Transcript C2 MG Review Process for C2

C2 MG Review Process for C2-led Projects
CG Editor/Managing
Editor requests full
methods review for a
protocol or review
1-2 days
MG Associate
Editor/Managing Editor
scans for specialized
peer reviewer needs
1-7 days
MG Managing Editor
solicits methods peer
review
2-4 weeks
CG Editor/Managing
Editor requests inhouse methods review
for a protocol
MG approves CG inhouse review
MG vetoes CG in-house
review
MG Associate
Editor/Managing Editor
notifies CG of veto
1 day
MG receives methods
peer review
1-2 weeks
MG Editor/Associate
Editor sends peer
review & action letter
to CG Managing Editor
Current C2 MG Review Process for CDPLPG-led Projects
CDPLPG Managing
Editor requests
methods review from
MG Editor/Associate
Editor
2 weeks
MG Editor/Associate
Editor sends peer
review to CDPLPG
Managing Editor
Proposed C2 MG Review Process for C1-led Projects
C1 Editorial Team
solicits at least one
methods/statistics peer
reviewer
Authors R&R document
based on peer review
C1 provides C2 MG a
copy of revised &
original document &
peer review comments
4 weeks
C2 MG notes methods
flaws: sends action
letter to C1 Editorial
Team & C2 CG
C2 MG approves C1
methods review
C2 MG notifies C1
Editorial Team & C2 CG
of approval