Transcript Lecture 32.ppt
DRAMA II MODERN DRAMA
Lecture 32
Review
PYGMALION
George Bernard Shaw
George Bernard grew up in an atmosphere of genteel poverty, which to him was more humiliating than being merely poor
The Myth Behind the Play
PYGMALION
The Myth Behind the Play
There is never any overt reference in the play to Pygmalion; Shaw assumes a classical understanding.
According to the beauty.
Mythology Guide
“Pygmalion saw so much to blame in women that he came at last to abhor the relation with them, and resolved to live unmarried. He was a sculptor, and had made with wonderful skill a statue of ivory, so beautiful that no living woman could be compared to it in It was indeed the perfect sem-blance of a maiden that seemed to be alive, and only prevented from moving by modesty. His art was so perfect that it concealed itself, and its product looked like the workmanship of nature.
The Myth Behind the Play
Pygmalion admired his own work, and at last fell in love with the counter-feit creation. Oftentimes he laid his hand upon it, as if to assure himself whether it were living or not, and could not even then believe that it was only ivory. The festival of Venus was at hand, a festival celebrated with great pomp at Cyprus. Victims were offered, the altars smoked,and the odor of incense filled the air. When Pygmalion had performed his part in the solemnities, he stood before the altar and timidly said, "Ye gods, who can do all things, give me, I pray you, for my wife" he dared not say "my ivory virgin," but said instead "one like my ivory virgin." Venus, who was present at the festival, heard him
The Myth Behind the Play
While he stands astonished and glad, though doubting, and fears he may be mistaken, again and again with a lover's ardor he touches the object of his hopes. It was indeed alive! The veins when pressed yielded to the finger and then resumed their roundness. Then at last the votary of Venus found words to thank the goddess, and pressed his lips upon lips as real as his own.
The Play Itself: PYGMALION
One of the most popular plays of Bernard Shaw, first performed in 1913 in Vienna and published and performed in London in 1916.
Contextual Background
PYGMALION
Pygmalion: Background
Pygmalion is set in London, England, around the beginning of the twentieth century.
During this time in London, working-class people like Eliza Doolittle • lived in slums • had no heat or hot water • had to put coins in a meter to get electric light
Pygmalion: Background
The class structure in England at this time was very rigid.
upper class middle class working class
Pygmalion: Background
The government did provide some schooling.
However, an education did not teach the proper speech that was considered a sign of the upper class.
The way that many working-class people spoke was an obstacle to their becoming middle class.
George Bernard Shaw’s Philosophy
PYGMALION
George Bernard Shaw
“I must warn my readers that my attacks are directed against themselves, not against my stage figures.” -Shaw
George Bernard Shaw
• • • • Shaw wanted to force his viewers to face the reality of unpleasant events. He promoted the “unpleasant” plays by publishing a long preface in which he could argue his views.
Shaw was awarded the Nobel Prize for literature in 1925. He continued to write until he was 94.
Likewise, how we behave impacts what people think about us. Ultimately, how they behave towards us reinforces what we believed about ourselves in the first place
http://www.meghanwilliams.com/ugb.html
Meg Williams
What we believe influences how we behave In turn, this affects how others behave towards us.
Plot Overview
PYGMALION
Pygmalion: Introduction
In this play, George Bernard Shaw uses humor and lively characterization to explore how language, class structure, education, and gender influence how people are seen by society.
Pygmalion: Introduction
The two main characters are • Eliza Doolittle—a poor but proud flower girl with a cockney accent — a way of speaking associated with the working classes.
• Henry Higgins—an arrogant and insensitive linguistics professor
Pygmalion: Introduction
Eliza comes to Higgins’s house to ask him to give her speech lessons.
She wants to learn to speak properly so that she can get a job in a flower shop instead of selling flowers on the street.
Pygmalion: Introduction
Higgins decides to take the girl on as a professional challenge.
He boasts to his associate Colonel Pickering that with six months of lessons, Eliza could be passed off as a duchess.
Pygmalion: Introduction
Higgins has Eliza move into his home. With the help of Pickering and the housekeeper, Mrs. Pearce, he teaches Eliza the proper speech and manners of the upper class.
Pygmalion: Introduction
Although Eliza wants to learn, there is tension between her and Higgins. She also wants to be treated with respect—as a person. Higgins, however, persists in treating her as a project and an object.
Pygmalion: Introduction
Will Eliza and Henry Higgins become friends, or will their differences drive them apart?
If Higgins’s experiment succeeds, where will Eliza go from there? Will learning to speak like a duchess allow her to live like one?
A Look at the Play
Characters, Role, Relationship, Conflicts & Significance
Eliza Doolittle Role
• Protagonist, poor flower girl who wishes to be rich and happy
Relationship
• Daughter of Alfred, experiment subject to Higgins and Pickering, possibly means more to Higgins
Conflict
• Cannot change her inner characteristics to suit the newly changed outer appearance. Argues with Higgins on this subject
Significance
• Is able to stay true to herself and to not conform to please society.
Mr. Higgins Role
• Antagonist, Professor of phonetics and tries to teach Eliza the proper ways of society.
Relationship
• Friend to Higgins, wishes to be friends with Eliza
Conflict
• He tries to change Eliza's personality but she wont let him. He also has a hard time understanding women.
Significance
• His actions show that no one can change another's character
Col. Pickering Role
• Another researcher of phonetics
Relationship
• Friend to Higgins, and a friend to Eliza
Conflict
• Trying to get Eliza and Higgins to understand each other
Significance
• He did not change his morals to suit Higgins' needs
Mrs. Pearce Role
• Motherly figure, and Housekeeper
Relationship
• Protector of Eliza, and keeps Higgins in line
Conflict
• Has trouble in trying to reason with Higgins
Significance
• Is a role model to Eliza
Freddy Hill Role
• Ideal image of a man at the time (to Eliza)
Relationship
• has feelings for Eliza over time, they marry
Conflict
• Argues with the people of his society on his choice of Eliza.
Significance
• Gives hope to Eliza
Class Representation
PYGMALION
impatient, rude, confident, superior, self-important kind, polite, generous, enthusiastic, eager, confident anxious, eager, emotional, ambitious, unsure
Character Position in society Evidence in the play Eliza Lower class Behaviour:
respectful to people of higher class
Language: calls
gentleman “sir” and “cap’in” (or captain) which is a compliment
Character Position in society Henry Higgins Evidence in the play Middle class Behaviour: rude
(and patronizing) to lower class; polite to same or upper class
Language: calls
Eliza “you silly girl” and Pickering “my dear man” (an equal and friend)
Character Position in society Colonel Pickering Evidence in the play Upper class Behaviour: generally
confident and polite; but ignores Eliza
Language: prepared
to begin a conversation with Henry, whom he does not know; generous with praise to him
Words to know
• • • • • • • • • • Phonetics Dialect Cockney Dramatist Fin de siecle Social satire Aestheticism Fabian society Shavian Naturalism Fabian Society
Themes and the Major Conflicts
PYGMALION
Major Conflicts
Status Divide Social Snobbery Conflicts Gender Relations Self Consciousness
Major Conflicts 1. Status Divide
The nature of class structure
Upper Class
: Higgins, Col. Pickering, Mrs. Higgins, Mrs. Clair and Freddy Eynsford Hill.
Middle Class:
Mrs. Pierce She does not, however, represent “
middle-class morality
” alone. In many ways that is also a quality of Higgins’ and Col. Pickering’s class.
Lower Working Class:
Eliza, Alfred Doolittle and his never seen but often heard about “wife.” and Eliza’s step mother.
Major Conflicts 1. Status Divide
A vast gulf between the poor and even the lower upper class.
Higgins’ “cast-off” change is a fortune to Eliza who assumes later that he must have been drunk.
Eliza’s belief that riding in a taxi is the ultimate badge of upper class quality of life.
Major Conflicts
2. Gender Relations/Differences
The relationship between genders
“No, no, no, you two infinitely stupid male creatures!”
Major Conflicts 2. Gender Relations/Differences
Gender Differences
Neither Col. Pickering nor Henry Higgins have a clue about the situation they are putting Eliza or themselves into.
Mrs. Pierce recognizes that Higgins is immorally using the power granted him by his patriarchal culture to pressure Eliza, a presser which if she gives in could lead her to a life of wickedness.
Major Conflicts 3. Self-consciousness
Self Perception
Eliza’s sense of worth She is infected with the lie.
Major Conflicts 3. Self-consciousness
Eliza learns that women in the upper classes in fact
do not have the independence
that women of the lower classes do. They must be connected to a man in some way to be respectable within
“middle-class morality.”
Eliza rejects being a “gold-digger” and Higgins rejects female “puppy-dog” tricks.
Only a working skill frees Eliza.
Major Conflicts 3. Self-consciousness
Eliza has a powerful sense of her value: “I’m a good girl I am!” Therefore she will never become a “kept woman.” She has ambition willing to give up two thirds of her daily income to improve herself.
But she is infected with class-prejudice Put the girls in their place just a bit You’re going to allow yourself to marry that low born woman?
Major Conflicts 4. Social Snobbery
Eliza’s Struggle
To work at a flower-shop She is infected by social snobbery herself.
Discovers that a rise in culture means a loss of independence (as does her step-mother). Eventually achieves independence.
Probably the most Important conflict in the play: the class system is Eliza’s primary antagonist
PLOT THEMES
PYGMALION
Themes
Manipulation Language & Communication Transformation Appearance Identity
Themes
Society and Class Women and Femininity Middle Class Morality Dreams, Hopes and Plans
Pygmalion 1. Theme of Language and Communication
We hear language in all its forms in
Pygmalion
pleas and big talk about soul and poverty. : everything from slang and "small talk," to heartfelt Depending on the situation, and depending on whom you ask, language can separate or connect people, degrade or elevate, transform or prevent transformation. Language, we learn, doesn't necessarily need to be "true" to be effective; it can deceive just as easily as it can reveal the truth. It is, ultimately, what binds
Pygmalion
pays to read carefully; even something as small as a single word can define a person.
together, and it
Pygmalion 1. Theme of Language and Communication
Science of Language Misinterpretation Act of Speech Status Ambivalence
Pygmalion 1. Theme of Language and Communication
Influences Rebel Unifying Force Association Emotional Link
Themes
Manipulation Language & Communication Transformation Appearance Identity
2. Theme of Transformation
This one may seem like a no-brainer:
Pygmalion
sure, and Eliza's metamorphosis is stunning. 's all about turning a poor girl into a duchess, right? Well, You could even go so far as to call it a Cinderella story. But remember: Cinderella turned back into a poor girl before she finally found her prince. Pay attention and you'll notice that not all the attempts at transformation here are successful. There are plenty of false starts and false endings. By play's end, Shaw's made one thing very clear: be careful what you wish for.
2. Theme of Transformation
Status Divide Perceptions Environmental suitability Over ambition
2. Theme of Transformation
Fear of unknown Control of Emotion Control of Manner
2. Theme of Transformation
Subjectivity Nature Confidence
Themes
Manipulation Language & Communication Transformation Appearance Identity
Pygmalion 3. Theme of Identity
Every single day we talk about ourselves, saying "I did this," "I did that," "I am," and "I'm not," but we don't usually think about what "I" means. In
Pygmalion
, Shaw forces us to think this through. Some characters want to change who they are, others don't want to change at all. Things get even more complicated when identities are made up, constructed. The play wants us to ask ourselves what I really means to think about different versions of the self, and whether that self can ever
really
be changed.
Pygmalion 3. Theme of Identity
Identity
Minor Details Gender Specific Attitudes Uncertainty Prejudice Prejudice
Pygmalion 3. Theme of Identity
Identity
Stereotypes Object vs. Subject Clash Within Multidimensionality Fallacies
4. Theme of Appearance
Is beauty only skin deep? Is it in the eye of the beholder? Or is it the consequence of social circumstances? Shaw's more interested in dealing with the big questions – like that last one – than with old saws. In
Pygmalion
, anything from a pair of boots to a bath to an expensive dress can tell us important stuff about a character, like their place in the world or their state of mind. They can reveal what might normally be hidden from view, or hide that which might normally be obvious. So appearances can be deceiving, and the trick is learning how to judge what is true and what is false. The thing is, it's not an easy skill to pick up.
4. Theme of Appearance
Physical appeal Standards of appearance Behavior Deceptive attribute Language vs. Visual
4. Theme of Appearance
Awareness Genteel poverty Subject to change Conflict Acknowledgment
5. Theme of Manipulation
In
Pygmalion
, we see different types of influence and control, sometimes literal and other times metaphorical: the teacher training his student, the artist shaping his creation, the con artist fleecing his mark, the child playing with his toy. That said, these roles aren't always well-defined; they can change easily, without warning. Sometimes the master becomes the slave and the slave the master, in the blink of the eye, while other times the two simply become equals. Shaw wants us to observe the consequences of control, to see how these changes occur.
5. Theme of Manipulation
Manipulation
• ambitiousness • Entertainment • Behavior • Control • Rhetoric
5. Theme of Manipulation
Manipulation • Uncompassionate • Excitement • Fear • Reversibility • transformation
6. Theme of Society and Class
In
Pygmalion
, we observe a society divided, separated by language, education, and wealth. Shaw gives us a chance to see how that gap can be bridged, both successfully and unsuccessfully. As he portrays it, London society cannot simply be defined by two terms, "rich" and "poor." Within each group there are smaller less obvious distinctions, and it is in the middle, in that gray area between wealth and poverty that many of the most difficult questions arise and from which the most surprising truths emerge.
7. Theme of Women and Femininity
A lot, as you've probably guessed, has changed in the last century. Back when Shaw wrote
Pygmalion
, women could not vote in the United Kingdom; in 1918 women over the age of 30 were given the right, and it took another ten years for all women to be given a voice. Shaw's depiction of women and attitudes toward them is impressively and sometimes confusingly varied. They are shown in conventional roles – as mothers and housekeepers – and as strong-willed and independent. The play pays special attention to the problem of women's "place" in society (or lack thereof), and Shaw offers no easy answers to the tough questions that arise.
Pygmalion Theme of Dreams, Hopes, and Plans
Mick Jagger is right when he sings, "You can't always get what you want." It's true, sometimes just by trying you can get what you need, but that's not always the way it works. What if you get what you want only to find out it isn't what you imagined it would be? What if your dreams come true, only to turn into nightmares? They say the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray. Well, in
Pygmalion
that's true. That said, Shaw also shows us what happens he does leave room for hope.
after
everything ends up wrong. He offers no quick fixes, but