Transcript Slide 1

Risk and Resilience:
The Impact of Substance Misusing
Parents on children
LSCB/ LSAB Annual Conference,
25th September 2013
Professor Richard Velleman
Emeritus Professor of Mental Health Research,
University of Bath
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
• Problematic alcohol, and drug use in
parents and the effects on their children
• Intergenerational Transmission (of
substance misuse, and other –ve outcomes)
• Prevention, treatment and support for
these families
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
1. Problematic alcohol and drug use in parents
How big is this problem?
The figures we have equate to almost 4 million people
in the 16-65 age group in the UK being dependent
on alcohol and/or drugs.
Assuming (conservatively) that every substance
misuser will negatively affect at least two close
family members, this suggests about eight million
family members (spouse, children, parents, siblings)
in the UK are living with the negative consequences
of someone else’s drug or alcohol misuse.
Best estimate is that 4 - 5 million UK children (out
of 13.2 million – 34%) are affected.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
What is known about the effects on families?
Lots of families have lives which are very
negatively affected by substance misuse, all
across the world – we have studied this in the
UK, in Mexico, in Australia in the aboriginal
outback, in Italy, but others have looked at this
also, and the conclusion is the same:
Family members (especially children, but also
spouses and parents) are often very badly
affected by having someone with a serious drug
or alcohol problem living in their midst.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
There is a solid evidence base for the impact of
substance misuse on families generally, and on
children in particular, both as children and
when adults.
There are a very large number of studies that
demonstrate negative effects on children whilst
they are still young and in early adolescence
(again, reviewed a number of times, see the
references I have left with the organisers as a
separate file).
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
All this work has led to the following conclusions:
People who develop a serious problem with their
use of alcohol or drugs can and often do behave
in ways that have a significantly negative impact
• on family life in general,
• and on other individual members of the family.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
In terms of the impact on family life in general:
substance misuse can impact negatively on a range
of family systems and processes, including
• family rituals,
• roles within the family,
• family routines,
• communication structures and systems,
• family social life,
• and family finances.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
And, as well as on these family systems, it can also
often impact negatively on other individuals
within the family: problems such as
• domestic and other types of violence,
• child abuse,
• individuals driving whilst intoxicated,
• or disappearing for days on end,
• or embarrassing family members,
• or spending all the money so that there is
nothing left for the family
are all typical of the types of behaviour which
people have described as stressful and with
which they have to cope.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
The results of these and other uncertainties are
that family members commonly develop
problems in their own right, often manifested in
high levels of physical and psychological
symptoms.
These things are often worse for the children.
Many of these children experience negative
childhoods, including
• violence, abuse and living with fear;
• inconsistency from one or both parents;
• having to adopt responsible or parenting roles at
an early age
(more)
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
• having to deal with denial, distortion and
secrecy;
• having problems related to attachment,
separation and loss;
• disturbed family functioning, conflict and
breakdown;
• role reversal and role confusion, both related to
their parents, and themselves.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Many of these children subsequently demonstrate
negative effects of these experiences: these
problems include
• higher levels of behavioural disturbance,
• anti-social behaviour (conduct disorder),
• emotional difficulties,
• school problems,
• ‘precocious maturity’,
• and a more difficult transition from childhood
through adolescence,
than children who have not had this upbringing.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Other recent work has also shown that children
affected by parental substance misuse
are more likely to reach the attention of social
services than are children affected by other
issues, and when they do so,
are more likely to experience problems in the
interaction between their parents and social
services than occurs with other types of problem.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
There are longer-term impacts on these children:
• more likely themselves to develop problems with
substances,
• often linked to earlier onset of use,
• and therefore at greater risk of developing
problems in other areas of life as adults.
Family factors predominate: family dysfunction
and disharmony in their family of origin seems
most responsible for problems for these children,
both when they are children, and later as adults,
as opposed to problems caused by the drinking
itself.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
HOWEVER, there is growing evidence that not all
children are adversely affected, either as
children or adults; some children are resilient
and do not develop significant problems.
This has important implications for prevention and
intervention, and I shall return to this in a
minute.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
2. Intergenerational Transmission
http://www.communities.gov.uk/communities/trouble
dfamilies/
• Known for years that alc & drug probs ‘run in
families’ (refs to all of this are in the separate file)
• But lots of bad research led to a too strong,
deterministic model …..
• That led to ‘risk over-prediction’
• But better research has still shown that there
ARE (some) inter-generational continuities
• An example from my own research: R&R ….
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
250 Young people, 16-35
2 groups – with, and without, seriously problem
drinking parent
We did not obtain confirmation of the idea of
problem drinking being passed on from generation
to generation. There were very few differences
between the two groups in terms of their drinking
and drug-taking.
• whether they had ever used alcohol or any other
drug,
• whether use had ever been a problem,
• whether they were still using,
• how much used, how often used –
in all these areas of drinking and drug-taking, there
were no differences between our two groups.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Some differences did emerge relating to drinking and
drug-taking.
• The offspring group started using at a younger age
(and this was the case with alcohol, cannabis, and
other illicit drugs);
• They were somewhat more likely to either be using
alcohol in a 'risky' fashion currently, or to have
previously had problems with their alcohol use;
• and they were somewhat more likely to be using in
a 'risky' fashion in more than one area of
substance use - alcohol, cannabis, other illicit
drugs, prescribed drugs, smoking, and home
medicines.
SO – there IS a risk, but it is not as strong as
previously thought.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
What is the evidence that there is intergenerational transfer of OTHER poor outcomes?
Very similar results here as well.
In our R&R research, we also looked at both
childhood adjustment, and adulthood adjustment.
Childhood adjustment – generally, very poor.
Massive differences between our two groups on
virtually all of our measures – family problems
relating to family rituals, roles, routines,
communication, social life, and finances, family
disharmony, violence, aggression, arguments,
relationships with parents, childhood problems,
friendship problems etc
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
But Adulthood adjustment – generally, no
differences!
No real differences emerged between our two groups
in terms of areas such as
• self-esteem,
• life-satisfaction,
• problems with anxiety and depression,
• problems with delinquency and deviance, etc.
(Some people in both groups DID have problems – the
difference was in attribution!)
So again, we looked more closely, and again we DID
find some differences:
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
• we found that some of our sample also had an
increased risk of a more negative adulthood
adjustment - some were likely to be more
depressed, more anxious, have relationship
difficulties, leave home early, and generally be
more dissatisfied with their lives.
So, we had a situation where most of our offspring
group seemed to be OK as young adults, although
some did seem to be damaged.
• The big question, then, was what made the ones
with the worse outcome worse?
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
What we found relates to RESILIENCE (a topic I
have written about and talked about lots over
the last few years).
What we know is that some children are resilient:
some children who grow up in a family where
one or both parents misuse alcohol or drugs do
NOT develop serious problems, either as
children and especially as adults.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
So what leads to resilience? Two things:
• fewer risk factors (things which INCREASE
negative impact), and
• more protective factors (which protect FROM
those risk factors).
What are Risk Factors for these children:
Interestingly - NOT drinking or drug-taking, or
even drunkenness or intoxication. Instead, they
are the family problems which arise because of
this intoxication.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
We know that the major negative impact comes
from:
• family disharmony, and within this, from
• family violence,
• parental conflict,
• parental separation and loss,
• and inconsistent and ambivalent parenting.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
What are the Protective Factors?.
They are (again) Family factors,
and Individual/Community ones
Family protective factors:
• Harmony (absence of violence, rows, disharmony)
• presence of a stable adult figure
• close positive bond with one+ adult, caring role
• affection, good support network wider family
[More!]
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
• Spending significant time together as a family
(family meals),
• Characteristics and positive care style of parents (a
balance between ‘care’ and control’. ‘Care’ includes
parental support, warmth, nurturance, attachment,
acceptance, cohesion, and love; ‘Control’ includes
parental discipline, punishment, supervision, and
monitoring – eg ESPAD);
• Utilisation of rules and consequences, and
experiencing strong parental supervision or
monitoring of behaviour related to those rules,
• Parental modelling of the behaviours expected of or
wished for from their children,
• The child having family responsibilities,
• Family observing traditions and rituals (cultural,
religious, familial).
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Individual/community protective factors include:
• Having a hobby or a creative talent or engagement
in outside activities or interests (such as sport,
singing, dancing, writing, drama, painting, etc) –
anything that can provide an experience of success,
and/or approbation from others for the child’s
efforts,
• Successful school experience,
• Strong bonds with local community / community
involvement,
• Self-monitoring skills and self-control,
• Religion or faith in God.
• A sense of humour,
• Intellectual capacity,
• Easy temperament and disposition,
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Why are these protective factors??
Because ALL of them • both the ones relating to positive family
functioning,
• and those relating to external support and
outside interests,
work because they can produce attachment and
security as opposed to unpredictability,
insecurity, exclusion and isolation;
• Attachment and Security are the key elements
that lead to resilience.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
To summarise what we know about
Intergenerational Transmission:
The risks are not as bad as some people suppose or
make out – lots of children are resilient. It is
NOT a foregone conclusion that children brought
up in these environments are doomed to carry on in
the same way.
The ones who are resilient seem to have fewer risk
factors and/or more protective factors in their
environments, which allow them to grow up
feeling more secure and more attached to others.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
These factors relate to
• someone offering the child warmth and affection
over a significant period,
• and to the child doing at least something which
provides a sense of achievement or worth.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
So, onto my third area – Prevention, Treatment &
Support: How might we break the links so that
kids who are not receiving a protected
upbringing become more resilient?
Answer: we provide interventions which create
these protective factors, either from the parent
or parents; or from others!
• It is not the case that people and family systems and
structures are immovable objects.
• And there are an increasing number of interventions
that are being developed and used which help
families and individuals in those families change.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
So, what do good interventions do, to help families
change and children become more resilient?
• First, they work on the RISK factors. All the main
areas which lead to major negative impact are prime
areas for intervention with families where one parent
drinks or uses drugs problematically, even if the
drinking or drug-taking itself is not amenable to
change.
Good interventions work on the risk factors mentioned:
• –
family disharmony, and within this, on
• –
family violence,
• –
parental conflict,
• –
parental separation and loss,
• –
and inconsistent and ambivalent parenting
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Second, good interventions work on the
PROTECTIVE factors: if we understand some of the
elements which make up resilience in children, again we
can work with families to develop these characteristics.
So good interventions work with
• the other parent, enabling them to provide a stable
environment and give the time and attention which
so many children require;
• the parental relationship, enabling parents to retain
their cohesive relationship and present a united and
caring front to the children;
• the family relationship, ensuring that family
relationships, family affection, and family activities
and positive family rituals are maintained;
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
• Good interventions work with other adult figures
outside of the nuclear family, ensuring that there is
at least someone who can provide the necessary
stabilising influence;
• Good interventions work with these adult figures
(either inside or outside of the family), to encourage
the child to develop those aspects of their lives which will
give them a sense of success, achievement, mastery,
competence – all things which enable a young person to
develop the self esteem and self confidence necessary to
enable them to become resilient.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
And good interventions work with the child him- or
her-self,
• helping the child to remove him- or her-self from the
disruptive behaviour of the problem parent or parents;
• helping the child to disengage from the disruptive
elements of family life and engage with stabilising
others outside the family,
• or with stabilising activities (school, clubs, sports,
culture, religion) within which the child can develop a
sense of self and self-esteem.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
So there are many protective factors,
• Both ones relating to positive family functioning,
• and ones relating to external support and outside
interests,
As well as having fewer or less intense risk factors
[eg violence]).
These all lead to resilience, because they can
produce attachment and security as opposed to
unpredictability, insecurity, exclusion and
isolation;
• Attachment and Security are the key elements
that lead to resilience.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Interestingly, similar factors exist related to
helping other young people, who DON’T have
parents with alc or drug problems, to also be
resilient. Many of these relate to the family:
• Parental modelling of appropriate alcohol use;
Monitoring and Supervision; Responsive and
supportive parenting; Having clear, consistent and
enforced rules, and clear expectations about alcohol
and use; Higher family cohesion, levels of family
bonding and family cooperation; and Satisfactory
child-parent relationships and children wanting to
emulate parents .
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
So, all of these things mean that there are lots of
things that people can do to help
• reduce the risks to these children,
• and to increase the probability of children being
resilient.
And most of these are unrelated to substance
misuse.
There is much more about this in a paper Lorna
Templeton and I produced a few years ago
which is in the reference list :
Velleman, R. & Templeton, L. (2007) Understanding
and modifying the impact of parental substance
misuse on children. Advances in Psychiatric
Treatment, 13, 79-89.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Treatment & Support
This is not just theory: services exist which do
these things.
There are not that many: but some services and
some interventions have been developed to assist
these children who are having to cope with a
relative’s (usually a parent’s) drinking or drug
taking,
• either in dealing with their current distress
• or in trying to prevent future problems.
And some services exist to promote resilience in the
general population as well.
Some examples in the UK are:
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
STARS
Option 2
Strengthening Families
FAS
Breaking the Cycle
M-PACT
Young Addaction Plus
Preventure
Base Camp – Turning Point
GBG – Good Behaviour Game
Blackpool Substance Misuse
Family Intervention Project
Family Drug & Alcohol Courts
and increasingly, more.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
OK – but do they work??
Findings?
1. Lots of research in the USA shows they DO
work. In the UK, all research and evaluation
do far provides indications, not conclusive
evidence (small samples, insufficient length of
time, evaluation of pilots etc)
2. BUT - all indications are positive.
• Strengthening Families – best evaluated, over
some years, in USA and elsewhere – strongly
positive findings. Major impacts on substance
use and problems, and on other problem
behaviours.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Findings (Cont)
• Good Behaviour Game: undertaken when
children are aged 6-8, evaluated 14 years later,
when the children are 19-21.
• Major impacts on substance use and problems,
anti-social behaviour & delinquency, risky
sexual behaviour, etc
• Preventure: major reduced rates of starting
using and misusing alcohol, other drugs, and +ve
effects on truancy, panic attacks and depression.
• Our work, evaluating many of the others (FAS,
M-PACT, Base Camp, BtC, YAP, etc) …
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Some extracts:
Young Addaction Plus:
• young people: 82% had attempted to reduce their engagement in harmful
behaviours; 96% had attempted to reduce or avoid their involvement in
crime; 91% were making important changes in their lives in an attempt
to secure stable housing, and 78% were attempting to engage in
activities such as accessing education or taking up sports or hobbies.
• families, 80% improved their ability to cope more effectively; 78% were
successfully taking steps to address problematic family functioning, and
85% of families were beginning to re-establish their relationship with the
young person.
Breaking The Cycle
• 88% showed a reduction in: substance use, and in harmful behaviours;
and an improvement in social and parenting skills; and that they were
more successfully prioritising the wellbeing of their children ….
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Breaking The Cycle (cont)
Clients who have been involved with Breaking the Cycle for some time felt
that:
• They had a clear future; They had goals they were working towards;
They felt that change was possible and sustainable
Overall,
83% of clients achieved some level of progress in working towards their
treatment goals;
81% of parents stabilised, reduced or stopped highly problematic substance
use that was impacting negatively on their and their family’s lives
82% of parents reduced their involvement in harmful behaviours including
involvement in unresolved disputes, domestic violence and engagement
in crime
84% of parents acknowledged the benefits of engaging in a meaningful
occupation
87% of mothers and/or fathers increased their efforts to prioritise their
children’s healthy development.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Option 2 significantly reduced the time children spent in care,
and was significantly cheaper, saving thousands of pounds
per child.
M-PACT programme empowered families to make positive
changes.
• The biggest change was in what the families communicated
about, and how they communicated – the group and family
work allowed them to learn to listen to each other and accept
different feelings and points of view, leading to an enhanced
understanding of each other, the addiction and its impact.
• Being supported to set realistic and relevant goals was also
valued.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
Conclusion
1. Children are often badly affected by being
brought up with a parent with a drug or alcohol
problem.
2. One effect can be that these children in turn go
on to have serious problems with substances
themselves , or to have other poor outcomes (ie
SOME inter-generational transfer).
3. We break these links by developing resilience in
children, by working with them and their
families.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
4. Interventions which use these methods are
insufficiently evaluated as yet, but all of the
indications are very positive.
So - I cannot emphasise enough the fact that there
are a huge number of ways of intervening with
children, parents, and family members, even if
the drinker or drug misuser is unwilling to
address their alcohol or drug consumption;
and of intervening more generally with parents
and families to try to develop resilience in their
children.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
It is important is that we professionals are not left
feeling powerless to help these families and
children, and I hope I have shown that there is
lots we can do with children, and their families
• by focusing on reducing risk factors,
• and building up resilience ones.
Risk & Resilience for children in substance misusing families
So, let me by conclude by stating that
• These families and children clearly do need our
help,
• they have a right to expect it,
• and there are (many) things we can do;
• so it is all of our responsibilities to ensure that
this help is provided.
Thank you.