Delivering Shared Education Vani Borooah and Colin Knox Knowledge Exchange Seminar 1st November 2012

Download Report

Transcript Delivering Shared Education Vani Borooah and Colin Knox Knowledge Exchange Seminar 1st November 2012

Delivering Shared Education
Vani Borooah and Colin Knox
Knowledge Exchange Seminar
1st November 2012
Challenges for Education
 ‘Pattern of provision that is both unsustainable
educationally or financially’.
 85,000 spare places or the equivalent of 150
excess schools
 Public spending cuts
Further challenges
 ETI Chief Inspector’s Report: two (of three)
themes: achieving value and transforming
communities.
 Achieving value: FSM pupils – ‘low level of
achievement and the widening gap in outcomes
are unacceptable’
 Improving the quality of leadership and
management across all sectors
Further challenges
 Transforming communities: closing the
achievement gap – ‘all schools need to work as
united community…to improve standards and
outcomes for all learners.’
 ‘More cohesive planning and closer collaboration
are required to serve the best interests of the
learners..’
 We have a hugely segregated system
In summary
 There are 3 key challenges facing education
system:
 Education outcomes are too variable
 Significant access and performance inequalities
 High level of segregation
Proposals for change
 ‘Ensure that every learner fulfils his/her potential
at each stage of development’
 Viability audits to identify stress:
Quality of educational experience
Enrolment trends
Financial standing of schools.
Proposals for change
 Viability audits used to develop strategic plans
leading to network of viable and sustainable
schools.
 Drive up educational standards and address
social needs
 Promote principles of equality of opportunity and
good relations throughout the process.
 Consistent with DE policies
Progress to date
 Guidance from DE to ELBs: ‘realistic, innovative
and creative solutions’ – where are they?
 Evidence from draft area plans does not suggest
serious commitment so far.
Underpinning assumptions
 Factors driving reform agenda:
 Excess demand (85,000 empty desks)
 Need to save money
 Trend towards larger schools
•Is the current premise of education reform flawed?
Two Red Herrings
1.Big Schools are “Cost-Saving”
and “Educationally Beneficial”
2. There are 85,000 “empty
desks in NI’s educational
system
Three Neglected Issues
1. Why are schools Struggling financially?
88% of schools were either not in any budgetary difficulty not in
any serious budgetary difficulty.
So, essentially 25 schools out of 217 post-primary schools were in
financial difficulty.
The unasked question is: Is it structural or is lack of training and
competence in financial management?
2. Why do FSM pupils not get access to grammar schools? They
constitute 17% of post-primary pupils but only 7% of grammar
school enrolment
3. Why are Protestant grammars worse than Catholic grammars at
enrolling FSM pupils? 4.2% versus 9.9% of enrolment were FSM
Another Neglected Issue
4. Why is there so much inequality in performance between secondary
schools?
If two secondary schools were chosen at random, the difference between
their respective proportions of pupils achieving 5+ A*-C grades, including
English and Mathematics, in their GCSE examinations 18 points.
If two grammar schools were chosen at random, the difference between
their respective proportions of pupils achieving 5+ A*-C grades, including
English and Mathematics, in their GCSE examinations 6 points
Table 1: Distribution of FSM and SEN pupils by type of School
Source: Borooah, V.K. and Knox, C. (2012) Educational Performance and Post-Primary Schools in Northern Ireland. University of Ulster.
Grammar School
Secondary Schools
Total
FSM Pupils
4,150
22,419
26,569
SEN Pupils
4,147
20,615
24,762
Other Pupils
53,836
42,735
96,571
Total Pupils
62,133
85,769
147,902
Table 2: Average Educational Performance of Schools by Type of School, 2010
Source: Borooah, V.K. and Knox, C. (2012) Educational Performance and Post-Primary Schools in Northern Ireland. University of Ulster.
Number of
Schools
Enrolment
2011/12
(years 8-12)
Average Total
Enrolment
Free
school
meal pupils
SEN pupils
Year 12
pupils
5+ GCSE,
A*-C
5+
GCSE,
A*-C
including E
&M
Grammar
Schools
68
663
914
61
61
137
133
128
Secondary
Schools
149
478
576
150
138
98
58
35
Two More Neglected Issues
5. Why do some schools have such poor attendance? There
are schools where over 40% of pupils are “poor attenders”.
What effect does poor attendance have on school educational
performance?
What does it say about leadership in schools? The quality of
teaching and education provided?
6. How to raise school performance in terms of the proportion
of GCSE passes at A*-C grades including English and
Mathematics?
Although this features large in educational policy aspiration,
there is no strategy to deal with it.
In this seminar we will propose a solution.
Large Schools will Save Money?
They will not reduce the Department’s budget significantly.
Considering primary and post-primary school closures in their entirety, if all
schools with enrolments below the threshold number of pupils were to be closed,
the Department of Education would cut the Northern Ireland Aggregate Schools
Budget by 3.1% (£35 million out of a budget of £1.126 billion) but
simultaneously displace nearly 50,000 school pupils.
This is because under AWPU, money follows the pupil. The saving in school
closures will come from: Premises Factor, Small Schools Factor, the Principals'
Release Factor, and the Foundation Schools Factor.
The additional travel costs and opportunity costs of time on pupils will be large.
Our study for Fermanagh showed that they would swallow up most of the
budgetary saving made by the WELB in closing schools that were “too small”.
And there are community costs!!
Large Schools Confer Educational Benefits
Large Schools are neither necessary nor sufficient for a good educational
performance
Good Small Schools:
1. St. Paul’s College in Kilrea/Coleraine (NEELB) with 317 pupils: 98% of its
pupils obtained 5+ GCSEs at A*-C grades and 58% of its pupils obtained 5+
GCSEs at A*-C grades (including E&M).
2. Rathfriland High School in Newry (SELB) with 296 pupils: 96% of its pupils
obtained 5+ GCSEs at A*-C grades and 54% of its pupils obtained 5+ GCSEs
at A*-C grades (including E&M).
3. Newtownhamilton High School in Newry (167 pupils)
4. St. Mary’s College near Ballymena (278 pupils)
5. Saintfield High School in Saintfield (369 pupils)
Poorly-Performing Large Schools
1. St. Brigid’s College in Londonderry with 687
pupils,
2. St. Patrick’s College in Belfast with 785 pupils,
3. Monkstown Community College in
Newtownabbey with 710 pupils,
4. Newtownbreda High School in Belfast with 682
pupils, and
5. Dunclug College in Ballymena with 639 pupils
What Affects School Educational Performance?
Grammar school status: Largest effect on school performance was made by grammar school
status.
School size: the size of sixth form mattered significantly for performance at all levels (GSCEs
and A levels) in both grammar and secondary schools.
SEN and FSM pupils: Presence of SEN pupils has no effect on educational performance. BUT
the presence of FSM pupils adversely affecting GCSE performance of secondary schools, and
affected the A level performance of both secondary and grammar schools.
Maintained Vs Controlled Schools: performance of maintained secondary and grammar
schools was significantly better than controlled secondary and grammar schools.
Absenteeism has a much larger, and more significant, effect on school performance than
school size – yet, as an issue, it is almost entirely neglected in NI’s education debate.
Absenteeism lower in Maintained than in Controlled Schools
85,000 Empty Desks?
First, the robustness of the methodology for calculating the “approved
intake” for schools is open to question.
Second, pupils in receipt of a statement of special educational needs and
pupils admitted on appeal by the independent Appeals Tribunals, or by
direction of the independent Exceptional Circumstances Body are
excluded from the enrolment numbers
Third the overfill in oversubscribed schools is set to zero.
So, if one corrects for this, instead of 85,000 empty desks we estimate
that there are 63,000 empty desks – a 25% reduction.
Questions?
 Can institutional response via area planning raise
education standards?
 Exclusion of key criteria in area planning which
are core to school improvements?
 Support the implementation of DE’s policies?
 ALCs – do they raise education standards – what
is the evidence?
 Promote equality of opportunity and good
relations?
What else should be considered?
 ‘Realistic, innovative and creative solutions’ may
be considered and may include options that
increase sharing in education and infrastructure
in line with Departmental commitments in PfG’
 ‘Light touch’ on shared education to date
 This should change
What is shared education?
 Shared Education refers to schools from different
sectors working together in a sustained process
ranging from two or more schools making shared
use of specialist facilities, through to coordinated
timetabling, and pupils taking classes across a
network of schools.
What is shared education?
Shared education means the organisation and delivery
of education so that it:
• meets the needs of, and provides for the education
together of, learners from all Section 75 categories and
socio-economic status;
• involves schools and other education providers of differing
ownership, sectoral identity and ethos, management type
or governance arrangements; and
• delivers educational benefits to learners, promotes the
efficient and effective use of resources, and promotes
equality of opportunity, good relations, equality of identity,
respect for diversity and community cohesion.
Origins of shared education
 Curricular initiatives
 Contact schemes
 Integrated schools
Collaboration and sharing
 Collaborative networks of schools
 Rationale for collaboration and sharing according
to Bain (2006) – 3 factors:
 Educational case
 Societal case (body of research work by Hughes
et al)
 Economic case
External Intervention
 Move schools from a model of competition and
isolation to one of collaboration centred on the
needs of the learner within a collaborative
network.
 Atlantic Philanthropies and International Fund for
Ireland (risk takers)
How does it work?
How does it work?
 Delivering shared education
 Supporting teacher development to deliver
shared education
 Ensuring organisational learning and intercommunity collaboration amongst partner
schools
Examples
 Enhanced Qualifications Framework
 Rural Primary Schools
 Shared Teacher Initiative
Political Support




Party Manifestos
Peter Robinson statement
Minister’s recent statement
Shared education part of the reform lexicon
Alignment with DE policies




DE Strategic Objective on performance
Programme for Government Commitments
CRED
CSI (OFMDFM)
Proposals: from the margins to mainstream
 Shared education peer learning:
 more effective schools paired with less effective
schools to help them to improve,
 where leadership has been strong and
supportive of networking,
 where the number of schools involved is limited,
 external support
Proposals: from the margins to mainstream
Constituent elements:
 Generating positive relationships
 Focusing on teaching and learning
 Understanding, leading and managing changes
 Committing to continuous professional development
 Building community
 Drawing on external support.
Conclusions
 Two-tier system emerging from area plans:
-large single identity (‘we’re all right’) mainly
grammar schools
-the remainder: scramble to close, rationalise
and amalgamate.
 First group can become peer learners
 Second group explore shared education options
 Move away from ‘one-size-fits all solution’
Conclusions
 Opportunities to embed shared education:
Salisbury; area plans; MAG and ESA bill.
 Shared education offers the following
opportunities:
 To improve education outcomes
 To address access and performance inequalities
 To improve good relations