Notes to Chapter Six English 308 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 11/6/2015 Nonlinear Components Nonlinear design is chosen, either because  Readers can more easily, accurately,

Download Report

Transcript Notes to Chapter Six English 308 Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6 11/6/2015 Nonlinear Components Nonlinear design is chosen, either because  Readers can more easily, accurately,

Notes to Chapter Six
English 308
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
1
4/29/2020
Nonlinear Components
Nonlinear design is chosen, either because
 Readers can more easily, accurately, or
conventionally access the textual
information in a nonlinear form rather than
in paragraphs or continuous text
 The relations among the textual elements
call for a schematic rather than literal, lineby-line expression.
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
2
4/29/2020
For example, tabular data
Can be represented as
 Jared Miller, catcher and pitcher, bats right and
throws right, five foot eleven inches tall, weight
205 pounds, senior, from Arcadia HS in Phoenix,
Arizona
 Paul Beringhaus, pitcher, bats left and throws
left, six foot one inch tall, weight 170 pounds,
sophomore, from Brophy College Prep in
Phoenix, Arizona
 Etc.
Or
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
3
4/29/2020
As a nonlinear matrix
No.
Name
Pos
B-T
Ht
Wt
Yr
Hometown (Previous School)
OF
R-R
6-1
165
FR Mill Valley, CA (Tamalpais HS)
4
David Foster
5
Tommy McGrail
2B
R-R
5-10
175
SO South Pasadena, CA (South Pasadena HS)
7
Shannon Stewart
OF/P
R-R
6-0
185
SO Oceanside, CA (El Camino HS)
8
Joey Ramaeker
3B/C
R-R
5-11
210
FR Phoenix, AZ (Brophy College Prep)
SR Phoenix, AZ (Arcadia HS)
9
Jared Miller
C/P
R-R
5-11
205
10
Noah Van Hilsen
OF/P
R-R
6-2
190
FR Gilbert, AZ (Gilbert HS)
11
Paul Beringhaus
P
L-L
6-1
170
SO Phoenix, AZ (Brophy College Prep)
13
Sam Kline
C/OF
R-R
6-1
185
FR San Francisco, CA (Urban HS)
17
Adrian Mols
SS/P
R-R
5-10
180
SR Honolulu, HI (Roosevelt HS)
18
Blake Lichtig
OF
R-R
6-0
175
SO Woodland Hills, CA (Campbell Hall)
20
Dan Murphy
OF
R-R
6-1
195
JR Alamo, CA (Canterbury Prep)
22
Jeremy Ayres
OF
R-R
6-2
160
FR Moreno Valley, CA (Riverside Christian HS)
24
Doug Tisdale
2B/OF L-R
5-11
155
FR Palos Verdes, CA (Peninsula HS)
29
Andres Trujillo
P
R-R
6-0
205
SO Ranchos de Taos, NM (Taos HS)
30
Noel Coleman
INF/P
R/R
6-2
170
FR Gunnison, CO (Gunnison HS)
31
Matt Piazza
INF/P
R/R
6-0
230
SO Hacienda Heights, CA (Glen Wilson)
35
Tim Loper
1B/P
R-R
6-0
175
SO Huntington Beach, CA (Marina HS)
44
Zach Phillips
P
R-R
6-5
210
FR Upland, CA (Damien HS)
55
Chris Wilson
DH/P
R-R
6-6
240
JR Washington, D.C. (Sidwell Friends)
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
4
4/29/2020
Nonlinear Displays Reveal
Nonlinear displays often reveal facts and
relationships that linear description hides.
 For example, from the table on the
previous page it is easy to see that there
are only two seniors on the team, that Paul
is the only left-handed pitcher on the team,
and that four players went to high school
in Arizona.

Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
5
4/29/2020
Schematic Representation
Some information is nearly impossible to put
in linear text form.
Take this decision chart used by students at
the University of Nevada at Reno to
determine the right meal plan for them.
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
6
4/29/2020
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
7
4/29/2020
More Schematic
Representation

Or consider how useless words alone are
when trying to describe the complex
organizational structure of the United
States Department of Justice
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
8
4/29/2020
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
9
4/29/2020
A Variety of Genres
Nonlinear displays include
 Tables
 Flowcharts
 Organizational charts
 Decision trees
 Concept charts
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
10
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Textual Elements
Textual elements provide
 The raw material of nonlinear displays (i.e.
data in tables, labels in charts)
 Row and column headings in tables
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
11
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Spatial Elements
Spatial elements can be a
 String—one-directional track of text units
arranged horizontally or vertically
 Matrix—two-dimensional arrangement
(horizontal and vertical)
 Branching display—a hierarchical
structure that usually begins with one or a
few units and then branches into many.
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
12
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Spatial Elements
Strings
Draft  Revise  Edit  Proofread
Draft

Revise

Edit

Proofread
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
13
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Spatial Elements
Matrix
Batting Leaders
AB
H
HR
RBI
SB
AVG
Gonzalez
120
41
8
19
1
.342
Murphy
105
35
4
14
5
.333
83
27
1
9
6
.325
Santos
118
38
5
17
0
.322
Boozer
109
35
2
13
2
.321
Henderson
Santos has 5 home runs
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
14
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Spatial Elements
Branching Display
President
Vice President
Academic Affairs
Undergrad Studies
Grad Studies
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
Vice President
Student Affairs
Student Life
Academic Support
Vice President
Administration and Finance
Facilities
Accounting
15
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Graphic Elements
Graphic elements can serve as
 Framing Devices
 Linking Devices
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
16
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Graphic Elements
Framing devices include
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
17
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Graphic Elements
Linking devices include
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
18
4/29/2020
Conventions of Nonlinear
Displays—Graphic Elements
Linking devices also include the lines in a table,
which guide the eye across rows or down columns
Batting Leaders
AB
H
HR
RBI
SB
AVG
Gonzalez
120
41
8
19
1
.342
Murphy
105
35
4
14
5
.333
83
27
1
9
6
.325
Santos
118
38
5
17
0
.322
Boozer
109
35
2
13
2
.321
Henderson
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
19
4/29/2020
Applying the Cognate Strategies
How do we apply this rich visual vocabulary
to nonlinear displays?
We can do so by considering the six cognate
strategies.
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
20
4/29/2020
Arrangement Questions

How can I use the visual language to
signal relationships—parallel, hierarchical,
syntactical—among the text units?
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
21
4/29/2020
Arrangement Strategies
Work with existing genres—flowcharts
and organization charts show hierarchy
well, while directional arrows show syntax
(sequence)
 Determine the primary relationships that
exist between the data and take into
account how users will use the display

Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
22
4/29/2020
Arrangement Strategies (cont.)

A traditional organization chart is hierarchical,
implying a clear chain of command
President
Operations Manager
Finance Manager
Sales Manager
Operations Staff
Finance Staff
Sales Staff
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
23
4/29/2020
Arrangement Strategies (cont.)

A different display might emphasize a less
hierarchical management style
Operations Mgr
Operations Staff
President
Finance Mgr
Sales Mgr
Sales Staff
Finance Staff
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
24
4/29/2020
Arrangement Strategies (cont.)

Determine the primary relationships that exist.
For example, what’s wrong with the table
below?
Steve M.
Maria H.
Stacy J.
Reginald F.
Year Admitted
2000
1999
2000
2001
Date of Birth
8/19/1981
2/11/1980
4/19/1981
7/3/1982
Total at Entry
$3,435
$2,876
$3,138
$4,198
Current Total
$5,378
$6,683
$4,982
$4,845
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
25
4/29/2020
Arrangement Strategies (cont.)

Tables usually are arranged with
characteristics or values as the columns and
individuals or items as the rows.
Year Admitted
Date of Birth
Total at
Entry
Current
Total
Steve M.
2000
8/19/1981
$3,434
$5,378
Maria H.
1999
2/11/1980
$2,876
$6,683
Stacy J.
2000
4/19/1981
$3,138
$4,982
Reginald F.
2001
7/3/1982
$4,198
$4,845
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
26
4/29/2020
Emphasis Questions
Which text units need to stand out more
than others?
 How can I use visual language to get
readers to notice these text units?

Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
27
4/29/2020
Emphasis Strategies
Because nonlinear text is often isolated in
fragments, arranged in space, and framed
and linked by boxes and lines, the designer
can readily select which elements to
emphasize.
 However, emphasis strategies are often the
subtle management of emphasis across a
variety of elements.

Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
28
4/29/2020
Emphasis Strategies
The table below uses shading to call attention to a pattern
in the data.
Enrolled
Visits
Visits
English 102
English 101
English 096
English 095
Enrolled
Visits
Enrolled
Visits
Enrolled
168
473
116
359
166
688
277
1035
Winter 2000
15
59
194
456
134
407
239
1013
Spring 2000
4
37
10
123
389
460
256
864
Summer 2000
3
0
54
36
14
60
182
374
Fall 2000
97
413
122
368
128
606
222
821
Winter 2001
28
81
137
429
95
424
150
864
Spring 2001
8
28
24
137
224
468
187
804
Summer 2001
4
0
21
34
27
82
145
444
Fall 2001
89
474
124
315
90
587
203
841
Winter 2002
27
90
179
480
116
420
184
900
Fall 1999
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
29
4/29/2020
Emphasis Strategies (cont.)

There is no emphasis on any particular
item in the flowchart below.
Draft
Revise
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
Edit
30
4/29/2020
Emphasis Strategies (cont.)

These versions emphasize “Revise”
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
31
4/29/2020
Emphasis Strategies (cont.)

These versions emphasize “Revise” while
de-emphasizing “Edit”
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Draft
Revise
Edit
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
32
4/29/2020
Clarity Questions
How can I ensure that readers will
understand the display?
 Am I using spatial and graphic
conventions they understand?

Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
33
4/29/2020
Clarity Strategies
Watch
 Too wide columns in tables
 Hard to read/distinguish headings
 Not following conventions
Try using
 Shading to distinguish adjacent columns or rows
 Sans serif fonts for data displays
 Boldface for row and column headings
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
34
4/29/2020
Clarity Strategies (cont.)

The table below is a bit difficult to read. Simple
changes can make it much more readable.
PLAYER
Johnson, Randy
Maddux, Greg
Colon, Bartolo
Glavine, Tom
Perez, Odalis
Oswalt, Roy
Dessens, Elmer
Ohka, Tomo
Wolf, Randy
Rueter, Kirk
W
24
16
20
18
15
19
7
13
11
14
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
L
5
6
8
11
10
9
8
8
9
8
IP
260.0
199.3
233.3
224.7
222.3
233.0
178.0
192.7
210.7
203.7
H
197
194
219
210
182
215
173
194
172
204
R
78
67
85
85
76
86
70
83
77
83
ER
67
58
76
74
74
78
60
68
75
73
BB
71
45
70
78
38
62
49
45
63
54
SO
334
118
150
127
155
208
93
118
172
76
ERA
2.32
2.62
2.93
2.96
3.00
3.01
3.03
3.18
3.20
3.23
35
4/29/2020
Clarity Strategies (cont.)

We can add 3 points of leading and narrow the
columns.
PLAYER
W
L
IP
H
R
ER
BB
SO
ERA
Johnson, Randy
24
5
260.0
197
78
67
71
334
2.32
Maddux, Greg
16
6
199.3
194
67
58
45
118
2.62
Colon, Bartolo
20
8
233.3
219
85
76
70
150
2.93
Glavine, Tom
18
11
224.7
210
85
74
78
127
2.96
Perez, Odalis
15
10
222.3
182
76
74
38
155
3.00
Oswalt, Roy
19
9
233.0
215
86
78
62
208
3.01
7
8
178.0
173
70
60
49
93
3.03
Ohka, Tomo
13
8
192.7
194
83
68
45
118
3.18
Wolf, Randy
11
9
210.7
172
77
75
63
172
3.20
Rueter, Kirk
14
8
203.7
204
83
73
54
76
3.23
Dessens, Elmer
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
36
4/29/2020
Clarity Strategies (cont.)

We can make the column headings bold and add
horizontal lines to improve tracking.
PLAYER
W
L
IP
H
SO
ERA
Johnson, Randy
24
5
260.0
197
78
67
71
334
2.32
Maddux, Greg
16
6
199.3
194
67
58
45
118
2.62
Colon, Bartolo
20
8
233.3
219
85
76
70
150
2.93
Glavine, Tom
18
11
224.7
210
85
74
78
127
2.96
Perez, Odalis
15
10
222.3
182
76
74
38
155
3.00
Oswalt, Roy
19
9
233.0
215
86
78
62
208
3.01
7
8
178.0
173
70
60
49
93
3.03
Ohka, Tomo
13
8
192.7
194
83
68
45
118
3.18
Wolf, Randy
11
9
210.7
172
77
75
63
172
3.20
Rueter, Kirk
14
8
203.7
204
83
73
54
76
3.23
Dessens, Elmer
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
R ER BB
37
4/29/2020
Clarity Strategies (cont.)

We can add vertical lines to improve tracking. This,
however, creates a “boxy” look.
PLAYER
W
L
IP
H
SO
ERA
Johnson, Randy
24
5
260.0
197
78
67
71
334
2.32
Maddux, Greg
16
6
199.3
194
67
58
45
118
2.62
Colon, Bartolo
20
8
233.3
219
85
76
70
150
2.93
Glavine, Tom
18
11
224.7
210
85
74
78
127
2.96
Perez, Odalis
15
10
222.3
182
76
74
38
155
3.00
Oswalt, Roy
19
9
233.0
215
86
78
62
208
3.01
7
8
178.0
173
70
60
49
93
3.03
Ohka, Tomo
13
8
192.7
194
83
68
45
118
3.18
Wolf, Randy
11
9
210.7
172
77
75
63
172
3.20
Rueter, Kirk
14
8
203.7
204
83
73
54
76
3.23
Dessens, Elmer
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
R ER BB
38
4/29/2020
Clarity Strategies (cont.)

We can remove the vertical lines and try to differentiate
the columns by using shading. This approach might be
over-design (checkerboard pattern creates unexpected
emphasis).
PLAYER
W
L
IP
H
SO
ERA
Johnson, Randy
24
5
260.0
197
78
67
71
334
2.32
Maddux, Greg
16
6
199.3
194
67
58
45
118
2.62
Colon, Bartolo
20
8
233.3
219
85
76
70
150
2.93
Glavine, Tom
18
11
224.7
210
85
74
78
127
2.96
Perez, Odalis
15
10
222.3
182
76
74
38
155
3.00
Oswalt, Roy
19
9
233.0
215
86
78
62
208
3.01
7
8
178.0
173
70
60
49
93
3.03
Ohka, Tomo
13
8
192.7
194
83
68
45
118
3.18
Wolf, Randy
11
9
210.7
172
77
75
63
172
3.20
Rueter, Kirk
14
8
203.7
204
83
73
54
76
3.23
Dessens, Elmer
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
R ER BB
39
4/29/2020
Conciseness Questions
How can I get the most impact for the least
use of design elements?
 How can I avoid over-designing the
display?

Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
40
4/29/2020
Conciseness Strategies

Rarely is it appropriate to sacrifice clarity
for conciseness, since lack of clarity might
render the display useless, as in the
following example.
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
41
4/29/2020
Conciseness Strategies

While we can figure out what this table is for, it
is not easy?
Guests in Cabin
Duration
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
1
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
2
150
170
190
210
230
250
270
3
220
240
260
280
300
320
340
4
290
310
330
350
370
390
410
5+
355
375
395
415
435
455
475
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
42
4/29/2020
Conciseness Strategies

This table is less concise, but it is more usable. It
might, however, be over-designed.
Le ngt h o f S t a y
( in da ys )
G ue s t s in C a bin
up t o 2
up t o 4
up t o 6
up t o 8 up t o 1 0 up t o 1 2 up t o 1 4
1
$80
$100
$120
$140
$160
$180
$200
2
$150
$170
$190
$210
$230
$250
$270
3
$220
$240
$260
$280
$300
$320
$340
4
$290
$310
$330
$350
$370
$390
$410
5+
$355
$375
$395
$415
$435
$455
$475
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
43
4/29/2020
Conciseness Strategies (cont.)
Sometimes redundancy is necessary, as in this simple flowchart.
Is the weakness
confined to one
area of the body?
Yes
No
Is the weakness
associated with flu or
cold symptoms?
Is it present now?
Yes
SEE PHYSICIAN
TODAY
No
Yes
MAKE
APPOINTMENT WITH
PHYSICIAN
APPLY HOME
TREATMENT
No
APPLY HOME
TREATMENT
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
44
4/29/2020
Tone Questions

How do I want the tone of the text field to
sound to my readers: serious, friendly,
tentative, authoritarian, non-threatening,
formal, informal?
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
45
4/29/2020
Tone Strategies

How does this display sound?
Draft
Revise
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
Edit
46
4/29/2020
Tone Strategies

How does this compare?
Draft
Revise
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
Edit
47
4/29/2020
Tone Strategies (cont.)
Here’s the medical flowchart we just looked at.
Is the weakness
confined to one
area of the body?
Yes
No
Is the weakness
associated with flu or
cold symptoms?
Is it present now?
Yes
SEE PHYSICIAN
TODAY
No
Yes
MAKE
APPOINTMENT WITH
PHYSICIAN
APPLY HOME
TREATMENT
No
APPLY HOME
TREATMENT
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
48
4/29/2020
Tone Strategies (cont.)
Here’s it is again, with a very different tone.
Is the weakness
confined to one
area of the body?
Yes
No
Is the weakness
associated with flu or
cold symptoms?
Yes
Is it present now?
SEE PHYSICIAN
TODAY
No
Yes
MAKE
APPOINTMENT WITH
PHYSICIAN
APPLY HOME
TREATMENT
No
APPLY HOME
TREATMENT
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
49
4/29/2020
Ethos Questions

How can I use the visual language of the
display to create credibility for me, the
other authors, or the organization?
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
50
4/29/2020
Ethos Strategies
As before
 Create a professional look
 Respect genre conventions
 Develop a style
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
51
4/29/2020
Conclusion
Remember that the six cognate strategies do
not exist in separate, isolated packages but
constantly work together (and at times
against one another) to respond to the
rhetorical situation.
Designing Visual Language-Chapter 6
52
4/29/2020