Transcript Document
Low Energy Precision Tests of
Supersymmetry
M.J. Ramsey-Musolf
Caltech
Wisconsin-Madison
M.R-M & S. Su, hep-ph/0612057
J. Erler & M.R-M, PPNP 54, 351 (2005)
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (U ncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Outline
I.
Motivation: Why New Symmetries ?
Why Low Energy Probes ?
II. Prime Suspect: Supersymmetry
III. Low Energy Precision Tests
• Weak Decays
• PVES
I.
Motivation
Why New Symmetries ?
Why Low Energy Probes ?
Fundamental Symmetries & Cosmic History
Electroweak symmetry
Puzzles thebreaking:
Standard
Model
can’t solve
Higgs
?
1.
2.
3.
4.
Origin of matter
Unification & gravity
Weak scale stability
Neutrinos
Beyond the SM
What are the symmetries
(forces) of the early
universe beyond those of
the SM?
SM symmetry (broken)
Fundamental Symmetries & Cosmic History
Electroweak symmetry
breaking: Higgs ?
Baryogenesis: When?
CPV? SUSY? Neutrinos?
WIMPy D.M.: Related
to baryogenesis?
“New gravity”? Lorentz
violation? Grav baryogen ?
?
Weak scale
baryogenesis
can
Beyond the
SMbe
tested experimentally
SM“Known
symmetry
(broken)
Unknowns”
Cosmic Energy Budget
Fundamental Symmetries & Cosmic History
Early universe
Present universe
Standard Model
4 for
A “near miss”
2
grand unification
g
Gravity
i
Is there unification?
What new forces are
responsible ?
Weak scale
High energy desert
log 10 ( / 0 )
Planck scale
Fundamental Symmetries & Cosmic History
Early universe
2
GF ~ 1 Muniverse
Present
W EAK
Weak Int Rates:
Solar burning
Element abundances
Standard Model
4
Weak scale
2
gi
unstable:
Why is GF
so large?
Weak scale
Unification
Neutrino
mass Origin of
matter
High energy desert
log 10 ( / 0 )
Planck scale
There must have been additional
symmetries in the earlier Universe to
• Unify all matter, space, & time
• Stabilize the weak scale
• Produce all the matter that exists
• Account for neutrino properties
• Give self-consistent quantum gravity
Supersymmetry, GUT’s, extra dimensions…
What are the new fundamental
symmetries?
Two frontiers in the search
Collider experiments
(pp, e+e-, etc) at higher
energies (E >> MZ)
Large Hadron Collider
Ultra cold neutrons
CERN
High energy
physics
Indirect searches at
lower energies (E < MZ)
but high precision
LANSCE, NIST, SNS, ILL
Particle, nuclear
& atomic physics
Precision Probes of New Symmetries
Electroweak symmetry
New Symmetries
breaking: Higgs ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
Origin of Matter
Unification & gravity
Weak scale stability
Neutrinos
˜
e
W
˜0
˜
e
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompress ed) dec ompres sor
are needed to s ee this pic ture.
QuickTi me™ and a
T IFF (Uncom pressed) decom pressor
are needed to see this picture.
QuickT ime ™an d a
TIFF ( Uncomp res sed) deco mpre ssor
ar e need ed to see this pictur e.
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompr essed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Beyond the SM
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompress ed) dec ompres sor
are needed to s ee this pic ture.
SM symmetry (broken)
Precision Probes of New Symmetries
Direct
Measurements
Radiative
corrections
Probing Fundamental
• Precision
measurements
Symmetries
beyond
predicted
a range
for mt
the SM:
before
top quark discovery
low• mUse
mb !
t >> precision
energy measurements
• mt is consistent with that
to probe virtual effects
range
of new symmetries &
• Itcompare
didn’t have
tocollider
be that
with
way
results
Stunning SM Success
J. Ellison, UCI
Precision, low energy measurements can
probe for new symmetries in the desert
Precision ~ Mass Scale
NEW
O
M
SM
O
M˜
NEW
2
M=m ~ 2 x 10-9
M=MW
exp ~
1 x 10-9
~ 10-3
Interpretability
• Precise, reliable SM predictions
• Comparison of a variety of observables
• Special cases: SM-forbidden or suppressed processes
II. Prime suspect: Supersymmetry
SUSY: a candidate symmetry of the
early Universe
• Unify all forces
3 of 4
• Protect GF from shrinking
Yes
• Produce all the matter that exists
Maybe so
• Account for neutrino properties
Maybe
• Give self-consistent quantum gravity
Probably
necessary
Couplings unify with SUSY
Early universe
Present universe
Standard Model
4
2
gi
Supersymmetry
High energy desert
Weak scale
log 10 ( / 0 )
Planck scale
SUSY protects GF from shrinking
NEW
H0
˜ NEW
H0
H0
H0
M
2
WEAK
~ M M log terms
2
2
˜
=0 if SUSY is exact
SUSY may help explain observed
abundance of matter
Cold Dark Matter Candidate
0
Lightest SUSY particle
Baryonic matter: electroweak phase transition
Unbroken
phase
Broken phase
CP Violation
t˜
H
SUSY: a candidate symmetry of the
early Universe
Supersymmetry
Fermions
Bosons
e L,R , q L,R
e˜ L,R , q˜ L,R
˜ , Z˜ ,
˜, g
˜
W
˜ ,H
˜
Higgsinos H
u
d
W,Z , , g
gauginos
sfermions
Hu,Hd
0
˜ , Z˜ ,
˜
˜, H
˜
˜
W
,
u, d
Charginos,
neutralinos
SUSY must be a broken symmetry
105 new parameters: masses, mixing angles, CPV phases (40)
Superpartners have
not been seen
Theoretical models
of SUSY breaking
Models: relate weak scale parameters to each other at high
SUSY Breaking
scales (“hidden sector”)
M e˜ me
M q˜ mq
M ˜ MW ,Z ,
How is SUSY broken?
Visible
World
Hidden
World
Flavor-blind mediation
SUSY and R Parity
If nature conserves
PR
PR 1
3(B L)
1
2S
vertices have even
number of superpartners
Consequences
0
˜
Lightest SUSY particle
is stable
viable dark matter candidate
Proton is stable
Superpartners appear only in loops
R-Parity Violation (RPV)
L=1
WRPV = ijk LiLjEk + ijk LiQjDk +/i LiHu
+ ijkUiDjDk
B=1 proton decay:
Set ijk =0
Li, Qi
SU(2)L doublets
Ei, Ui, Di
SU(2)L singlets
RPV : Four-fermion Operators
e
e
d
e
k
e˜ R
j
q˜ L
12k
1j1
12k
e
1j1
d
L=1
L=1
12k
12k
2
2
˜eRk
4 2GF M
/
1j 1
/ 2
iji
2
4 2GF Mq˜ j
L
III. SUSY & Weak Decays
Weak Decays & SUSY
d u e e
u
s u e e
b u e e
b-decay
W
˜
˜
0
n p e e
˜
GFb
Vud 1 rb r
GF
SUSY
New physics
e
0
˜e
e e
˜
O
~ 0.001
SM
O
e
Vus Vub d
Vcs Vcb s
Vts Vtb b
SUSY
A(Z,N) A(Z 1,N 1) e e
˜0
˜
e
c
Vud
t Vcd
Vtd
e
r
SUSY Radiative Corrections
W
Propagator
Vertex &
External
leg
˜
W
˜0
W
e
˜
e
e
e
W
˜ e
W
˜
0
˜
˜
e
e
e˜
W
˜
0
˜
˜
˜
e
˜0
Box
˜
e
e
e
e
Weak Decays & SUSY
R Parity Violation
R-M,
V Flavor-blind
dSu
VKurylov,
VSUSY-
d u e e
ud
us
breaking
u c t Vcd
V
MW td
s u e e
b u e e
e
e
O
~ 0.001
SM
12k
12k ˜
n p e e e O
b-decay
e˜
˜
˜
0
e
SUSY
k
W
R
d
A(Z,N)q˜ A(Z 1,N 1) e e
˜0
ee
˜e
e e
˜
e
0
j
L
˜
1j1
1j1
e d
ub
Vcs Vcb s
CKM Unitarity
Vts Vtb b
CKM, (g-2),
MW, Mt ,…
b
F
F
APV
l2
G
Vud 1 rb r
G
M˜ L Mq˜ L
Kurylov,
No
long-lived LSPNew
or SUSY
physics
DMR-M
SUSY
RPV
Weak decays
d u e e
u
s u e e
b u e e
kaon decay
0
K e e
Value of Vus important
c
Vud
t Vcd
Vtd
Vus Vub d
Vcs Vcb s
Vts Vtb b
GFK
Vus 1 rK r
GF
New physics:
too small
Situation
Unsettled
UCNA
CKM Summary: PDG04
CKM Summary: New Vus & tn ?
New tn !!
Vus & Vud
theory ?
UCNA
New 0+
info
Weak decays & new physics
d u e e
u
s u e e
b u e e
˜
W
˜0
e
u˜
d
Vus Vub d
Vcs Vcb s
Vts Vtb b
pe p
pe
dW 1 a
An
E e E
Ee
˜0
u
˜
O
~ 0.001
SM
O
e
SUSY
c
Vud
t Vcd
Vtd
Correlations
e
˜e
˜
e
SUSY
Non (V-A) x (V-A)
interactions: me/E
b-decay at SNS, RIACINO?
Weak decays & SUSY : Correlations
Chiral symmetry breaking in SUSY
˜0
u
Is SB / mf as in SM ? u˜
˜e
J
d
e
˜
e
Future
exp’t ?
J p
Profumo,
R-M, Tulin
Large symmetry
breaking: New
SUSY models
Mass suppressed
symmetry breaking:
“alignment” models
Collider signature:
SUSY but only SMlike Higgs
Pion leptonic decay & SUSY
SM strong interaction
effects: parameterized
by F Hard to compute
SM radiative
corrections
also have
QCD effects
˜0
u
To probe effects of new
physics in NEW we need
to contend with QCD
˜
u˜
d
˜
Pion leptonic decay & SUSY
New TRIUMF, PSI
Leading QCD uncertainty:
Marciano
& Sirlin
˜0
u
e
˜e
u˜
d
˜
e
?
Can we do better on
Tulin, Su, R-M
˜
d
˜
Prelim
u˜
vs
˜0
u
Probing Slepton Universality
Min
(GeV)
Lepton Flavor & Number Violation
e
Present universe
Early universe
Y1
MEG: B!e ~ 5 x
e
AZ,N
R=
10-14
MECO: B!e~ 5 x
Also PRIME
AZ,N
B!e
1
L
B!e
1
S
?
?
log 10 ( / 0 )
10-17
Weak scale
Planck scale
Lepton Flavor & Number Violation
0bbdecay
e
W
u
d
MEG:
LightBM
~ 5 x 10-14?
!eexchange
u
e
e
M
u W
d
Raidal, Santamaria;
Cirigliano, Kurylov, RM, Vogel
LFV Probes of RPV: !e
e
AZ,N
e˜
e˜
e
u
AZ,N
d
Heavy particle exchange
?
-17
MECO:
B
~
5
x
10
!e
˜
0
d
e
e
k11/ ~ 0.008
0.09 for
formm
TeV
SUSY
SUSY~~11TeV
e
e
e
e
*
Logarithmic enhancements of R
Low scale LFV: R ~ O(1)
*
e
GUT scale LFV: R ~ O
Lepton Flavor & Number Violation
e
e
e
e
e
e
N
N
N
N
Short distance contributions
Long range nuclear effects (’s)
N
N
Faessler
et al
Prezeau, R-M,
Vogel
Lepton Flavor & Number Violation
111/ ~ 0.06 for mSUSY ~ 1 TeV
1000
0bbsignal equivalent to
Degenerate
100
Effective bb Mass (meV)
degenerate hierarchy
Inverted
10
Normal
Loop contribution to m of
inverted hierarchy scale
m
Ue1 = 0.866
1
Ue2 = 0.5
m
2
2
atm
s ol
= 70 meV
= 2000 meV
2
2
Ue3 = 0
0.1
2
1
3
4
5 6 7
2
3
4
5 6 7
10
100
Minimum Neutrino Mass (meV)
2
3
4
5 6 7
1000
IV. SUSY & PVES
QW and SUSY Radiative Corrections
Tree Level
Q g g
f
W
f
V
e
A
Flavor-dependent
Radiative Corrections
Q PV (2I 4Qf PV sin2 W ) f
f
W
f
3
Normalization
Constrained
by Z-pole
precision observables
Scale-dependent effective
weak mixing
Flavor-independent
SUSY Radiative Corrections
e
Z
Propagator
e
Vertex &
External leg
0
e
˜
e˜
˜
Z
e
e˜
e
˜
e
Z
˜
0
f
f
f˜
f
f
f
˜e
˜e
f
e˜
˜
0
e
f
˜
e
e
f
0
Z
˜0
Box
e˜
e
f
f
Probing SUSY with PV eN Interactions
e
Z
SUSY
dark matter
e
0
˜
Z0
f
SUSY
loops
˜
e˜
e
f
e
e˜
f
f
0 ->
QuickTime™ and a TIFF (Uncompressed)
e+e decompressor are needed to see this picture.
is Majorana
e
e
˜ Rk
e
RPV 95% CL fit to
12k decays, M ,etc.
12k
weak
W
Kurylov, Su, MR-M
Probing SUSY with PV eN Interactions
QWP, SUSY / QWP, SM
Lattice for fK+
Large NC for fK+
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (LZW) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
QWe, SUSY / QWe, SM
Probing SUSY with PV eN Interactions
12k ~ 0.3 for mSUSY ~ 1 TeV & QWe / QWe ~ 5%
Kurylov, Ramsey-Musolf, Su
95% C.L.
JLab 11 GeV
Møller
0bbsensitivity
111/ ~ 0.06 for mSUSY ~ 1 TeV
Probing SUSY with PV eN Interactions
12k ~ 0.3 for mSUSY ~ 1 TeV & QWe / QWe ~ 5%
0bbsensitivity
111/ ~ 0.06 for mSUSY ~ 1 TeV
LFV Probes of RPV:
!e
k31 ~ 0.15 for mSUSY ~ 1 TeV
LFV Probes of RPV: !e
k31 ~ 0.03 for mSUSY ~ 1 TeV
Comparing Qwe and QWp
“DIS Parity”
SUSY
Kurylov, R-M, Su
SUSY loops
dark matter
QWp,SUSYQuickTime™
QWp,SM and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture.
Linear
collider
E158 &QWeak
JLab Moller
RPV 95% CL
QWe, SUSY QWe, SM
Comparing AdDIS and Qwp,e
e
RPV
p
Loops
Low Energy Probes of SUSY
We’re making
progress…
…won’t leave
until the job is
done…
…and open to
new ideas.
Back Matter
-Nucleus DIS: SUSY Loop Corrections
wrong
sign
-Nucleus DIS: RPV Effects