FIRST WORKSHOP ON SPACE-BASED ARCHITECTURE FOR CLIMATE Continuity and Architecture Requirements for Climate Monitoring WMO Gap Analysis with respect to GCOS requirements Presented.
Download ReportTranscript FIRST WORKSHOP ON SPACE-BASED ARCHITECTURE FOR CLIMATE Continuity and Architecture Requirements for Climate Monitoring WMO Gap Analysis with respect to GCOS requirements Presented.
FIRST WORKSHOP ON SPACE-BASED ARCHITECTURE FOR CLIMATE
Continuity and Architecture Requirements for Climate Monitoring
WMO Gap Analysis with respect to GCOS requirements
Presented by B. Bizzarri on appointment by WMO This working paper addresses the gap analysis for the Essential Climate Variables (ECV) defined in the framework of the “Implementation Plan for the Global Observing System for Climate in support of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC)“ The analysis was performed upon request of the WMO Expert Team on Satellite Systems (ET SAT) as a discussion paper for the “Workshop on Continuity and Architecture Requirements for Climate Monitoring”, Geneva 13-14 January 2011.
An advanced presentation was made at CGMS-38, New Delhi 8-12 Nov 2010.
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
1
INDEX
1.
2.
3.
4.
Introduction Definition of the Essential Climate Variables Identification of the measurements implied by the ECVs Short-list: ECVs based on components observable from satellite 5.
6.
6.1
6.2
6.3
6.4
Gap analysis Conclusion and important notice
Requirements coverage Time coverage Systematic gaps Important warning
Appendix 1 - Instruments/missions gap analysis in the period 2008-2025 Appendix 2 - Acronyms and lists of satellites and instruments
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
2
List of GCOS Essential Climate Variables (ECV) Surface including measurements at standardized, but globally varying heights in close proximity to the surface Upper-air up to the stratopause Composition Surface Including measurements within the surface mixed layer, usually within the upper 15 m Sub-surface A.01 A.02 A.03 A.04 A.05 A.06 A.07 A.08 A.09 A.10 A.11 A.12 A.13 A.14 A.15 A.16 ATMOSPHERIC (over Land, Sea and Ice) Air pressure Air temperature Precipitation Surface radiation budget Water vapour Wind speed and direction Cloud properties Earth radiation budget (including Solar irradiance) Temperature Water vapour Wind speed and direction Aerosol Carbon dioxide Methane Other long-lived greenhouse gases Including N 2 0, CFCs, HCFCs, HFCs, SF 6 and PFCs Ozone Ozone and aerosol precursors, in particular NO 2 , SO 2 , HCHO and CO T.01 T.02 T.03 T.04 T.05 T.06 T.07 T.08 T.09 T.10 T.11 T.12 T.13 OCEANIC O.01 Carbon dioxide partial pressure O.02 Current O.03 Ocean colour O.04 Sea ice O.05 Sea level O.06 Sea state O.07 Sea surface salinity O.08 Sea surface temperature Ocean acidity O.15 Phytoplankton O.09 Temperature O.10 Salinity O.11 Current O.12 Nutrients O.13 Carbon dioxide partial pressure O.14 Ocean tracers Ocean acidity Oxygen TERRESTRIAL River discharge Water use Ground water Lakes Snow cover Glacier and ice caps Permafrost Albedo Land cover (including vegetation type) Fraction of Absorbed Photosynthetically Active Radiation (FPAR) Leaf Area Index (LAI) Above-ground biomass Fire disturbance Ice sheets Soil moisture Soil carbon Number of ECVs: 43 consolidated 06 in the waiting list 11 further chemical species (two CFCs considered) Total: 60
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
3
Steps for the gap analysis
Each ECV actually implies a number of observable variables.
The first step was to identify the variables that can be observed from Space:
-
16 ECVs were disregarded because implying all variables not-for-satellites.
-
4 ECVs were disregarded waiting for more detailed definition.
- 40 ECVs were carried forward because could draw benefit from satellites.
Each geophysical variable observable from satellite serves more ECVs.
The gap analysis for ECVs consists of the gap analysis of the observable variables possible to be measured from Space.
The gap analysis for observables from Space has been imported from the GOS Dossier vol. III (Gap analysis), limited to the period 2008-2025.
The period 1975-2007 has been covered by reviewing historical information, recorded to some extent in the GOS Dossier vol. I (Programmes).
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
4
One example
Gap analysis for temperature and humidity profiles Satellite observation(s)
001 Atmospheric temperature 002 Specific humidity
Supported ECV(s)
Upper A.09 Temperature Upper A.10 Water vapour
Relevant instruments / missions
[click on hyperlinks for detailed gap analysis in years 2008-2025] IR temperature/humidity sounding from LEO IR temperature/humidity sounding from GEO MW temperature/humidity sounding from LEO Radio occultation Limb-sounding IR spectrometry [short-wave and millimetre-submillimetre wave have inferior quality] Continue…
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
5
Continuation…
Analysis
Troposphere
Current and future - Tropospheric temperature and humidity sounding is available with high quality (e.g. from AIRS and IASI, and AMSU and MHS) since several years, and plans for long-term continuity seem secured. Historical - Temperature/humidity sounding is a long-standing application. Referring only to operational instruments in LEO, probably the most appropriate to long-term climatic records, we have: - IR sounding: before 2002 and since 1978, IR sounding has been provided by HIRS with inferior vertical resolution than AIRS and IASI. The previous IR sounder, VTPR, dates since 1972. - MW sounding: AMSU is available since 1998, whereas before, since 1978, there was MSU, with very coarse vertical resolution and no water vapour, but very high radiometric stability.
Stratosphere
Current and future - A number of radio-occultation missions seem secured for the long term. For the upper levels (ECV-A.09 and ECV-A.10 are required up to the stratopause) IR limb sounders are needed. Currently there are several, e.g., MIPAS and TES-limb. However, there is no plan to continue limb sounding beyond these. Therefore,
a gap will appear in the higher stratosphere
very few years from now. Historical - This also is a long-standing activity: - IR limb sounding: Nimbus 6 (LRIR) and Nimbus 7 (LIMS, SAMS) covered the period 1975-1994, and UARS (CLAES, ISAMS, HALOE) the period 1991-2005, addressing both temperature and water vapour. - Radio occultations: the first was GPM/MET on Microlab-1 (1995) followed by many others, generally on small satellites. The first flown on an operational satellite is GRAS on MetOp (2006). Continue…
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
6
Continuation…
Conclusion
Troposphere - Records are available since at least 1972, with quality improved at intervals. Long-term continuity seems to be ensured. Stratosphere - Records are available since at least 1975 and will continue to be available till the early 201 0’s. After that, long-term continuity seems to be ensured by radio-occultation, only extending to mid stratosphere and with poor performance as water vapour is concerned.
T(z) IR-nadir & MW H(z) IR-limb R.O. 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
7
1 st
Programmes for IR temperature/humidity sounding from LEO
A.04 A.14 SfcRad CH4 A.07 A.16 Cloud O3 A.09 A.17.1 T(z) NO2 A.10 A.17.2 H(z) SO2 O.08 A.17.4 SST CO A.13 T.07 CO2 Perma
AIRS ASI CrIS HIRS-3/4 IAS IASI IRAS IRFS-2 Current or planned instruments relevant for the mission “IR temperature/humidity sounding from LEO”
Atmospheric Infra-Red Sounder Atmospheric Sounding Interferometer Cross-track Infrared Sounder High-resolution Infra Red Sounder Infra-Red Atmospheric Sounder Infrared Atmospheric Sounding Interferometer Infra Red Atmospheric Sounder IR Sounding Spectrometer EOS-Aqua FY-3 D to G NPP, JPSS 1 and 2 TIROS-N, NOAA 6 to 19 MetOp A & B Post-EPS MetOp A to C FY-3 A to C Meteor-M N2 2002-2011 2015-2024 2011-2026 1978-2014 2006-2016 2020-2035 2006-2020 2008-2018 2011-2016
Instrument class Instrument HIRS/3 HIRS/3 HIRS/4 IASI IRFS-2 IAS IRAS ASI HIRS/3 AIRS CrIS CrIS HIRS/4 HIRS/4 IRAS ASI Satellite NOAA-15 NOAA-16 MetOp A/B MetOp A/B/C Meteor-M N2 Post-EPS FY-3 A/C FY-3 E/G NOAA-17 EOS-Aqua NPP JPSS 1 & 2 NOAA 18 NOAA-19 FY-3 B FY-3 D/F IR radiometer IR spectrometer LST 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 05:00 X 05:30 X X X 09:30 X 09:30 X 09:30 09:30 10:00 X 10:00 10:20 X 13:30 X 13:30 13:30 13:40 X 14:00 14:00 14:00 X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X 2023 2024 2025 X X X X X X X X Feature No. of channels Spectral resolution Swath IFOV Comparative characteristics of IR temperature/humidity sounders in LEO FY-3 IRAS
26 10-20 cm -1 2250 km 17 km
NOAA/MetOp HIRS 3/4
20 10-20 cm -1 2200 km 10 or 18 km
EOS-Aqua AIRS
2378 0.5-2.0 cm -1 1650 km 13.5 km
Meteor-M IRFS-2
4000 0.5 cm -1 2500 km 35 km
NPP/JPSS CrIS
1300 0.625-2.5 cm -1 2230 km 14 km
MetOp IASI
8461 0.25 cm -1 2230 km 12 km
8
Requirements coverage
40 out of the 60 ECV’s can be supported by satellite observation, to a major or minor extent.
Atmos, Surf Atmos, Surf Atmos, Surf A.03 Precipitation A.04 Surface radiation budget A.06 Wind speed and direction Ocean, Surf O.02 Current Ocean, Surf O.03 Ocean colour Ocean, Surf O.04 Sea ice Atmos Upper A.07 Cloud properties Atmos Upper A.08 Earth radiation budget (+ Solar irradiance) Ocean, Surf O.06 Sea state Atmos Upper A.09 Temperature Ocean, Surf O.05 Sea level Ocean, Surf O.07 Sea surface salinity Atmos Upper A.10 Water vapour Atmos Upper A.11 Wind speed and direction Atmos Comp. A.12 Aerosol Atmos Comp. A.13 Carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) Atmos Comp. A.14 Methane (CH 4 ) Ocean, Surf O.08 Sea surface temperature Ocean, Surf O.14 Ocean tracers Ocean, Surf T.04 Lakes Terrestrial T.05 Snow cover Terrestrial T.06 Glacier and ice caps Atmos Comp. A.15.1 Trichlorofluoromethane (CFC-11) Atmos Comp. A.15.2 Dichlorodifluoromethane (CFC-11) Atmos Comp. A.15.3 Nitrous Oxide (N 2 0) Atmos Comp. A.15.4 Sulphur hexafluoride (SF 6 ) Atmos Comp. A.16 Ozone Atmos Comp. A.17.1 Nitrogen peroxide (NO 2 ) Atmos Comp. A.17.2 Sulfur dioxide (SO 2 ) Atmos Comp. A.17.3 Formaldehyde (HCHO) Atmos Comp. A.17.4 Carbon monoxide (CO) Terrestrial T.07 Permafrost Terrestrial T.08 Albedo Terrestrial T.09 Land cover (+ vegetation type) Terrestrial T.10 Fraction of Absorbed PAR (FAPAR) Terrestrial T.11 Leaf Area Index (LAI) Terrestrial T.12 Above-ground biomass Terrestrial T.13 Fire disturbance Terrestrial T.14 Soil moisture Terrestrial T.15 Ice sheets
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
9
Requirements not covered
The following 16 out of the 60 ECV’s are unlikely to draw any support from satellites, at least as current technology enables.
Atmos, Surf Atmos, Surf Atmos, Surf Ocean, Surf Ocean, Surf Ocean, Surf Ocean, Sub Ocean, Sub A.01 A.02 A.05 O.01 O…. O…. O.09 O.10 Air pressure Air temperature Water vapour Carbon dioxide partial pressure Ocean acidity Phytoplankton Temperature Salinity Ocean, Sub Ocean, Sub Ocean, Sub Ocean, Sub Ocean, Sub Terrestrial Terrestrial Terrestrial O.11 O.12 O.13 O…. O…. T.01 T.03 T…. Current Nutrients Carbon dioxide partial pressure Ocean acidity Oxygen River discharge Ground water Soil carbon The following 4 out of the 60 ECV’s have not been considered, waiting for more specific definition: Atmos Comp. A.15… Atmos Comp. A.15… Hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) Atmos Comp. A.15… Terrestrial T.02 Perfluorocarbons (PFCs) Water use
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
10
Major conclusions
Requirements coverage: Out of the 60 ECV’s, 40 draw benefit from satellite observation, 16 draw no benefit or marginal benefit, 4 need to be better specified.
Time coverage For many observations, data records exist since at least 1975, and long term commitment to continuity are available till at least 2025.
Systematic gaps:
-
limb sounding missions after the conclusion of the currently flown ones, that implies future gap of data on the middle and high stratosphere; and
-
measurements requiring large facilities uneasy to be accommodated on operational satellites.
Important warning It is stressed that this gap analysis only refers to the availability of satellite observations. However, the existence of observational data sets does not imply that the product has being or will be effectively retrieved and archived. Thus, the identified contribution is only potential.
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
11
Any action ?
Some suggestions (in increasing order of difficulty): 1) To bring the detail of the gap analysis for period 1975-2008 to the same level as for 2008-2025 - all the necessary information is in the GOS Dossier
;
two steps possible: - to just add mention of the past instruments and periods - to add the information on instrument performances - to evaluate and add the information on product performances (this is available in Dossier vol. IV for reference post-2020 instruments). 2) To re-edit the current document expanding the text of the analysis and of the conclusions for each ECV. [ insert slide ] [warning: current text is 80 pages !] 3) To compare existing previous gap analysis (there are several !) with the present one (probably the most systematic, with wider coverage).
• •
Preliminary questions: is this Gap analysis useful ?
is it cost/effective to improve it ? Maybe the essential message is already in.
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
12
Gap analysis for wind profile Satellite observation(s)
003 Wind (horizontal)
Supported ECV(s)
Upper A.11 Wind speed and direction
Relevant instruments / missions
[click on hyperlinks for detailed gap analysis in years 2008-2025] Multi-purpose VIS/IR imagery from GEO [by cloud and water vapour trace tracking] IR temperature/humidity sounding from GEO [by tracking water vapour profile] Multi-purpose VIS/IR imagery from LEO [in polar regions, by cloud and water vapour trace tracking] Doppler lidar Limb-sounding SW spectrometry [Doppler shift of observed oxygen lines]
W(z) 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cloud GOES GOES + Meteosat + INSAT/Kalpana + FY-2 + GMS/MTSAT + GOMS + COMS ... same, improved H(z) Polar Lidar D-shift TERRA/Aqua MODIS Hyperspectral (FY-4, MTG)
Post-EPS UARS (HRDI, WINDII) TIMED (TIDI) Aeolus … same
1 st Workshop on space-based architecture for Climate, Geneva, 13-14 January 2011
13