Transcript One Billion Dollars

One Billion Dollars !
The impact of IP and thickets on firms
[email protected]
One Billion Dollars !
“
Apple won the courtroom battle,
and rightly so
-James Dyson, 26 Aug 2012
“
They are not as cool
-Judge Colin Birrs
OPINION
pogląd
FACT
fakt
DATA
dane
IP
IPR
THICKETS
zarośla
IP
UK investment has changed
IP
Fixed Capital
And there is a link to innovation
2.0
1.64
EU Innovation Scoreboard with
Intangible-tangible ratio
1.60
1.5
1.23
1.20
1.0
0.89
0.89
0.86
0.84
0.73
0.71
0.65
0.46
0.5
0.44
0.40
0.30
0.23
Slovak Republic
Italy
Czech Republic
Australia
Spain
Austria
Portugal*
Japan*
Canada*
Germany
France
Denmark
Finland
Sweden
United States
United Kingdom
0.0
20
Slovak Republic
-
Italy
18
Czech Republic
0.5
Australia
17
Spain
-
Austria
3
Portugal*
10
Japan*
-
Canada*
2.0
Germany
5
France
1.0
Denmark
1
Finland
Sweden
4
United States
United Kingdom
Poland scored
th
24
in 2009…
EU Innovation Scoreboard with
Intangible-tangible ratio
1.5
2
6
16
22
0.0
IPR
Ideas can be protected, but much is
.... unpatented R&D, business processes and skills in UK
Covered by IPRs, £bn
Not covered by IPRs, £bn
0
15
Artistic Originals
Branding
R&D
Software
Design
Workplace skills
Business Organisation
5
10
20
25
30
35
Patents are good for some
Very good… for very few
100%
Cumulative value of patents
90%
Single Patent
Intertwined Patents
Single patents:
Top 0.8% represents 42% of total patent value.
Top 3.5% represents 77%
80%
70%
Intertwined Patents:
Top 0.8% represents 52% of total patent value.
Top 6.1% represents 87.2%.
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Percentile of Patents
70%
80%
90%
100%
But far from all… by asset growth
Waste collection, treatment and disposal activities, materials
recovery
35%
Electricity, gas, steam and air conditioning supply
30%
Fishing and aquaculture
22%
Other mining and quarrying
-27%
Residential care activities
-35%
Activities of extraterritorial organisations and bodies
-39%
Having Trade Marks and Patents…
helps
Waste collection, treatment and disposal activities, materials
Insurance, reinsurance and pension funding
recovery
109%
35%
Electricity,
gas, steam
conditioning
supply production, sound
Motion picture,
videoand
andair
television
programme
recording
music publishing activities
Fishing
andand
aquaculture
30%
34%
22%
Food and beverage service activities
32%
Other mining and quarrying
Legal and accounting activities
Residential
Sewerage care activities
Extractionofofextraterritorial
crude petroleum
and naturaland
gasbodies
Activities
organisations
-27%
-31%
-35%
-32%
-41%
-39%
But Trade Marks alone add
®
And those designs?
Well… They’re not European
It’s complicated
“
I want to be in telecoms
-Ragnar Olson, yesterday
THICKETS
zarośla
“a dense web of overlapping
IP rights that a company must
hack its way through
in order to actually
commercialize new technology
-Carl Shapiro
PAE NPE Troll
But little to no PAE action in UK
What 2005 looked like in telecoms
HARRIS
MURATA MACHINERY
FUJI PHOTO FILM
NIPPON KOGAKU
CASIO COMPUTER
BOEING
OCE
AGILENT TECHNOLOGIES
HITACHI METALS
OKI ELECTRIC
AGERE SYSTEMS
VODAFONE
MITSUMI ELECTRIC
UNIV CALIFORNIA
AGENCY SCI TECH &
ITT MFG ENTERPRISES
NDS
ANDREW
DEUT TELEKOM
BOSCH ROBERT
NIPPON TELEGRAPH & TELEPHONE
MURATA MFG
TEKELEC US
SUMITOMO ELECTRIC INDUSTRIES
PIONEER
DIRECTV GROUP
ERICSSON
ZTE
SAMSUNG
TELECOM ITAL SPA
INFINEON TECHNOLOGIES
SONY
OKI DATA
TEXAS INSTRUMENTS
INNOVATIVE SONIC
ALCATEL LUCENT
UNITED VIDEO PROPERTIES
RIM
PHILIPS
KYOCERA WIRELESS
QUALCOMM
FUJITSU
FREESCALE SEMICONDUCTOR
SEIKO EPSON
BROTHER
MOTOROLA
SYMBOL TECHNOLOGIES
CANON
NOKIA
HP
MICROSOFT
FRAUNHOFER GES FORSCHUNG
EASTMAN KODAK
INTEL
SHARP
ST MICROELECTRONICS
XEROX
TELCORDIA
BROADCOM
MITSUBISHI
RICOH
GEN INSTR
AGFA GEVAERT
CISCO
TOSHIBA
AVAYA
IPWIRELESS
ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES
HITACHI
CIT ALCATEL
THOMSON LICENSING
NTT DOCOMO
IBM
AT & T
SIEMENS
ADC TELECOM
HITACHI CHEM
LUCENT TECHNOLOGIES
FRANCE TELECOM
MATSUSHITA
SCI ATLANTA
KONICA MINOLTA BUSINES
INTERDIGITAL
OMRON TATEISI ELECTRONICS
NEC
NORTEL
HUAWEI
OLYMPUS
APPLE
UTSTARCOM
LG
LOCKHEED
TOYOTA MOTOR
SPRINT SPECTRUM
KYOCERA
ALPS ELECTRIC
BRITISH TELECOMM
SK TELECOM
SKYWORKS SOLUTIONS
RISO KAGAKU
THOMSON BRANDT
NIPPON ANTENNA
FUJIFILM
KOREA ELECTRONICS TELECOMM
SANYO ELECTRIC
SANTERA SYSTEMS
RAYTHEON
CONEXANT SYSTEMS
HITACHI INT ELECTRIC
BRITISH BROADCASTING
TELECOMM SYSTEMS
What did it do to firms?
What did it do to firm entry…
Lost marginal entry into patent technology space
Telecom
135%
Computer Tech
118%
Audiovisual
114%
Digital Communication
105%
Semiconductors
100%
Medical technology
60%
Pharmaceuticals
Analysis/Biomatter
30%
0%
IP
IPR
THICKETS
IP
IPR
THICKETS
Thank you
dziękuję
[email protected]