Chapter 4 - Adjudications Due Process Substantive Due Process Substantive Due Process refers to the limits on what government can regulate Federal -
Download ReportTranscript Chapter 4 - Adjudications Due Process Substantive Due Process Substantive Due Process refers to the limits on what government can regulate Federal -
Chapter 4 - Adjudications Due Process 1 Substantive Due Process Substantive Due Process refers to the limits on what government can regulate Federal - commerce clause, national security powers, foreign affairs, State - police powers v. privacy (abortion) Important in the early days of the court before the modern expansive reading of the commerce clause 2 Modern Substantive Due Process Substantive Due Process is a limited concept in modern supreme court jurisprudence But a controversial one Even when there are constitutional bars, the court generally allows significant regulation There may be a right to an abortion, but the state can regulate health and safety aspects of abortion clinics There may be a right to own a gun, but the state can regulate carrying the gun - probably 3 Procedural Due Process Procedural due process refers to the procedures by which government may affect the rights of an individuals in a specific situation Procedural due process arises through adjudications and other proceeding that affect a small group of persons based on the specific factual determinations There is no procedural due process right in legislation What is your appeal for legislation? 4 History of Due Process The constitution mostly did not apply to the states The 14th amendment was eventually used to apply the constitution to the states Many of the due process protections we take for granted stem from the Warren Court and cases decided in the 1950s and 1960s. Criminal due process was developed earlier than administrative due process The cutting edge of due process is transforming criminal due process into administrative, as with terrorist detainees 5 Takings Review What is a traditional property "taking"? What due process is involved? What about compensation? How is compensation measured? Why is traditional takings jurisprudence much older than individual rights jurisprudence? 6 Regulatory Takings What is a regulatory taking? Why are these a hot topic in land use? What are the consequences of forcing the state to pay for any diminished value caused by regulation? Do you really think we can sort this out for coastal restoration? Should the owner pay the state if regulation enhances property values? Right of reclamation in LA 7 Accidental Deprivations Assume the postman runs over your dog or the forest service accidentally burns down your home Have you suffered a taking? Are these due process deprivations? If so, how could the government provide due process? What if the government repeatedly forgets to give mental patients a hearing before committing them? Is this different? 8 Rights v. Privileges - History In 1940 a city fires a policeman because the police chief heard a rumor that the policeman had accepted free coffee and doughnuts from a shop on his beat. Due process violation? Did not need to provide due process for not granting or for terminating a government benefit Government benefits were construed broadly - going to a state college You could condition these with restrictions that would otherwise be impermissible Bitter with the Sweet Doctrine 9 Goldberg v. Kelly, 397 U.S. 254 (1970) The Last Gasp of Liberal United States Supreme Court Due Process Jurisprudence 10 Learning Objectives Learn how the status of the affected persons can change the nature of the due process needed for fundamental fairness Learn how increasing due process rights can have unintended consequences in a program with limited resources 11 The pre-1996 Welfare System What is the general attitude toward people on Welfare? How was this reflected in the administration of the welfare programs? What was AFDC? What were the unintended consequences of the welfare system? How does this affect health care financing? 12 Stopped here 13 Supreme Court Context Earl Warren Appointed Chief Justice in 1953 - by which president? What was Warren's background? Served until 1969 What was the jurisprudential shift on the United States Supreme Court in the 1950s and 1960s? Who became Chief Justice after Earl Warren? 14 Facts of the Case What state did this case arise in? What program was providing benefits to the plaintiffs? What was the economic status of plaintiffs? How does this complicate their effectively asserting their legal rights? Why did this result in the right to appointed counsel for indigent criminal defendants? 15 Statutory Entitlements What makes a benefit an entitlement? What is a matrix regulation? 16 Matrix Regulation Test 1 Test 2 Claimant Status Income less than $3000 for family of 2 Assets less than $2000 Income less than x $6000 for family of 4 Head of x household is disabled 17 Pre-Goldberg: Post vs Pre-Deprivation Due Process What was the administrative process that plaintiffs were contesting? What do you think is the relationship between the agency personnel and the plaintiffs? What were the problems with the informal system of reevaluating beneficiaries status? What was the impact on plaintiffs of terminating benefits? How does this further complicate post-deprivation hearing rights? 18 Why a Hearing? Why couldn't plaintiff hire an attorney and file a written response to the termination letter? What could she do at a hearing that she could not do in writing? Why wasn't a post-termination hearing enough? Why didn't the state want to give everyone a pre-termination hearing? 19 Goldberg Rights - I 1) timely and adequate notice 2) oral presentation of arguments 3) oral presentation of evidence 4) confronting adverse witnesses 5) cross-examination of adverse witnesses 20 Goldberg Rights - II 6) disclosure to the claimant of opposing evidence 7) the right to retain an attorney (no appointed counsel) 8) a determination on the record of the hearing 9) record of reasons and evidence relied on; and 10) an impartial decision maker 21 Administrative Costs of Goldberg What does granting these hearings do to the cost (delay + personnel time) of removing someone from welfare? What does it do to the balance of benefits costs to administration costs? What does this do to the global cost of the benefits system? 22 Short-Term Impact of Goldberg How does raising the administrative costs affect new claims for welfare? What is the incentive for the welfare officers under the Goldberg ruling? What expectation does it create for welfare recipients? What long term problem did this contribute to? 23 Why Administrative Due Process is Not Liberal or Conservative Conservatives Want the little man (and the rich man) to be fairly treated by the government, i.e., to be able to resist regulation Liberals Want the individual to get lots of due process, and cannot exclude corporations Both think the government losing against individuals is good 24 Fixing Welfare - The 1996 Act Who pushed for welfare reform? Who signed it? What is the new name for AFDC? TANF - Temporary assistance for Needy Families What does the name change tell you about the change in philosophy? How long do you get on the program? How does this affect future Goldberg actions? Will there be facts in dispute? 25 The Subsequent History of Goldberg Never overruled Superseded by Matthews Ultimately limited to its specific facts Unfortunately, many public health scholars did not notice then and have argued that all deprivations that affect individuals should have pre-deprivation process. 26