Transcript Chapter 1

大學部 生態學與保育生物學學程 (必選)
2010 年 秋冬
溝通的演化
(The Evolution of Communication)
─動物行為學 (Ethology)
鄭先祐(Ayo)
國立 臺南大學 環境與生態學院
生態科學與技術學系 教授
Ayo NUTN Web: http://myweb.nutn.edu.tw/~hycheng/
Part 3. 個體間的互動
 生殖行為 (Reproductive Behavior)
 親代照顧與交配體系 (Parental Care and Mating




Systems)
溝通：管道與功能 (Communication: Channels and
Functions)
溝通的演化 (The Evolution of Communication)
衝突 (Conflict)
團體生活，利他和合作 (Group Living, Altruism,
and Cooperation)
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
2
15b 溝通的演化
Communication: Evolution
 The changing views of communication


Sharing information
Manipulating others
 Signals and honesty
 The evolutionary origins of signals


Retualization
Receiver-bias mechanisms
By Goodenough, McGuire, and Jakob
 Selective forces that shape signals
 Language and apes


What is language?
Ape language studies
 Communication and animal cognition (認知)
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
3
Views about communication are changing
 We can answer the questions of who, what, where, and
when of the communication process

But it is difficult to answer questions of how and why have
signals taken various forms that they have
 Communication involves the transmission of information
from one animal to others
 A cooperative view of communication: both sender and
receiver benefit from the accurate transfer of information


Selection should make signals efficient, reliable, and
unambiguous
Dishonest or inaccurate signaling was thought to be unlikely
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
4
Animals manipulate other animals
 The cooperative view of communication does not fit
every situation
 A sender might gain by sending an inaccurate signal


In a territorial dispute, the sender might bluff by sending
signals that exaggerate its willingness to escalate the
contest
A male competing for a female’s attention might
exaggerate his qualities
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
5
Dishonesty may benefit an animal
 An animal that gives a dishonest signal gains an
advantage

Over animals that honestly communicate their abilities or
intentions
 So, animals don’t communicate to convey information
 But to manipulate the behavior of others to their own
advantage
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
6
Signals: normally reliable, occasionally
deceptive
 An animal produces a signal when, on average, it
increases its own reproductive success


By influencing the behavior of others
For signals to evolve, they must benefit senders overall
 Senders may not be trustworthy
 If signals are potentially dishonest, why not just
ignore them?


On average, the receiver must benefit from responding
to signals
Even if it is sometimes deceived
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
7
When are honest signals likely?
 Four circumstances under which we expect to see
honest signals:




When senders and receivers share overlapping goals
When signals indicate something about the sender that
cannot be faked
When signals are costly to produce
When dishonest signalers can be identified
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
8
Honest signals: senders and receivers share
goals
 Natural selection favors unambiguous, honest signals for
coordination of mating activities
 The sexes share overlapping goals in the relationship
between parent and offspring

But even this relationship can entail significant conflict
 Altricial baby bird s(幼鳥) beg their parents to feed them

Baby birds stand, gape, flap their wings, and call
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
9
Honest communication
 Begging chicks are obvious to predators
 Begging too much, when food is not needed, is a poor
strategy
 Parents provide food to chicks that beg most vigorously
 Parents respond because their own fitness depends on the
survival of their offspring

Communication between baby birds and parents is honest
 Other examples of similar goals of the sender and receiver
 Belding’s ground squirrels call to warn relatives of a
predator
 Every bee benefits when scouts convey the location of a
patch flowers
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
10
Honest signals: signals cannot be faked
 Signals are honest because they are tightly linked to a
trait of the sender

The sender simply cannot fake the signal
 Size is a good predictor of fighting success
 Displays allow opponents to judge one another’s size
 Combatants(戰鬥人員) enhance their apparent size



Puffing up their feathers
Fluffing out their fur
Assuming an upright posture
 In other species, size is not so easily faked
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
11
Male stalk-eyed flies send honest signals
 During an aggressive display, these flies strike a pose
that


Allows each competitor to compare the length of its
eyestalks
Males with shorter eyestalks usually retreat without a
fight
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
12
Honest signals are linked to an animal’s
health
 Bright red and yellow feathers, scales, or fleshy necks
or combs of some birds


Depend on chemicals called carotenoids
Carotenoids must be obtained in the diet
 These bright colors honest signal of foraging ability
and health

Female house finches prefer brighter, redder males
 Females benefit from their choice
 Brighter males are better parents
 Bringing more food to the nestlings.
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
13
Honest signals: are costly to produce
 What prevents a male from exaggerating his qualities?
 Handicap principle (障礙原則): reliable signals are
favored when signals are costly to the sender

Their very extravagance indicates the owner’s qualities
 These signals are handicaps
 Their owners are perceived as doing well
 In spite of the handicap of investing in the signal
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
14
Criteria for a signal to evolve as a
handicap
 The signal must be costly
 It must relate to the quality of the sender
 The receiver must be interested in the quality of the
sender that is being signaled

And must benefit from attending to an honest signal
 Receivers benefit from correctly assessing the quality
of a signaler

Especially in the context of sexual selection
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
15
Signals may be costly
 Energetic costs are the most common measurements
 Oxygen consumption increases in insects and frogs
 Male red deer lose weight during the rut cost (發情代價)
 Other costs: decreased ability to move, escape, or forage
 Long tail feathers of male birds serve as sexual ornaments
 And impair their ability to fly
 Higher-quality senders can pay the cost of higher-quality
signals


Brighter colors, vigorous displays
Only male red deer in top physical condition can continue
roaring (咆嘯) to win the vocal duel (聲音對抗)
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
16
Honest signaling in the blue-footed booby
 Seabirds with brightly colored feet
 During their courtship ritual, boobies stand facing one
another

The male lifts his feet to display them to the female
 Males in good condition have bright blue-green feet
 Unfed males have dull blue feet
 Females prefer males with brightly colored feet
藍腳鰹鳥
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
17
 blue-footed booby (藍腳鰹鳥)
 blue penguins : Few penguin
interactions end in fighting
because they suffer flesh
wounds and sometimes eye loss
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
18
Signal costs also affect receivers
 In the form of the response of receivers to the signal
 Little blue penguins have aggressive displays that
differ in



Cost (risk of injury)
Effectiveness in deterring an opponent
Ability to predict an attack
 A penguin conveys information about its willingness to
sustain injury while performing the display

And its willingness to fight
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
19
Penguin displays are honest
 Because aggressive encounters are potentially costly
 Attempting to intimidate (威嚇) an opponent into
retreat could be costly

If the rival called the bluff (嚇唬)
 Penguin encounters begin with low-risk displays
 They escalate until one opponent retreats or a fight
occurs
 One “bidder” decides that the territory is not worth the
risk
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
20
Honest signals: dishonest signalers can
be identified
 A stable social unit favors honest communication
 Individuals both send and receive signals at different
time
 The advantages of sending dishonest signals would be
reversed


When the animal is the receiver
So honesty predominates in the population
 Members of social units recognize one another
 And learn whether a particular individual is honest
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
21
Vervet monkeys don’t believe dishonest
signalers
 Members of a social group stop believing an individual
that gives unreliable signals
 Vervet monkeys have two different calls that warn of
another group of monkeys on their territory

Monkeys stopped responding and no longer believed a liar
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
22
 Vervet monkey alarm calls that alert group members
of the approach of a neighboring troop are of two
types. The “chutter” warns that another group is
nearby. The “wrr” is given when another group is
spotted in the distance.
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
23
Dishonest signals: senders and receivers
have different goals
 Different goals set the stage for deception (欺騙)
 A father bird and his chick share the goal of the
chick’s survival


But the chick may want more parental investment than
the father would like to give
At the cost of his other chicks or his future reproduction
 Signals between parents and chicks are essentially
honest

But with some attempt by the chick at manipulation
and deceit
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
24
Some signals are bluffs (嚇唬)
 Honest signals can be corrupted by dishonest bluffs
 Stomatopods (mantis shrimps)蝦蛄 ferociously
defend their burrows
 Stomatopods have two appendages used in prey
capture and territorial defense
 Combatants may be injured or killed during battles
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
25
 Stomatopods
(mantis shrimps)
蝦蛄
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
26
Mantis shrimp (蝦蛄) signal their
readiness to attack
 Readiness to attack is signaled by a threat display
(meral spread)
 A newly molted stomatopod is defenseless


But still gives the meral spread display
Its opponent is deceived and retreats
 A stomatopod can get away with the bluff
 The receiver would pay dearly (付出昂貴代價) if it
tested the honesty of the signal
 The signal is stable because, on average, it is honest
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
27
Honest and dishonest signals coexist
 The costliness of signals can reinforce honesty
 When signals are generally honest
 A low level of deceit is stable and is expected to evolve
 Populations are in flux
 At any time dishonesty may spread
 A signal may be perceived by different receivers
 Some have the same goals as the sender (i.e. prospective
mate)
 Some have different goals (a competitor)
 A mixed signaling strategy, sometimes honest and
sometimes deceptive, may be best
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
28
The evolutionary origins of signals
 Two approaches may explain the evolutionary origins of
signals


Identifying the behaviors of the senders that form the raw
material for signals
 Ritualization
Focusing on how signals exploit the receiver’s sensory
biases
 Ability to detect some information better than others
 These two evolutionary pathways are not mutually
exclusive
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
29
Ritualization
 Many signals get their start as part of another behavior
 Or as a physiological response
 That takes on a signaling function later
 Ritualization: evolution favors modification of the
incipient signal

It becomes more stereotyped and unmistakable
 The three sources of raw material for signals are
1. Intention movements
2. Displacement activities
3. Autonomic responses
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
30
1. Intention movements
 Animals begin behavior patterns with characteristic
movements

That prepare them for action
 It is possible to judge what the animal intends to do
 A wolf pulls back its lips and bares its teeth before
biting
 It improves another wolf’s fitness if he correctly
interprets the bared teeth
 Rather than waiting to get bit
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
31
Avian displays originated with intention movements
 For flight or walking
 A bird about to fly crouches, points its beak, raises its
tail, and spreads its wings
 Components of the takeoff leap have been ritualized
into communicative signals
 The blue-footed booby incorporates “sky pointing”
into its courtship dance


This display originated in flight
But changed during ritualization
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
32
2. Displacement activities
 Irrelevant actions performed in situations in which an
animal has conflicting motivations and is thus
indecisive (無法決斷)
 Faced with an aggressor, an animal may have
conflicting motivations


To fight and to flee
So it may instead preen itself (鳥)用喙理(毛);
 Displacement activities are often incomplete actions
 Courtship is a time of conflicting tendencies
 Sexual partners must come together to mate
 In spite of aggressive tendencies that keep them apart
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
33
Displacement activities in male ducks
 Mock preening of the courtship displays of male ducks
 Originated in displacement preening
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
34
3. Autonomic responses
 The autonomic nervous system (自主神經系統)
regulates many basic body functions

Digestion, circulatory activities, heart rate, diameter of the
blood vessels, thermoregulation
 Displays may have originated from autonomic functions
 At times of stress or conflict
 The naked head or neck skin of turkey, jungle fowl, and
bateleur flush (發紅) and swell (腫脹)during stress
because of vasodilation

These changes are now part of signaling during courtship
and aggressive encounters
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
35
Evolution of signals from the respiratory system
 Modifications of the respiratory system
produce sound signals

And visual signals
 In inflation displays of birds, males fill
pouches with air to attract mates

The male frigate bird’s throat pouch
inflates to an enormous size and brilliant
color to attract females
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
36
Evolution of signals from thermoregulation
 Piloerection (erection of feathers and hair) traps heat
It is also a part of aggressive(攻擊) and appeasement(緩和)
displays
 A zebra finch that cannot escape from a dominant individual
 Fluffs its feathers as an appeasement signal
 Feather position can be part of courtship displays
 Tail-raising courtship display of the peacock (孔雀)
 In mammals the message’s meaning varies with the part of the
body on which hair is erected
 If all the hair is erect on tamarins (狨猴) : attack or be
indecisive
 If only the tail hair is erected: flee (逃走)

Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
37
 zebra finch
 tamarins (狨猴)
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
38
Other behaviors as raw materials for displays
 Ritualization is a highly opportunistic evolutionary
process

It can be launched from almost any behavior pattern,
anatomical structure or physiological change
 Predatory behaviors have been ritualized in the male
gray heron (灰鷺)



During courtship, he erects his crest and body feathers
Points his head downward and snaps his mandibles
closed
Movements are similar to those used during fishing
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
39
 Masked lovebirds
 gray heron (灰鷺)
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
40
Food exchange has also been ritualized
 The touching of bills is derived
from the parental feeding
 Is common in courtship and
appeasement display

Establishes or maintains bonds
 Masked lovebirds bill during
greetings and after a spat
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
41
Flight can also be ritualized
 Yellow-headed blackbirds and red-winged blackbirds
perform aerial displays to entice(誘惑) females

Ritualized flight is more conspicuous than normal flight
 Movements are accentuated and reveal plumage patterns
 Courtship displays of the fiddler crab evolved from the
movement of the male while entering his burrow
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
42
 Ritualized flight in blackbirds.
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
43
The ritualization process
 During the evolutionary process of ritualization
 Signaling behaviors become more stereotyped
 They may also change
 Slow down, speed up, become more exaggerated
 Anatomical features (colors, claws) might evolve to draw
attention to the display
 Emancipation (解放): behaviors that become freed from
the internal and external factors that originally caused them


The original triggers no longer cause the behavior to occur
The behavior has only a communicative function
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
44
Evolution of the whistle-shake in ducks
 The body-shake is the evolutionary precursor of the
whistle-shake in ducks

Serves to dry and rearrange the feathers
 Whistle-shakes resemble body shakes
 But are ended by the duck tilting(翹起) back its head and
emitting a trill (顫音)
 And are given in social situations
 Some signals are not completely emancipated from their
original causes

Whistle shakes are still given in response to water
sprays
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
45
Receiver-bias mechanisms
 Ritualization focuses on characteristics of the sender
 Sensory exploitation hypothesis: the receiver has a
preexisting preference for a particular signal

Features of the receiver’s nervous system makes it more
responsive to a particular form of stimulus
 The sender takes advantage of the receiver’s preexisting
sensory biases when new signals are evolving.

Evolution of swordtails (劍尾魚) in fish
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
46
Sensory bias in frogs
 Female túngara frogs prefer males with lower frequency
chuck calls
 Female túngara frogs benefit from their preference


Low-frequency chucks are produced by larger males
Resulting in more fertilized eggs
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
47
Sensory bias in water mites
 Male courtship signals have exploited the females’
sensory adaptations for prey detection

Water mite hunts by ambush
 When a courting male detects a female he moves his
legs


These vibrations mimic prey
Leading the female to grab him
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
48
Sender characteristics shape signals
 Anatomical structures form the foundation for
producing signals

i.e. sensory organs of electric fish
 Body form (i.e. size) influences signal design
 Small species not be visible, so other sensory modalities
are favored for long-distance communication
 Physical characteristics may evolve that enhance visual
signals (i.e. facial expression, erection of hair)
 Smaller species give more acrobatic (特技的) displays
 In vertebrates it influences vocalizations
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
49
Signal evolution does not happen in a vacuum
 Many signals are produced by structures that have other
functions


Body size, hair, beaks, and respiratory tracts are under
selection for other reasons
Besides their role in producing signals
 For example, beak shape in Darwin’s finches is
important in


Feeding behavior
Song production
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
50
Environmental characteristics affect the
choice of communication
 The habitat helps determine which channel of
communication (sound, chemical, visual, etc.) a
species uses
 Visual signals are not much use in the ocean’s depths

So whales rely on sound for long-distance
communication
 The habitat affects sound transmission
 Attenuation (weakening): how far the sound will carry
 Degradation: how distorted the signal becomes during
transmission
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
51
The acoustic adaptation hypothesis
 Acoustic properties of bird song are shaped by habitat structure
 Songs attenuate and degrade differently in different
environments
 Songs are more attenuated and degraded in dense foliage
 Lower frequencies become less distorted in dense foliage
 In habitats with complex vegetation structure
 Songs should have low frequencies, narrow bandwidths
 Whistles and long notes
 In open habitat (i.e. grasslands)
 Songs should have high frequencies and broad bandwidths
 Trills and short notes
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
52
Habitat structures influence bird songs
 Great tits have a large geographic distribution
 Forest dwellers sing songs with a lower pitch
 A narrower range of frequencies
 Fewer notes per phrase than open woodland birds
 No differences were found between other species in
different habitats


But a review of the literature (meta-analysis) shows that
Habitat structure weakly influences acoustic properties
of bird songs
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
53
Displays vary according to the background
 The environment influence transmission of other
channels of communication
 Visual signals differ in visually “noisy” versus plain
environments
 Many lizard species rely on visual displays

Head bobs, push-ups, back arching, extension of the
dewlap and tail flicks
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
54
Lizard displays and background motion
 Jacky lizard species that live in trees display faster and
flick their tails more

When it is windy and the vegetation moves
 Senders of signals may change their behavior when the
environment changes
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
55
 Jacky lizard
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
56
Habitat changes caused by humans
 Human activities alter the environment in which animals
communicate

And alter selection pressures on signal form
 Great tits do well in both urban and rural environments
 Urban birds sing shorter, faster songs with higher
minimum frequencies
 Most likely due to competition with the noise of the urban
background
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
57
Human-induced environmental changes
affect visual signals
 Visual signals can be impeded (阻礙)
 The Baltic Sea has grown turbid (cloudy)
 Making it harder for female stickleback fish to see
males
 Males have to court much more vigorously to get the
female’s attention
 The honesty of male signals is reduced because males
are not as likely to see each other
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
58
Receiver characteristics: sensory drive
 Sensory drive: the environment shapes receiver
characteristics
 Surfperch (海鯽) are marine fish that live in a variety of
habitats

Differing in light intensity and variability
 The retinas of surfperch species differ
 They are good at detecting differences in color contrast
 Or differences in brightness
 But not both
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
59
 Different optical habitats of related surfperch species.
 (left) live in an environment that is highly variable in light intensity.
Striped surfperch (right) live in deeper water in the kelp forest where
the background light is more even.
 Deepwater surfperch are better at detecting brightness differences
 Species living in shallow water can better see color differences
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
60
Language and apes
 Humans are very interested in what separates us from
other species


Tool use was thought to be confined to humans
But this is not the case
 Language seems to clearly be a talent confined to
humans



Which elements of language are unique to humans
Which are more broadly shared?
Are differences a matter of kind or degree?
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
61
True language has four elements
Words or signs must be used as true symbols
 That stand for, or take the place of, a real object, event,
person, action, or relationship
2. Symbols should permit reference to objects or events
 That are not present
3. There should be some elements of grammar (rules)
 That determine the relationship between words
 Changing the order of symbols alters the meaning of the
message
4. Words or signs should be combined to form novel phrases
 Or sentences that are understandable to others
1.
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
62
Early studies taught chimps to talk
 Researchers have studied the ability of great apes
(chimpanzees, western (lowland) gorillas orangutans,
bonobos) to learn language
 A chimp named Viki was taught to say three words

“Mama,” “papa,” and “cup”
 These attempts failed
 Chimpanzees lack the vocal apparatus to make the
range of sounds of human speech
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
63
Studies taught chimps nonverbal languages
 Washoe, a young chimpanzee, was taught American Sign
Language (ASL)
 Washoe and other chimps were reared like human
children


Spoken English was not allowed
Washoe had a vocabulary of 132 signs
 Her signs were not restricted to requests
 She applied them correctly to a wide variety of referents
 She extended the sign for dog from a picture to all pictures
of dogs, living dogs, and even the barking of an unseen dog
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
64
Washoe signs with ASL
Washoe combines signs to denote “water bird” for a
swan
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
65
Stop and think:
 Do you agree that the best way to test whether apes
have linguistic skills is to incorporate them into human
society as much as possible?
 What are the advantages and disadvantages of this
approach?
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
66
Koko, Chantek and Nim Chimpsky
 A gorilla named Koko and an orangutan named Chantek
were taught ASL



Spoken English was permitted
Emphasized the production of language (the use of signs)
Not comprehension (understanding the meaning of signs)
 Nim Chimpsky a young male chimp, was accused of
imitating his trainers


But Nim’s language abilities were stunted(受礙) by the
operant-conditioning procedures used in his training
And Nim’s trainers changed so often that he could not form
the relationships essential for language development
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
67
It was accepted that chimpanzees could
not learn language
 But when other trainers worked with Nim
 His language skills improved
 Chantek’s signs were more spontaneous
 Could not be attributed to imitation
 Washoe and the other language-trained chimps
 Signed to other animals and objects
 And frequently to themselves
 Washoe adopted a ten-month-old infant named Loulis
 Loulis learned his first 55 signs by observing other chimps
 Washoe and her family signed to one another their daily
activities (playing, eating, family fights)
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
68
Sarah used plastic chips as words
 The chimpanzee Sarah used a particular
plastic chip as a word


To complete a preformed statement
She arranged four to five words into a
sentence
 Sarah named many objects and used
complicated relationships

Such as if-then and same-different
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
69
The LANA Project
 A chimpanzee named Lana was trained to use a
computer to communicate

Eliminating social cueing and the difficulty of
interpreting symbols
 Lana communicated in Yerkish, a symbolic language
 Yerkish words (lexigrams) are geometric figures
 Pressing a computer key labeled with the lexigram
selects words
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
70
The LANA Project
 Lexigrams had to be used
in an appropriate order


Lana had to learn syntax rules governing word order
She developed a large
vocabulary and mastered
grammar
 She also coined new words
 She called an orange soda a
“Coke-which-is-orange”
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
71
Apes learn words in various forms
 To refer to objects not present
 Stringing words together in short sequences
 Follow rules of grammar
 They coin new words
 But do apes use words as symbols?
 When a chimp uses a “word” (sign, plastic chip, or
lexigram) to name an object
 Is it used as a symbol that stands for the object
 Or is it a label that is associated with the object through
a reward system?
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
72
Using “words” as true symbols
 Two chimpanzees, Sherman and Austin communicated
with each other symbolically

By pressing computer keys with lexigrams
 The emphasis was on interanimal communication,
 They were not taught to produce strings of lexigrams
 Or to adhere to grammatical rules
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
73
Chimps communicate with each other
 Sherman and Austin specify foods to one another using
lexigrams


They communicate with each other
Regardless of which of them is the observer
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
74
Chimps use symbols in communication
 To inform each other of the appropriate tool to use to
solve a problem

Clearly using words as symbols and not simply labeling
objects
 This shifted the emphasis from demonstrating that apes
can produce language


To showing that they can understand symbols or words
of language
It also showed how important the learning environment
is in developing language comprehension
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
75
Kanzi and Panbanisha
 Bonobo (pygmy) chimpanzees
 Kanzi was adopted and raised by Matata
 And was always present during Matata’s training
sessions
 After Kanzi was separated from Matata
 He used symbols on the keyboard that they had tried to
teach to Matata
 Not only did he know the lexigrams
 He also knew the English words that the lexigrams
represented
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
76
Kanzi has a large vocabulary
 Kanzi learned communication skills by observing his
mother’s training

Much the same way as a child would
 Panbanisha, Kanzi’s half-sister
 Was reared in the same learning environment as Kanzi
 She, too, shows remarkable comprehension of spoken
English
 Reward-based language training was stopped and
replaced with conversation

Kanzi’s human companions served as communicative
models
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
77
Kanzi learned symbols through observation
• Kanzi observed and interacted with humans who used
gestures and lexigrams to communicate
Kanzi communicates using a board with 256 lexigrams
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
78
Kanzi and others understand spoken
English
 Besides being able to produce language
 Kanzi was not trained to vocalize
 But spontaneously makes sounds with different content
 Chimpanzees utter natural sounds when they find food
 Producing distinct grunts when encountering different
foods
 This skill is found in other animals besides apes
 Including vervet monkeys and even chickens
 Ape communication fulfills the four requirements of
language
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
79
Communication and animal cognition
 Do nonhuman animals have thoughts or subjective
feelings?


Are they are aware of other animals’ feelings?
Are they cognitive, conscious, aware beings?
 Tapping animals’ communication lines can indicate
whether animals have conscious thoughts or feelings


If nonhuman animals thoughts and feelings
They probably communicate them to others through
their communication signals
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
80
Evidence of cognition: forming mental
representations
 Of objects or events that are out of sight
 Some animal signals are symbolic
 They refer to things that are not present
 Some animals learn a language that uses symbols
 i.e. apes
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
81
Other species understand symbols
 Alex the parrot could vocally request more than 80 items
 Even if they were out of sight
 He could quantify and categorize these objects
 He understood the concepts of color, shape, and same versus
different for both familiar and novel objects
 Bottlenosed dolphins also understand symbolic languages
 “Words” are gestures or are generated by a computer
 They can refer to objects, actions, and relationships
 Dolphins understand experimenter’s references to objects that
are not present
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
82
Evidence of cognition(認知): natural
communication systems
 Language involves the ability to relate words to
meanings
 In some species, individuals classify signals by their
meaning

Not by some obvious physical property (the way a signal
sounds)
 When a rhesus monkey finds food
 It announces this with one or more of five different food
calls
 A different type of call announces if the item is of high
quality or rare
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
83
Classifying calls by meaning or sound
 Animals habituate (gradually stop responding) to a
stimulus that is repeated many times without
consequence
 If monkeys classify a food call by its sound

After habituating to one type of call they still respond to
any other type of call because it sounds different
 If they classify a food call by its meaning
 They will be unresponsive to a call in the same category
 But remain responsive to a call in a different category
 Rhesus monkeys classify calls by their meaning.
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
84
Evidence of cognition: understanding
mental states of others
 Does a communicating animal understand what
potential receivers know?

Vervet monkeys apparently do not
 Mother vervet monkeys give alarm calls when they
sense a predator

But do not take into account whether their offspring
are ignorant or knowledgeable about the predator
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
85
Langurs call to their audience
 Male Thomas langurs give alarm calls
 But only if there is an audience
 Males call persistently after spotting a predator
 Stopping only when every other member in the group
also gave an alarm call
 Callers seem to keep track of all the other members in
their groups
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
86
Ethical ramifications of cognition in
animals
 The question of animal awareness is difficult to answer
scientifically
 The answer has ethical ramifications




If the line between animals and humans is erased or even
smudged a bit, should we rethink the way we treat animals?
Should we keep them in zoos?
Should great apes be used for language studies?
What about dolphins?
 So what’s your opinion?
 Are animals aware, cognitive beings? All of them?
 Where do we draw the line?
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
87
Summary
 Signals should be honest, unambiguous and informative
 Sometimes the sender of a signal benefits from being dishonest
On average, a sender manipulates the behavior of others to its
own advantage
 Receivers should respond to signals when they benefit from
them, on average, even if they are sometimes deceived
 Conditions for honest signals (1) senders and receivers share
overlapping goals, (2) they cannot be faked, (3) they are costly
to produce, and (4) dishonest signalers can be identified
 Conditions that favor dishonest signals (1) senders and receivers
have different goals, (2) they are costly to assess or to challenge

Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
88
Summary
 Honest and dishonest signals can coexist in a population
 Signals originate through ritualization and sensory exploitation
 Evolutionary sources of ritualization (1) intention movements,
(2) displacement activities, and (3) autonomic responses
 The design of the signal may be influenced by the anatomy and
physiology of the sender and the habitat
 Most animal communication signals are not true language
 They do not use symbols that can replace their referent
 They do not string signals together to form novel sentences
 Researchers have attempted to teach apes language
 Some animals understand signals that represent unseen items
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
89
問題與討論
[email protected]
 Ayo 台南 NUTN 站
http://myweb.nutn.edu.tw/~hycheng/
Ayo 教材 (動物行為學 2010)
90