www.acsa.org

Download Report

Transcript www.acsa.org

RTTT, Proposition 39, and
Charter Schools: The Facilities
Factor
by
Laura Preston
Melanie Petersen
Susan Park
January 15, 2010
Overview
•
•
•
•
•
•
Race to the top (RTTT)
Proposition 39
New Timelines
Legal Standard
Facilities Use Agreement
Negotiation Strategies
RTTT: What is it?
•
•
•
•
RTTT is a competitive grant program, authorized
under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act
of 2009, which encourages and rewards states that
implement significant reforms in 4 areas:
Enhancing standards and assessments
Improving the collection and use of data
Increasing teacher effectiveness and achieving equity
in teacher distribution
Turning around struggling schools
RTTT: Funding
The U.S. Department of Education will make
awards in 2 phases:
Phase 1 funding  Spring, 2010
Phase 2 funding  by September 30, 2010
RTTT: Deadlines
• Letter of Intent: December 31, 2009
• MOU due January 8, 2010
• California must submit applications to the U.S.
Dept. of Education by January 19, 2010
RTTT: Charter School Model
• Whether California receives Race to the Top funding
or not, schools in the bottom 5% will be faced with
one of four turnaround models to choose from.
• Charter schools are one of the models.
• While the use of the existing school site alleviates
some portion of a Proposition 39 request, the fact that
the school may need reconfiguration, materials, etc.
could lead to a district being faced with Proposition
39 obligations.
Proposition 39
• Passed November 2000.
• Added Ed. Code section 47614 creating
obligation to provide facilities to charter schools.
• Don’t confuse with other major part of Prop. 39
(55% Vote for Passage of Bonds)
• Intent: “. . . public school facilities should be
shared fairly among all public school pupils,
including those in charter schools.”
Proposition 39
Prior Version of Education Code section 47614:
A school district in which a charter school
operates shall permit a charter school to use, at no
charge, facilities not currently being used by the
school district for instructional or administrative
purposes, or that have not been historically used
for rental purposes provided the charter school
shall be responsible for reasonable maintenance
of those facilities.
Proposition 39
Amended Version of Ed. Code section 47614:
(a) The intent of the people in amending Section
47614 is that public school facilities should be
shared fairly among all public school pupils,
including those in charter schools.
Proposition 39
What else does Ed. Code section 47614 require?
Each district shall make available, to each charter
school operating in the district, facilities sufficient for
the charter school to accommodate all of the charter
school's in-district students in conditions reasonably
equivalent to those in which the students would be
accommodated if they were attending other public
schools of the district. Facilities provided shall be
contiguous, furnished, and equipped, and shall remain
the property of the district.
New Timelines
• Amended regulations are operative for use of
facilities in 2009-2010.
• Established new deadlines, with penalties for
missing a deadline.
• Expanded the definition of terms such as
"reasonably equivalent."
• Imposed additional duties on a school district
that is unable to offer a "contiguous" site.
New Timelines
Summary of Prop 39 Deadlines:
November 1: Charter school must submit a written
facilities request for the following school year.
December 1: District must object to a charter
school’s projected ADA, or charter school’s
projections are no longer subject to challenge.
January 2: Charter school must respond to the
district’s objections or the district’s projection is no
longer subject to challenge.
New Timelines
Summary of Prop 39 Deadlines (cont’d)
February 1: District’s preliminary proposal is due.
March 1: Charter school must respond to the
preliminary proposal.
April 1: District’s final notification is due.
May 1: Charter school must notify the district if it
intends to occupy the offered space by May 1 or 30
days after the district’s notification, whichever is
later.
November 1: Written Facilities Request Eligibility
• A charter school must be "operating" in the district.
• Operating means 80 in-district ADA.
• A student attending a charter school is "in-district" if
he or she is entitled to attend the schools of the
district and could attend a district-operated school,
except that a student eligible to attend the schools of
the district based on interdistrict attendance or based
on parental employment shall be considered a student
of the district where he or she resides.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.2(c); Ed. Code §§ 46600-46611,
48204(b).)
November 1: Written Facilities Request –
Eligibility (cont’d)
• New charter schools are eligible to request
facilities only if
– Submitted its charter petition on or before
November 1, 2009, and
– Receive approval of the petition before March 15,
2010. (5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(a).)
November 1: Written Facilities Request – CDE Form (optional)
http://www.cde.ca.gov/sp/cs/as/documents/csfacilityreqform.doc
November 1: Written Facilities
Request - Components
Reasonable projections:
• In-district and total ADA
• In-district and total classroom ADA
• Based on ADA claimed for apportionment in the
prior year
• Adjusted for expected changes in enrollment in the
forthcoming year
• Broken down by grade level
• Broken down by the school in the district that the
student would otherwise attend
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(c).)
November 1: Written Facilities
Request – Components (cont'd)
Description of the methodology:
• Independent study program?
• Is the attendance rate reasonable?
• Has the charter school experienced growth
trends?
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(c).)
November 1: Written Facilities
Request – Components (cont'd)
•
•
•
•
Sufficient documentation of the number of in-district students
meaningfully interested in attending the charter school to
allow the district to determine the reasonableness of the charter
school's projection, but that need not be verifiable for precise
arithmetical accuracy.
Does the documentation reflect the appropriate grade level?
Has the charter school opened yet? (intent to enroll forms)
Has there been in a decline in enrollment?
Has there been a substantial increase in in-district ADA?
(grade level bubble, closed school)
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(c).)
November 1: Written Facilities
Request – Components (cont'd)
• Charter school's operational calendar
• The district site or general geographic area
where the charter school wishes to locate
• Information about the educational program
that is relevant to assignment of facilities, i.e.,
"specialized classroom space“ (science labs,
technology, P.E.)
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(c).)
November 1: Written Facilities
Request – Components (cont'd)
Anything else required by board policy?
Districts may also require the charter school
either to distribute a reasonable number of
copies of the written facilities request for
review by other interested parties, such as
parents and teachers, or to otherwise make the
request available for review.
December 1: District’s Objections
• On or before December 1, the district shall review the
charter school's ADA projections and express any
objections in writing and state the projections the
district considers reasonable.
• Consequence: If the district misses this deadline, the
charter school's projections are no longer subject to
challenge, and the district must base its offer of
facilities on those projections.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(d).)
December 1: District’s Objections Examples
• Charter school is ineligible to submit a
facilities request because:
– Failed to submit its charter petition prior to
November 1.
– Failed to identify at least 80 in-district students
who are meaningfully interested in enrolling.
– Failed to provide the required information (e.g.,
operational calendar, ADA breakdown by grade
level, etc.)
December 1: District’s Objections –
Examples (cont’d)
• Inaccurate methodology:
– Attendance rate, retention rate, etc. are too high
based on prior year(s) data.
– Growth rate is inconsistent with prior year(s)
trends.
• Exceeds the maximum enrollment capacity
described in the charter and/or MOU.
January 2: Charter School Responds to
District’s Objections
• On or before January 2, charter school must
respond to district's objection.
• Charter school shall reaffirm or modify its
original projections as necessary to respond to
the information received from the district.
• Consequence: If the charter school misses the
deadline, the district's projections are no longer
subject to challenge, and the district shall base
its offer of facilities on its projections.
January 2: Charter School Responds to
District’s Objections
Q: Is the district required to reply to
the charter school's response?
A: See April 1 deadline.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(e), (h)(3).)
February 1: Preliminary Proposal Components
•
•
•
•
•
•
On or before February 1, the district shall prepare in writing a
preliminary proposal which shall include:
Projections of in-district classroom ADA on which the
proposal is based
Specific location of the space
Conditions pertaining to the space, including a draft of any
proposed agreement
Projected pro rata share amount and methodology
Comparison group schools used
Description of the differences between the preliminary
proposal and the charter school's facilities request
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(f).)
February 1: Preliminary Proposal –
Legal Standard
•
•
•
•
"Contiguous"
"Furnished and equipped"
"Comparison group"
"Reasonably equivalent"
Contiguous
• Facilities are contiguous if they are contained on the
school site or immediately adjacent to the school site.
• If the district's preliminary proposal (or final
notification) does not accommodate a charter school
at a single school site,
– District's governing board must first make a finding that the
charter school could not be accommodated at a single site;
and
– Adopt a written statement of reasons.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.2(d).)
Contiguous (cont'd)
If the in-district average daily classroom
attendance of the charter school cannot be
accommodated on any single district school
site, contiguous facilities also includes
facilities located at more than one site,
provided that the district:
– Minimize the number of sites assigned; and
– Consider student safety.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.2(d).)
Contiguous: Case law
Ridgecrest Charter School v. Sierra Sands USD (2005).
Facts:
• Charter school submitted facilities request to school
district for 223 students.
• District offered the use of 9.5 classrooms at 5
different school sites separated by a total of 65 miles.
• Charter school claimed entitlement to a single site
since several sites were capable of accommodating all
223 students.
• Court ruled that the district abused its discretion.
Contiguous: Case law (cont'd)
What the court said:
• "…it seems to reflect a preference for a time before passage of Proposition
39, when a school district was required only to provide a charter school
with facilities it was not using."
• "…at least begin with the assumption that all charter school students will
be assigned to a single site, and attempt from there to adjust the other
factors to accommodate this goal."
• "…regulations contemplate that some disruption and dislocation of the
students and programs in a district my be necessary to fairly accommodate
a charter school's request for facilities."
• "...accommodating a charter school might involve moving district-operated
programs or changing attendance areas…" (quoting CDE).
• "Classroom size is only one of several criteria for determining
equivalency…."
Furnished and Equipped:
“Furnishings”
Reasonably equivalent furnishings necessary
to conduct classroom instruction and
to provide for student services that directly
support classroom instruction as found in the
comparison group schools
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.2(e).)
Furnished and Equipped: “Equipment”
• Reasonably equivalent equipment
• Equipment means:
– Property that does not lose its identity when removed from its location
– Is not changed materially or consumed immediately (e.g., within one
year) by use
– Has relatively permanent value, and its purchase increases the total
value of the district's physical properties.
– E.g., furniture, vehicles, machinery, motion picture film, videotape,
furnishings that are not an integral part of the building or building
system, and certain intangible assets, such as major software programs.
• As found in the comparison group schools
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.2(e).)
Furnished and Equipped:
“Non-District Resources”
Furnishings and equipment acquired for a
school site with non-district resources are
excluded when determining reasonable
equivalence (e.g., PTA-donated garden)
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.2(e).)
Comparison Group
• Comparison group shall be the district-operated schools with
similar grade levels that serve students living in the high
school attendance area in which the largest number of students
of the charter school reside.
• For districts whose students do not attend high school based on
attendance areas, e comparison group shall be 3 schools in the
district with similar grade levels that the largest number of
students of the charter school would otherwise attend.
• For districts with fewer than 3 schools with similar grade
levels, the comparison group shall be all district schools with
similar grade levels.
• If none of the district-operated schools has similar grade
levels, then a contiguous facility shall be an existing facility
that is most consistent with the needs of students in the grade
levels served at the charter school.
Modifying Existing Sites - Q
Q: District operates K-5 elementary schools,
6-8 middle schools, and 9-12 high schools.
Charter schools wants a facility to serve grades
K-8 that includes playgrounds for primary
grades and science labs for older students. Is
the District required to build a science lab on
an elementary school site?
Modifying Existing Sites - A
A: District is not obligated to pay for the
modification of an existing school site to
accommodate the charter school's grade level
configuration. However, the parties may enter
into an agreement by which the costs of the
modifications being paid exclusively by the
charter school or by the district, or paid jointly.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.3(a)(4).)
Conditions Reasonably Equivalent –
Capacity
District's obligation to provide classrooms:
• Same ratio of classrooms (teaching stations)
• Use the district's classroom inventory, adjusted to
exclude classrooms identified as interim housing.
"Interim housing" means the rental or lease of
classrooms used to house students temporarily
displaced as a result of the modernization of
classroom facilities, and classrooms used as
emergency housing for schools vacated due to
structural deficiencies or natural disasters.
Capacity – Q
Query: The charter petition describes a 20:1
student to teacher ratio. The district has
eliminated class size reduction and will be
increasing its ratio to 30:1. Is the district
required to offer facilities according the charter
school's lower loading rate?
Capacity – A
A: No, the standard for determining whether
facilities are sufficient to accommodate charter
school students in conditions reasonably
equivalent to those in which the students
would be accommodated if they were
attending public schools of the district. The
district satisfies its Proposition 39 obligation
by offering the same ratio of classrooms as the
comparison group of schools.
Reasonably Equivalent –
Specialized Classroom Space
Factors for providing specialized teaching space:
• Grade levels of the charter school's in-district
students
• Charter school's total in-district classroom ADA
• Per-student amount of specialized classroom space in
the comparison group schools.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.3(b).)
Reasonably Equivalent –
Non-Teaching Station Space
•
•
•
•
Non-teaching station space means all of the
space that is not identified as teaching station
space or specialized classroom space:
Administrative space,
Kitchen,
Multi-purpose room,
Play area space.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.3(b).)
Reasonably Equivalent –
Good Faith Duty
District has a duty to negotiate in good faith
with the charter school to establish time
allocations and schedules so that educational
programs of the charter school and district are
least disrupted.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.3(b).)
Reasonably Equivalent – Condition
Factors to consider:
• Age (from latest modernization)
• Size (of the site)
• Interior and exterior surfaces
• Mechanical, plumbing, electrical, and fire alarm
systems, including conformity to applicable codes
• Technology infrastructure
• Safe learning environment (suitability of lighting,
noise mitigation)
• Athletic fields and/or play areas.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.3(c).)
Reasonably Equivalent – Case Law
Bullis Charter School v. Los Altos Sch. Dist (2009)
Charter school filed a petition for writ of mandate,
alleging that the district failed to:
– Offer physical space “reasonably equivalent” to that
available at district-operated schools
– Offer a school site with sufficient capacity
– Allocate reasonably equivalent specialized teaching and
non-teaching space
– Establish arrangements for shared use of non-teaching
facilities.
Reasonably Equivalent – Case Law (cont'd)
Bullis Charter School v. Los Altos Sch. Dist.
Capacity: Dispute over square footage and comparison group
schools.
Court ruling:
• Relevant calculation is based on ratio of in-district classroom
ADA to teaching stations.
• No requirement ratio be calculated for individual grade levels.
• Comparison group not limited to 3 schools because students
lived in high school attendance area.
• District used appropriate comparison group for calculation.
• District’s calculation of ADA/classroom ratio was not
arbitrary, capricious, or lacking in evidentiary support.
Reasonably Equivalent – Case Law (cont'd)
Bullis Charter School v. Los Altos Sch. Dist. (2009)
Teaching and (indoor) non-teaching space: District
calculated specialized teaching and non-teaching
space for each type of facility common to all
comparison group sites (e.g., teacher lounges,
libraries, and playgrounds), but did not include types
of space not present at all sites (e.g., dedicated PTA
space).
Court ruling: District allocated reasonably
equivalent specialized teaching space and indoor nonteaching space.
Reasonably Equivalent – Case Law (cont'd)
Bullis Charter School v. Los Altos Sch. Dist. (2009)
Shared use of non-teaching facilities: Charter school alleged
that the final offer of space failed to clearly identify proposed
sharing of facilities, particularly use of fields for physical
education and sports-related activities. Final offer noted
district’s attempts to finalize facilities agreement for past 8
months, with issue of share use of fields during after school
hours still outstanding.
Court ruling:
– District failed to comply with 5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(k) by not
identifying arrangements for shared space with appropriate specificity,
which prevented proper calculation of pro rata share to be charged for
such shared use.
– District and charter school were ordered to negotiate an agreement in
good faith regarding use and payment for outdoor space.
March 1: Charter School Responds
to Preliminary Proposal
On or before March 1, the charter school shall
respond in writing to the district's preliminary
proposal:
• Express concerns
• Make counter proposals
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(g).)
April 1: Final Notification
On or before April 1, the district must
provide a final notification of the space
offered to the charter school, including a
response to the charter school's concerns
and/or counter proposals.
April 1: Final Notification (cont'd)
Final notification must specifically identify:
• Classrooms, specialized classroom space, and non-teaching
station space offered for exclusive use of the charter school
• Classrooms, specialized classroom space, and non-teaching
station space offered for the on a shared basis with
district-operated programs, and arrangements for shared space
• In-district classroom ADA assumptions for the charter school
that the offer was based, if the assumptions are different than
what the charter school submitted on or before January 2
• Written explanation of the reasons for the differences
April 1: Final Notification (cont'd)
Final notification must specifically identify:
• Specific location of the space
• All conditions pertaining to the space
• Pro rata share amount
• Payment schedule for the pro rata share amount,
which shall take into account the timing of revenues
from the state and from local property taxes
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(h).)
May 1: Intent to Occupy
By May 30, or 30 days after the district's final
notification, whichever is later, the charter school
must notify the district in writing whether or not it
intends to occupy the offered space.
Consequence: If the charter school misses the
deadline, the charter school shall not be entitled to
use facilities in the following fiscal year.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(i).)
Giving the Charter School the Keys
• At least 10 working days prior to charter school's first
day of instruction, the space must be furnished,
equipped and available for occupancy.
• For good cause, the period is subject to reduction by
the district, but to no fewer than 7 working days.
• This is why it is important that the Proposition 39
request submitted by November 1 includes the charter
school's operational calendar.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.9(j).)
Facilities Use Agreement
Required Minimum Terms:
• All information included in final facilities offer.
• Exclusive/shared space allocation, location, and conditions pertaining
to space.
• Pro-rata share amount/payment schedule
•
Other Common Terms:
-Term/Termination provisions
-Maintenance and Operations
-Utilities
-Installation of Improvements
-Insurance
-NEW: Reciprocal indemnification provision required
-Full Satisfaction of Prop 39/Release of Claims
Facilities Use Agreement –
Facilities Costs
• District has no obligation to use unrestricted
general fund revenues to rent, buy, or lease
facilities for charter school students.
• District may:
– Charge a pro rata share for facilities costs paid for
out of general fund.
– Based on ratio of space allocated to charter school.
– Cannot otherwise charge charter school for use of
facilities.
Facilities Use Agreement –
Facilities Costs (cont'd)
“Facilities costs” include:
• Maintenance and operations
• Facilities acquisition and construction
• Facilities rents and leases
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.7.)
Facilities Use Agreement –
Supervisorial Oversight Costs
If district charges
pro rata share
May also charge up to
1% of charter school’s
revenue for supervisorial
oversight costs
If district does not charge
pro rata share
 May also charge up to
3% of charter school’s
revenue for supervisorial
oversight costs
(Ed.. Code § 47614(b)(1); 5 C.C.R. § 11969.7.)
Facilities Use Agreement –
Calculating Pro Rata Share
Pro rata share may not exceed:
• Per-square-foot amount equal to facilities costs
paid for with unrestricted general fund
revenues,
• Divided by total space of district,
• Multiplied by amount of space allocated to
charter school.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.7.)
Reimbursement
for Over-Allocated Space
• If, by February 1 of its first year of operation, a
charter school notifies the district that it will have
over-allocated space in the following fiscal year, the
space identified is not subject to reimbursement for
over-allocated space.
• Over-allocated means:
– Charter school's actual in-district classroom ADA is less
than the projected in-district classroom ADA upon which
the facility allocation was based, and
– The difference is greater than or equal to a threshold ADA
amount of 25 ADA or 10 percent of projected in-district
classroom ADA, whichever is greater.
(5 C.C.R. § 11969.8.)
Reimbursement for
Over-Allocated Space (cont'd)
• Charter school must notify the district when it anticipates that it will have
over-allocated space.
• District must notify the charter school whether or not it intends to use the
over-allocated space within 30 days of the notification.
• If the district notifies the charter school that it does not intend to use the
space, the charter school must continue to make payments for overallocated space and pro rata share payments.
• The per-pupil rate for over-allocated space shall be equal to the statewide
average cost avoided per pupil set pursuant to Ed. Code § 42263 for
2005/2006, adjusted annually thereafter by the CDE by the annual
percentage change in the general-purpose entitlement to charter schools
calculated pursuant to Ed. Code § 47633, rounded to the next highest
dollar, and posted on the CDE Web site.
(5 C.C.R. §§ 11969.3, 11969.8.)
Facilities Negotiations
Agree to avoid calculations:
• Supervisorial oversight rate (fixed amount
rather than billing for actual cost)
• Over-allocated reimbursement rate (fixed
amount rather than state rate)
Facilities Negotiations (cont'd)
Identify potentially controversial issues:
• Signage
• Recruitment/outreach
• Shared campus (e.g., staff lounge, recess
schedule, testing schedule)
• Traffic
Facilities Negotiations (cont'd)
Multi-year agreement
• Stability
• Avoid risk of missing a deadline/consequence
• Negotiate for the term of the charter instead of
annually
• Prevent material revision to a charter
Facilities Negotiations (cont'd)
Can be creative
• Agree to satisfy Proposition 39 obligation
through alternative methods
• Admission/participation in district events
(e.g., dances)
• Non-district students
Final Thoughts
• Evolving area of the law
• Importance of maintaining a
positive relationship
NewsFlash, a complimentary service from
F3, brings you the most current news on
legal decisions and legislative action that
affect public education. Subscribe today at
fagenfriedman.com.
F3 is pleased to announce the opening of
our Fresno office.
Visit
www.acsa.org/e-ducation
To download today’s powerpoint
presentation or to view recordings of
previous webinars.
Thank You!