Transcript Pacific Northwest Canola Variety Trials

An Evaluation Scheme
to Identify Superior
Cultivars of …
Canola…. and Mustard
PNW-WVT 2008
PNW-CVT 2008
PNW-MVT 2008
Jim Davis and Friends
Funded by…
Idaho Oilseed Association
-Spring canola and mustard trials 2008
Don Wysocki’s Research Group/OSU
University of Idaho Canola Program
PNW Canola Research Program
-Winter and spring canola 2009-2010
Funded by…
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Bayer CropScience
Cargill Specialty Canola Oils
Croplan Genetics
DL Seeds, Inc
Helena Chemical
Kansas State Univ Canola Program
Monsanto Company
Wilbur-Ellis Company
Special Thanks
Hal Johnson
Bob Hutchens
Bert Henriksen
Del Teade
Steve Teade
Steve Riggers
Nathan Riggers
U of I Farm Staff
Darcy Huffman
Jeff Schibel
Thomas Zwaintz
Tim Dillin
David Ostheller
Diana Roberts
Nick Sirovatka
U of I Canola Crew
Regional Variety Trials
Multiple Sites in PNW
Four Replicates per site
Small Plots (5 ft x16 ft)
http://www.ag.uidaho.edu/brassica/
Winter Canola/Rapeseed
Variety Trials
• 1 Control Variety
• 11 Commercial Entries
• 7 U of I Entries
Winter Sites
•
•
•
•
•
Hermiston OR
Moses Lake WA
Reardan WA
Moscow ID
Genesee ID
• Not reported:
Irrigated, Conv. Tillage
Irrigated, Conv. Tillage
Conventional Fallow
Conventional Fallow
Conventional Fallow
– Pendleton OR; dry, poor stands
– Grangeville ID; poor stands, hail, herbicide drift
– Genesee no-till; dry, poor stands
Winter Canola/Rapeseed
Yield by Location
4000
Mean = 3265 lbs/acre
lbs per acre
3000
2000
1000
0
Mo
sco
w
Ge
ne
se
e
Mo
se
sL
ak
e
Re
ard
an
He
rm
is t
on
Winter Canola/Rapeseed
Yields by Variety
• Yield range:
2,961-3,992 lbs/acre
– Visby
– Kronos
– Baldur
– 06.UIWC.5 (Amanda)
– Athena
3,992
3,693
3,472
3,420
3,049
– Least Significant Diff.
410
Winter Canola/Rapeseed
Yields by Variety
• Yield range:
– Camas RR
– HyCLASS 107W RR
– HyCLASS 154W RR
– NPZ.0791 RR
– Least Significant Diff.
2,961-3,992 lbs/acre
3,090
3,209
3,307
3,509
410
Spring Canola/Rapeseed
Variety Trials
Spring Canola/Rapeseed
Variety Trials
• 5 Control Varieties
• 17 Commercial Entries
• 14 UI Varieties or Breeding Lines
Spring Sites
– Bonners Ferry
– Genesee
– Craigmont
Conventional
Conventional
Direct Seed
– Davenport
– Fairfield
– Dayton
Direct Seed
Minimum Till
Direct Seed
– Pendleton
– Hermiston
Conventional
Irrigated, Conventional
Spring Canola/Rapeseed
Yield by Location
3000
Mean = 1737 lbs/acre
2000
1500
1000
500
Locations
HERM
PEND
DAYT
FAIR
DAVE
CRAG
GENE
0
BONN
lbs per acre
2500
Spring Canola Yields
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Hyola 401
DKL 30-42 RR* (Monsanto)
INT 3739 RR (Wilbur-Ellis)
HyCLASS 940 RR** (Croplan)
InVigor 5550 LL (Bayer )
Hyola 357 Magnum RR
V1035 RR (Cargill)
• Yield range:
* MB 52142
2008
1932
2007
1937
1981
2203
1976
2052
2007
2179
2338
2290
2261
2198
2197
2143
1319-2203 lbs/acre
**MB 52140
Mustard Variety Trials
Mustard Variety Trials
•11 Yellow Mustard Varieties
•5 Oriental Mustard Varieties
•2 Brown Mustard Varieties
Mustard Sites
–
–
–
–
Bonners Ferry
Genesee
Craigmont
Lewiston
Conventional
Conventional
Direct Seed
Conventional
–
–
–
–
Davenport
Fairfield
Dayton
Colfax
Direct Seed
Minimum Till
Direct Seed
Direct Seed
– Pendleton
– Moro
Conventional
Conventional
Mustard Yield by Location
3000
Mean = 1402 lbs/acre
2000
1500
1000
500
Locations
MORO
PEND
DAYT
COLF
FAIR
DAVE
CRAG
LEWI
GENE
MOSC
0
BONN
lbs per acre
2500
Mustard Yields
• Yield range:
1210-1561 lbs/acre
• Tilney
• AC Pennant
• Andante
1308
1316
1334
• IdaGold (U of I)
• Ace
1409
1425
• 98.CY.50.1 (U of I)
1561
Mustard Yields
• Yield range:
1210-1561 lbs/acre
• Cutlass
• Pacific Gold (U of I)
• BJ.0Z.24 (U of I)
1352
1518
1558
• Kodiak (U of I)
• Duchess
1425
1470
Future Goals
• Continue to evaluate new
commercial cultivars and
advanced breeding lines.
• Continue to share performance
data with canola growers.
Questions?
Jim Davis <[email protected]> 208-885-6710
Jack Brown <[email protected]>
208-885-7760
http://www.ag.uidaho.edu/brassica/