
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
TGv Timeline
Third recirculation (TGv draft 7.0)
Open
23-Jul-09
Close
7-Aug-09
Clean recirculation (TGv draft 7.0)
25-Sep-09
10-Oct-09
Pool formation
17-Aug-09
1-Oct-09
First sponsor ballot
5-Oct-09
4-Nov-09
Second sponsor ballot
3-Feb-10
18-Feb-10
Third sponsor ballot
30-Mar-10
15-Apr-10
Fourth sponsor ballot
15-May-10
30-May-10
EC to RevCom
Mar-10 (cond.) or
Jul-10
RevCom to SB
Jun-10 or Sep-10
Submission
Slide 11
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)
September 2009
doc.: 11-09-1057-00
References
Submission
Slide 12
D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)