Affirmative Action–Or Not Thomas A. Timmerman, Ph.D., SPHR • 2010 AA Fishing ©SHRM 2010

Download Report

Transcript Affirmative Action–Or Not Thomas A. Timmerman, Ph.D., SPHR • 2010 AA Fishing ©SHRM 2010

Affirmative Action–Or Not
Thomas A. Timmerman, Ph.D., SPHR
• 2010
AA Fishing
2
©SHRM 2010
20% good fish $5/lb
30% mediocre fish $2/lb
50% worthless fish
3
©SHRM 2010
AA Fishing
Lake 2
20% good fish $5/lb
30% mediocre fish $2/lb
50% worthless fish
4
©SHRM 2010
AA Fishing
Lake 1
Lake 2
Lake 3
5
©SHRM 2010
Conclusions From the Fish Story
• We want good fish regardless of which lake they
come from.
• If we concentrate on one lake only, we will
eventually run out of good fish and have to settle
for mediocre or bad fish.
• We are willing to spend money to pursue good fish
in other lakes.
• It makes no sense to wait for the good fish in other
lakes to swim to us.
• We won’t be satisfied with our catch from the
smaller lakes until we catch them in proportion to
their availability.
6
©SHRM 2010
Affirmative Action in Action
Affirmative Action’s First Victim
> Ed Stevens
7
©SHRM 2010
Affirmative Action in Action
•
•
•
•
•
Rickey wanted the most talented players
regardless of where they came from.
By concentrating on white players only, mediocre
and bad players were filling out the rosters.
The Dodgers spent money sending scouts into the
Negro Leagues to find the most talented players.
The Dodgers didn’t wait for African-American
players to knock down the doors demanding equal
treatment.
Robinson was the first, but not the only, good fish
landed by the Dodgers from the African-American
pool.
8
©SHRM 2010
Bertrand and Mullainathan Study
• 5,000 resumes mailed for entry-level jobs in Boston
and Chicago.
• Resumes designed to be a good fit or poor fit for
job.
11.00%
9.20%
10.00%
% Receiving 9.00%
Call Backs 8.00%
7.60%
7.00%
6.00%
5.00%
Good Fit
Poor Fit
9
©SHRM 2010
Bertrand and Mullainathan Study
• Resumes also designed to reflect gender of
applicant.
11.00%
10.00%
8.60%
%
9.00%
Receiving
8.00%
Call
7.00%
Backs
6.00%
7.70%
5.00%
Male
Female
10
©SHRM 2010
Bertrand and Mullainathan Study
• One other name manipulation:
Male
1. Brad, Jay,
Matthew, Todd
2. Tyrone, Leroy,
Jamal, Rasheed
Female
1. Kristen, Laurie,
Meredith, Jill
2. Ebony, Lakisha,
Keisha, Latoya
11
©SHRM 2010
Bertrand and Mullainathan Study
11.00%
10.10%
10.00%
%
Receiving
Call
Backs
9.00%
8.00%
6.70%
7.00%
6.00%
5.00%
White
AfricanAmerican
12
©SHRM 2010
Bertrand and Mullainathan Study
11.31%
11.00%
10.00%
%
9.00%
Receiving
8.00%
Call
7.00%
Backs
6.00%
5.00%
8.80%
6.99%
6.41%
White
Poor Fit
©SHRM 2010
Good Fit
AfricanAmerican
13
Affirmative Action Summary
•
•
•
•
The fish story demonstrated what affirmative
action is really about. It’s about noticing
underutilization and proactively addressing it.
The baseball story demonstrated that affirmative
action done well leads to better organizational
performance.
The Bertrand and Mullainathan study
demonstrated that underutilization still happens,
even across the labor market.
So far in our discussion, the government hasn’t
forced anyone to engage in affirmative action.
14
©SHRM 2010
What Is Affirmative Action?
• Attempt to ensure that the organization is attracting
and selecting the best talent from every available
source.
• Only mandated by law for:
> Federal contractors and subcontractors with 50 or
more employees and contracts of at least $50,000.
• Required by Executive Order 11246.
> Organizations found guilty of illegal discrimination.
> For everyone else, it’s just a good idea.
15
©SHRM 2010
What Is Affirmative Action?
•
Utilization analysis:
Are there any pools that are not being tapped?
> Compare your workforce to the relevant labor force.
>
•
Establish goals and timetables for tapping
underutilized pools.
>
>
•
Goals should match availability in the relevant labor
force.
Timetables should consider anticipated growth and
typical turnover rates.
Develop plans to reduce underutilization:
>
>
Recruit in nontraditional areas.
Examples….
16
©SHRM 2010
Recruiting in Nontraditional Areas
• SAS Institute, Inc.
> Family-friendly work environment.
• Raytheon
> Finding new untapped pools.
• Sempra Energy
> Building social networks.
• Goldman Sachs
> Educating women in underdeveloped nations.
> LEAD program.
17
©SHRM 2010
What Is Affirmative Action?
• Utilization analysis:
> Are there any pools that are not being tapped?
> Compare your workforce to the relevant labor force.
• Establish goals and timetables for tapping
underutilized pools:
> Goals should match availability in the relevant labor
force.
> Timetables should consider anticipated growth and
typical turnover rates.
• Develop plans to reduce underutilization:
> Recruit in nontraditional areas.
> Selection practices that reduce subjectivity.
> Examples….
18
©SHRM 2010
Selection Practices that Reduce Subjectivity
• Changing Selection Practices
> Home Depot:
• Changes driven by growth and class-action
lawsuits.
• Job Preference Program (JPP) automated
the selection process.
• Number of female managers increased by
30 percent.
• Number of minority managers increased by
28 percent.
19
©SHRM 2010
What Is Affirmative Action?
1. Utilization analysis:
1. Are there any pools that are not being tapped?
2. Compare your workforce to the relevant labor force.
2. Establish goals and timetables for tapping
underutilized pools:
1. Goals should match availability in the relevant labor
force.
2. Timetables should consider anticipated growth and
typical turnover rates.
3. Develop plans to reduce underutilization:
1. Recruit in nontraditional areas.
2. Selection practices that reduce subjectivity.
4. Monitor progress.
20
©SHRM 2010
What Affirmative Action Is Not
• Not a government mandate for many employers.
• Not reverse discrimination.
> Court rulings have placed limits on affirmative action
programs:
• Affirmative action plans must be temporary.
• The purpose must be to correct underutilization.
• The plan may not completely ban the hiring/promotion of
majority members.
• The plan may not cause the termination of majority members.
• Preferences may only be given to qualified minority
members..
• Not quotas.
> Specifically forbidden.
• Not diversity for the sake of diversity.
> Evidence is not clear.
21
©SHRM 2010
Wrap-Up
• What Affirmative Action IS:
> An attempt by an organization to actively recruit and
select talented employees from traditionally
undertapped pools.
• What Affirmative Action IS NOT:
> A government mandate that forces organizations to
hire unqualified employees.
22
©SHRM 2010