Transcript a statistical comparison of open source CMS

Joomla,Drupal and WordPress –
A Statistical Comparison of Open
Source CMS
Authors：Savan K Patel , V.R. Rathod , Satyen Parikh
Source：2011 3rd International Conference on Trendz in Information Sciences
and Computing (TISC)
指導教授：Ku-Yaw Chang
報告者： 孫粹璞
Outline
2
 Introduction
 What is CMS？
 Joomla
 Drupal
 WordPress
 Case Studies
 Conclusion
 References
3
Introduction
 Prove out of this which CMS is preferable for getting better
performance.
 Doing the created a page in all CMS to take statistics of different
page criteria.
 Taken statistics of a page with only textual information to check
which CMS handle load better and give faster response.
What is CMS？
4
 CMS(Content Management System)，內容管理系統。
 現在流行的CMS系統：WordPress、Joomla、Drupal、Xoops
 共通特色：
 為數眾多的人員投稿及分享所儲存的資料。
 以類似於人力資源職位管理的方式，賦予使用者不同的權限。
 有助於快捷簡便地儲存資料及檢索到所需要的資料。
 減少資料的重複輸入工作。
 降低工作報告寫作的難度。
 加強使用者間的交流。
Outline
5
 Introduction
 What is CMS？
 Joomla
 Drupal
 WordPress
 Case Studies
 Conclusion
 References
Joomla－Core Features
6
 User Management
 Web Link Management
 Media Manager
 Content Management
 Banner Management
 Syndication and Newsfeed
Management
 Contact Management
 Polls
 Search
 Template Management
 Integrated Help System
 Powerful Extensibility
Joomla－特色
7
 大部分用在一般的公司網站。因為其後端控制台美觀且容易學習，易於交接
及教育訓練。
 非常容易安裝，並有許多模組可供使用。
 說明文件詳盡而簡潔。
 管理者操作介面是直覺式的，且功能強大。
 後端控制台非常合用，且用「所見即所得」方式編輯內容。
 規模大小剛好且提供許多自訂選項。
 龐大且活躍的社群。
 但後台功能非常「專業化」
8
Joomla－控制介面
9
Joomla樣式首頁－保時捷的巴西網站
Outline
10
 Introduction
 What is CMS？
 Joomla
 Drupal
 WordPress
 Case Studies
 Conclusion
 References
11
Drupal－Core Features
 Administer
 Build
 Collaborate
 Connect
 Create
 Design & Display
 Extend
 Organize & Find
12
Drupal－特色
 高度客製化、模組化的內容管理系統。
 使用者範圍從部落客至社群創辦人、替客戶建置或設計網站等。
 安裝後，就只是個「原型」，許多功能得自己安裝。但要架設一個已經有明
確目的網站的話，就可以善用 Drupal 的 Distributions 和 Installation
Profile 。
13
Drupal－控制介面
14
Drupal樣式首頁－哈佛大學
Outline
15
 Introduction
 What is CMS？
 Joomla
 Drupal
 WordPress
 Case Studies
 Conclusion
 References
16
WordPress－Core Features
 Custom Taxonomies
 Password Protected Posts
 Custom Post Types
 Easy Importing
 WordPress Themes
 XML-RPC interface
 Cross-blog
communication tools
 Workflow
 Spam protection
 Menu management
 Full user registration
 Intelligent text formatting
17
WordPress－特色
 適用於個人或組織的部落格，當中一些版型亦可作中小型企業、公司網站。
 系統與外掛只需在後台處理即可，無須安裝。
18
WordPress－控制介面
19
WordPress樣式首頁－Press75精緻樣板站
Outline
20
 Introduction
 What is CMS？
 Joomla
 Drupal
 WordPress
 Case Studies
 Conclusion
 References
21
Case Studies
 Following are the parameters measured for page performance.
 Page Load Time： in Mile Second (M.S).
 Page Size ： Total Size of the page in Kilo Byte (KB).
 Request ： Number of request send to the server to load the page.
 cascading style sheet (CSS) files ： Number of CSS files used by CMS to
make a page.
 java script (JS) files ： Number of JS files used by CMS to make a page.
 PL T after caching ： when page load first time some of its content store
in cache memory so when we load that page again only rest of the
data which is not in cache will load from the server so it decrease load
time.
 PS after caching ： As system cache used to decrease the PL T it also
reduces PS as mention above.
22
Case Studies－Server configuration
Operating System
WindowsXP
Hardware Configuration
Processor
Core 2 Duo
RAM
2 GB
Hard Disk
320 GB Hard Disk
Motherboard
Intel Motherboard
Server
Apache Server 2.2.19
Front End
PHP 5.0
Back End
My SQL 5.0 Server
23
Case Studies－PLT Comparison
 Page Load Time is an important parameter for comparing page
performance.
24
Case Studies－ PS Comparison
 Page Size has a direct effect on Page Load Time.
25
Case Studies－ Request Comparison
 To load a page number of request has been send to the server from
client machine.
26
Case Studies－Java Script Comparison
 When any CMS creates a page it uses some JS files and some CSS
files.
27
Case Studies－CSS File Comparison
28
Case Studies－PLT after Caching
 Page gets loaded from server to client machine, the client machine
stores some data on its site .
29
Case Studies－
Page Size after Caching
Outline
30
 Introduction
 What is CMS？
 Joomla
 Drupal
 WordPress
 Case Studies
 Conclusion
 References
31
Conclusion
 If anybody wants informative website, Drupal is the best choice.
 consumes very less PS as well as load time.
 If wants intranet site with multiple objects and needs faster
response in this case Joomla is the first choice.
 handles the load better.
 According to the picture that WordPress has shown its performance
and proved it best in most of all areas.
Outline
32
 Introduction
 What is CMS？
 Joomla
 Drupal
 WordPress
 Case Studies
 Conclusion
 References
33
References
 [1] http://blog.cmsart.net/compare-joomla-drupal-wordpress/webdesign/
 [2] http://blog.cmsart.net/features-of-joomla-drupal-xoops-andwordpress/web-design/
 [3]http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%86%85%E5%AE%B9%E7%AE%A1
%E7%90%86%E7%B3%BB%E7%BB%9F
 [4] http://drupaltaiwan.org/is_drupal_right_for_you