Psychology of Succession Planning Guess Who’s (Not) Coming to Dinner Presented by Dennis I. Blender, Ph.D.

Download Report

Transcript Psychology of Succession Planning Guess Who’s (Not) Coming to Dinner Presented by Dennis I. Blender, Ph.D.

Psychology of Succession
Planning
Guess Who’s (Not) Coming to
Dinner
Presented by
Dennis I. Blender, Ph.D.
Every family
is
unique
Every family
is
uniquely
the same
Family Business Model
Family
Business
Ownership
Family Business Model
4
1
5
7
2
6
1
3
1 – Family member
2 – Staff member (non-family, not an owner)
3 – Owner (non-family member, not working in business)
4 – Family member in the business
5 – Family member/owner, not in business
6 – Staff member, owner, not family
7 – Family member, owner, in business
Family
Business
Ownership
Family Business Model
Family
• Structure
• Values, traditions
• Family system dynamics
Business
• Industry, size
• Life cycle
• Strategy, culture
Ownership
• Structure
• Distribution
• Governance
Family Businesses
in
the United States
•
Family firms comprise 80-90% of all business
enterprises in North America.
•
Family owned businesses account for;
• 37% of Fortune 500 companies,
• 60% of all public companies,
• 78% of all new jobs,
• 60% of total U.S. employment.
•
30% of family-owned firms survive into the
second generation. 12% will survive into the
third generation. 3% operate at fourth
generation and beyond.
•
By 2005, virtually all closely-held and familyowned businesses will lose their primary
owner to death or retirement ( post-WWII
generation entrepreneurs).
Family Businesses
in
the United States
•
3 primary causes of failure of family-owned
firms:
• Inadequate estate planning,
• Failure to prepare and provide for
transition to the next generation, and
• Lack of funds to pay estate taxes.
•
The founder’s death precipitates nearly 50%
of family firms to collapse.
•
Fewer than 30% of family-owned firms have a
written strategic plan.
•
43% of family-owned businesses will have
changed leadership hands by 2003.
•
More than 25% of family firms expect the next
CEO to be a woman.
Family Businesses
in
the United States
•
70% of family business owners cite life
insurance as their top source of funds to pay
for death taxes.
•
25% of senior generation family business
shareholders have not completed any estate
planning other than writing a will.
• 81% want the business to stay in the
family.
• 20% are not confident of the next
generation’s commitment to the business.
•
Of primary importance among family firm
wealth holders is not only transferring their
financial wealth but also transferring their
values surrounding their wealth.
•
The oldest family-owned business operating in
the U.S. – Zildjian Cymbal Co. – founded in
1623 in Constantinople (and moved to U.S. in
1929).
Continuing Evolution of the Family, the
Business, and Ownership
Rejuvenation
Maturity
Expansion/
Formalization
Start Up
BUSINESS
Controlling
Owner
Sibling
Partnership
Cousin
Consortium
Young
Business Family
Entering the
Business
Working
Together
Passing the
Baton
Family Axis
Young Business Family
• Adults under 40, kids under 18
• Creating workable family, marriage
• Work-family balance
Entering the Business
• Adults between 35-55, kids in teens, twenties
• Managing midlife transition
• Independence of children
• Facilitating a process for initial career decisions
Working Together
• Adults between 50-65, “kids” between 20-45
• Cross-generational cooperation, communication
• Encouraging positive conflict management
Passing the Baton
• Adults – 60+
• Senior generation disengagement
• Generational transfer of leadership
Business Axis
Start-up
• Informal organization structure
• Simple model (one product, service)
• Survival
Expansion/Formalization
• Increasing structure, multiple products lines
• Evolving owner role and professionalism
• Strategic planning: policies, systems
• Cash management
Maturity
• Stable (or declining) customer base
• Well-established routines
• Strategic re-focus, re-investment
• Management/ownership commitment - variable
Rejuvenation
• New strategic direction
• Renewed commitment, leadership
• Willing to change, re-direct
Ownership Axis
Controlling Owner
• Ownership control in one individual
• Generating capital
• Balancing control with other stakeholders
• Choosing next generation
Sibling Partnership
• Two or more siblings
• Developing shared control
• Defining roles of non-employed owners
• Retaining capital
• Controlling family branches
Cousin Consortium
• Many cousin shareholders
• Mixture of employed and non-employed
owners
• Managing complexity of family
• Creating family business capital market
Common
Transition Stage
Family - Passing the Baton
• Leadership transfer
• Founder’s willingness to release control
• Next generation’s ability to assume control
• Founder – looking at retirement
• Next generation – looking to make their mark
Business – Maturity
• Examining the current state of the business
• Establishing new strategic direction
• Determining needs of the business (financial, human
resources, etc)
Ownership - Controlling Owner
• Passing ownership to others
• Passing control to others
• Understanding needs of different generations
• Psychological readiness to move forward
The Family Dream
The Family Dream
Business
• A deeply held vision of the family business in the
future
• An imagined possibility that generates
Ownership
excitement and commitment.
• Serves as a beacon.
• Adds meaning, purpose and inspiration.
• Helps rank priorities and guides decision making.
• Individual dreams of the founder are usually
connected to aspirations for the family business.
• Not all family members share the same dream
• Place to work
• Place for my children to work
• Source of unlimited income
• Opportunity for a legacy
Clandestine Planning
The Psychology of
Transition
Common sources of succession conflict
• Leadership
– Who will be next leader?
• Control
– How to share, empower, distribute?
• New vs. old
– Products
– Procedures
– People
• Sharing between the “ins” and “outs”
– Family vs. family
– Family vs. non-family
• Transition timing
• Black sheep and the prodigal son/daughter
• “Blood” vs. marriage
• Compensation
– Internal vs. external equity
The Psychology of
Transition
Family Patterns
• Traditions and values
• Methods of communication
• Enmeshment and disengaged
• Degree of triangulation
The Psychology of
Transition
Individual Patterns
• Personal dreams and aspirations
• Developmental stage
• Assessment of skills and abilities
Conflict Resolution
The Psychology of
Transition
Methods of Conflict Resolution - Intrapersonal
• Minority decisions
• Majority decisions
• Compromise
• Consensus/win-win
• No deal
Methods of Conflict Resolution - Interpersonal
• Withdrawers
• Smoothers
• Compromisers
• Fighters
• Problem solvers
The Psychology of
Transition
Promoting Healthy Dialogue
• Mutual purpose
• Mutual trust and respect
• Mutual communication and meaning
The Psychology of Transition
The Psychology of
Transition
Successor Selection
1. Identify future business challenges
2. Define strategic implications
3. Develop leadership requirements
4. Gather information about likely candidates
a) Internal and external
5. Assess candidates’ capabilities
a) Skills, abilities, personality
b) Strengths and weaknesses
c) Perceptions of others
The Psychology of
Transition
Successor Selection (continued)
6. Internal candidates
a) Competence
b) Time to develop
7. External candidates
a) Compatibility
8. Proceed with choice
a) Implications, consequences
b) Establish time table
9. Make announcement
10. Cross fingers
Business
The Psychology
of Transition
General Observations
• Succession is a Ownership
journey. To succeed, the family
must keep the ultimate destination in mind.
• Succession is often driven by the biological clock.
• Transitions are normal and predictable.
• Family patterns are easy to identify and
extremely hard to change.
• An active, deliberative exploration of all options
and implications is critical to successful planning.
• Consider the short-term and long-term interests
of the business and family members.
• Continuity planning requires anticipating future
challenges and developing strategies to address
them before they happen.
BCG
Principles and
Approach
•
The family business is the client.
•
Respect and honor the preservation of the
family values.
•
Use knowledge, experience and observations
to educate and anticipate likely results.
•
Facilitate goal setting and implementation
strategies without being judgmental.
•
Facilitate solutions through dialogue and
communication.
•
Collaboration amongst professionals through
an interdisciplinary approach best serves the
clients needs.