Notes to Chapter Six English 308 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 11/6/2015 Nonlinear Components Nonlinear design is chosen, either because Readers can more easily, accurately,
Download ReportTranscript Notes to Chapter Six English 308 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 11/6/2015 Nonlinear Components Nonlinear design is chosen, either because Readers can more easily, accurately,
Notes to Chapter Six English 308 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 1 4/29/2020 Nonlinear Components Nonlinear design is chosen, either because Readers can more easily, accurately, or conventionally access the textual information in a nonlinear form rather than in paragraphs or continuous text The relations among the textual elements call for a schematic rather than literal, lineby-line expression. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 2 4/29/2020 For example, tabular data Can be represented as Jared Miller, catcher and pitcher, bats right and throws right, five foot eleven inches tall, weight 205 pounds, senior, from Arcadia HS in Phoenix, Arizona Paul Beringhaus, pitcher, bats left and throws left, six foot one inch tall, weight 170 pounds, sophomore, from Brophy College Prep in Phoenix, Arizona Etc. Or Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 3 4/29/2020 As a nonlinear matrix No. Name Pos B-T Ht Wt Yr Hometown (Previous School) OF R-R 6-1 165 FR Mill Valley, CA (Tamalpais HS) 4 David Foster 5 Tommy McGrail 2B R-R 5-10 175 SO South Pasadena, CA (South Pasadena HS) 7 Shannon Stewart OF/P R-R 6-0 185 SO Oceanside, CA (El Camino HS) 8 Joey Ramaeker 3B/C R-R 5-11 210 FR Phoenix, AZ (Brophy College Prep) SR Phoenix, AZ (Arcadia HS) 9 Jared Miller C/P R-R 5-11 205 10 Noah Van Hilsen OF/P R-R 6-2 190 FR Gilbert, AZ (Gilbert HS) 11 Paul Beringhaus P L-L 6-1 170 SO Phoenix, AZ (Brophy College Prep) 13 Sam Kline C/OF R-R 6-1 185 FR San Francisco, CA (Urban HS) 17 Adrian Mols SS/P R-R 5-10 180 SR Honolulu, HI (Roosevelt HS) 18 Blake Lichtig OF R-R 6-0 175 SO Woodland Hills, CA (Campbell Hall) 20 Dan Murphy OF R-R 6-1 195 JR Alamo, CA (Canterbury Prep) 22 Jeremy Ayres OF R-R 6-2 160 FR Moreno Valley, CA (Riverside Christian HS) 24 Doug Tisdale 2B/OF L-R 5-11 155 FR Palos Verdes, CA (Peninsula HS) 29 Andres Trujillo P R-R 6-0 205 SO Ranchos de Taos, NM (Taos HS) 30 Noel Coleman INF/P R/R 6-2 170 FR Gunnison, CO (Gunnison HS) 31 Matt Piazza INF/P R/R 6-0 230 SO Hacienda Heights, CA (Glen Wilson) 35 Tim Loper 1B/P R-R 6-0 175 SO Huntington Beach, CA (Marina HS) 44 Zach Phillips P R-R 6-5 210 FR Upland, CA (Damien HS) 55 Chris Wilson DH/P R-R 6-6 240 JR Washington, D.C. (Sidwell Friends) Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 4 4/29/2020 Nonlinear Displays Reveal Nonlinear displays often reveal facts and relationships that linear description hides. For example, from the table on the previous page it is easy to see that there are only two seniors on the team, that Paul is the only left-handed pitcher on the team, and that four players went to high school in Arizona. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 5 4/29/2020 Schematic Representation Some information is nearly impossible to put in linear text form. Take this decision chart used by students at the University of Nevada at Reno to determine the right meal plan for them. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 6 4/29/2020 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 7 4/29/2020 More Schematic Representation Or consider how useless words alone are when trying to describe the complex organizational structure of the United States Department of Justice Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 8 4/29/2020 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 9 4/29/2020 A Variety of Genres Nonlinear displays include Tables Flowcharts Organizational charts Decision trees Concept charts Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 10 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Textual Elements Textual elements provide The raw material of nonlinear displays (i.e. data in tables, labels in charts) Row and column headings in tables Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 11 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Spatial Elements Spatial elements can be a String—one-directional track of text units arranged horizontally or vertically Matrix—two-dimensional arrangement (horizontal and vertical) Branching display—a hierarchical structure that usually begins with one or a few units and then branches into many. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 12 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Spatial Elements Strings Draft Revise Edit Proofread Draft Revise Edit Proofread Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 13 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Spatial Elements Matrix Batting Leaders AB H HR RBI SB AVG Gonzalez 120 41 8 19 1 .342 Murphy 105 35 4 14 5 .333 83 27 1 9 6 .325 Santos 118 38 5 17 0 .322 Boozer 109 35 2 13 2 .321 Henderson Santos has 5 home runs Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 14 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Spatial Elements Branching Display President Vice President Academic Affairs Undergrad Studies Grad Studies Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 Vice President Student Affairs Student Life Academic Support Vice President Administration and Finance Facilities Accounting 15 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Graphic Elements Graphic elements can serve as Framing Devices Linking Devices Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 16 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Graphic Elements Framing devices include Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 17 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Graphic Elements Linking devices include Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 18 4/29/2020 Conventions of Nonlinear Displays—Graphic Elements Linking devices also include the lines in a table, which guide the eye across rows or down columns Batting Leaders AB H HR RBI SB AVG Gonzalez 120 41 8 19 1 .342 Murphy 105 35 4 14 5 .333 83 27 1 9 6 .325 Santos 118 38 5 17 0 .322 Boozer 109 35 2 13 2 .321 Henderson Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 19 4/29/2020 Applying the Cognate Strategies How do we apply this rich visual vocabulary to nonlinear displays? We can do so by considering the six cognate strategies. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 20 4/29/2020 Arrangement Questions How can I use the visual language to signal relationships—parallel, hierarchical, syntactical—among the text units? Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 21 4/29/2020 Arrangement Strategies Work with existing genres—flowcharts and organization charts show hierarchy well, while directional arrows show syntax (sequence) Determine the primary relationships that exist between the data and take into account how users will use the display Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 22 4/29/2020 Arrangement Strategies (cont.) A traditional organization chart is hierarchical, implying a clear chain of command President Operations Manager Finance Manager Sales Manager Operations Staff Finance Staff Sales Staff Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 23 4/29/2020 Arrangement Strategies (cont.) A different display might emphasize a less hierarchical management style Operations Mgr Operations Staff President Finance Mgr Sales Mgr Sales Staff Finance Staff Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 24 4/29/2020 Arrangement Strategies (cont.) Determine the primary relationships that exist. For example, what’s wrong with the table below? Steve M. Maria H. Stacy J. Reginald F. Year Admitted 2000 1999 2000 2001 Date of Birth 8/19/1981 2/11/1980 4/19/1981 7/3/1982 Total at Entry $3,435 $2,876 $3,138 $4,198 Current Total $5,378 $6,683 $4,982 $4,845 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 25 4/29/2020 Arrangement Strategies (cont.) Tables usually are arranged with characteristics or values as the columns and individuals or items as the rows. Year Admitted Date of Birth Total at Entry Current Total Steve M. 2000 8/19/1981 $3,434 $5,378 Maria H. 1999 2/11/1980 $2,876 $6,683 Stacy J. 2000 4/19/1981 $3,138 $4,982 Reginald F. 2001 7/3/1982 $4,198 $4,845 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 26 4/29/2020 Emphasis Questions Which text units need to stand out more than others? How can I use visual language to get readers to notice these text units? Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 27 4/29/2020 Emphasis Strategies Because nonlinear text is often isolated in fragments, arranged in space, and framed and linked by boxes and lines, the designer can readily select which elements to emphasize. However, emphasis strategies are often the subtle management of emphasis across a variety of elements. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 28 4/29/2020 Emphasis Strategies The table below uses shading to call attention to a pattern in the data. Enrolled Visits Visits English 102 English 101 English 096 English 095 Enrolled Visits Enrolled Visits Enrolled 168 473 116 359 166 688 277 1035 Winter 2000 15 59 194 456 134 407 239 1013 Spring 2000 4 37 10 123 389 460 256 864 Summer 2000 3 0 54 36 14 60 182 374 Fall 2000 97 413 122 368 128 606 222 821 Winter 2001 28 81 137 429 95 424 150 864 Spring 2001 8 28 24 137 224 468 187 804 Summer 2001 4 0 21 34 27 82 145 444 Fall 2001 89 474 124 315 90 587 203 841 Winter 2002 27 90 179 480 116 420 184 900 Fall 1999 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 29 4/29/2020 Emphasis Strategies (cont.) There is no emphasis on any particular item in the flowchart below. Draft Revise Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 Edit 30 4/29/2020 Emphasis Strategies (cont.) These versions emphasize “Revise” Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 31 4/29/2020 Emphasis Strategies (cont.) These versions emphasize “Revise” while de-emphasizing “Edit” Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Draft Revise Edit Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 32 4/29/2020 Clarity Questions How can I ensure that readers will understand the display? Am I using spatial and graphic conventions they understand? Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 33 4/29/2020 Clarity Strategies Watch Too wide columns in tables Hard to read/distinguish headings Not following conventions Try using Shading to distinguish adjacent columns or rows Sans serif fonts for data displays Boldface for row and column headings Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 34 4/29/2020 Clarity Strategies (cont.) The table below is a bit difficult to read. Simple changes can make it much more readable. PLAYER Johnson, Randy Maddux, Greg Colon, Bartolo Glavine, Tom Perez, Odalis Oswalt, Roy Dessens, Elmer Ohka, Tomo Wolf, Randy Rueter, Kirk W 24 16 20 18 15 19 7 13 11 14 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 L 5 6 8 11 10 9 8 8 9 8 IP 260.0 199.3 233.3 224.7 222.3 233.0 178.0 192.7 210.7 203.7 H 197 194 219 210 182 215 173 194 172 204 R 78 67 85 85 76 86 70 83 77 83 ER 67 58 76 74 74 78 60 68 75 73 BB 71 45 70 78 38 62 49 45 63 54 SO 334 118 150 127 155 208 93 118 172 76 ERA 2.32 2.62 2.93 2.96 3.00 3.01 3.03 3.18 3.20 3.23 35 4/29/2020 Clarity Strategies (cont.) We can add 3 points of leading and narrow the columns. PLAYER W L IP H R ER BB SO ERA Johnson, Randy 24 5 260.0 197 78 67 71 334 2.32 Maddux, Greg 16 6 199.3 194 67 58 45 118 2.62 Colon, Bartolo 20 8 233.3 219 85 76 70 150 2.93 Glavine, Tom 18 11 224.7 210 85 74 78 127 2.96 Perez, Odalis 15 10 222.3 182 76 74 38 155 3.00 Oswalt, Roy 19 9 233.0 215 86 78 62 208 3.01 7 8 178.0 173 70 60 49 93 3.03 Ohka, Tomo 13 8 192.7 194 83 68 45 118 3.18 Wolf, Randy 11 9 210.7 172 77 75 63 172 3.20 Rueter, Kirk 14 8 203.7 204 83 73 54 76 3.23 Dessens, Elmer Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 36 4/29/2020 Clarity Strategies (cont.) We can make the column headings bold and add horizontal lines to improve tracking. PLAYER W L IP H SO ERA Johnson, Randy 24 5 260.0 197 78 67 71 334 2.32 Maddux, Greg 16 6 199.3 194 67 58 45 118 2.62 Colon, Bartolo 20 8 233.3 219 85 76 70 150 2.93 Glavine, Tom 18 11 224.7 210 85 74 78 127 2.96 Perez, Odalis 15 10 222.3 182 76 74 38 155 3.00 Oswalt, Roy 19 9 233.0 215 86 78 62 208 3.01 7 8 178.0 173 70 60 49 93 3.03 Ohka, Tomo 13 8 192.7 194 83 68 45 118 3.18 Wolf, Randy 11 9 210.7 172 77 75 63 172 3.20 Rueter, Kirk 14 8 203.7 204 83 73 54 76 3.23 Dessens, Elmer Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 R ER BB 37 4/29/2020 Clarity Strategies (cont.) We can add vertical lines to improve tracking. This, however, creates a “boxy” look. PLAYER W L IP H SO ERA Johnson, Randy 24 5 260.0 197 78 67 71 334 2.32 Maddux, Greg 16 6 199.3 194 67 58 45 118 2.62 Colon, Bartolo 20 8 233.3 219 85 76 70 150 2.93 Glavine, Tom 18 11 224.7 210 85 74 78 127 2.96 Perez, Odalis 15 10 222.3 182 76 74 38 155 3.00 Oswalt, Roy 19 9 233.0 215 86 78 62 208 3.01 7 8 178.0 173 70 60 49 93 3.03 Ohka, Tomo 13 8 192.7 194 83 68 45 118 3.18 Wolf, Randy 11 9 210.7 172 77 75 63 172 3.20 Rueter, Kirk 14 8 203.7 204 83 73 54 76 3.23 Dessens, Elmer Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 R ER BB 38 4/29/2020 Clarity Strategies (cont.) We can remove the vertical lines and try to differentiate the columns by using shading. This approach might be over-design (checkerboard pattern creates unexpected emphasis). PLAYER W L IP H SO ERA Johnson, Randy 24 5 260.0 197 78 67 71 334 2.32 Maddux, Greg 16 6 199.3 194 67 58 45 118 2.62 Colon, Bartolo 20 8 233.3 219 85 76 70 150 2.93 Glavine, Tom 18 11 224.7 210 85 74 78 127 2.96 Perez, Odalis 15 10 222.3 182 76 74 38 155 3.00 Oswalt, Roy 19 9 233.0 215 86 78 62 208 3.01 7 8 178.0 173 70 60 49 93 3.03 Ohka, Tomo 13 8 192.7 194 83 68 45 118 3.18 Wolf, Randy 11 9 210.7 172 77 75 63 172 3.20 Rueter, Kirk 14 8 203.7 204 83 73 54 76 3.23 Dessens, Elmer Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 R ER BB 39 4/29/2020 Conciseness Questions How can I get the most impact for the least use of design elements? How can I avoid over-designing the display? Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 40 4/29/2020 Conciseness Strategies Rarely is it appropriate to sacrifice clarity for conciseness, since lack of clarity might render the display useless, as in the following example. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 41 4/29/2020 Conciseness Strategies While we can figure out what this table is for, it is not easy? Guests in Cabin Duration 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 1 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 2 150 170 190 210 230 250 270 3 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 4 290 310 330 350 370 390 410 5+ 355 375 395 415 435 455 475 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 42 4/29/2020 Conciseness Strategies This table is less concise, but it is more usable. It might, however, be over-designed. Le ngt h o f S t a y ( in da ys ) G ue s t s in C a bin up t o 2 up t o 4 up t o 6 up t o 8 up t o 1 0 up t o 1 2 up t o 1 4 1 $80 $100 $120 $140 $160 $180 $200 2 $150 $170 $190 $210 $230 $250 $270 3 $220 $240 $260 $280 $300 $320 $340 4 $290 $310 $330 $350 $370 $390 $410 5+ $355 $375 $395 $415 $435 $455 $475 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 43 4/29/2020 Conciseness Strategies (cont.) Sometimes redundancy is necessary, as in this simple flowchart. Is the weakness confined to one area of the body? Yes No Is the weakness associated with flu or cold symptoms? Is it present now? Yes SEE PHYSICIAN TODAY No Yes MAKE APPOINTMENT WITH PHYSICIAN APPLY HOME TREATMENT No APPLY HOME TREATMENT Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 44 4/29/2020 Tone Questions How do I want the tone of the text field to sound to my readers: serious, friendly, tentative, authoritarian, non-threatening, formal, informal? Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 45 4/29/2020 Tone Strategies How does this display sound? Draft Revise Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 Edit 46 4/29/2020 Tone Strategies How does this compare? Draft Revise Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 Edit 47 4/29/2020 Tone Strategies (cont.) Here’s the medical flowchart we just looked at. Is the weakness confined to one area of the body? Yes No Is the weakness associated with flu or cold symptoms? Is it present now? Yes SEE PHYSICIAN TODAY No Yes MAKE APPOINTMENT WITH PHYSICIAN APPLY HOME TREATMENT No APPLY HOME TREATMENT Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 48 4/29/2020 Tone Strategies (cont.) Here’s it is again, with a very different tone. Is the weakness confined to one area of the body? Yes No Is the weakness associated with flu or cold symptoms? Yes Is it present now? SEE PHYSICIAN TODAY No Yes MAKE APPOINTMENT WITH PHYSICIAN APPLY HOME TREATMENT No APPLY HOME TREATMENT Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 49 4/29/2020 Ethos Questions How can I use the visual language of the display to create credibility for me, the other authors, or the organization? Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 50 4/29/2020 Ethos Strategies As before Create a professional look Respect genre conventions Develop a style Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 51 4/29/2020 Conclusion Remember that the six cognate strategies do not exist in separate, isolated packages but constantly work together (and at times against one another) to respond to the rhetorical situation. Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 52 4/29/2020