SRC Risk informatics SOI Hydrometcentre of Russia AA RI SIMULATION OF THE BEHAVIOR OF OIL SPILLS IN THE COURSE OF OIRFP "PRIRAZLOMNAYA“ OPERATION. ASSESSMENT OF THE POSSIBILITY.
Download ReportTranscript SRC Risk informatics SOI Hydrometcentre of Russia AA RI SIMULATION OF THE BEHAVIOR OF OIL SPILLS IN THE COURSE OF OIRFP "PRIRAZLOMNAYA“ OPERATION. ASSESSMENT OF THE POSSIBILITY.
SRC Risk informatics SOI Hydrometcentre of Russia AA RI SIMULATION OF THE BEHAVIOR OF OIL SPILLS IN THE COURSE OF OIRFP "PRIRAZLOMNAYA“ OPERATION. ASSESSMENT OF THE POSSIBILITY OF EMERGENCY RESPONSE RELATED TO OIL SPILLS Moscow 2012 SOURCES AND SCENARIOS OF OIL SPILLS According to the Customer's initial data the following sources and scenarios of oil spills are to be considered: o oil spill in an open uncontrolled flowing wells – 1,500 tons in 72 hours; o oil spill resulting from a tanker accident – 10,000 tons in 120 hours; o oil spill resulting from temporary storage leakage of oil at the OIRFP – 16,000 tons in 120 hours. RISK OF EMISSIONS BY ACCIDENTS AT WELLS Distribution of time needed to recover control over flowing well RISK OF OIL SPILL FROM TANKER ACCIDENT Probability of zero spills in collisions and landings tankers with deadweght of Revised Interim Guidelines for the Approval of Alternative Methods of Design 60 ,000 tons – 0.81 and Construction of Oil tankers under Regulation 13F (5) of Annex I of MARPOL 73/78 Resolution IMO MEPC.110(49), 2003 Estimating probability of a spill with volume of 10,000 tons for tankers with a deadweight of 60,000 tons - http://efficiensea.org Average volume of spills in collisions and landings of tankers with a deadweight of 60,000 tons – 5,169 tons, probability of exceedance – 8,5×10-5 Probability of spills 10,000 tons or more in collisions and landings of tankers with a deadweight of 60,000 tons – 2.5×10-5 ×(1-0.81) = 4.85×10-6 OIL FEATURES According to: Oil and gas condensate in Russia. Handbook. Volume 1. Oil in European part of Russia and gas condensate in Russia. Ed. K.A. Demidenko. Moscow: Pbl.h. "Tehnika", 2000. Features Density by 20 °С, kg/m3 Kinematical viscosity by 20°С, mm2/s Congelation point, °С Gas-oil ratio, м3/м3 Concentrations, % mае.: total sulfur paraffins/melting point silica gel resins asphaltenes Fractional composition Concentration Density % mass. by 20 °С, kg/m3 4.5 730.2 Figures 911.0 19.3 -30 2.2 1.8/50 11.0 2.0 Kinematical viscosity by 20 °С, mm2/s - Fraction b.p.-120 °С, % mass. 11.7 751.8 Fraction b.p.-180 °С, % mass. 11.9 791.0 1.35 Fraction 120-210 °С, % mass. 31.6 840.0 3.50 Fraction 120-311 °С, % mass. Emissions of reservoir water is not taken into account 4.9 26.8 859.2 Fraction 180-320 °С, % (the initial period of operation) mass. 61.5 950.0 Fraction > 320 °С, % mass. BASIC DATE 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. For the calculation we used data from NCEP / NCAR reanalysis for a 10-year period from 01.01.2002 to 31.12.2011. Spatial resolution data in the platform area is ~ 12 km x 34 km, the discreteness in time is 1 hour. Calculation of the velocity fields of near-water wind was produced according to the fields of atmospheric pressure used with the processing by the method of Russian Hydrometcentre of Russia (by Popov, S., Lobov A.) on a grid of 5 * 5 nautical miles. Calculated near-water wind fields used for calculation of ocean currents in the basin of the Barents Sea. Fields of currents and wind are calculated in increments of 1 hour, each year includes about 8,000 meteorological situations. Each of the seasons, ice (January-May) and ice-free (July-November) recorded 36 240 cases. For estimates of restrictions on the responses two other sources of data on wind conditions were considered. Comparison showed a fairly high correlation between all the data. HYDROMETEOROLOGICAL CONDITIONS (EXAMPLES) Sea level pressure and near-water wind for 15 hours of July 14, 2009 Sea level and current velocity on the surface for 15 hours of 14 July 2009 HYDROLOGICAL CONDITIONS (EXAMPLES) September Ellipses of tidal currents of M2 wave at the sea surface (The color shows counter-clockwise rotation) April ICE CONDITIONS 1. To consider the ice conditions we used climatic maps of ice boundaries with defined levels of cohesion. 2. Characteristics of ice conditions in the ISM point prepared by specialists at AARI (V. Smolyanitsky and V. Stanovoy). Information about ice conditions obtained by AARI from Global data assimilation system (GDAS), operating in Global Forecast System (GFS) NCEP / NOAA (USA). 3. Spatial resolution of the date 20 km 20 km, discretion by time of 3 hours. OIL WEATHERING Oil spill of 16,000 tons in 5 days Oil spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days OIL WEATHERING Estimates show that changes in viscosity due to evaporation are small and make several percent (max. 4%). At the same time, the viscosity can increase about 20 times due to emulsification, taking the maximum water concentration in oil for 70%. Oil density starting with a value of 911 kg/m3, due to evaporation increases up to 1,021 kg/m3, and further, due to emulsification, goes to the turn of 1,025 kg/m3. ISM oil can have a high ability to go underwater due to a low buoyancy balance. POSSIBLE OIL POLLUTION OF OFFSHORE WATERS AND COASTAL WATERS Spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days Ice period Non-ice period POSSIBLE OIL POLLUTION OF OFFSHORE WATERS AND COASTAL WATERS Spill of 16000 tons in 5 days Ice period Non-ice period SPILL SPREAD RISK ZONES Spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days, foil thickness > 10 mk Ice period Non-ice period SPILL SPREAD RISK ZONES Spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days, foil thickness > 50 mk Ice period Non-ice period SPILL SPREAD RISK ZONES Spill of 16,000 tons in 5 days, foil thickness> 10 mk Ice period Non-ice period PROBABILITY OF WATER AREAS POLLUTION Spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days, foil thickness> 10 mk 5 days Ice period Non-ice period PROBABILITY OF WATER AREAS POLLUTION Spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days, foil thickness > 10 mk 10 days Ice period Non-ice period PROBABILITY OF WATER AREAS POLLUTION Spill of 16,000 tons in 5 days, foil thickness > 10 mk 10 days Ice period Non-ice period PROBABILITY OF COASTS POLLUTION Spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days, foil thickness > 10 mk 10 days 5 days PROBABILITY OF COASTS POLLUTION Spill of 1,500 tons in 3 days, foil thickness > 50 mk 10 days 5 days PROBABILITY OF COASTS POLLUTION Spill of 16,000 tons in 5 days, foil thickness > 10 mk 10 days 5 days PROBABILITY OF COASTS POLLUTION Spill of 16000 tons in 5 days, foil thickness > 50 mk 10 days 5 days CALCULATED SCENARIOS (1,500 tons/3 days, pollution of the Ostrov Matveyev (Matveyev Island), 25 hours) CALCULATED SCENARIOS (1,500 tons/3 days, access to Dolgiy island, 18 hours) Quick transfer results in high dispersion CALCULATED SCENARIOS (16,000 tons/5 days, pollution of islands Matveyev and Dolgiy, 96 hours) Time to reach the coastline 44 hours. Total length of shoreline affected 56,124 m. Mass on the shores = 235 tons Wind, m/s Current, cm/s CALCULATED SCENARIOS (16,000 tons/5 days, pollution of islands Matveyev and Dolgiy, 96 hours) Transfer dynamics Wind m/s Time to reach the coastline 17 hours (islands). The total length of the affected coastline - 40 km. Oil mass on coast = 87 tons Current, cm/s CALCULATED SCENARIOS (16,000 tons/5 days, pollution of islands Gulyaevskiye Koshki, 96 hours) Time to reach the coastline 54 hours. Total length of shoreline affected 36,430 meters. Oil mass on coast = 455 t. Wind, m/s Current, cm/s CALCULATED SCENARIOS (16,000 tons/5 days, pollution of the coast Varandey, 96 hours) Time to reach the coastline 43 hours. Total length of shoreline affected 17,937 m. Oil mass on coast = 344 t. Wind, m/s Current, cm/s EXISTING AND PROPOSED PROTECTED AREAS IN THE BARENTS SEA habitat for birds and the area covered by the Ramsar Convention specially protected natural sites ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE AREAS IN THE BARENTS SEA habitat for birds coast types SPILL ELLIMINATION PERFORMANCE STATISTICS Elise DeCola. Review of Oil Spill Responses on ModeratelySized Spills in US Waters from 1993-2000. NUKA Research&Planning Group, 2002 TERMS OF RESPONSES - CURRENT The distribution of current velocity in the ice season OIRFP AREA The distribution of current velocity in the non-ice season TERMS OF RESPONSES - WIND Frequency of wind speed >7,5 m/s Frequency of wind speed >10 m/s Frequency of wind speed >12,5 s/m TERMS OF RESPONSES - COMMOTION Frequency of occurrence of significant wave with height of 1.5 m The distribution functions fo significant wave height (SWH) were constructed according to the calculation of wind waves on the spectral model WaveWatch III version 3.14 [Tolman, H.L., 2009: User manual and system documentation of WAVEWATCH III version 3.14. NOAA / NWS / NCEP / MMAB Technical Note 276, 194 pp + Appendices at http://polar.ncep.noaa.gov/waves/wavewatch/]. The frequency of occurrence of significant wave height exceeding 2.5 m TERMS OF RESPONSES - CURRENT The frequency of flow velocity > 0.9 knots Pechora Sea The frequency of flow velocity > 1.2 knots TERMS OF RESPONSES - OBSERVABILITY Duration of OSR work based on day light ICE CONDITIONS ICE CONDITIONS ICE CONDITIONS Average Climatic borders of the ice with 30% cohesion ICE CONDITIONS Information on the ice was obtained by AARI from Global data assimilation system GDAS, operating in Global Forecast System - GFS, NCEP / NOAA (USA). The spatial resolution of the data ~20 km x 20 km, time discretion 3 hours. The cohesion of ice in the vicinity of the OIRFP (2010-2012) EXTREME ICE CONDITIONS Cohesion of ice for 31.01.2011 according to NIC (National / Naval Ice Center NOAA) CALCULATIONS IN ICE CONDITION, SAMPLES (1,500 tons/3 days, 18.11.2000) CALCULATIONS IN ICE CONDITION, SAMPLES (16,000 tons/5 days, 20.11.2000) CALCULATIONS IN ICE CONDITION, SAMPLES (10,000 tons/5 days, 24.11.2000) OSR RESCUE MEANS The vessel "Vladislav Strizhov" The vessel "Toboy", Varandey terminal " BRAND NEW CONSTRUCTION MULTIFUNCTIONAL ICE CLASS VESSELS The vessel "Yuri Topchiev" Federal Program "Development of the transport system of the Russian Federation (20102015) years," provides the construction of specialized rescue vessels : • rescue vessel 7 МВт by project MPSV06 - 4 units in 2012-2015; • rescue vessel 4 МВт by project MPSV07 - 4 units in 2011-2012; • rescue boom-laying boat by project A40-2Б - 12 units in 2010-2014. MPSV06 MPSV07 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR EQUIPMENT OF OSR SHIPS It is recommended to consider the necessity and appropriateness of the equipment of OSR ships by following special systems and equipment : 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. execution and placement, taking into account the use of equipment in arctic conditions (winterization - shelter, heating, frost protection, maintenance, etc.); special surveillance systems for water surface to detect and estimate parameters of oil spills (specialized detection and control over spills system, side-scan sonar with variable frequency aperture on the ship, laser fluorometer in a helicopter); kits with coils and circuits enclosing booms with energy boosting blocks enclosing booms); means of launching, hauling, control and recovery-gathering equipment (slips, crane girders, cranes, controllers, towing devices, etc.); kits for the collection of various types of oil; sets of mounted oil-gathering systems for trawling and taking oil from contaminated waters; set of equipment for emergency transfer of oil and petroleum products from vessels in distress (pumps, hoses and connections for the reception and transmission to be performed, adapted for operation in ice conditions and heavy oil); power units and hydraulic actuators of oil collecting devices (usually bundled with the device); piping and pumps for receiving and pumping oily mixture, including those with a flashpoint below 60°C, from the oil-gathering devices overboard, working at low temperatures and ice conditions; RECOMMENDATIONS FOR EQUIPMENT OF OSR SHIPS 10. tanks for receiving and storing the collected hydrocarbons, including those with a flashpoint below 60° C; fittings; 10. steam generators and steam lines for processing and cleaning of equipment contaminated with oil; 11. boom-laying boats of necessary power and autonomy navigation with equipment for exploration of oil pollution, complex (involved in oil recovery orders), and independent OSR operations, (delivery and set up of light protective boom barriers in shallow water); 12. hydromonitors for cleaning the ice overboard and on board of a ship; 13. clamshell devices and other types for collection on board the contaminated snow and ice; 14. equipment for purification of contaminated snow and ice on board (open container with removable slatted flooring and heated); 15. kits and equipment for work on the ice cover; 16. steam generators and steam lines for processing and cleaning of equipment exposed to icing and oil pollution; 17. separation equipment for the primary water separation of the mixture collected; 18. control devices and pipelines for release of purified water with continuous monitoring of the volume and content of hydrocarbons on the release; 19. standard hoses and unified connectors for delivery of oil to transport vessels and terminals; RECOMMENDATIONS FOR EQUIPMENT OF OSR SHIPS 21. supply of free floating buoys with GPS transmitters, buoys with reflectors and beacons; 22. supply of light and reflecting markers to be installed on a descent overboard equipment; 23. set of security tools by OSR works (PPE, sensors for dangerous concentrations of hydrocarbons, devices for determining the flash point of hydrocarbon); 24. additional means of illumination of the sea surface; 25. kits for sampling of oil pollution (water, ice and snow) overboard and in containers; 26. instrumentation and analytical tools for sampling and determination of the hydrocarbons in the water discharged; 27. instrumentation for the treatment of operations with oil; 28. placement of stocks of materials and equipment for preparation and spraying of dispersants - when making a decision about the use of dispersants. APPLIED OSR TECHNOLOGY Technology and examples of equipment Terms of use Localization by oil barriers and/or oil-gathering trawling order (J-order) Booms in open sea with the height of the board with boom-laying boats Open water, favorable weather conditions, compact spill Trawling with mounted oil recovery systems with branches in the outrigger booms Open water and low water (20-30%), the cohesion of the ice Collection of oil with skimmer descent from the board (such as Free Floating Offshore) The cohesion of the ice up to 50 % Collection of oil using on-board (such as Oil Ice Separator to collect oil en route) or external (such as Oil Recovery Bucket to collect oil in the drift and/or SEA-MOP) systems The cohesion of the ice up to 50-70%, broken ice Collection of oil with a descent from board (such as Arctic Skimmer) or remote (such as Oil Recovery Bucket and/or SEA-MOP) skimmer The cohesion of ice up to 90% Collection of broken ice with ascent and on-board processing The cohesion of ice up to 90% Delivery of oil to tankers and offshore installations With control of the composition and volume of oily mixtures transferred Initial cleaning of oily mixture and discharge of purified water Controlled burning with the introduction of the initiators of combustion The use of dispersants by spraying from a craft and a helicopter In conjunction with overboard ice washing with water With control of the concentration of oil on discharge A massive sluggish spill, including ice conditions, approval by the environmental authorities With the threat of pollution of protected areas and sensitive coastal areas, coordination with environmental authorities WORK EXECUTION TECHNOLOGIES Ice conditions - skimmer LAS 125 W/P Features Figures Performance Up to 70 m3/h Collecting efficiency No less than 90 % Drive hydraulic, 8 kWt Oil delivery pump centrifugal Archimedes screw The descent / ascent to the water / management crane Dimensions 1,85 м 1,41 м 2,18 м 750 kg Weight WORK EXECUTION TECHNOLOGIES Ice conditions - skimmers RO-MOP, SEA-MOP WORK EXECUTION TECHNOLOGIES Remote hydraulic grab External brush skimmer Oil Recovery Bucket QUESTIONS CRUCIAL IN THE SENSE OF OSR 1. Ensuring OSR : • anti-blowout equipment; • external fire fighting; • supply vessels (boats for oil recovery orders, boom barriers to contain and haul, oil-gathering system, reception and removal of collected hydrocarbons); • hydrometeorological supply; • eco-monitoring and monitoring at the working period; • helicopter and ship (icebreaker) supply (reconnaissance). 2. OSR Operations Management : • unity of Operations Management; • Operational monitoring and forecasting the spread of spills and alert shore-based services; • coordination of the LRA "sea-shore"; • mobilization and engagement with the forces and means. QUESTIONS CRUCIAL IN THE SENSE OF OSR 3. Staff and facilities : • training of staff (recruitment and / or creation of ASF); • boats (specifications for ice conditions, contracts for ship maintenance and servicing); • boom barriers; • skimmers and oil-gathering system; • Trawling spills (mounted systems); • reception and storage of oily mixture (contracts for vessel services). 4. Quality of contracts of LRA OSR : • compliance with the Plan of OSR; • composition and deployment of forces and equipment (security levels); • preparatory activities (scouting, reconnaissance, deployment and mobilization); • readiness (location, speed); • control over the work period (public, corporate and authorized supervision). ORIGIN, DEVELOPMENT AND THE ELIMINATION OF SPILLS OF HYDROCARBONS, ASSESS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE MEASURES Environment Environmental sensitivity Financial and material resources Influence Leakage and spills Control over sources Transfer and weathering Control over spills Impact on water area and coast Environmental damage and consequences Fees and Compensations Localization and collection Elimination and recovery Elimination costs ??? applicability in Arctic??? ??? Efficiency ??? ??? Efficiency??? Planning and application Establishment costs Development dynamics ES(Н) Costs of maintaining readiness Decisions making ?? ? E F F I C I E N C Y ?? ? ISSUES TO BE SOLVED 1. Oil properties: behavior at low temperatures; tendency to form emulsions "water in oil". Equipment features : equipment tests; determination of the limiting characteristics of the equipment under the terms of the wind, currents, commotion. 3. Preparedness: • training of staff; • Adequacy of equipment and software for arctic conditions; • providing transport to remote areas; • mobilization of additional resources; • interaction with the terminal Varandey. • • 2. • • ISSUES TO BE SOLVED 4. Working in difficult conditions : • control over spills at night; • control over spills in ice conditions, including longterm (remote detection, drifting buoys, etc.); • work in the ice conditions and on ice; • limitations of illumination and visibility. 5. Environmental security : • account of the victims and help for animals and birds. 6. etc. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION V. Jouravel tel.: +7 499 235 6585, + 7 985 928 0736 E-mail [email protected] Any questions?