Transcript https://mentor.ieee.org/802.19/dcn/13/19-13-0060-00-0001-initial-review-of-comments-related-to-new-no-votes.pptx

May 2013
doc.: IEEE 802.19-13/0060r0
Initial review of comments related to new
no votes
Date: 2013-05-13
Authors:
Name
Company
Mika Kasslin
Nokia
Address
Phone
email
[email protected]
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 802.19. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in
this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Submission
Slide 1
Mika Kasslin, Nokia
May 2013
doc.: IEEE 802.19-13/0060r0
Abstract
This presentation contains draft results of validity
analysis of comments received together with a new no
vote
– A vote is considered a new no vote if the voter has voted yes or
abstain in the WG LB on DF3.02 and no in the WG re-circulation
LB on DF3.03
– The analysis was done to check whether the new no votes were
associated with at least one comment that relates to changes from
the DF3.02 to the DF3.03
Submission
Slide 2
Mika Kasslin, Nokia
May 2013
doc.: IEEE 802.19-13/0060r0
New no votes
• Six new no votes were issued in the re-circulation ballot
–
–
–
–
–
–
William Carney (Abstain to No)
Hyunduk Kang (Yes to No)
Mika Kasslin (Yes to No)
Naotako Sato (Abstain to No)
Ryo Sawai (Abstain to No)
Chen Suo (Abstain to No)
Submission
Slide 3
Mika Kasslin, Nokia
May 2013
doc.: IEEE 802.19-13/0060r0
Comment validity review
•
•
•
•
•
•
William Carney’s comments (CIDs 21, 52) relate to the parts of the draft that have
changed from the DF3.02 to the DF3.03 => Valid new no vote
Hyunduk Kang’s comments (e.g. CIDs 1, 2, 7) relate to the parts of the draft that
have changed from the DF3.02 to the DF3.03 => Valid new no vote
Mika Kasslin’s comments (e.g. CIDs 14, 16, 23) relate to the parts of the draft that
have changed from the DF3.02 to the DF3.03 => Valid new no vote
Naotako Sato’s comments (CIDs 11, 19, 24, 51) relate to the parts of the draft that
have changed from the DF3.02 to the DF3.03 => Valid new no vote
Ryo Sawai’s comments (CIDs 12, 46) relate to the parts of the draft that have
changed from the DF3.02 to the DF3.03 => Valid new no vote
Chen Suo’s comments (CIDs 20, 27, 30, 33) relate to the parts of the draft that have
changed from the DF3.02 to the DF3.03 => Valid new no vote
Submission
Slide 4
Mika Kasslin, Nokia
May 2013
doc.: IEEE 802.19-13/0060r0
Summary
• All six new no votes appear to be valid as they are
associated to at least one comment that relate to part of
the draft that has changed from the DF3.02 to the
DF3.03
Submission
Slide 5
Mika Kasslin, Nokia