Transcript Document

COMMON ETHICAL ISSUES
The global body for professional accountants
AGENDA
• Access to clients (beneficial owners) and
control of audits
• Serious issues on audit independence;
 Serving as director or officer of audit clients
 Undue financial dependence on audit clients
• Network firms and audit independence
• Other common independence issues
The global body for professional accountants
Access to clients (beneficial owners) and
control of audits
Common with international business company audit clients referred by
lawyers or corporate service providers
No contact with beneficial owners or manager of the business of audited
entity to:
• Obtain an understanding of business and associated risks for audit
planning and to communicate under ISA 260
• Understand the rationale behind existence of business and transactions
• Deal with evidential matters including on analytical reviews and
subsequent events and going concern reviews
• Communicate internal control deficiencies under ISA 265
• Obtain management representation letter and approval of financial
statements
The global body for professional accountants
Access to clients (beneficial owners) and
control of audits (Continued)
RESULTS IN FIRM NOT IN A POSITION TO
PROPERLY CONTROL THE AUDITS IN SERIOUS
BREACH OF ISA 220
The global body for professional accountants
Serious issues on audit independence
Serving as director or officer of audit client
Breach of s43(3) of Law 42(I)/2009 - None of the following individuals can
be appointed as statutory auditor:
• Officer, shareholder or an employee of the audit client
• Parent, Spouse, brother, sister or child of an officer
• Partner or employee of an officer of the audited entity
Breach of IFAC Code of Ethics (S290.146, s290.148 and s290.127 to
s290.132)
• Partners and employees
• Immediate family relations of partners
• Close family relations of partners
• Other close personal relatives
Common with international business company audit clients
The global body for professional accountants
Serious issues on audit independence
Undue financial dependence
• Significant proportion of firm’s income for one client or group of
connected clients
• Significant proportion of firm’s income from clients referred from a single
source
Common where all or significant proportion of the firm’s income from
international business company audit clients referred to the firm by one
lawyer or company services provider
No safeguards workable if dependence high
Breach of s220 of IFAC Code of Ethics
The global body for professional accountants
Network firms and audit independence
• Common with international business audit clients where fiduciary
services provided by another entity
• Paragraph 28 (2) of Law 42(I)/2009 states that a statutory auditor
or a statutory audit firm shall not carry out a statutory audit if there
is any direct or indirect financial or business or employment or
other relationship between the statutory auditor, the statutory audit
firm or network and the audited entity
• Paragraph 290.3 of the IFAC Code of Ethics states the term
“Firm” in section 290 includes network firm, except where
otherwise stated
The global body for professional accountants
Network firms and audit independence
(Continued)
•
s290.13 to s290.24 of IFAC Code of Ethics cover networks
•
Although two entities are legally separate entities, there may be facts and
circumstances that would suggest that they are associated in such a way
that a network exists (s290.14 of IFAC Code of Ethics)
•
The judgment as to whether the larger structure is a network shall be made
in light of whether a reasonable and informed third party would be
likely to conclude, weighing all the specific facts and circumstances,
that the entities are associated in such a way that a network exists (s290.15
of IFAC Code of Ethics)
•
Larger structure between audited entity and fiduciary services provider
aimed at co-operation
The global body for professional accountants
Network firms and audit independence
Common characteristics identified of networks:
 Common ownership (or immediate and close family relationships)
 Ownership of fiduciary services provider hidden behind firm’s employees
or relations or friends of practitioner / partners
 Virtually all clients of fiduciary services provider are audit clients of the
firm – Fiduciary services provider appears as extension of the audit firm
or as a separate department of the audit firm.
 The firm’s website promotes the services of the fiduciary services
provider as its own or as offered through associates or collaborators or
vice versa.
 Promotional activity (presentations and material) carried out jointly
offering respective services - one stop shop.
…
The global body for professional accountants
Network firms and audit independence
Common characteristics identified of networks:
 Invoices for services are issued by either the audit firm or fiduciary
services provider.
 Invoices show the same contact details for both entities.
 Joint statement of account to clients showing the transactions and
balances relating to both entities.
 A current account between the two entities and financial transfers
made between them for mutual financial support.
 The practitioner acts a signatory or has viewing rights on the bank
accounts of the fiduciary services provider
 Both entities share resources (e.g. staff, server etc.)
The global body for professional accountants
Other common independence issues:
 Acting as signatory on bank accounts of audit clients
 Book-keeping and accounts preparation services provided to audit
clients
 Long association of senior personnel with audit clients
 Key partner rotation on audits of public interest clients
The global body for professional accountants
ANY QUESTIONS ?
The global body for professional accountants
THANK YOU
The global body for professional accountants