Transcript Minnesota State Colleges and Universities Facilities Division

Sustainability Energy Benchmarking
B3
LEED – Leadership Energy and
Environmental Design
Chief Financial and Facilities Officers Meeting
January 27, 2010
The Minnesota State Colleges and Universities system is an Equal Opportunity employer and educator.
2010 System Action Plan
• System Strategic Goal 4.2
Reward and support institutions, administrators, faculty
and staff for innovations that advance excellence and
efficiency
• Energy Conservation
1. Develop a comprehensive environmental sustainability
policy for Board adoption
2. Publish procedures and standards for sustainable
planning, design, construction and operation of
facilities
3. Develop a System-wide energy benchmarking system
Slide 2
4. Report system accomplishments to the Board
2010 System Action Plan – status
1. Policy – under development
2. Design & construction standards – updated
– Building to B3 and MnSCU Standards is at least
LEED “certifiable” and maybe Silver
3. Energy Benchmarking – ongoing results!
–
More details in Facilities breakout session II
4. Report on accomplishments
– Colleges and universities will report
accomplishments on sustainability issues
Slide 3
– Report (“Green Report”) template issued in March
Design and Construction Standards
• Design & Construction Sustainable
Standards Update
• Stanley Consultants and LHB retained
• Performed a “credit analysis” by LEED standards
• Updated standards to ensure compliance with both
B3 and LEED
• Final review (April 2009):
• “… any significant new construction projects that
comply with .... MnSCU Design Standards would be
comparable to LEED “Silver” certification project.”
Slide 4
History – Energy Benchmarking
“Cannot improve what you cannot measure.”
• Department of Administration began energy
tracking system several years ago
• Mixed success
• Official Benchmark in place using B3 as basis
• Campus work began May 2009 – completed
Dec 2010…..Thanks!
• Results! Separate attachment with 2008 data
Slide 5
• System-wide awareness of energy use and
opportunities to reduce consumption, save $$
B3 – Buildings, Benchmark and
Beyond
• Started in 2004 as an initiative
• Law in 2009
• Use of B3 allows campus to review data and
improve understanding
• Use of B3 allows Office of Chancellor to
create analysis
• Use of B3 allows campus to have access
funding in BEEEP program: improve your
campus with this audit !
Slide 6
B3 – Buildings, Benchmark and
Beyond
• Minnesota Sustainable Building Guidelines (MSBG)
Compliance with Minnesota Statute §M16B.235, identify
Sustainable and High Performance goals for the project using
“The State of Minnesota Sustainable Building Guidelines” at
www.csbr.umn.edu/b3/index.html.
• §16B.325: Sustainable Guidelines (B3) for new building or
adds/replaces a stand-alone mechanical system. (after Jan 1,
2009, all renovations over 10,000 sf )
• §16B.335, Subd 4: Energy Conservation Standards ( Minnesota
Energy Code MN Rule 7676
http://www.doli.state.mn.us/bc_energy.html )
• §216B.241 Subd 9: Sustainable Building 2030 - Energy
Conservation Goals www.mn2030.umn.edu
Slide 7
Using the B3 Benchmarking System
• Location of B3 website:
http://www.mnbenchmarking.com/
• Go to the B3 website for:
– Login ID and password for B3 System
– Tutorial illustrating the data entry, features,
and reports
• It is just that simple !
Slide 8
Using the B3 Benchmarking System
• Update utilities data every month: This will insure
greater accuracy and up to date information for users.
• Review Data: The B3 website data can be viewed
monthly in a numeric and graphical format. A review
can quickly ensure the accuracy and changes that
occur in your campus energy use.
Slide 9
• Future Updates: The B3 website will contain additional
reports. Also a feature downloading pertinent data into
a Excel spreadsheet for customizing reports and
analysis.
Metrics used to Benchmark Buildings?
• Cars use: Miles per gallon
• Lighting efficiency: Lumens per Watt
• Buildings: Energy Use Intensity (EUI) typically
expressed in units of annual energy
consumption per floor area per year such as
kBtu/sq ft/ year OR
kBtu / FYE
• or maybe in the future …CO2 / Square foot/
year
Slide 10
Results from 2008 attached in web link
• Review carefully your campus data !
• Contact Facilities Planning if you want 2006 or 2007 data.
All of the 2009 data needs improvement.
• ‘Grey numbers’ indicate minor gaps
• ‘Red numbers’ indicate major gaps in consumption data
• Overall $29.8 million was expended for total energy costs in 2008
for all campuses – which reflects a consistency that the system
has been at approx. $30 million for utilities in the last three years
• Averages 89.65 total kBtu/sq ft: previous study indicated national
average was between 50 and 120 kBtu/sq ft
• Average $ 1.24/square foot
• Average $218.33/year per FYE or $76.54/year per headcount
• Average water consumption was approx 5 gallons/occupant
• New seminar on B3 will be offered in the future !
The Minnesota State Colleges and Universities system is an Equal Opportunity employer and educator.
Energy Costs - total in 2008 was $28.9 million
Draft data as 11 campuses have major consumption gaps
2008 Energy Exenditures
$4,000,000
$3,500,000
$3,000,000
$2,500,000
$2,000,000
$1,500,000
$1,000,000
$500,000
Slide 12
$0
Draft Campuses by Alpha order with
kBtu/sq ft/ year - averages
2008 (kBtu/SF)
200.00
180.00
160.00
140.00
120.00
100.00
80.00
60.00
40.00
20.00
Slide 13
0.00
1
3
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
29
31
33
35
37
39
41
43
45
47
49
51
Alphabet Soup
• B 3 – Buildings Benchmark and Beyond
– Initiative in 2004 and statute in 2009
• USGBC – U S Green Building Council created
• LEED: Leadership in Energy Environmental
Design started by the U S Green Building
Council in 1998
– Over 114,000 registered consultants
• Sustainable Building 2030 - Energy
Conservation Goals www.mn2030.umn.edu
Slide 14
What is LEED ?
LEED certification provides independent, third-party verification that a
building project meets the highest green building and performance
measures.
Sustainable building strategies should be considered early in the
development cycle.
An integrated project team will include the major stakeholders of the project
such as the developer/owner, architect, engineer, landscape architect,
contractor, and asset and property management staff. I
Implementing an integrated, systems-oriented approach to green project
design, development and operations can yield synergies and improve
the overall performance of a building.
Slide 15
Initial LEED assessment will bring the project team together to evaluate and
articulate the project's goals and the certification level sought.
The Triple
Bottom Line
Facilities
Slide 16
ENVIRONMENT
Reduced
Environmental
Impact.
Peak
Efficiency.
Improved
Capitalization
Rates.
Increased
Marketability.
Higher Lease
Rates.
Improved
Productivity.
Reduced
Absenteeism.
Academics
Test
Finance
What is a green building?
Design and construction practices that meet specified standards,
resolving much of the negative impact of buildings on their
occupants and on the environment.
Site
Planning
Slide 17
Test
What is the
LEED System?
Scores are tallied for
different aspects of
efficiency and design
in appropriate
categories.
For instance, LEED
assesses in detail:
1. Site Planning
2. Water Management
3. Energy Management
4. Material Use
5. Indoor
Environmental
Air Quality
6. Innovation &
Design Process
Slide 18
Slide 19
LEED is an option; way to evaluate design,
Construction (monitoring) and operations
Slide 20
USGBC began in 1993 – developed LEED
Version 1- 1998
Version 3 – 2009
Slide 21
Version 2- 2000
Version 3 – different ratings/reference
Slide 22
Slide 23
•
Represents one’s knowledge of rating system specific
technical information required for the successful
implementation of LEED
•
Intended building practitioners
•
2-hour exam in addition to the LEED Green Associate
•
Eligibility:
• Demonstrate professional experience on at least
one LEED project
• Document work on a LEED project within the last 3
years - verification
•
Biennial Maintenance Requirements: 30 hours (6 LEED
Specific)
If a project follows B3 and the MnSCU Design and Construction
Standards: likely be a ‘silver’ project based on previous Version 2
scale noted below:
Previous point system in Version 2.2:
Certified was 26-32
Silver was 33 – 38
Gold was 39-61
Platinum was 52 - 69
100 point scale – new in 2010 – Version 3 – up to 110 points w/innovative and regional credits
Slide 24
Lake Superior College
System’s 1st LEED Bldg
In process:
Winona Memorial Hall – Silver
St Cloud State Univ Science – ISELF Silver
Planned for 2010 :
Rochester Comm Technical College
Classroom Renovation
Normandale
Community College –
Classroom Addition
Slide 25
Why do this?
Slide 26
LEED Myths : Beware of these !
This product is LEED Certified
This product is LEED Approved
This product will earn you LEED points
This product is VOC compliant
This product meets requirements
specified by……..
This product can help CONTRIBUTE to LEED
certification……..
Slide 27
Example of projects nationally certified as of May 2008
Slide 28
National
Perspective
Slide 29
Case Study
Lillis Business
Complex,
Lundquist
College of
Business
LEED Silver
44%
University of
Oregon,
Eugene, OR
Higher
Education
140,000 sq ft
energy savings
51%
water savings
96%
Slide 30
waste diverted
from landfill
Case Study
Seattle Pacific
University
Science
Building
LEED Certified
60%
energy savings
Seattle
Pacific
University,
%
Seattle, WA water savings
53
Higher
%
education
63,000 sq ft waste diverted
91
Slide 31
from landfill
85% recycled content
Case Study
The Chicago
Center for
Green
Technology
Chicago Dept.
of
the
Environment
LEED Silver
40%
energy savings
Multi use:
government
%
and
of storm water
commercial
is reclaimed
offices,
assembly and
educational
40,000 sq ft
%
50
84
Slide 32
construction
waste salvaged
Great River
Energy
Headquarters
Maple Grove, MN
McGough Construction
Perkins + Will Architects
Tegra Group
The Weidt Group®
166,000 SF.
New
Headquarters
LEED-NC
15% Total Energy Produced Onsite, Saving $90,000
90% Less Water Than Comparable Buildings
Slide 33
PLATINUM
75% Construction Waste Diverted From Landfill
Reflections at
Bloomington
Central Station
McGough Companies
McGough Construction
ESG Architects
URS Corporation
The Weidt Group®
Karges-Faulkenbridge
Two 17story towers
267 units
LEED-NC
98.9% of Spaces Provide Direct Access to Views
50% Water Savings in Landscape Irrigation
Slide 34
CERTIFIED
50% Construction Waste Diverted From Landfill