What are we testing… when we think we are testing listening?
Download
Report
Transcript What are we testing… when we think we are testing listening?
John Field
Universities of Bedfordshire and Cambridge
ISLI, University of Reading
12th November, 2013
With thanks to Cambridge English
language assessment and the ISLC,
University of Reading, for their
support for the research cited here
A theme of the talk
Teachers and EFL materials writers tend to favour standard
test formats: partly to prepare learners for international
tests and partly through lack of alternatives
But the needs of teachers and the designers of international
high stakes tests are clearly very different
Testers aim for:
Reliability (avoiding ‘subjective judgement’)
Ease of marking
Teachers / local testers need:
In depth information about the listening skills of individual
learners so that testing can lead into instruction.
What do we think we test?
Comprehension.
So what do we mean by comprehension?
‘Understanding’
Understanding what?
Giving correct answers to comprehension questions
What do we think we test? 2
‘Listening for gist’
‘Listening for information’
‘Listening for main idea’
‘Local listening’
‘Global listening’
What do we think we test? 3 [CEFR B2 goals]
‘Can understand standard spoken language, live or broadcast, on
both familiar and unfamiliar topics normally encountered in
personal, social, academic or vocational life. Only extreme
background noise, inadequate discourse structure and/or
idiomatic usage influence the ability to understand
Can understand the main ideas of propositionally and
linguistically complex speech on both concrete and abstract
topics delivered in a standard dialect, including technical
discussions in his/her field of specialisation
Can follow extended speech and complex lines of argument
provide the topic is familiar and the direction of the talk is
signposted by explicit markers’..
OK, so…
That tells me what L2 listeners should aim for
under my teaching/ testing…
But how are they supposed to get there?
These descriptors define the input or output in
listening, but say nothing about the process we are
trying to test.
They cannot be said to support assessment for
learning.
A cognitive account
The need for a cognitive approach
There is a new interest among testers in what goes on
in the mind of the test taker.
We need to know whether high-stakes test actually
test what they claim to test. Can a listening test, for
example, accurately predict the ability of a test taker to
study at an English medium university?
At local level, we need to use tests to diagnose learner
problems so that the tests can feed into learning. This
is especially true of listening.
Cognitive validity asks…
Does a test elicit from test takers the kind of process
that they would use in a real-world context? In the
case of listening, are we testing the kinds of process
that listeners would actually use ?
Or do the recordings and formats that we use lead test
takers to behave differently from the way they would in
real life?
Two possible approaches
A. Ask learners to report on the processes they
adopted when taking a test (e.g. by explaining how
they got their answers)
B. Use a model of listening that is supported by
evidence from psychology. Match the processes
produced by a test against the model.
Listening to learners
Learner report 1: Location
Item: A demand for golf courses attracted the interest of both
………… and businessmen.
Key: There was … enormous interest amongst landowners not to
mention businessmen
S: I think I um + I the key words. I think most + most useful for
me is the ‘businessmen’
R: right
S: because when I heard this before + I heard I heard
‘landowners’ and ‘businessmen’
R: so you you recognised the the word ‘landowners’
S: oh yeah
R and [it was] close to the word ‘businessmen’
S: yeah this is ever close so I think maybe
Conclusion
Test takers listen out for words from the (written)
items in order to locate where the answer is likely
to be.
Learner Report 2: order
R: is there anything that you heard that helped you?
S: I have the problem about that because I am
concentrate on the two of the questions so …I didn’t
realise
R: so
S: his his + he’s already go to the 9
R: right ok so you were still listening out for number 8
S: yeah and number 7
Professional Development for IATEFL 2013
15
Conclusions
Learners recognise and exploit the convention that
questions are asked in the same order as the recording.
This provides them with a rough sequential outline of
the recording before they even begin to listen.
If a listener fails to find the answer to one question,
he/she may go on to miss the answer to the next one as
well..
Professional Development for IATEFL 2013
16
What a written set of items provides
The items in (e.g.) a gap-filling task potentially provide a
candidate with:
An outline of what the recording covers
A set of gapped sentences that follow the sequence of
the recording
Key words with which to locate information
Sequences which may echo the wording of the recording
or the order of words
Learner report 3: prominent words
Correct answer: Tom suggests that golf courses could
also be used as NATURE RESERVES’
S: number 13 is I’m not sure but um + he said ‘crack’
R: you heard the word ‘crack’?
S: crack …but I don’t know the meaning of ‘crack’
R: er you know it seemed to be an important word
S: yes I think so
R: ok + how did you spell ‘crack’ if if you don’t know the
S: c-r-a-c-k
R: right so you guessed the spelling did you?
S: I guess yes
Most importantly, courses should be designed to attract
rather than drive away wildlife.
Professional Development for IATEFL 2013
18
Conclusion
Learners sometimes simply listen out for prominent
words – even if they do not understand them.
This is partly a reflection of their level. At level B1 and
below, listeners are very dependent upon picking up
salient words rather than chunks or whole utterances.
This tendency is increased by the use of gap filling tasks,
which focus attention at word level.
Professional Development for IATEFL 2013
19
General conclusions
a. Conventional test formats provide much more
information than is available in real-world contexts
(and do so in a written form) BUT…
b. Conventional test formats may also be more
demanding than real-life listening because of divided
attention effects, where the learner has to read and
listen or read, write and listen.
Recordings
Does the input impose similar listening demands to
those of a real-world speaker?
Natural speech ( Recording Level B2)
To what extent do these recordings resemble
authentic everyday speech?
Recording origin
Authentic
Scripted
Semi-scripted / re-recorded
Improvised
‘All tests are based on authentic situations’ Cambridge
ESOL PET Handbook
Why re-recorded material?
Exam Boards prefer this type because it enables them to
‘ Reduce noise’
Control speech rate
Simplify vocabulary and grammar if necessary
Introduce distractors
Eliminate redundancy (or add it with single-play tasks)
Some conclusions on studio recordings
Actors adapt their delivery to fit punctuation.
They pause regularly at the ends of clauses
There are few hesitation pauses.
No overlap between speakers
Speaker variables
Accent
Speech rate: speed and consistency
Pausing
Level and placing of focal stress
Number of speakers
Pitch of voice; familiarity of voice
Precision of articulation
Normalisation and testing L2 listening
Test takers need time to adjust (normalise) to the voice of
an unfamiliar speaker. Best not to focus questions on the
opening 10 seconds of a longer recording.
Because of the need to normalise, it is best not to have too
many speakers in a test recording. Listening difficulty
increases as the number of voices increases beyond one M
and one F (Brown & Yule, 1983).
Adapting to voices is cognitively demanding. Testers must
bear in mind the cognitive demands of normalising to
speech rate and voice pitch . Is it fair to add to those
demands by featuring a variety of accents?
Tasks
Does the task elicit processes which resemble those
that a listener would use in a real-world listening
event?
Task types in international tests
Multiple-choice
Gap filling
True/False/Don’t know
Multiple matching: Identify which of the five speakers
is a lorry driver / a politician / a musician
Visual multiple choice
Examination boards recognise that all of these have their
drawbacks - which is why they argue for a mixture of
tasks
Multiple choice questions
You hear an explorer talking about a journey he’s
making. How will he travel once he is across the
river?
A. by motor vehicle
B. on horseback
C. on foot
(FCE Handbook, 2008: 60)
Recording 1 (FCE Sample Test 1:1)
The engine’s full of water at the moment, it’s very
doubtful if any of the trucks can get across the
river in this weather. The alternative is to carry all
the stuff across using the old footbridge, which is
perfectly possible …and then use horses rather
than trucks for the rest of the trip all the way
instead of just the last 10 or 15 kilometres as was
our original intention. We can always pick up the
vehicles again on the way down…
Recording 1 (FCE Sample Test 1:1)
The engine’s full of water at the moment, it’s very
doubtful if any of the trucks can get across the
river in this weather. The alternative is to carry all
the stuff across using the old footbridge, which is
perfectly possible …and then use horses rather
than trucks for the rest of the trip all the way
instead of just the last 10 or 15 kilometres as was
our original intention. We can always pick up the
vehicles again on the way down…
Conclusion
Conventional formats require the listener to:
Map from written information to spoken
Eliminate negative possibilities as well as identify
positive ones (esp with MCQ and T/F)
Read and write as well as listen (esp gap filling)
Engage in complex tasks which take us well beyond
listening (esp. multiple matching)
The task: solutions
for the teacher / local tester
Suggestions for using conventional tasks
Provide items after a first playing of the recording and
before a second. This ensures more natural listening,
without preconceptions or advance information other
than general context.
Keep items short. Loading difficulty on to items
(especially MCQ ones) just biases the test in favour of
reading rather than listening.
Items should avoid echoing words in the recording
Favour tasks (e.g. multiple matching) that allow items
to ignore the order of the recording and to focus on
global meaning rather than local detail.
More natural tasks
Ignore the questions in the coursebook or present them
orally.
Ask questions and get answers in the first language
Use whole class oral summary (What have you
understood so far?), then replay the recording
At lower levels of English, ask learners to transcribe
small parts of a recording
At higher levels, use note-taking and reporting back
Get learners to work in pairs and compare notes
Items:
What to target in a listening test?
Five phases of listening (Field 2008)
Decoding
Speech signal
Words
Word search
Parsing
Meaning construction
Meaning
Discourse construction
38
Targets
An item in a test can target any of these levels:
Decoding:
She caught the (a) 9.15 (b) 9.50 (c) 5.15 (d) 5.50 train.
Lexical search:
She went to London by …….
Factual information:
Where did she go and how?
Meaning construction:
Was she keen on going by train?
Discourse construction.
What was the main point made by the speaker?
Targeting levels of listening
In theory, a good test should target all levels of listening
in order to provide a complete picture of the test taker’s
command of all the relevant processes.
In practice, higher levels may be too demanding in the
early stages of L2 listening. Novice listeners focus quite
heavily on word-level decoding, which does not leave
them enough spare attention to give to wider meaning.
In addition, certain test formats may tap almost
exclusively into one level. Gap-filling is a good example
Higher-level listening
Higher processes (Field 2008)
PROPOSITION
ENRICH
MEANING
MEANING REPRESENTATION
HANDLE INFO
DISCOURSE REPRESENTATION
Implications for testing
Questions may and should be asked at three levels:
Factual: local information
Meaning in context: requiring the listener to relate
what the speaker says to the context or to draw
conclusions which are not expressed by the speaker
Discourse: showing a global understanding of what
was said (including speaker intentions etc.)
Meaning representation
The listener has to:
Relate what was said to its context
Enrich the meaning (drawing upon world
knowledge)
Make inferences
Resolve reference (she, it, this, did so)
Interpret the speaker’s intentions
All of these indicate possible question types
Discourse building / handling information
Choose
Connect
Is it important? Is it relevant?
How is it linked to the last utterance?
Compare
Is what I think I heard consistent
with what was said so far?
Construct
What is the overall line of argument?
Spread of targets
Why is information handling omitted in
present test design?
Choose: the tester chooses which information points
to focus on – sometimes choosing points that are not
central to the recording
Connect: Much testing focuses on single points, with
no connection to those before and after
Compare: Tests rarely ask learners to check
information (for example, comparing two accounts of
an accident)
Construct. Tests rarely seek for evidence that learners
can construct an outline based upon macro-and micro
points / headings and subheadings
Solutions for local testers
Ask questions at discourse level:
What is the main point of the recording? / Give three
main points.
What is the connection between Point A and Point B?
Complete a skeleton summary of the text with main
points and sub-points
Ask learners to compare two recordings for similarities
and differences
Ask learners to summarise a recording orally or in the
form of notes (in L1 or L2)
Some thoughts on teacher testing of
listening and its impact on teaching
The inflexibility of high stakes tests
Large scale high-stakes tests have major constraints
which prevent them from testing listening in a way
that fully represents the skill.
Reliability and ease of marking
Highly controlled test methods, using
traditional formats that the candidate knows
Little attention possible to individual variation
or alternative answers
Advantages of more local tests and tasks
Local smaller-scale tests afford the possibility of
testing a wider rage of listening processes with:
• More open ended questions
• More scope for testing information handling
• Marking on an individual basis
• Possible acceptance of alternative answers
Progress testing / diagnostic teaching
Properly designed, progress tests might enable the
tester to diagnose specific listening problems.
In a follow up (ideally soon after), the teacher/tester
can ask: Why did you give that answer? What do you
think you heard?
In this way, a test can help to determine which
aspects of listening should be focused on in later
small-scale practice exercises.
In other words, this kind of test can be formative
rather than just judgemental.
References
Field, J. (2008) Listening in the Language Classroom.
Cambridge: CUP
Field, J. (2009). The cognitive validity of the lecture
listening section of the IELTS listening paper. IELTS
Research Reports 9, Cambridge
Field, J. (2013) Cognitive validity. In Geranpayeh, A. &
Taylor, L. (eds.) Examining Listening. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press
Thanks for listening!
[email protected]
What makes listening a special case?
Transitory: no long-term record to refer to
Happens in real time
Need to store while analysing
Need to carry forward information in the
mind
Speech rate is not under listener's control
Few word boundary markers
The speech signal is highly variable as
compared to spelling / fonts.
Two consequences of high variability
Knowledge of a word recognition of the word in
connected speech
Many high level errors of comprehension have their
origins in low-level errors of word recognition