SHRM Survey Findings: Financial Wellness in the Workplace Sponsored by McGraw-Hill Federal Credit Union May 14, 2014
Download ReportTranscript SHRM Survey Findings: Financial Wellness in the Workplace Sponsored by McGraw-Hill Federal Credit Union May 14, 2014
SHRM Survey Findings: Financial Wellness in the Workplace Sponsored by McGraw-Hill Federal Credit Union May 14, 2014 Definitions • Financial education: Any workplace initiative, program or resource designed to provide employees with information on how to manage their resources effectively for a lifetime of financial well-being. • Employee Generations » Traditionalists: born before 1946; 69 years of age or older. » Baby Boomers: born between 1946 and 1964; 50 to 68 years of age. » Generation X: born between 1965 and 1980; 34 to 49 years of age. » Millennials: born after 1980; 33 years of age or younger. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 2 Key Findings • What are the most common financial challenges faced by employees? According to 42% of HR professionals, medical expenses are the most common personal financial challenge affecting employees. As of December 2013/January 2014, this number increased seven percentage points compared with 2011. Furthermore, 41% of HR professionals reported that an overall lack of monetary funds to cover personal expenses affected employees at their organization. • Do personal financial challenges affect overall employee performance? Seven out of 10 HR professionals indicated that personal financial challenges have a “large” or “some” impact on overall employee performance. Of these HR professionals, approximately one-half reported that employees’ stress (50%) and their ability to focus on work (47%) were the aspects of employee performance that were most negatively affected by personal financial challenges. • Are employees currently faced with more personal financial challenges than before? Thirtyeight percent of HR professionals reported that their employees have more personal financial challenges now compared with the early part of the Recession in late 2007, while 23% of HR professionals said their employees are experiencing more personal financial challenges compared with 12 months ago. • Are employees more likely to request a defined contribution savings plan loan or hardship withdrawal now than before? Almost two-thirds of HR professionals (62%) agreed or strongly agreed that employees have been more likely to request a defined contribution plan loan over the past 12 months compared with previous years, whereas 44% agreed or strongly agreed that employees have been more likely to request a defined contribution savings hardship withdrawal. Financial Wellnessplan in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 3 Key Findings (continued) • Are organizations providing financial education to their employees? Nearly three-fifths of organizations (57%) provide some kind of financial education to their employees. Nonprofit organizations are more likely than privately owned for-profit organizations to offer this benefit to their employees. • What challenges do organizations that provide financial education face? One-quarter of organizations reported facing obstacles in providing financial education for their employees. The greatest challenges among organizations that offer financial education to their employees are the cost (33%) and the lack of interest among staff (28%). • What type of financial education do organizations provide to their employees? The most common types of financial educations organizations offer to their employees are retirement planning (79%), financial counseling/resources through an employee assistance program (75%) and financial investment planning (56%). • Which generations are most likely to take advantage of financial education benefits? HR professionals indicated that Baby Boomers (70%) and Generation X employees (53%) are the generations most likely to participate in financial education programs. Furthermore, Baby Boomers are most interested in retirement planning (77%), and Generation X in financial investment planning (44%). • What are the biggest obstacles that prevent organizations from offering financial education to their employees? The most common concerns for organization that do not currently offer financial education to their employees are the cost (24%) and the lack ofFinancial staff resources pursue offering Wellness in theto Workplace ©SHRM 2014 4 financial education (22%). What do these findings mean for HR professionals? • Even in an improving economy, many workers continue to struggle with their finances. This research shows that nearly two out of five workers are having a harder time with money now compared with the onset of the Great Recession in 2007. Knowing this, organizations should consider offering some type of financial counseling program for their employees. • Other SHRM research has shown that most employers do not leverage their benefits programs as a retention/recruitment tool; less than one-fifth (18%) use their benefits program as a retention tool and about one-quarter (26%) as a recruitment tool).* However, organizations that do leverage these benefits frequently cite their retirement savings and planning benefits as a means of keeping or attracting workers (57% of HR professionals who leverage benefits programs use retirement savings and planning benefits for retention, and 70% of HR professionals use them for recruitment). • When developing a formal financial and/or retirement counseling program, HR professionals should tailor that benefit for different generations in the workplace. Baby Boomers and members of Generation X are most likely to participate in a financial education program at work. But younger workers, such as Millennials, represent a fast-growing segment of the labor force, and other research has shown that they value an assortment of retirement options and other types of financial planning they receive through their jobs. *Source: Society for Human Resource Management (2013, December). 2013 State of Employee Benefits in the Workplace Series. Retrieved from http://www.shrm.org/Research/SurveyFindings/Articles/ Pages/2013StateofBenefits-BenefitstoRecruit.aspx. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 5 The Impact of Financial Challenges on the Workplace Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 6 In the past 12 months, which of the following personal financial challenges have affected employees at your organization the most? 42% Medical expenses 35% Overall lack of monetary funds to cover their personal expenses 41% 49% 31% 26% Saving for retirement 25% 22% Credit card debt 16% Child care expenses* 15% Home mortgage payments 22% 13% 12% Education expenses Home rental payments Other debt 2014 (n = 401) 2011 (n = 459) 7% 9% 5% 8% Elder care expenses* 4% Bankruptcy 2% 4% Other 2% 4% Note: Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Percentages may not equal 100% due to multiple response options. An asterisk (*) indicates that the response option was not offered in 2011. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 7 How much of an impact do employees’ personal financial challenges have on employees’ work performance? 15% A large impact 22% 55% Some impact 61% 2014 (n = 351) 2011 (n = 424) 26% A slight impact 16% 4% No impact at all 2% Note: Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Percentages may not equal 100% due to rounding. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 8 What aspects of overall employee work performance are MOST negatively affected when employees face personal financial challenges? 50% 46% Overall employee stress Ability of employees to focus on work 47% 47% 29% 26% Overall employee productivity 26% 24% Employee absenteeism/tardiness 15% Employee engagement* 2011 (n = 341) 15% 20% Overall employee morale 7% 12% Overall employee health Working relationships with other employees Other 2014 (n = 234) 6% 7% 0% 1% Note: Only respondents who said that personal financial challenges have “a large impact” or “some impact” on overall employee work performance were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Percentages do not equal 100% due to multiple response options. An asterisk (*) indicates that the response option was not offered in 2011. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 9 Were employees at your organization faced with more, about the same or fewer personal financial challenges in December 2013/January 2014 compared with…? 68% 46% 38% 23% 16% 9% The early part of the Recession* (n = 321) 12 months ago (n = 333) More personal financial challenges About the same personal financial challenges Fewer personal financial challenges Note: Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. * The early part of the Recession refers to late 2007. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 10 In the past 12 months, has the amount employees contributed to their organization-sponsored defined contribution plans (e.g., 401(k), IRA, etc.) changed compared with previous years? Decreased 24% Stayed the same Increased 54% 22% Note: n = 335. Respondents who answered “Not sure” or “My organization does not offer this benefit” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 11 In the past 12 months, compared with previous years, employees have been more likely to request a… Defined contribution plan loan (n = 263) Defined contribution savings plan hardship withdrawal (n = 269) Strongly agree 15% 9% Agree 47% 35% Disagree 32% 46% 5% 10% Strongly disagree Note: Respondents who answered “Not sure” or “My organization does not offer this benefit” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 12 Employer-Sponsored Financial Education Resources Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 13 Does your organization currently provide any kind of financial education to your employees? 57% Yes 52% 64% 2014 (n = 362) 2011 (n = 435) 2009 (n = 401) 43% No 48% 36% Of those organizations that do not currently provide financial education, 21% plan to do so in the next 12 Note: Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 14 Does your organization currently provide any kind of financial education to your employees? Comparisons by organization sector • Nonprofit organizations are more likely than privately owned for-profit organizations to provide any kind of financial education to their employees. Comparisons by organization sector Nonprofit (71%) > Privately owned for-profit (50%) Note: Only statistically significant differences are shown. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 15 What type of financial education do organizations provide to employees? Retirement planning 79% Access to an Employee Assistance Program (EAP)* 75% Financial investment planning 56% Medical/health care costs planning 40% General budgeting advice 26% Privacy, security and fraud protection 25% Education planning 24% Credit restoration/repair resources Home buying seminars Other 11% 7% 3% Note: n = 208. Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Percentages do not equal 100% due to multiple response options. An asterisk (*) indicates that the EAP includes financial counseling/resources. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 16 How do organizations provide financial education to employees? 2014 (n = 208) 2011 (n = 219) 2009 (n = 256) Seminars during work hours using outside speakers* 61% 60% 57% Paper resources (e.g., pamphlets, handouts) 51% - - New-hire employee orientation 44% 44% 47% Self-directed e-learning 37% - - Intranet* 36% 40% 42% Seminars during work hours lead by trained in-house staff* 25% 17% 31% In-house newsletter 23% 25% 30% Seminars outside of work hours* 20% 22% 15% Employee assistance program (EAP)** 5% - - - 11% 17% 6% 9% 2% Mandatory seminars/training Other Note: Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Percentages may not equal 100% due to multiple response options. A dash (-) indicates that the response was not asked that specific year. An asterisk (*) indicates that the response option was modified from previous years. A double asterisk (**) indicates that the response option was developed from open-ended responses. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 17 In the past 12 months, has your organization seen an increased demand for financial education from employees? 32% Yes 37% 35% 2014 (n = 171) 2011 (n = 154) 2009 (n = 195) 68% No 63% 65% Note: Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 18 In 2013, have the financial education offerings at your organization changed compared with 2012? Increased 27% Stayed the same Decreased 73% 1% Note: n = 195. Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Percentages do not equal 100% due to rounding. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 19 For your 2014 budget, will you request more, about the same or fewer funds for financial education than in previous years? More funds 6% About the same funds Fewer funds 88% 6% Note: n = 164. Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” or “No funds for financial education in 2014” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 20 Which generations are most likely to participate in the financial education offerings at your organization? Traditionalists 10% Baby Boomers 70% Generation X Millennials 53% 15% Note: n = 208. Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Percentages do not equal 100% due to multiple response options. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 21 What financial education topic is most important to each generation? Baby Boomers (n = 144) Generation X (n = 105) Millennials (n = 29) Retirement planning 77% 20% 14% Medical/health care costs planning 9% 7% 10% Financial investment planning 9% 44% 31% General budgeting advice 1% 12% 24% Credit restoration/repair resources 1% 9% 7% Home buying seminars 1% 4% 3% Privacy, security and fraud protection 1% 1% 3% Education planning 0% 4% 0% Other 0% 0% 7% Note: Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Percentages may not equal 100% due to rounding. Respondents were asked to select one financial education topic for the generation that was most likely to participate. Data are sorted by the “Baby Boomers” column. Results on “Traditionalists” are not included due to a small sample size (n=20). Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 22 Has your organization conducted a needs assessment (including surveys, focus groups, etc.) to determine what topics or delivery methods of financial education would be most beneficial to your employees? 16% Yes 10% 2014 (n = 197) 12% 2011 (n = 214) 2009 (n = 253) 84% No 90% 88% Note: Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 23 Overall, how effective has your organization’s financial education initiative been in improving your employees’ financial wellness? Very effective 6% Somewhat effective 66% Somewhat ineffective Very ineffective 19% 9% Note: n = 143. Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 24 Has your organization’s financial education initiatives faced any obstacles? 25% Yes 21% 33% 2014 (n = 167) 2011 (n = 215) 2009 (n = 256) 75% No 79% 67% Note: Only respondents whose organizations offered financial education were asked this question. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 25 What is the biggest obstacle that your financial education initiatives face? Organizations currently offering financial education Organizations not currently offering financial education 2014 (n = 43) 2011 (n = 48) 2009 (n = 171) 2014 (n = 86) 2011 (n = 150) 2009 (n = 132) Cost of providing financial education 33% 33% 25% 24% 25% 27% Lack of interest among employees 28% 27% 37% 16% 23% 19% Lack of staff resources to pursue this offering* 16% 10% - 22% 0% - Concern about perceived violation of fiduciary duty if providers of financial education (i.e., outside providers) are not objective* 7% 6% 11% 8% 9% 14% Lack of support from organization’s leaders 5% 8% 11% 15% 15% 14% Not sure how to create or find financial education resources 2% 4% 8% 2% 14% 7% Lack of need in the workplace 0% 6% 6% 7% 8% 17% Note: An asterisk (*) indicates that the survey choice was changed from prior survey years. Percentages may not equal 100% due to rounding. A dash (Other 9% 4% 2% 5% 6% 2% ) indicates that data are not available. Data are sorted by “Organizations currently offering financial education” in 2014. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 26 Demographics Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 27 Demographics: Employee Generations in Respondents’ Workplace Traditionalists 1% Baby Boomers 45% Generation X 60% Millennials Employees are more or less equally distributed across all generations 20% 5% Note: n = 361. Percentages may not equal 100% due to multiple response options. Respondents were asked to select up to two generations that primarily represented their workforce. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 28 Demographics: Employee Gender in Respondents’ Workplace Mostly female employees 36% More or less equally distributed between male and female employees Mostly male employees 39% 25% Note: n = 346. Respondents who answered “Not sure” were excluded from this analysis. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 29 Demographics: Organization Industry Percentage Professional, scientific and technical services 22% Health care and social assistance 18% Finance and insurance 14% Manufacturing 11% Educational services 10% Government agencies 10% Transportation and warehousing 6% Retail trade 5% Administrative and support and waste management and remediation services 5% Accommodation and food services 4% Religious, grant-making, civic, professional and similar organizations 4% Note: n = 354. Percentages may not equal 100% due to multiple response options. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 30 Demographics: Organization Industry (continued) Percentage Utilities 3% Information, publishing industries 3% Wholesale trade 3% Construction 2% Arts, entertainment and recreation 2% Real estate and rental and leasing 1% Repair and maintenance 1% Mining 1% Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting 1% Personal and laundry services 0% Other 5% Note: n = 354. Percentages may not equal 100% due to multiple response options. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 31 Demographics: Organization Sector Privately owned for-profit organization 48% Nonprofit organization 23% Publicly owned for-profit organization 14% Government sector Other 11% 3% Note: n = 353. Percentages do not equal 100% due to rounding. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 32 Demographics: Organization Staff Size 1 to 99 employees 23% 100 to 499 employees 41% 500 to 2,499 employees 22% 2,500 to 24,999 employees 25,000 or more employees 9% 4% Note: n = 345. Percentages do not equal 100% due to rounding. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 33 Demographics: Other Is your organization a single-unit company or a multi-unit company? Does your organization have U.S.based operations (business units) only, or does it operate multinationally? U.S.-based operations only 83% Multinational operations 17% n = 359 Single-unit company: A company in which the location and the company are one and the same 36% Multi-unit company: A company that has more than one location 64% n = 358 What is the HR department/function for which you responded throughout this survey? Are HR policies and practices determined by the multi-unit corporate headquarters, by each work location or both? Corporate (companywide) 81% 65% Business unit/division 13% Multi-unit headquarters determines HR policies and practices Facility/location 6% Each work location determines HR policies and practices 1% A combination of both the work location and the multi-unit headquarters determine HR policies and practices 35% n = 232 Note: n = 234. Percentages do not equal 100% due to rounding. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 34 SHRM Survey Findings: Financial Wellness in the Workplace Sponsored by McGraw-Hill Federal Credit Union Survey Methodology • Response rate = 14% • Sample composed of 401 randomly selected HR professionals with the title of assistant director or above from SHRM’s membership • Margin of error = +/- 5% • Survey fielded December 17, 2013 – January 27, 2014 Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 35 Additional SHRM Resources • Retirement Plans Resource Page • Retirement and Financial Planning Articles • Defined Contribution Plans Resource Page • Defined Contribution: Loans and Withdrawals • Defined Contribution: Education and Advice Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 36 About SHRM Research For more survey/poll findings, visit shrm.org/surveys. For more information about SHRM’s Customized Research Services, visit shrm.org/customizedresearch. Follow us on Twitter @SHRM_Research. Project leader: Christina Lee, researcher, SHRM Research Project contributors: Alexander Alonso, Ph.D., SPHR, vice president, SHRM Research Evren Esen, director, Survey Research Center, SHRM Research Copy editor: Katya Scanlan, SHRM Knowledge Center Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 37 About SHRM Founded in 1948, the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) is the world’s largest HR membership organization devoted to human resource management. Representing more than 275,000 members in over 160 countries, the Society is the leading provider of resources to serve the needs of HR professionals and advance the professional practice of human resource management. SHRM has more than 575 affiliated chapters within the United States and subsidiary offices in China, India and United Arab Emirates. Visit us at shrm.org. Financial Wellness in the Workplace ©SHRM 2014 38