Transcript Social protection in Asia
Rapid assessment methodology and experience - Relevance for Cambodia
Valerie Schmitt, Social Security Specialist, ILO DWT Bangkok
Skill Training Workshop to diagnostic the extension of Social Protection and Promoting Employment Phnom Penh, 2-4 Nov 2011
Agenda
• Assessment methodology & some concrete
examples
• Countries where the assessment has been conducted/is planned & main achievements • Relevance for Cambodia?
Assessment methodology
ASSESSMENT MATRIX (INVENTORY OF SCHEMES, GAPS AND IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES, RECOMMENDATIONS)
NATIONAL DIALOGUE # 1
RAP PROTOCOL: DATA COLLECTION FOR THE COSTING, TRANSLATION OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS INTO SCENARIOS, COSTING SOME OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS
NATIONAL DIALOGUE
NATIONAL DIALOGUE # 2
FINALIZATION OF THE ASSESSMENT REPORT, TRANSLATION, DISCUSSION WITH POLICY MAKERS, DECISION ON NEXT STEPS
Assessment matrix
• The assessment based national dialogue uses the Social Protection Floor framework to assess the whole Social Security situation (and not just non-contributory Social Protection schemes) • According to the SPF framework, all the population should enjoy four guarantees – Access to health care – Income security for children – Minimum income for the working age – Income security for the elderly and the disabled • Is it the case in the given country?
Assessment matrix
Existing provision Gaps/issues Recommendations/ priorities Health care Income security for children
existing programs?
Minimum income for working age Income security for elderly/disabled
Analysis: Is all population covered? Are benefits adequate? Other issues??
Policy gaps & Implementation issues
Recommendations
•New schemes •Expansion of existing schemes •Higher levels of benefits
Assessment matrix - Thailand
Describe present and planned SP provisions: legal framework, overview of schemes, indicators Identify design gaps and implementation issues SPF Guarantees: Health / Children / Working Age / Elderly Priority policy options decided through national dialogue
Assessment matrix
The assessment matrix answers three questions:
• Does the country has already a complete SPF? • What is missing? What is not functioning? • What can be recommended to fill the SPF gap?
National dialogue # 1
• Objectives: – Share the SPF concept and framework – Discuss the diagnostic made of Social Security situation with main stakeholders – Complete the Assessment Matrix – Formulate jointly (in group works using the World Café exercise or Jeopardy…) recommendations to bridge the Social Protection gaps and overcome implementation issues
Example of recommendations on health in Indonesia
*
National dialogue # 1
Recommendations on Health in Indonesia
R1- Develop & apply a specific benefits package that can be guaranteed by the Jamkesmas program, establish a checklist of services and interventions that should be available at the different levels of the health care pyramid (health clinics, centers, hospitals…), ensure that HC staff is sufficiently trained and available to provide at least the services included under benefit package, inform beneficiaries on the guaranteed benefit package and establish control / monitoring and appeals mechanisms (hot line) R2- Include other costs such as transportation costs in the benefit package of the Jamkesmas program R3- Improve Jamkesmas database of members and targeting methods R4- Improve payment methods/procedures/tools of hospitals under the Jamkesmas program by reviewing existing tools and methods and sharing an updated database of members with all health care infrastructures R5- Improve reception of patients (covered by Jamkesmas) in HC infrastructures R6- Increase enforcement of Jamsostek Law in the private sector (by establishing adapted supervisory & labour inspection mechanisms – see the TWIN service developed in China)
National dialogue # 1
R7 - Design adapted enrolment & contribution mechanisms for Informal Economy sector (e.g. the creation of professional or area based associations, the development of micro- insurance schemes to facilitate enrolment and collection of premiums and serve as “agents” for Jamsostek) * R8 - Develop a Database and mapping of informal economy workers (for the above to take effect) R9 - Explore the possibility of extending Jamkesmas to all informal economy workers or a larger part of informal economy workers, notably those not targeted by Jamsostek (cost calculation, fiscal space analysis, learning from experiences in Bali and other provinces that have expanded coverage to the whole provincial population) R10 – Support the development of regulations for the implementation of the Law 40, 2004 on the coverage of Informal Economy workers - or if not at national level, start in a few provinces R11- Expand benefit packages of PT Askes and PT Jamsostek to include more diseases and provide higher levels of benefits * R12- Calculate the additional cost of covering HIV-AIDS related care by all schemes
Assessment methodology
ASSESSMENT MATRIX (INVENTORY OF SCHEMES, GAPS AND IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES, RECOMMENDATIONS)
NATIONAL DIALOGUE # 1
RAP PROTOCOL: DATA COLLECTION FOR THE COSTING, TRANSLATION OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS INTO SCENARIOS, COSTING SOME OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS
NATIONAL DIALOGUE # 2
FINALIZATION OF THE ASSESSMENT REPORT, TRANSLATION, DISCUSSION WITH POLICY MAKERS, DECISION ON NEXT STEPS NATIONAL DIALOGUE
GENERAL GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS MODEL
RAP Protocol
LABOUR MARKET MODEL DEMOGRAPHIC FRAMEWORK MACROECONOMIC MODEL BENEFITS COSTING EXERCISE SUMMARY AND RESULTS
Demographic data & projections
Active population data & projections
Economic data & projections
Inflation Average and minimum wage Poverty line GDP Useful for cost of new provisions in % of GDP Useful for the costing of scenarios
Economic data & projections
Government expenditure Useful for cost of new provisions in % of Government expenditure
RAP Protocol: translation of recommendations into scenarios
Recommendations on Health
* R2- Include other costs such as transportation costs in the benefit package of the Jamkesmas program * R9 - Explore the possibility of extending Jamkesmas to all informal economy workers or a larger part of informal economy workers, notably those not targeted by Jamsostek * R12- Calculate the additional cost of covering HIV-AIDS related care by all schemes Scenario 1: Extension of Jamkesmas to all informal economy workers Scenario 2: Provision of higher levels of benefits under the Jamkesmas program to all informal economy population Scenario 3: Inclusion of HIV treatments and checkups for all the population Scenario 4: Introduction of a universal package to reduce Mother to Child HIV Transmission
RAP Protocol: costing of scenarios
Scenario 1: Extension of Jamkesmas to all informal economy workers
To calculate the cost of scenario 1 we need to know: 1- The unit cost per head of the HC benefit package in 2011 2- The administrative costs in 2011 3- Inflation rates from 2011 to 2020 (both HC package cost and admin cost will increase with inflation) 4- The percentage of population to be covered in 2011, 2012, … 2020 5- The total population in 2011, 2012, … 2020
RAP Protocol: costing of scenarios
Scenario 1: Extension of Jamkesmas to all informal economy workers
2011 2012 2020 Unit cost per head of the HC benefit package HC (1 + I 2012 ) * HC Admin costs per head AC (1 + I 2012 ) * AC Inflation rate ( ECO ) Total population ( POP ) Percentage of the population covered Total cost per year Pop 2011 32.0% (HC + AC) * Pop 2011 * 32% I 2012 Pop 2012 40.0% (HC 2012 + AC 2012 ) * Pop 2012 * 40% 62.9%
RAP Protocol: costing of scenarios
Scenario 1: Extension of Jamkesmas to all informal economy workers Year
Unit cost per head Admin cost per head Coverage (% of total population) Total cost in million IDR Total in % GDP Total in % Govt Expenditure
Scenario 1: Extension of Jamkesmas to all informal economy workers 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
66,754 70,452 73,622 76,567 78,919 81,251 83,688 86,199 88,785 91,448 1,609 32.0% 5,183,62 4 0.07% 0.38% 1,691 40.0% 6,916, 742 0.08% 0.45% 1,748 50.0% 1,798 60.0% 1,834 62.9% 1,867 62.9% 1,902 62.9% 1,939 62.9%
2019
1,977 62.9%
2020
2,016 32.0% 9,133, 983 0.10% 11,520 ,691 0.11% 12,577 ,568 0.11% 13,088 ,205 0.10% 13,625, 442 14,180, 814 0.10% 0.09% 14,753 ,397 0.09% 15,344 ,231 0.09% 0.53% 0.60% 0.58% 0.55% 0.52% 0.49% 0.46% 0.44% Total in % GDP Total in % Govt Expenditure 0.07% 0.38%
Status quo: without expanding coverage
0.07% 0.06% 0.06% 0.06% 0.05% 0.05% 0.36% 0.34% 0.32% 0.29% 0.28% 0.26% 0.05% 0.25% 0.05% 0.24% 0.04% 0.22%
National dialogue # 2
• Objectives: – Validate the assumptions used for the RAP protocol – Share the result of the costing – Confirm the scenarios or propose new scenarios and cost them – Train participants for the utilization of the costing tool
Assessment methodology
ASSESSMENT MATRIX (INVENTORY OF SCHEMES, GAPS AND IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES, RECOMMENDATIONS)
NATIONAL DIALOGUE # 1
RAP PROTOCOL: DATA COLLECTION FOR THE COSTING, TRANSLATION OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS INTO SCENARIOS, COSTING SOME OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS
NATIONAL DIALOGUE
NATIONAL DIALOGUE # 2
FINALIZATION OF THE ASSESSMENT REPORT, TRANSLATION, DISCUSSION WITH POLICY MAKERS, DECISION ON NEXT STEPS
Finalization of the assessment
• Finalization of the assessment report • Presentation & discussion with policy makers which recommendations will be implemented? which institutions (Government, DPs…) will be involved?
• Start design & implementation : Extension of existing schemes (more people covered, higher levels of benefits) or Creating new schemes ; Trying to find solutions to implementation issues …
Agenda
• Assessment methodology & some concrete examples • Countries where the assessment has been
conducted/is planned & main achievements
• Relevance for Cambodia?
Countries where the assessment has been conducted/is planned
2011 2012 Workshop BKK Nov 2010 Jan.
April July Oct Dec.
methodology & assessments in Viet Nam, Indonesia and Thailand Viet Nam Indonesia Thailand Vanuatu Solomon Is.
Development of the methodology and training of participants from 5 countries & UN Cambodia?
Philippines?
Lao PDR?
The assessment methodology is used systematically to review existing Social Security situations and develop National plans on SP (UNDAF, DWCP…)
Maximum duration: 6-7 months
May August June July Sept Oct Nov Dec.
Literature review & consultations
Relevant ministries, UN Agencies …
Assessment matrix completed through workshops Data collection for Costing tool Choice of scenarios and cost calculation National validation workshop Finalization of assessment report Dissemination of recommendations & costing results
9 May Maluku 5 July NTT 26 May, Jakarta 20 July East Java Relevant ministries, UN Agencies, Statistical office 1-4 August 4 August Valerie is late… Consultations Experts meeting 12-15 Dec
What was achieved?
Viet Nam Indonesia Thailand Assessment matrix Scenarios & costing Ongoing (#1,2) (#1) National dialogue Report finalized Decisions of extension by policy makers & feasibility studies Ongoing Nov-Dec 2011 Dec 2011 Beginning of 2012
Examples of results in Viet Nam
Examples of recommendations (Not exhaustive):
– R1 - Elderly pension at the level of the poverty line for elderly not covered by the contributory pension – R2 - Employment guarantee scheme of 100 days per household per year and social assistance for those who are unable to work – R3 - Child allowance for all poor children aged 0-15 years old Cost in 2020: 0.7% GDP 0.8% GDP 0.6% GDP
Simulation of impacts on poverty rates of the different benefits components of the Social Protection Floor
Examples of results in Viet Nam
• Recommendations included in the new DWCP and ILO plan in Viet Nam – Actuarial review of the old age pension scheme and feasibility study of the extension of the non contributory pension scheme – Design and establishment of PWPs • The child allowance component is being supported by UNICEF
Examples of results in Indonesia
Examples of recommendations on health care (Not exhaustive):
Cost in 2020: – R1- expand JAMKESMAS to all informal economy (package US$8/year) – R2- expand JAMKESMAS with higher levels of benefits (package US$17/year – R3- include HIV treatments and checkups for all the population – R4- universal package to reduce HIV Transmission between mothers and children
Other recommendations on income security for children, working age, the elderly…
0.09% GDP 0.18% GDP 0.3% GDP 0.01% GDP
Examples of results in Indonesia
• The ILO in the framework of the implementation of the Indonesian Jobs Pact will support the extension of health care coverage, the design of a UI scheme and the establishment of a SWS (to facilitate access to employment and social protection)
Preliminary results in Thailand
• The assessment based national dialogue of social protection in Thailand provided several recommendations that are part of the UNPAF on social protection
Agenda
• Assessment methodology & some concrete examples • Countries where the assessment has been conducted/is planned & main achievements • Relevance for Cambodia?
In Cambodia we don’t start from scratch
ASSESSMENT MATRIX (INVENTORY OF SCHEMES, GAPS AND IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES, RECOMMENDATIONS)
We have:
Inventory of schemes / situation analysis … with the SPER and other background documents Indicators of coverage and benefits level (with the SPER)
We don’t have:
Agreement on gaps and implementation issues Joint recommendations on the way forward
Next steps?
•Complete and consolidate the Assessment Matrix at National level and in a few provinces •Validation workshop of the Matrix
In Cambodia we don’t start from scratch
RAP PROTOCOL: DATA COLLECTION FOR THE COSTING, TRANSLATION OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS INTO SCENARIOS, COSTING SOME OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS
We have:
Data collection for the costing (POP, EAP, ECO, Govt Expenditure) – thanks to the Social budget model
We don’t have:
Shared recommendations Assumptions & parameters to translate the recommendations into scenarios that can be costed
Next steps?
•Come up with shared recommendations and
realistic scenarios
•This can be done through a national dialogue and also field experience (in the provinces) •Finalize the costing & train people to use the RAP
In Cambodia we don’t start from scratch
Once the Assessment matrix and RAP protocol are completed :
•Decisions on priority schemes •Feasibility studies •Pilot testing & rolling out phases
The Assessment matrix can then be used as a monitoring tool to monitor the progress of the extension of social security coverage (number of persons covered, levels of benefits), and should be regularly updated.
The pilot testing of new schemes enables to refine the parameters which are used for the cost calculations … The Assessment process (matrix and RAP) is not a One time exercise but can be repeated over time
… Take away message
• The assessment, based on social protection floor framework, helps assessing social security situation and identifying priorities • The recommendations are translated into scenarios and the RAP protocol gives an indication of their cost • Feasibility studies need to be conducted for the detailed design of the new schemes • Assessment matrix and RAP can be repeated over time…