Transcript Community-Based Monitoring System (CBMS) PAL AW AN

Community-Based Monitoring
System (CBMS)
P A L AW A N
CBMS builds the capacity of the LGU and
community
• Community leaders and
volunteers are trained in the
various aspect of the CBMS
process, i.e., collect,
process, validate, analyze
and use of data
DEVELOPMENT VISION
Palawan is envisioned to become a
province where people, culture, and
economy are in harmony with the
environment and natural resources
living in peaceful, orderly and
prosperous communities.
SEVEN (7)
INTERRELATED
ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT
STRATEGIES
60 0 0 0 0
75 0 0 0 0
90 0 0 0 0
Bu suang
.-, a
.-,
Culi on.-,
.-,
10 5 0 0 0 0
1350000
1350000
45 0 0 0 0
Coron
Proposed Tourism
Development Areas Map
Linapacan
El Nid o
.-,
12 00000
12 00000
Agut aya
Mag saysay
.-,
San Vice nte
.-,
Taytay
Cuyo
Araceli
.-,
Dum ar an
.-,
Ro xas
Cagayanci llo
.-,
1050000
1050000
Puer to Pri ncesa C it y
.-,
Que zon
Ri zal
.-,
40 00 00
50 00 00
60 00 00
70 00 00
80 00 00
100 00 0 0
Ab orlan
Bu s u an g a
Narr a
Español a
1 30 00 0 0
Cu lio n
900000
Lin a p ac a n
IN T ER M E DI A R Y S M A L L U R B A N CE N T ER S
To u ri sm d ev elo p m en t a rea
Ag u ta y a
1 20 00 0 0
N
W
Cu y o
Tay t ay
E
M ag s a ys a y
Sa n V icen t e
S
12 00 00 0
Bal ab ac
El N id o
PRO V IN C E O F P A LA W A N
900000
.-,
Co ro n
13 00 00 0
Le ge nd :
Bat araza
90 00 00
Ar ac el i
Du m a ra n
Ro x as
75 0 0 0 0
90 0 0 0 0
10 5 0 0 0 0
1 100 0 00
60 0 0 0 0
11 00 00 0
45 0 0 0 0
Pu er to P r in c esa City
Ca g ay a n cill o
Ab o rla n
10 00 00 0
1 00 00 0 0
Q uez o n
N a rra
Riz a l
Es p añ o la
Br o ok e 's P o int
Int erm ed iary S mall Ur b an Cent ers
9 0 00 00
9 00 00 0
Proposed Intermediary Small
Sized Urban Center (ISUC)
Leg end :
Ba ta ra z a
Ba l ab ac
40 00 00
50 00 00
60 00 00
70 00 00
80 00 00
90 00 00
100 00 0 0
60 0 0 0 0
75 0 0 0 0
90 0 0 0 0
10 5 0 0 0 0
1350000
1350000
45 0 0 0 0
0#
Bu suang a%
U
Culi on Cor on
%ô
U
Ö
Linapacan
&
Ö 0#
%0#
U
1200000
$
U%
$%
Öa
[ {x 0#
%
ô
ôÖ
{xÖ %
UU0#
0# %
[%
Ö
Taytay
ôÖ
Ñ %
U
Ö%
[
San Vice nte
Mag says ay
Cuyo
Ñô
%{x Ö
U
Ar aceli
{x 0#
[%Dum
ar an
Ñ
Ro xas
[% Ö
Que zon
Ñ %
a
&Ú r
Ri zal
Ú
[ $Öa
%
Ñ &%
Narr a
Ñ
$ 0# Es pañol a
Ú
[
%
Ú$
& Br ook es poi nt
$
Ö
%
a
[ BatÑar aza
%
Bal ab ac
aô
Ö%
$
C oconut pr od uct ion and pr oce s s in g
U
%
C ash e w p r od uction and pr oces s ing
&
Banana p rod u ction an d p ro ces s ing
a
%
C ass av a. and ot he r ro otcr op s p r od uction
0#
Veg et ab le and Le gum es Pr od uct ion
{x
Man go pr od uct ion and pr oce s s in g
Ö
C ult ur e an d p ro ces s ing of fis h & ot h er m arine pr od uct
ô
Se aw ee d s an d s e a v ege t able c ult ur e & pr oces s ing
Ñ
Liv es t ock and p oultr y pr od uc tion
Ú
Oil palm plantat ion and pr oce s s ing
45 0 0 0 0
60 0 0 0 0
75 0 0 0 0
Linapacan
El Nid o
ô
a%
a%
ô
Agut aya
r
Land cov e r
aTaytay
%
C rop lan d
a
ô%
a
%
San Vice nte
Ot h er palnt ation
75 0 0 0 0
a%ô %
a
Mag saysay
12 00000
C oconut plant ation
60 0 0 0 0
10 5 0 0 0 0
Cor on
Culi on
Rub b er plant ation a nd pr oces s ing
Pad dy fie ld
Cuyo
ô
a aceli
%
Ar
Dum ar an
90 0 0 0 0
ô
10 5 0 0 0 0
a
%
Ro xas
Cagayanci llo
a
%
Que zon
Ri zal
ô
1050000
1050000
Puer to Pri ncesa C it y
a
%
a
%
Ab or lan
Narr a
Español a
a
%
Bat ar aza
Le ge nd :
a
%
ô
Bal ab ac
a ô
%
45 0 0 0 0
60 0 0 0 0
Cult ure and p rocessing of fish & ot he r m arine pr oduct
Seawe eds and se a ve get able cultur e & proce ssing
75 0 0 0 0
90 0 0 0 0
10 5 0 0 0 0
900000
Proposed Fisheries
Development Areas
900000
45 0 0 0 0
90 0 0 0 0
Bu suang a
900000
900000
r
$
Rice and ot h er cer e al gr ains pr od uct ion
12 00000
Ú
0#
ô
[
%
1350000
&
[%ÚÑ 0#
r
Cagayanci llo
Le ge nd :
$&
1050000
1050000
Puer to Pri nces a C it y
[Ñ %
%
Öa
1200000
${x
r
Proposed Agri-Industrial
Development Areas
Uô
%
Agut aya
aÑ
%
1350000
El Nid o
CUYO, MAGSAYSAY,
AGUTAYA
STRENGHT LIES IN
ITS FISHERY AND
MARINE RESOURCES
CORON, CULION,
BUSUANGA & LINAPACAN
CONSIDERED TO BE A N
AQUA-BASED
ECOTOURISM DESTINATION
AREA
TAYTAY, EL NIDO , ROXAS &
SAN VICENTE
WELL-SUITED TO
BE
AN
AGRO,
FISHERY AND ECOTOURISM AREA
ABORLAN, NARRA &
SOFRONIO ESPAÑOLA
DUBBED AS THE
RICE
GRANARY
OF PALAWAN
BOOKE’S POINT, BATARAZA,
QUEZON, RIZAL & BALABAC
A
CROSS
BORDER
TRADING
AREA
BETWEEN BROOKE’S
PT., KOTA KINABALU,
SABAH AND MALAYSIA
ARACELI & DUMARAN
THE
ZONE
FOR
SEAWEED
PRODUCTION, ESTABLISHMENT
OF
MANGROVE-FRIENDLY
SHRIMP CULTURE, MARINE FISH
CULTURE IN CAGES
AND
MANGROVE
CRAB
AND
MOLLUSK CULTURE
KALAYAAN
HAS
TREMENDOUS
POTENTIAL
FOR FISHERY
AND DIVING
SITE
DEVELOPMENT
Municipality
Surveyed
Population
Total Surveyed Children in
Households Elementary
Children in
Secondary
Literate
Persons
Households with
Members in Org.
Employment Underemployme Malnourished
Rate
nt Rate
Children
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
Agutaya
39.48
75.45
37.55
81.40
83.54
82.64
49.59
53.08
97.29
95.71
31.86
28.15
69.43
73.97
48.93
50.79
6.02
5.09
Cagayancillo
92.85
74.98
96.20
84.17
85.03
90.24
69.20
87.81
97.26
97.41
52.91
50.83
81.64
53.27
29.70
81.19
2.34
3.91
Cuyo
92.74
52.17
87.64
57.39
94.61
89.19
86.23
89.30
98.27
96.16
30.07
50.26
73.34
85.29
70.89
69.52
4.03
2.41
104.46
64.40
93.61
62.97
94.27
91.05
88.41
70.36
98.73
97.62
27.17
48.46
79.87
86.02
50.87
37.75
3.78
0.63
83.44
63.79
67.35
91.68
87.72
80.58
73.83
98.15
96.58
13.99
76.68
75.92
52.88
57.70
3.90
3.24
Busuanga
79.68
57.91
79.59
66.07
82.21
89.90
54.09
63.71
90.26
94.82
43.96
38.30
85.61
77.66
82.52
69.97
8.72
8.34
Coron
99.09
56.33
96.12
55.36
79.30
82.80
42.89
54.43
95.76
88.63
37.15
56.68
74.89
91.18
52.08
29.22
5.39
4.90
Zone I
Magsaysay
Average
Zone II
Culion
No data
Linapacan
No data
No data
19.92
59.22
81.00
46.06
El Nido
57.25
84.57
Roxas
48.30
Taytay
35.78
San Vicente
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
58.86
82.71
80.52
25.97
57.64
79.53
93.06
46.13
80.24
84.34
45.19
57.61
93.65
90.98
57.81
86.73
88.08
79.01
49.60
54.53
88.93
81.18
15.12
51.37
16.26
88.47
83.79
69.45
67.89
90.63
28.59
37.00
28.05
90.22
87.30
63.25
62.70
91.27
89.43
94.03
91.26
95.91
91.45
88.68
73.50
72.71
53.07
44.56
45.09
89.61
84.44
65.13
Aborlan
67.91
95.26
70.30
68.14
94.91
91.81
Narra
98.92
56.75
98.45
58.94
96.51
89.31
20.98
21.18
96.12
Balabac
54.81
29.02
59.18
30.22
Bataraza
82.98
52.13
86.24
54.22
Brooke's point
87.52
49.48
86.76
51.86
Average
19.64
No data
No data
No data
31.66
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
15.51
62.85
74.90
94.85
49.24
13.77
0.00
27.04
76.97
84.75
62.65
42.72
6.75
5.06
36.52
41.52
84.60
76.04
65.35
57.53
4.66
7.52
88.13
43.80
36.58
78.10
84.77
66.86
58.50
2.40
4.32
87.72
32.21
20.03
80.97
80.03
64.39
74.26
3.36
6.45
91.86
90.29
41.84
45.34
78.67
82.81
50.04
72.36
3.20
2.76
63.28
91.57
86.13
20.28
80.86
80.30
61.19
65.75
3.66
5.56
72.81
89.41
87.28
87.89
54.12
53.71
75.68
61.00
81.85
52.52
3.82
5.73
93.02
82.80
82.40
92.29
89.69
33.62
32.89
75.90
84.11
53.22
96.00
4.96
2.00
92.56
80.50
85.31
93.87
89.03
19.96
79.56
74.76
68.01
81.65
5.30
3.30
69.27
76.56
50.00
32.90
79.89
89.21
34.49
23.95
88.79
93.68
57.15
71.64
10.57
4.23
73.69
68.86
59.63
55.92
82.91
81.42
26.65
11.64
82.71
93.52
65.44
73.39
3.58
2.91
80.25
74.32
56.79
62.95
90.72
84.86
26.07
33.64
82.07
86.23
76.70
57.44
4.43
6.86
Zone III
Average
Zone IV
Average
Zone V
Quezon
110.86 No data
113.23 No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
Rizal
26.95
42.25
28.54
40.89
57.06
63.43
30.85
41.27
70.20
77.25
27.71
29.50
95.30
97.46
73.98
63.03
1.41
8.75
Sofronio Espanola
54.76
78.48
48.09
79.93
74.95
88.32
50.84
67.33
78.05
75.29
23.35
33.01
52.84
88.77
74.10
70.32
5.73
0.00
Average
74.35
40.35
41.46
74.52
73.87
53.93
55.48
86.30
81.34
15.35
82.47
95.74
65.61
63.17
9.77
6.83
Dumaran
16.00
77.10
81.44
83.40
88.72
60.07
72.65
96.58
95.41
65.08
85.96
78.86
99.34
66.70
1.91
7.26
Araceli
66.84 No data
65.08
85.96
Zone VI
Average
Palawan
36.13
54.11
15.54
68.83 No data
47.53
50.25
No data
83.40
88.72
No data
60.07
72.65
64.27
No data
96.58
No data
95.41
64.27
37.15 53.55 37.72 84.74 83.06 63.69 66.21 90.16 87.36
32.91
No data
78.86
37.02 79.48 81.98
No data
99.34
66.70
No data
1.91
7.26
63.00 65.19 4.58
5.30
Municipality
HH with
HH NOT in
HH with Sanitary Access to Safe Makeshift
Toilet
Water
housing
HH with
Electricity
HH with
Sanitary Waste
Disposal
HH Greater than
Poverty Threshold
HH with NO
Victim of
Crime
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
2002
2000
Agutaya
58.88
52.13
45.04
61.91
88.25
99.95
39.02
49.27
0.92
0.00
19.97
21.99
100.00
99.53
Cagayancillo
79.91
86.53
19.98
37.87
99.23
96.70
50.17
33.80
7.24
0.25
11.75
6.61
100.00
100.00
Cuyo
80.81
91.15
29.43
87.70
97.94
99.63
73.41
80.39
5.75
15.04
29.65
41.45
100.00
Magsaysay
72.97
94.93
56.64
24.90
98.74
100.00
50.94
72.23
8.24
0.00
36.02
37.52
100.00
75.89
79.98
38.21
58.89
97.29
99.44
59.73
63.44
6.17
5.17
28.19
30.42
99.99
Busuanga
62.56
77.64
55.53
61.30
94.19
100.00
28.37
31.58
4.00
0.00
20.49
22.71
99.96
Coron
43.81
51.48
65.27
72.26
88.51
99.03
46.44
41.05
24.10
18.92
13.93
29.73
99.82
HH NO Infant
Death
2002 2000
HH with NO
Child Death
2002
2000
2002
98.05
95.83
98.92
98.70
99.21
99.26
99.67
100.00
99.86
99.37
96.87
94.78
99.74
100.00
98.71
98.95
100.00
98.60
98.97
97.40
97.56
99.19
99.84
94.65
96.65
99.03
99.89
99.98
97.86
96.14
99.69
99.54
Zone I
Average
Zone II
Culion
No data
Linapacan
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
No data
42.31
53.20
84.91
96.21
85.51
98.56
10.35
40.94
0.00
5.23
9.76
24.53
100.00
48.93
59.54
63.34
72.88
89.96
99.24
40.06
38.22
17.62
11.08
15.58
26.80
99.77
El Nido
77.84
83.98
31.79
26.91
99.23
98.13
21.99
35.96
2.03
8.35
28.66
16.92
99.97
Roxas
77.60
70.77
36.37
45.42
99.27
96.97
23.43
16.97
7.47
3.16
30.17
15.55
99.98
Taytay
54.31
65.37
30.29
79.33
75.10
98.92
19.08
29.91
20.00
0.27
20.40
22.39
San Vicente
63.56
57.44
62.40
66.93
95.08
98.47
23.21
34.56
1.68
2.35
30.52
26.72
68.52
70.24
40.45
52.80
92.12
98.27
21.68
32.03
8.57
4.14
26.27
20.97
99.84
Aborlan
69.70
65.13
77.29
82.35
98.42
99.69
32.30
50.35
5.24
0.96
38.44
0.00
99.86
Narra
73.26
87.73
85.19
88.94
98.49
98.50
32.37
57.49
1.07
1.88
25.25
38.77
98.07
72.38
79.85
83.25
86.64
93.61
98.92
48.83
55.00
48.39
1.56
46.37
25.25
99.83
Balabac
43.37
40.16
27.23
39.96
98.25
99.21
12.63
25.92
4.08
6.69
82.78
20.41
99.89
Bataraza
44.67
45.17
38.19
63.79
96.63
97.75
14.50
18.19
9.67
5.27
23.15
15.72
99.81
Brooke's point
57.10
66.09
72.49
81.91
96.09
91.25
28.03
28.57
18.26
12.91
69.85
29.60
99.96
Average
No data
99.97
No data
No data
No data
No data
97.34
98.11
98.12
99.67
96.55
96.76
99.46
99.65
100.00
97.86
98.18
99.04
99.47
99.83
97.01
96.55
97.33
99.10
100.00
99.97
96.67
98.62
99.23
99.51
99.77
99.89
94.76
98.60
98.13
99.88
96.32
98.27
98.18
99.58
99.58
97.19
99.22
99.57
99.92
99.89
96.80
98.33
98.94
99.58
97.48
98.64
98.07
99.73
99.76
90.73
100.00
94.89
98.93
99.76
97.51
99.33
98.44
99.71
98.30
98.46
94.60
99.60
99.84
Zone III
Average
Zone IV
Average
Zone V
Quezon
24.29 No data
98.12 No data
17.70 No data
Rizal
62.81
No data
41.30
69.71
23.54
98.68
100.00
16.62
7.81
0.58 No data
0.00
0.03
19.52 No data
0.31
Sofronio Espanola
65.26
60.42
95.07
64.99
99.51
95.91
57.80
24.38
14.31
15.27
Average
52.86
53.17
58.35
60.38
97.13
96.06
22.33
21.24
8.52
8.77
Dumaran
72.28
59.14
31.21
39.72
100.00
97.51
40.45
45.00
2.05
0.00
Araceli
71.44 No data
99.82 No data
99.40 No data
98.98 No data
12.66
99.95
99.97
100.00
99.37
100.00
99.86
27.09
6.12
100.00
99.78
89.51
86.41
95.89
97.37
38.01
17.26
99.80
97.13
95.54
98.44
99.15
15.19
18.72
100.00
90.41
94.87
99.62
98.57
Zone VI
Average
Palawan
25.23 No data
72.28
59.14
62.44
65.78
31.21
39.72
92.56 No data
100.00
97.51
34.59 No data
36.09
12.26 No data
24.16 No data
45.00
9.64
0.00
21.86
58.19 63.86 94.40 97.88 29.61 37.37
8.04
6.72
30.60
99.99
100.00 No data
18.72
99.95
22.11 99.65 99.73
97.84 No data
98.72 No data
96.83
98.95
98.57
99.58 98.60
99.40
97.02
94.87
Census Survey Processing
CBMS Statistics Simulator
Simple Composite Indicator, Household
Integration of the 13+1 indicators to identify the poor
hhid
1.75
E+14
1.75
E+14
1.75
E+14
1.75
E+14
1.75
E+14
region
IVB - SOUTHERN
TAGALOG (MIMAROPA)
IVB - SOUTHERN
TAGALOG (MIMAROPA)
IVB - SOUTHERN
TAGALOG (MIMAROPA)
IVB - SOUTHERN
TAGALOG (MIMAROPA)
IVB - SOUTHERN
TAGALOG (MIMAROPA)
province
municipality
PALAWAN
BROOKE'S
POINT
PALAWAN
BROOKE'S
POINT
PALAWAN
BROOKE'S
POINT
PALAWAN
BROOKE'S
POINT
PALAWAN
BROOKE'S
POINT
barangay
Aribungos
Aribungos
Aribungos
Aribungos
Aribungos
hh_s
ci
purokname
hhhead
Tagumpay
HERRERA,
ISMAEL
0
Tagumpay
LAUREANO,
ERNESTO
0
Tagumpay
CREADOR,
NELSON
0
Tagumpay
CREADOR,
EDWIN
0
Tagumpay
SADANG,
MERWIN
0
CBMS Indicator Summary,
2008
Province
Palawan
Municipality
Brooke’s Point
Indicator
Health
Households with Child Deaths (0-5 years old)
Total
No.
%
5870
36
0.6
Maternal Mortality Rate
2
Nutrition
Malnutrition Prevalence (0-5years old)
5870
333
5.70
Housing
Households Living in Makeshift Housing
12447
173
1.40
Households Classified as Informal Settlers
12447
399
3.20
Water &
Sanitation
Households with no Access to Safe Water
12447
2166
17.40
Households with no Access to Sanitary Toilet Facilities
12447
3914
31.40
Basic
Education
Elementary School Participation Rate
6224
4500
72.30
Secondary School Participation Rate
4070
2277
55.90
Income
Households with Income Below the Poverty Threshold
12447
3521
28.29
Households with Income Below the Food Threshold
12447
1760
14.14
Households which have Experienced Food Shortage
12447
401
3.22
Employment
Unemployment Rate
11879
93
0.78
Peace &
Order
Households with Members who Fell Victim to Crimes
12447
49
0.39
Proportion of households with malnourished children
Municipality of Magsaysay, Palawan, 2008
After Intervention
Before Intervention
Proportion of households with access
to safe water,
Brgy. Canipo, Magsaysay, Palawan,
2004
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
REPORTS FOR 2000 and 2006
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT INDEX
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
… maximum utilization of scarce resources;
Thank You !