Student Discipline Task Force
Download
Report
Transcript Student Discipline Task Force
Downtown School Parent Educational Event
February 19, 2013
Principal, Noreen Barthelmes
1
“In summary, there is considerable evidence that
involvement in bullying, as a victim, bully, or
bully-victim is associated with serious short-term
and long-term psychological and academic
consequences” (Swearer, Espelage, & Napolitano, 2009)
Bullying has been related to academic deficits
(Crick & Grotpeter, 1995, Murray-Close, Ostrov, & Crick, 2007, Prinstein,
Boergers, & Vernberg, 2001)
Reduced attendance rates, increased illnesses,
and even death
2
Statutory Definitions and Key Vocabulary
Working Definition
WB
3
Bullying means “any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act
or conduct, including communications made in writing or by
means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts
committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Education
Code Sections 48900.2 (sexual harassment), 48900.3 (hate
violence), or 48900.4 (harassment, threats and intimidation),
directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be
reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the
following: (a) placing a reasonable pupil(s) in fear of harm to
that pupil's or those pupils' person or property; (b) causing a
reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental
effect on his or her physical or mental health; (c) causing a
reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with his
or her academic performance; or (d) causing a reasonable pupil
to experience substantial interference with his or her ability to
participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or
privileges provided by a school” (Education Code Section
48900(r)).
4
Severe
Pervasive
Physical or verbal act/conduct
Written/electronic communication
Impact on the reasonable pupil
◦ Fear of harm (person or property) or
◦ Substantial interference with:
academic performance
participation in or benefit from school services,
activities, or privileges
MH
5
Bullying is generally not:
◦ Pesky and annoying behaviors that occur
occasionally
◦ Physical “rough housing” that regularly occurs
during the normal course of physical games or play
◦ Telling another that: you don’t like them, don’t
want to be their friend anymore, to get lost, etc.
◦ Acting in a mean, rude, unfriendly, or disrespectful
way
◦ Teasing, telling bad jokes, refusing to play with
someone…
These are poor behaviors that should be
appropriately dealt with, but not bullying!
6
Severe or pervasive verbal or physical
misconduct that would impact a
reasonable pupil resulting in either:
(1) fear of harm (person or property); or
(2) substantial interference with either:
(a) academic performance; or
(b) participation in or benefit from
services, activities, or privileges.
Note: California’s legal definition of bullying makes no reference
to a power imbalance between the bully and his/her victim.
MH
7
Victims report increased loneliness, greater school avoidance,
more thoughts of suicide, and less self-esteem (Hawker &
Boulton, 2000; Kochenderfer & Ladd, 1996).
Bullies report lower levels of school belonging and higher levels
of delinquent behavior (Espelage & Holt, 2001; Haynie, Nansel,
& Eitel, 2001).
Bully-victims are more hyperactive, more likely to be referred
for psychiatric consultation than peers (Nansel et al. 2001;
Nansel, Haynie & Simons-Morton, 2003), report higher levels of
depression (Swearer et al, 2001), and have lower grades than
both bullies and victims (Graham et. al. 2006)
Bystanders to bullying report feelings of anxiety and insecurity
(Rigby & Slee, 1993)
MG
8
Bully is the person perpetrating the conduct
listed in the bullying definition
Relational Aggressor means a bully that uses
social manipulation to harm others by
gossiping, threatening to withdraw
friendships, or using social exclusion (Leff,
Waasdorp, & Crick, 2010)
MH
9
A victim of bullying is a person physically or
psychologically abused by a peer who is
intentionally aggressive either in a severe
manner or repeatedly and over time (see Olweus,
1993)
Bully-Victim means a student who reports
both being a victim of bullying and being a
perpetrator of bullying.
MH
10
Out of the pool of four scenarios (#1 - #4),
assign each table two scenarios (Maximum
time: 10 minutes)
Table Reports. Objective: Identify the
specific facts in the scenario that support a
determination the conduct is or is not
bullying
MH
11
Transmission, by means of an electronic device,
including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless
telephone, or other wireless communication device,
computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but
not limited to, any of the following: (a) a message, text,
sound, or image; (b) a post on a social network Internet
Web site including, but not limited to: (1) posting to or
creating a burn page; (2) creating a credible
impersonation of another actual pupil or (3) creating a
false profile (Education Code 48900(r)).
Note: An electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct
solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the Internet or is
currently posted on the Internet (Education Code 48900(r)).
MH
12
Bullying
by an electronic act
Burn page
Credible impersonation
False profile
MH
13
Severe, pervasive, or persistent conduct that involves.
Sending cruel, vicious, or threatening messages.
Creating web sites with stories, pictures, and jokes
that ridicule others based on hatred or bias.
Breaking into an e-mail account and sending vicious or
embarrassing material to others.
Taking a picture (e.g., revealing) in the locker room
with a phone camera and sending it out.
MH
14
Repeated exposure over time to negative actions or acts
of aggression and intimidation.
Verbal, written, graphic, digital, or other physical conduct relating to a
student’s race, national origin, religion, color, disability, sexuality, or
gender1 that is severe, pervasive, or persistent.
Unprovoked, intentional, and usually repeated acts many of which may be
carried out by means of an electronic act and include:
Emotionally-based behavior (spreading rumors, manipulating social relationships,
rejecting, excluding, degrading, extorting, or intimidating);
Verbally-based behavior (taunting, malicious teasing, name calling, racial slurs,
insults, threatening, demanding money, property, or some service to be
performed); and Physically-based behavior (hitting, kicking, spitting, pinching,
pushing, excessive tickling).
1
See glossary for complete list of “protected classes”
MH
15
Indirect bullying that is severe, pervasive, or persistent.
such as:
Rejecting, excluding or isolating the target(s);
Humiliating the target(s) in front of friends;
Manipulating friends and relationships;
Sending hurtful or threatening e-mail or notes; and
Developing a Website to taunt or degrade a target and
inviting others to post humiliating notes or messages
MH
16
“School climate is emerging as an extremely important influence on
bullying/victimization” (Swearer, Espelage, & Napolitano, 2009).
Schools that emphasize learning to include a positive school climate
show a decrease in aggression and other school-related problems
(Kasen et al, 2004).
Bullies are sometimes viewed in a positive and influential manner by
their peers (Rose, Swenson, & Waller 2004). Bullies can reap benefits.
Prevention frameworks and programs that attempt to abate bullying
are increasing emphasizing improving school climate to stop the
reinforcement of bullying behavior or bullying perpetration (Cohen,
2006)
TF
17
A positive school climate including teacher,
classmate, and school support can buffer the
distress resulting from bullying; parent support
can also help (Davidson, & Demaray, 2007)
TF
18
Maintain a positive, collaborative school
climate
Clearly define behavioral expectations to
include: (1) rules against bullying and (2)
positive alternative behaviors
Use consistent processes for teaching and
acknowledging appropriate behavior
Help students and staff identify and label
bullying behaviors
Develop appropriate behavioral expectations
for bystanders
TF19
Bystander is an individual who lacks participation in bullying
scenarios as either the bully or the victim.
Teach bystander students to avoid laughing, watching or
otherwise rewarding the bully, but instead to support the victim,
to otherwise intervene and to report bullying (Bystanders may be
present when bullying occurs more than 80% of the time; a
bystander may serve to reinforce or sustain the bullying behavior;
the bullying is abated about half the time when bystanders
intervene)
Methods used in bullying prevention and intervention programs
include: awareness building, modeling, skill building, and roleplaying
TF
20
School-wide Positive Behavior Support Program
created by staff, students, and parents
◦ Be Respectful
◦ Be Responsible
◦ Be Safe
Systematic reinforcement for students exhibiting
positive behavioral expectations
Bully Prevention Component
◦ Stop
◦ Walk
◦ Talk
21
Keenan West, recording artist and activist
Friday, Feb. 22
K-2 8:30 AM
3-5 9:05 AM
6-8 10 AM
7 Courageous Actions
www.pacer.org
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=pl
ayer_detailpage&v=8Hj_-kcX3q8
22
After receiving a notice of suspected bullying behavior,
the Principal/Coordinator initiates a prompt, impartial
investigation of a bullying allegation regardless of
whether a formal complaint has been filed.
Interview all individuals who are relevant or potentially
relevant to the investigation (e.g., student complaining
or potential victim[s]), the person accused of bullying,
anyone who witnessed the reported bullying, and
anyone mentioned as having relevant information).
Take other steps such as reviewing any records, notes,
or statements related to the bullying and visiting the
location(s) of alleged bullying.
RR
23
Describe what conduct constitutes bullying
Give alleged bully an opportunity to describe the
incident(s)
Communicate bullying is prohibited
Give notice to cease any misconduct and process other
disciplinary actions as appropriate
Communicate that retaliation is prohibited, there will be
consequences, and follow up monitoring
As appropriate, inform of interim measures involving
that person
RR
24
If bullying was found to have occurred, what decisions
or actions are supported by the evidence?
Review the evidence and determine if the District
Discipline Code has been violated (District Code,
Education Code 48900 et seq.) (Suspension and
expulsion for bullying applies only to students in
grades 4-8).
Set a schedule to monitor potential reoccurrence of
bullying and retaliation.
RR
25
To judge the severity of the bullying consider:
◦ How the misconduct affected student(s) education
◦ The type, frequency, and duration of the misconduct
◦ The identity, age, and sex of the harasser and the student who
complained, and the relationship between them
◦ The number of persons engaged in the harassing conduct and at
whom the bullying was directed
◦ The size of the school, location of the incidents, and context in
which they occurred
◦ Other incidents at the school involving different students
RR
26
Bullying: What is it? What isn’t it? What are
you doing about it?
Summary, Questions, Closing Comments
Bullying: Why it matters?
Bullying: What is it?
Cyberbullying: What is it?
Examples of bullying and cyberbullying
Ways to create a safe, bully-free environment
What to do when you suspect or become aware of
bullying
All
27