COLLABORATION & INNOVATION: Advancing Town-Gown Relations and Student Learning at Sunnyvale University Charli Bryan, Caitlin Green, and Joan Kwiatek (Team Leader) Lynch School of Education Boston College 2013 Virtual.

Download Report

Transcript COLLABORATION & INNOVATION: Advancing Town-Gown Relations and Student Learning at Sunnyvale University Charli Bryan, Caitlin Green, and Joan Kwiatek (Team Leader) Lynch School of Education Boston College 2013 Virtual.

COLLABORATION
& INNOVATION:
Advancing Town-Gown Relations
and Student Learning
at Sunnyvale University
Charli Bryan, Caitlin Green,
and Joan Kwiatek (Team Leader)
Lynch School of Education
Boston College
2013 Virtual Case Study Competition
StudentAffairs.com
OUR CHARGE:
To foster collaboration and innovation across campus and the community to
support a thriving town/gown relationship and further the mission of SU.
Our Context:
Our Committee:
•
•
•
•
•
Located at the edge of a
quaint New England town
Has been an integral part of
the area since its founding
(mid-1800’s)
Has expanded into the town
center as it has grown in both
full-time students and prestige
(offering both undergraduate
and graduate programs)
Has experienced a
breakdown in its previously
symbiotic relationship with the
community (e.g., disruptive
late night parties)
•
•
Convened representatives from
across campus, including Residence
Life, Student Activities, Campus
Safety/Police, Health Promotion,
Service-Learning, VPSA/Assessment,
Multicultural Center, and LGBTQ
Center; chaired by Dean of Students.
Sought student representation by
reaching out to the Undergraduate and
Graduate Government and faculty
representation by reaching out to the
Faculty Senate.
Included community voice through
town’s Deputy Mayor.
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS
To best address the needs of the SU campus and community, we
would seek to better understand:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
What is SU’s mission?
How does SU define ‘student learning’?
How does SU use assessment to drive continuous
improvement?
How would SU characterize its organizational culture? What
barriers to collaboration have been encountered in the past?
What are SU’s most popular academic programs?
Does SU have service- or leadership-oriented living-learning communities?
How does SU structure its orientation program for incoming students?
What role do SU athletic events play in the community?
How active are SU alumni, and how does SU currently engage with its alumni?
What kind of budgetary constraints should the committee work within?
ASSUMPTIONS
For the purposes of this case study, we assume that SU:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Is coeducational and is composed of primarily traditional age, first-time
undergraduates.
Is a residential campus with students living off-campus as well.
Is a dry campus.
Is not religiously affiliated.
Has not established a strategic communication plan using social media.
Does not have sanctions for off-campus violations/community disturbances.
ANALYSIS OF PROBLEM
The committee intends to engage all stakeholders—including the student body,
administration, Board of Trustees, alumni, community leaders, and community
members—in its short-term and long-term considerations.
Over the past three weeks we have conducted focus groups with students in an effort
to determine what motivates their activity off-campus. Additionally, we have set up social
media and email accounts to which townspeople have been encouraged to send
concerns, questions, etc.
Survey:
Focus Groups:
•
•
•
Concerned students’
average alcohol
consumption and offcampus activities.
Was sent to a random
selection of 100 students
from each class level; 257
responses were received.
•
•
Conducted 3 focus
groups of 15
students each.
Randomly selected
students from the
pool of survey
respondents.
Lasted 1 hour each.
RESPONSE ANALYSIS:
Survey and Focus Groups
•
•
•
•
•
Students are unfamiliar with the residential population surrounding the
university; students are under the impression they are surrounded by an
older, affluent population and are unaware that young, middle-class families
also live near campus.
Because students believe there are large age and economic gaps between
themselves and the surrounding community, there a disconnect between
the two groups.
Students are only familiar with the affluent areas of Sunnyvale because that
area houses their campus. The less affluent areas are across town and
students do not usually venture that far; they get to the heart of
downtown where the nightlife is and don’t go any farther.
Students want to drink. Campus does not offer opportunities for such
activities.
There is a negative stigma attached to weekend, late-night
programming on campus.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK:
Kolb’s Experiential Learning Theory
•
•
•
•
Learning = "the process whereby knowledge
is created through the transformation of
experience" (Kolb, 1984, p. 41)
Emphasizes the integral role that experience
plays in the learning process
Associated with positive outcomes in:
personal and interpersonal development;
understanding and applying knowledge;
engagement, curiosity, and reflective practice;
critical thinking; perspective transformation;
and citizenship (Eyler & Giles, 1999)
RELEVANCE TO SU: Programs should
intentionally encourage students to move
through all four stages of the learning
cycle: be actively involved in an experience,
reflect on the experience, use analytic skills to
conceptualize and better understand the
experience, and develop the necessary skills
to apply the experience in new contexts.
POTENTIAL APPPLICATIONS of
Experiential Learning Theory for SU
• Community Service & Service-Learning Initiatives:
Universities can contribute to a community’s economic
development, educational and health needs, and
cultural life; they have valuable resources that "become
accessible to the community when partnerships
address community needs" (Bringle & Hatcher, 1996, p.
221). Consider programs that directly address identified
problems.
• Social Media: There is significant potential for the
intersection of experiential education and social media.
Arnold and Paulus (2010), for example, found the use
of social networking in formal learning environments to
result in community building and modeling.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK:
Astin’s Theory of Involvement
•
•
•
•
•
Student learning is positively related to level of involvement in the academic and
social aspects of the college environment
Involved students devote considerable energy to academics, spend significant time
on campus, actively participate in student organizations and activities, and interact
regularly with faculty (Astin, 1984)
Reflected in the National Survey of Student Engagement’s understanding of
student engagement as being related to (1) the amount of time and effort students
put into their studies and other educationally purposeful activities and (2) how an
institution uses its resources and organizes the curriculum and other learning
opportunities to get students to participate in activities linked to student learning
“Perhaps we need to expand the concept of ‘learning’ to include affective as well
as cognitive outcomes. Certainly it can be argued that students can and should ‘learn
about’ or ‘acquire skill in’ such things as leadership, self-understanding, interpersonal
relations, and citizenship” (Astin, 1999).
Relevance to SU: Student growth is fostered when there are high quality programs
and polices reflective of an institution’s commitment to student learning.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Launch Campaign:
“Putting You in the Community”
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Put the Social in Social Media
Connect with Our Community
Give Back to Our Community
Celebrate Our Community
Partner with Faculty
Focus on Community Conduct
Support Meaningful Campus
Involvement
• Hold Ourselves Accountable &
Foster Continuous Improvement
PUT THE SOCIAL IN SOCIAL
MEDIA
• Establish social media presence to encourage open
channels of communication among students,
administration, and community members.
• Create home base (web page) for university’s social
media presence to aggregate content and shape
digital identity.
• Instagram: Photograph various events that occur on
campus and in the neighboring area.
• Foursquare: Publicize new “mayors” of volunteer sites
and consider creating location-based rewards when
students check in to certain sites. Foursquare offers
users and businesses a "richer method of interacting”
and has significant potential for civic engagement
(Salt, 2011, p. 108).
PUT THE SOCIAL IN SOCIAL
MEDIA
• Twitter (#SU4U,
@OurSunnyvaleU)
• Facebook
(facebook.com/OurSu
nnyvaleU)
• Invite and respond to
community feedback;
post campus and
community news;
promote campaign
programs; engage with
followers through
questions and contests.
CONNECT WITH OUR COMMUNITY
• Attend town hall meetings to understand community
perspective and develop relationships with community
members.
• Seek input on ideas for a strategic communication
plan (e.g., monthly newsletter to community members,
preventative emails to students before large-scale
events).
• Create email address for community feedback for
those community members who do not feel comfortable
using Facebook or Twitter to share comments.
• Explore budget potential for full-time staff
person/community liaison in the Dean of Students
Office.
GIVE BACK TO OUR COMMUNITY
• Establish ‘Sunnyvale Saturdays,’ a new initiative
to establish an ongoing and consistent opportunity
for interaction between students and the Sunnyvale
community.
• Students will clean up the neighboring community
on Saturday mornings and then enjoy breakfast
provided by SU.
• Incorporate opportunities for reflection.
CELEBRATE OUR COMMUNITY
• Establish Servicepalooza, an
annual day of service, to
launch September 14, 2013.
• The goal of this program is to
bring together members of the
campus and the surrounding
community and to
provide students with various
ways to serve their larger
community.
• This event will occur in
September during each
academic year, followed by
Sunnyvale Saturdays to
continue serving the
neighboring community.
PARTNER WITH FACULTY
• Develop collaborative
relationships with faculty members
to continue to build community on
campus and support student
learning (through all four Kolb
stages) in and out of the classroom
(NASPA & ACPA, 2004).
• Consider opportunities to integrate
service-learning into academic
programs or assignments.
• Explore potential for a livinglearning community that focuses
on leadership through service
(collaboration between academic
and student affairs).
FOCUS ON COMMUNITY CONDUCT
•
•
Consider changes to on-campus policies regarding alcohol on campus.
Consider establishment of sanctions for community disturbances.
Violation
Category
Small Gathering
No Underage Alcohol Use
Documented
Small Gathering
Underage Alcohol Use
Documented
Large Gathering
No Underage Alcohol
Use Documented
Large Gathering
Underage Alcohol Use
Documented
Rationale for
Violation
Disruption to neighbors
Disruption to neighbors
and broader community
1st Violation
Disciplinary Warning
Disruptions to
neighbors, safety
concerns, and illegal
alcohol use
Disciplinary Probation
ADE Referral
$100 Fine
Disruption to neighbors and
broader community, safety
concerns, and illegal alcohol
use
University Probation
ADE Referral
Community Restitution
$300 Fine
2nd Violation
Disciplinary Probation
Community Restitution
$200 Fine
University Probation
ADE Referral
Community Restitution
$200 Fine
University Probation
Community Restitution
$300 Fine
University Suspension
ADE Referral
Community Restitution
$400 Fine
3rd Violation
University Probation
Community Restitution
$400 Fine
University Suspension
AIM upon return
University Suspension
AIM upon return
University Dismissal
Disciplinary Probation
Community Restitution
$200 Fine
SUPPORT MEANINGFUL
CAMPUS INVOLVEMENT
• Establish late-night programming
board to plan alcohol-free, oncampus events during the hours of
9pm and 2am, Thursdays through
Saturdays, in an effort to provide
students with alternatives to
drinking and other activities that
lead to community disruptions.
• With budget approval, consider
recruiting student leaders for the
board this spring.
HOLD OURSELVES ACCOUNTABLE
•
•
•
Develop systematic assessment
plan for developing, conducting, and
reviewing assessment to drive
continuous improvement (Upcraft &
Schuh, 1996). Consider impact of
campaign on all stakeholders (e.g.,
students, faculty, institution,
community).
As part of program development,
utilize logic models to create
student learning
outcomes/objectives for each
proposed program/policy (e.g.,
Servicepalooza, student conduct).
Consider focus groups to continue
to explore program/policy ideas
and/or better understand progress
toward campaign goals (Billson,
1996).
& FOSTER CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT
•
•
Reevaluate committee’s goals
on a regular basis.
Conduct benchmarking against
peer and aspirational institutions
using the National Survey of
Student Engagement (NSSE); if
possible, compare NSSE results
pre- and post-campaign. (If SU
did not already participate in
NSSE, have committee consider
the potential value of NSSE to
SU’s campaign and mission.)
•
After some period of program
implementation and if consistent with
SU’s mission and long-term goals,
consider applying for the Carnegie
Foundation for the Advancement
of Teaching’s Elective Community
Engagement Classification as a
way to further raise visibility of SU’s
commitment to community
engagement, foster institutional
alignment for community-based
teaching, learning and scholarship,
and provide an opportunity for
institutional self-assessment
(Campus Compact, n.d.).
REFERENCES
Arnold, N., & Paulus, T. (2010). Using a social networking site for experiential learning: Appropriating, lurking, modeling and community
building. The Internet and Higher Education, 13(4), 188-196.
Astin, A. W. (1984). Student involvement: A developmental theory for higher education. Journal of College Student Personnel, 25(4), 297-308.
Astin, A. W. (1999). Involvement in learning revisited: Lessons we have learned. Journal of College Student Personnel, 40, 518-529.
Billson, J. M. (1996). The power of focus groups: A training manual for social, policy, and market research; Focus on education. (3rd ed.)
Barrington, RI: Skywood Press.
Bringle, R. G., & Hatcher, J. A. (1996). Implementing service-learning in higher education. The Journal of Higher Education, 67(2), 221-239.
Campus Compact. (n.d.). Carnegie Community Engagement Classification. Retrieved from http://www.compact.org/initiatives/engagedcampus-initiative/carnegie-community-engagement-classification/
Eyler, J., & Giles, D. E., Jr. (1999). Where's the learning in service-learning? San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Kolb, D. A. (1984). Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Kolb, D. A., Boyatzis, R. E., & Mainemelis, C. (2009). Experiential Learning Theory: Previous research and new directions. In R. J. Sternberg and
L. F. Zhang (Eds.), Perspectives on cognitive, learning, and thinking styles (pp. 193-210). NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000.
National Association of Student Personnel Administrators and the American College Personnel Association. (2004). Learning reconsidered: A
campus-wide focus on the student experience. Washington, D.C.: Author.
Salt, S. (2011). Social location marketing: Outshining your competitors on Foursquare, Gowalla, Yelp, and other location sharing sites.
Indianapolis, IN: Pearson Education, Que Publishing.
Upcraft, M. L. & Schuh, J. H. (1996). Assessment in student affairs: A guide for practitioners. San Francisco, CA: Jossey Bass.