Transcript 15-05-0193-00-0000-isoiec-jtc1-sc6-liaison-report.ppt

March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks
(WPANs)
Submission Title: ISO/IEC JTC1 SC6 Liaison Report
Date Submitted: 18 March 2005
Source: Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
Address: (461-701) San-65 Bok-Jung-Dong, Soo-Jung-Gu, Sung-Nam-Shi, Kyung-Gi-Do, Korea
Voice: 82 – 19 – 9101 - 1394, FAX: 82 – 31 – 753 - 2532, E-Mail: [email protected]
Re: []
Abstract: Liaison Report
Purpose: For the purpose of informing the body.
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15 members to understand the
standardization activities of ISO/IEC JTC1 SC6. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not
binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject
to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add,
amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of
IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.
NOTE: Update all red fields replacing with your information; they are required. This is a manual update in appropriate
fields. All Blue fields are informational and are to be deleted. Black stays. After updating delete this box/paragraph.
Submission
Slide 1
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
ISO/IEC JTC1 SC6
Liaison Report
March 18, 2005
Atlanta, Georgia
Submission
Slide 2
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Terms of References of SC6 WGs
• WG 1 Terms of Reference : Services and protocols in the
OSI Physical and Data Link Layer.
• WG 7 Terms of Reference : Network and transport layer
services and protocols.
• WG 8 Terms of Reference : Directory services and
protocols.
• WG 9 Terms of Reference : Abstract Syntax Notation
One and Registration.
• SC6 is responsible for 284 published International
Standards and 57 open project items
Submission
Slide 3
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Memberships and Liaisons (1/2)
• 16 Participating members and 22 Observer
members
• Internal liaison within ISO/IEC JTC1
–
–
–
–
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC 17
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC 25
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC 29
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC 31
• Internal liaison within ISO/TCs and IEC/TCs
– ISO TC 215(Health Informatics)
Submission
Slide 4
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Memberships and Liaisons (2/2)
• External-Category A liaison
– ITU-T (International Telecommunication Union -Telecommunication
Standardization Sector)
– ECMA International (European Computer Manufacturer’s Association)
– ETSI (European Telecommunication Standards Institute)
– IETF (Internet Engineering Task Force)
– OASIS (Organization for the Advancement of Structured Information
Standards)
• External-Category B liaison
– SITA (International Society for Airline Telecommunication and
Information)
• External-Category C liaison
– IEEE 802 LMSC (LAN/MAN Standard Committee)
– ATM Forum
– FR Forum
Submission
Slide 5
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Highlights of Cooperative Works
• SC6/WG1 and IEEE
– Cooperation with IEEE 802 LMSC in the internationalization and joint
publishing agreement for combined IEEE and SC6 LAN Standards
– Cooperation agreement with IEEE RA in the area of LLC address for LAN
and Standard group MAC addresses
• SC6 and ECMA International
– Close cooperation using Fast Track procedures in the area of PISN (Private
Integrated Services Network) and NFCIP (Near Field Communication
Interface and Protocol)
• SC6/WG7 and ITU-T SG17
– Close collaboration through joint meetings and produced ECTP (Enhanced
Communication Transport Protocol), ASN.1 and Directory Standards in
common text
Submission
Slide 6
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Market Initiatives of SC6
• Local Area Networks
– The Ethernet Standard has been upgraded to 10Gbps level and Wireless
LAN Standard is rapidly growing into multi-Billion business with the speed
of 11Mbps and 54Mbps.
• Network/Transport
– The Standards developed in SC6/WG7 are challenged to increase speed and
provide greater Quality of Service.
• Private Telecommunication Networking
– PISN Standards should find greater application inside the enterprise
structure over the private telephone networks.
• Directory
– X.509 certificates, produced in collaboration with ITU-T, are used
extensively for secure transactions in e-commerce.
Submission
Slide 7
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Achievements (1/2)
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
ISO 7498
ISO/IEC 8877
ISO/IEC 13239
ISO/IEC 7776
ISO/IEC 8208
ISO/IEC 8882-2 & 3
ISO/IEC 8802-2
ISO/IEC 8802-3
ISO/IEC 8802-5
ISO/IEC 8802-11
ISO/IEC 11571
ISO/IEC 11579
ISO/IEC 11572
Submission
OSI 7 Layer Reference Model
ISDN Connector Specifications and Pin Assignments
HDLC Procedures
X.25 LAPB Protocol
X.25 Packet Layer Protocol
X.25 Conformance Testing
Logical Link Control
CSMA/CD
Token Ring
Wireless LAN
Numbering and Addressing for PISN
Reference Configuration for PIS
QSIG Basic PISN Call Function
Slide 8
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Achievements (2/2)
• ISO/IEC 11582
• ISO/IEC 13247
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
QSIG Generic Functional Protocol
BQSIG Basic Call/connection control
protocol
ISO/IEC TR 9577 Protocol identifiers for Worldwide MultiProtocol Environment
ISO/IEC 8348
NSAP Addressing
ISO/IEC 10589
IS-IS Routing Protocol
ISO/IEC 10747
Inter-domain Routing Pprotocol
ISO/IEC10021-x Message Handling System(X.400)
ISO/IEC 9594-x Directory(X.500)
ISO/IEC 8824-x Abstract Syntax Notation One Specifications
(X.680)
ISO/IEC 8825-x Abstract Syntax Notation One Encoding
Rules(X.690)
Submission
Slide 9
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Achievements in 2004
• 7 International Standards and 1 Technical Report
published
– ISO/IEC 18092:2004 Information technology – Telecommunications and information exchange between systems - Near
Field Communication -Interface and Protocol (NFCIP-1)
– ISO/IEC 17343:2004 Information technology Telecommunications and information exchange between
systems - Corporate telecommunication networks - Signaling
interworking between QSIG and SIP -Basic services
– ISO/IEC 20113:2004 Information technology Telecommunications and information exchange between
systems - Private Integrated Services Network - Specification,
functional model and information flows - Make call request
supplementary service
Submission
Slide 10
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
An Event
• China NB submitted Chinese WAPI (Wireless
Authentication and Privacy Infrastructure) standard to
JTC1 as an NP intending Fast Track.
• JTC1 issued the JTC1 number as 1N7506 in July 2004.
• As soon as JTC1 found that WAPI, as an NP, did not go
through SC6, it voided the 1N7506 in August 2004.
• China NB claimed the unfair treatment.
• SC6 and JTC1 decided to resolve the issue in the
Orlando meeting, Nov. 2004
Submission
Slide 11
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
SC6 Plenary Meeting at Orlando
• Held in November 2004 at Orlando.
• China NB claimed
– Failure to notify China NB and correct the procedure.
– Unfair treatment by VISA denial to Chinese security experts
– Possible Conspiracy between IEEE and US Government
– Suspension of IEEE 802.11i Fast Track
• Decided to have Ad Hoc meeting at Frankfurt, Germany
to have the technical discussion of WAPI and 802.11i
Submission
Slide 12
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
SC6 WG1 Interim at Frankfurt
• 15 security experts from China and 5 security experts
from IEEE attended.
• JTC1 Chairman
• 5 National Bodies
• China NB assumed that 1N7506 has been alive since last
Orlando meeting.
• When they knew that it does not exist, they requested to
make 1N7537 suspended indefinitely.
• The convener suggested 3 possible options, but not
accepted by China NB.
Submission
Slide 13
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Time-Line for the Standardization
July Aug. Aug. Nov. 8
2004 2004 2004 2004
WAPI
Submit
as an
NP and
Got
1N7506
IEEE
802.11i
Submit
as a
Fast
Track
Feb. 21
2005
Mar. 11
2005
Orlando Frankfurt Submit
Meeting: Meeting WAPI
Allowed
as the
Discussion
Fast
of Technical
Track
Matureness
1N7506
Voided
Submission
June 9
2005
Aug. 11 Aug. 29
2005
2005
IEEE
802.11i
Letter
Ballot
Ends
WAPI SC6
Letter Plenary
Ballot In
Ends France
5 Months
Slide 14
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Option 1: Submit an NP
• Will need 3 months letter ballot for the NP submission,
starting from this August.
• Will need 3 months letter ballot for the CD.
• Will need 3 months letter ballot for the FCD.
• Will need 3 months letter ballot for the DIS.
• Will need 3 months letter ballot for the FDIS.
• Risk: Will take a whole year for the completion of the
international Standardization.
Submission
Slide 15
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Option 2: Submit Fast Track ASAP
•
•
•
•
Submit fast track on March 11.
JTC1 relieved 1 month review period.
So, 5 months letter ballot ends at Aug. 11.
Prevent IEEE 802.11i from having letter ballot
resolution until SC6 Plenary on Aug. 2005.
• Chairman of JTC1 promised to do his best to
make it on time.
• Option 2 may be the best choice at the moment.
Submission
Slide 16
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Option 3: Suspend 11i by Plenary
• Hold IEEE 802.11i Fast Track to line up with
WAPI by Aug. 2005 SC6 Plenary.
• Risks:
– This cannot be obtained without paying any
compensation for IEEE 802 Working Group.
– IEEE 802.11i requests China to participate in the
IEEE 802.11 activities.
– May be a good choice for both China NB and IEEE
for the harmonious standardization work.
Submission
Slide 17
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Next Step of SC6
• Related mostly with Internet Infrastructure Technologies.
–
–
–
–
–
Specifications on LAN, MAN and WAN
QoS and Speed Enhancement for the Infra
Routing protocols (IS-IS and Inter Domain)
Message Handling Systems
Directories, and ASN.1
• The work scope of WG1 on PHY and DL Layer is not
enough for the future market including technologies
supporting Ubiquitous Networking Environment.
• Ubiquitous Networking Environment requires not only
the infrastructure but also the terminals which contains
all the layers.
Submission
Slide 18
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Proposal and Rationale to Extend
• Revised SC6 WG1 Terms of reference
– Physical and data link layer services and protocols, and
additional services and protocols running over these layers
• Rationale
– WG1 Project Scope needs to be extended to cover diverse and
fast changing market requirements in various IT areas
including ubiquitous networking applications.
– Since WG1 deals with network issues of Physical and Data
Link Layer, it is rather easy to extend the scope to higher layers
including application layers and services that require hardware
specifications across the entire layers.
Submission
Slide 19
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University
March 2005
doc.: 15-05-0193-00-0000
Next Meeting
• August 29 – September 2, 2005 at France.
• However, WG1 has been authorized to have additional
Ad-Hoc meeting for resolving the WLAN Security
Issues.
• The place can be China, Europe, but not probably in
U.S.A.
Submission
Slide 20
Ho-In Jeon, Kyung-Won University