Ontology and RadLex Robert Arp, Ph.D. Ontology Research Group (ORG) www.org.buffalo.edu National Center for Biomedical Ontology (NCBO) www.bioontology.org This work was funded by the National Institutes.
Download ReportTranscript Ontology and RadLex Robert Arp, Ph.D. Ontology Research Group (ORG) www.org.buffalo.edu National Center for Biomedical Ontology (NCBO) www.bioontology.org This work was funded by the National Institutes.
Ontology and RadLex Robert Arp, Ph.D. Ontology Research Group (ORG) www.org.buffalo.edu National Center for Biomedical Ontology (NCBO) www.bioontology.org This work was funded by the National Institutes of Health through the NIH Roadmap for Medical Research, Grant 1 U 54 HG004028. Information on the National Centers for Biomedical Computing can be found at http://nihroadmap.nih.gov/bioinformatics. Problem: radiologist wondering if radiation therapy in chest is linked to Cauda Equina Syndrome in lower back. she needs data and information to find a solution - calls colleagues - sends emails - queries RadLex Problem: radiologist wondering if radiation therapy in chest is linked to Cauda Equina Syndrome in lower back. She needs data and information to find a solution - calls colleagues - sends emails - queries RadLex RadLex: A Lexicon for Uniform Indexing and Retrieval of Radiology Information Resources RadLex: A Lexicon for Uniform Indexing and Retrieval of Radiology Information Resources direct result of the information age and information science Informatics: the science of data and information collection, categorization, management, storage, processing, retrieval, and dissemination. Informatics: the science of data and information collection, categorization, management, storage, processing, retrieval, and dissemination. retrieval and dissemination: the goal of information science Informatics: the science of data and information collection, categorization, management, storage, processing, retrieval, and dissemination. but goal depends upon accurate categorization and management Computers are dumb beasts: At this point,* they can mostly only accurately output what we accurately input. * Not ruling out the possibility of human-like thinking in the future So, a central informatics problem that hampers retrieval and dissemination is: incorrect thinking (IT) associated with categorization and management of data and information Can’t get the data and/or info: - radiologist gives up the search in frustration - cure is not found - suffering is not relieved* * moral obligation to retrieve and disseminate data and information? To combat incorrect thinking (IT) and assist in the accurate categorization and management of data and information so that retrieval and dissemination is maximally possible: ontologies are used What is an ontology? (1) Philosophical Ontology (2) Domain Ontology (3) Formal Ontology (1) Philosophical Ontology “...I can fit wholesale evolution and a creating god into my ontology without contradiction.” “...just because it has mental existence doesn’t mean it has ontological existence.” - Ontos (being, existence)+ Logos (word, account, explanation) - The study of what is, of the kinds and structures of objects, properties, events, processes, and relations in every area of reality - “The branch of Metaphysics that studies the nature of existence.” Random House College Dictionary Thing Material Substance Animate (Living) Entity Living Entity with Sensation (Animal) Rational Animal (Human) NonRational Animal Immaterial Substance Non-Animate Entity Living Entity without Sensation (Vegetation) Thing Material Substance Animate (Living) Entity Living Entity with Sensation (Animal) Rational Animal (Human) NonRational Animal Immaterial Substance Non-Animate Entity Living Entity without Sensation (Vegetation) PORPHYRIAN TREE Compare: Linnean Taxonomy and Periodic Table Sub-types (children) should inherit all the features of the relevant type (parent) Thing Material Substance Animate (Living) Entity Living Entity with Sensation (Animal) Rational Animal (Human) NonRational Animal Immaterial Substance Non-Animate Entity Living Entity without Sensation (Vegetation) PORPHYRIAN TREE Compare: Linnean Taxonomy and Periodic Table Sub-types Sub-types(children) (children) should shouldinherit inheritallallthe the features of the relevant features of the type (parent) along relevant type (parent) with some differentia (distinguishing feature) Thing Material Substance Immaterial Substance A is_aNon-Animate BEntity that/which Cs PORPHYRIAN Animate (Living) Entity A is_a B that/whichTREE has Cs - rational animal (A) is_a living entity withCompare: sensation (B) that LinneanforTaxonomy has the capacity conscious and Periodic Table Nonthinking (C) Rational Living Entity with Sensation (Animal) Rational Animal (Human) Animal Living Entity without Sensation (Vegetation) A is_a B that/which Cs A is_a B that/which has Cs - radiology (A) is_a science (B) that deals with medical imaging so as to understand, diagnose… (C) - domain ontology is_a ontology that deals with a specific area, sphere, or portion of reality - mouse trap is_a rodent trap which captures mice To a certain extent, all of us are Philosophical Ontologists in that we naturally and automatically categorize any and all things in reality so as to understand, explain, control, dominate, and navigate reality. What is an ontology? (1) Philosophical Ontology (2) Domain Ontology (3) Formal Ontology (2) Domain Ontology “...I’m working on an ontology for annelids.” “...the Gene Ontology has data on that HOX gene.” Representation of the entities and relations existing within a particular domain of reality such as biology, medicine, geography, ecology, or law - Gene Ontology (GO) - Foundational Model of Anatomy (FMA) - Environment Ontology (EnvO) See http://www.obofoundry.org/ - Opposed to ontology in the philosophical sense, which has all of reality as its subject matter - Ideally, provides a controlled, structured vocabulary to annotate data in order to make it more easily searchable by human beings and processable by computers ONTOLOGY: “a representational artifact, comprising a taxonomy as its main part, whose representational units are intended to designate some combination of universals, defined classes, and certain relations between them.” * * Smith, B., Kusnierczyk, W., Schober, D., & Ceusters, W. (2006). Towards a reference terminology for ontology research and development in the biomedical domain. Proceedings of KR-MED 2006, 1, 1-14. Domain ontology contrasted with: - Database - Rule-Based Language - Thesaurus Ontology hybrid of: - Glossary - Catalogue - Taxonomy - Various Relations - Inventory Axiomatic Rules - Axiomatic Theory of Inference - Simple Taxonomy Domain ontology contrasted with: - Database - Rule-Based Language - Thesaurus RadLex, as of now, - Glossary is a thesaurus of - Catalogue terms, although - Inventory confuses terms - Axiomatic Theory and entities those - Simple Taxonomy terms refer to… Mechanism Doorbell Thermometer Clock Trap Basic Mouse Trap Classification Animal Trap Rodent Trap Mouse Trap SpringLoaded Bar Mouse Trap Insect Trap Rat Trap Human Trap Bear Trap Fish Trap Simple Taxonomy: is_a, sub-type relation Electric Mouse Trap Glue Mouse Trap mouse trapping process baiting of mouse trap mouse trappee mouse trappee role s-l mouse trap mouse trapper mouse trapper role s-l trap attraction s-l trap function part_of preceded_by has_agent inheres_in adjacent_to removal of mouse trapping of mouse entrance of mouse Beginnings of Mouse Trap Domain Ontology s-l spring s-l trapping bar s-l spring release hook s-l bait trigger s-l platform MRI test patient MRI machine image referral patient’s role machine’s function technician technician’s role contrast contrast’s function radiologist radiologist’s role part_of Beginnings of MRI Test Ontology start of test end of test preceded_by has_participant inheres_in has_output A Gene Ontology Example: Cytokinesis is_a ─ part_of ─ A Gene Ontology Example Part of a Scientific Experiment Ontology Part of a Scientific Experiment Ontology p/o = part_of = is_a Now, it’s fine to have all of these domain ontologies attempting to classify and categorize data and information… But, there is so much data and information… Crazy and overwhelming, isn’t it? So, instead of using a STANDARD like the Periodic Table of Elements, people start classifying things their own different ways… this results in… SILO EFFECT Data Data Data Data Data Data Data SILO EFFECT Data Data Data Data Data Data Data PROBLEM: DE-SILOING all of this domain data and information so that it may be queried effectively, shared, and re-used INTEROPERABILITY PROBLEM: DE-SILOING all of this domain data and information so that it may be queried effectively, shared, and re-used INTEROPERABILITY SOLUTION: FORMAL ONTOLOGY: - Upper-level - Applicable to any domain What is an ontology? (1) Philosophical Ontology (2) Domain Ontology (3) Formal Ontology Assists in making communication between and among domain ontologies possible by providing: - Common language - Common formal framework for reasoning So, just as ENGLISH is a common world language enabling different people to communicate in common So too, FORMAL ONTOLOGY is a common “language” enabling different domain ontologies to communicate in common Formal ontology is like a backbone or spine making communication, interoperability, and optimal dissemination of data and information possible between and among domain ontologies Formal Ontology E.G., Basic Formal Ontology Data Data Data Data Data Data Data Formal ontology is like a backbone or spine making communication, interoperability, and optimal dissemination of data and information possible between and among domain ontologies Formal Ontology E.G., Basic Formal Ontology Data Data Data Data Data Data Data Data Data Data Data From this… Data Data To this… Data Formal Ontology E.G., Basic Formal Ontology Data Data Data Data Data Data Data From this… From this… To this… To this… Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) REALISM-BASED ONTOLOGY Universals (1) real objects, substances, endurants, or continuants - SNAP shots of reality (2) real processes, activities, perdurants, or occurrents - SPAN of time Relations is_a, part_of, has_participant... continuants vs. occurrents continuant (substance, object) occurrent (process) In classifying parts of reality, we keep track of these two different kinds of entities in two different ways continuant entities - have continuous existence in time - preserve their identity through change - exist in toto, if they exist at all occurrent entities - have temporal parts - unfold themselves phase by phase - exist only in their phases/stages continuant entities - have continuous existence in time - preserve their identity through change - exist in toto, if they exist at all objects, qualities, functions occurrent entities - have temporal parts - unfold themselves phase by phase - exist only in their phases/stages processes, activities continuant Relation: is_a Sub-types (children) should inherit all the features of the relevant type (parent) continuant HUMAN HEART human heart surface of the heart pink, smooth all hearts in this room stops if no circulation a biopsy of the heart pumps blood chest cavity prop in a display occurrent Relation: is_a occurrent ECG/EKG TEST TEST ECG/EKG ECG (EKG) test start/end of ECG all ECGs in clinic 2nd lead attached activities in clinic s/t ECG began moment ECG began s/t region of ECG time occupied (1) Philosophical Ontology (2) Domain Ontology (3) Formal Ontology Basic principles from philosophical ontology and formal ontology can assist a domain like radiology and a domain ontology like RadLex (although, RadLex is at the beginning stages of a domain ontology) Fundamental Step: Clear up the incorrect thinking (IT) in Radlex Incorrect Thinking (IT): - simply getting the facts wrong - perception/reality confusions - using examples instead of definitions when defining something - circular definitions - equivocation of terms - use/mention confusions - unclear or incoherent definitions Incorrect Thinking (IT): - these are just a few… - many more problems… - problems are legion in databases - we’ll look at just a few problems in RadLex IT: simply getting the facts wrong: True, these are all terms, but the terms are supposed to be referring to the actual entities in reality; confusing classification of terms with a taxonomy of things IT: simply getting the facts wrong: Is a substance a subtype of term? Is an imaging procedure attribute a sub-type of term? None of these are terms, they are things. IT: unclear or incoherent definitions: imaging procedure attribute (a) is not really a child/sub-type of RadLex term and (b) it is the only child when, on this account, treatment, substance, etc., should be subtypes as well IT: use/mention confusion: At the same time these terms are being used as a taxonomy that refers to reality, and mentioned in a lexical classification. Terms are representations that refer to things, but are being treated as the things themselves… confusion! Where is the definition of a RadLex term? Where are some examples? How am I supposed to know what these things are? ? Is a biopsy an imaging purpose? Is an infusion a purpose? Is an imaging purpose an imaging procedure attribute? Where are the definitions? Is a biopsy a RadLex term? Is an infusion a RadLex term? Sub-types (children) should inherit all the features of the relevant type (parent) IT: using examples instead of definitions when defining something - I still don’t know what an imaging service request is. - Also, isn’t a request something different from exams? - I know what an example of it might be… Also, isn’t a request something different from an exam or exams? Compare: Drinking service request Def.= The drinks that can be ordered by patrons at a bar A synonym is a RadLex child, too? A foreign body is a child of finding? A missile, by definition, is a foreign body? I can see it playing a role as a foreign body, but its essence is to be a foreign body? Same with personal item, surgical implement, and others… Three Levels to Keep Straight Level 1: The entities in reality such as universals and relations Level 2: Cognitive representations of this reality on the part of scientists Level 3: Publicly accessible concretizations of these cognitive representations in textual, graphical, or computational representational artifacts (like RadLex composed of terms) Three Levels to Keep Straight Cognitive representations Representational artifacts Reality Radiology and Ontology Literature - Bertaud, V., Belhadj, I., Dameron, O., Garcelon, N., Hendaoui, L., Marin, F., & Duvauferrier, R. (2007). Computerizing the radiological sign. Journal of Radiology, 88, 27-37. - Fielding, J., & Marwede, D. (2006). Four ontological models for radiological diagnostics. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics, 124, 761-766. - Kahn, C., Channin, D., & Rubin, D. (2006). An ontology for PACS integration. Journal of Digital Imaging, 19, 316-327. - Marwede, D., & Fielding, M. (2005). The epistemological-ontological divide in clinical radiology. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics, 116, 749-754. - Pommert, A., Höhne, K., Pflesser, B., Richter, E., Riemer, M., Schiemann, T., Schubert, R., Schumacher, U., & Tiede, U. (2001). Creating a high-resolution spatial/symbolic model of the inner organs based on the visible human. Medical Image Analysis, 5, 221-228. - Rubin, D. (2007). Creating and curating a terminology for radiology: Ontology modeling and analysis. Journal of Digital Imaging. Available at: http://www.springerlink.com/content/ 978708n776738132/fulltext.pdf. - Rubin, D., Dameron, O., Bashir, Y., Grossman, D., Dev, P., & Musen, M. (2006). Using ontologies linked with geometric models to reason about penetrating injuries. Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, 37, 167-176. Arp, R., Romagnoli, C., Chhem, R., & Overton, J. (2008). Radiological and Biomedical Knowledge Integration: The Ontological Way. In R. Chhem, K. Hibbert, & T. Van Deven (Eds.), Radiology Education (Chapter 8, pp. 87-104). Berlin: Springer-Verlag. Biomedical Informatics Literature • Baxevanis, A., & Ouellette, B. (2005). Bioinformatics: A practical guide to the analysis of genes and proteins. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. • Berman, J. (2006). Biomedical informatics. London: Jones & Bartlett Publishers. • Chen, H., Fuller, S., Friedman, C., & Hersh, W. (2005). Medical informatics: Knowledge management and data mining in biomedicine. The Netherlands: Springer. • Goldstein, D., Groen, P., Ponkshe, S., & Wine, M. (2007). Medical informatics 20/20: Quality and electronic health records through collaboration, open solutions, and innovation. New York: Jones & Bartlett. • Polanski, A., & Kimmel, M. (2007). Bioinformatics. London: Springer. • Shortliffe, E., & Cimino, J. (Eds.). (2006). Biomedical informatics: Computer applications in health care and biomedicine. London: Springer. • van Bemmel, J., & Musen, M. (Eds.). (1997). Handbook of medical informatics. The Netherlands: Springer. • Xiong, J. (2006). Essential bioinformatics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Domain and Formal Ontology Literature • • • • • • • • • • Arp, R. (2007). Philosophical ontology, domain ontology, formal ontology. The Reasoner, 1, 12-13. Bittner, T., Donnelly, M., & Winter, S. (2006). Ontology and semantic operability. In S. Zlatanova & D. Prosperi (Eds.), Large-scale 3D data integration: Challenges and opportunities (pp. 139-160). Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Ceusters, W., Smith, B., & van Mol, M. (2003). Using ontology in query answering systems: Scenarios, requirements and challenges. Proceedings of the 2nd CoLogNET-ElsNET Symposium, Amsterdam, 2, 5-15. Grenon, P., & Smith, B. (2004). SNAP and SPAN: Towards dynamic spatial ontology. Spatial Cognition and Computation, 1, 1-10. Grenon, P., & Smith, B. (2004a). A formal theory of substances, qualities and universals. In A. Varzi and L. Vieu (Eds.), Proceedings of FOIS 2004. International Conference on Formal Ontology and Information Systems (pp. 49-59). Amsterdam: IOS Press. Mars, N. (Ed.). (1995). Towards very large knowledge bases: Knowledge building and knowledge sharing. Amsterdam: IOS Press. Menzel, C. (2003). Ontology theory. In J. Euzenat, A. Gomez-Perez, N. Guarino, & H. Stuckenschmidt (Eds.), Ontologies and semantic interoperability (pp. 13-30). Hamburg: IOS Press. Smith, B. (2003). Ontology. In L. Floridi (Ed.), Blackwell guide to the philosophy of computing and information (pp. 155-166). Malden, MA: Blackwell. Smith, B., & Ceusters, W. (2007). Ontology as the core discipline of biomedical informatics: Legacies of the past and recommendations for the future direction of research. In G. Crnkovic & S. Stuart (Eds.), Computing, philosophy, and cognitive science (pp. 121-145). Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Press. Smith, B., Kumar, A., & Bittner, T. (2004). Basic Formal Ontology for bioinformatics. Available at: http://www.uni-leipzig.de/~akumar/JAIS.pdf. Thank You Robert Arp, Ph.D. Ontology Research Group (ORG) www.org.buffalo.edu National Center for Biomedical Ontology (NCBO) www.bioontology.org This work was funded by the National Institutes of Health through the NIH Roadmap for Medical Research, Grant 1 U 54 HG004028. Information on the National Centers for Biomedical Computing can be found at http://nihroadmap.nih.gov/bioinformatics.