presentation title - Politechnika Wrocławska

Download Report

Transcript presentation title - Politechnika Wrocławska

Time-Frequency Analysis
of Non-stationary Phenomena
in Electrical Engineering
Antonio Bracale, Guido Carpinelli
Universita degli Studi di Napoli “Federico II”
Zbigniew Leonowicz, Tomasz Sikorski, Krzysztof Wozniak
Wroclaw University of Technology, Poland
Modern Electrical Power Systems - MEPS 06
September 06-08, 2006, Wroclaw, Poland
Contents of presentation
• Motivations for applying time-frequency
analysis in electrical engineering
• How
to
obtain
time-frequency
representations?
• Mathematical backgrounds of applied tools
• Investigated non-stationary phenomena
• Results of investigations
• Conclusions
Motivations
• Increasing level of non-stationary phenomena in
contemporary power systems and its influence
on power quality
 Converter systems generate a wide range of characteristic
harmonics typical for the ideal converter operations, but also in
some cases they become a source of non-characteristic harmonics.
 The duration time of some transient states can reach values up to
5-10 periods of basic component.
• Limitation of one-dimensional Fourier spectrum and new
trends in signal processing for designing comprehensive
and adaptive algorithms
 Classical Fourier spectrum loses the information about transient
character of investigated phenomena. Non-stationarity is spread out
over the whole frequency domain.
 Fourier algorithm with sliding window has a inseparable tradeoff
between window width and time-frequency resolution.
To know how to merge two
dimensions in one
How to obtain joint time-frequency
representations?
Sliding window and different
spectrum estimation methods
Two-dimensional nonparametric equations
Linear
Non-Linear
Spectrograms:
- Gabor
- STFT
- S-transform
Scalograms:
- Wavelet transform
Spectrograms:
Bilinear:
Cohen's class (TFC):
- Wigner
- Wigner-Ville
- Page
- Levin
- Margenau-Hill
- Rihaczek
- Born-Jordan
- Choi-Williams
- Zhao-Atlas-Marks
- Butterworth
Scalograms:
Affine Wigner:
- Bertrand-Bertrand
- Rioul-Flandrin
Q distribution:
- Eichman-Marinovic
- Altes
Mathematical backgrounds – STFT
 i 2 ft
dt

•
•
•
•
•
•
0.8
STFT is classical method of time
frequency analysis
Involves both time and frequency and
allows a time-frequency analysis or in
other words a signal representation in
the time-frequency plane
The width of analysis window is fixed =
constant time-frequency resolution for
all frequency components
Time-frequency resolution is
dependent of analysis window width
Wide window
good frequency
resolution, poor time resolution
Narrow window
good time
resolution, poor frequency resolution
0.6
0.4
amplitude
 x(t )   t  e
*
Non-stationary signal with freguency components occure in different intervals time
100Hz 0-270ms ; 10Hz 270-500ms; 25Hz 500-760ms; 50Hz 760-100ms
1
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
0.8
0.8
0.9
0.9
0.9
111
time
Short-Time
-Spectrogram
Spectrogram
Short-Time Fourier
Fourier Transform
Transform-Spectrogram
Short-Time
Fourier
TransformHamming,
0.25s
Hamming,width
width0.02s
1s
200
180
160
140
Frequency
Frequency [Hz]
[Hz]
STFT( , f ) 

120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.3
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.5
0.6
Time [s]
[s]
Time
0.7
0.7
STFT cannot be used successfully to analyze transient signals which contain high and low
frequency components simulatneously
Mathematical backgrounds –
S-Transform
S( , f , ) 
0.6
160

x  t   (  t , ) e i 2 ft dt

0.4
140
0.2
120
frequency
• S transform uses a moving analyzing
window but unlike STFT the width of
the window is scaled with frequency
as in wavelets

0.8
180
Frequency
[Hz]
amplitude
• S transform is conceptually a hybrid
of STFT and wavelet analysis,
containing elements of both but
falling entirely into neither category
Short-Time
Fouriercomponents
Transform-Spectrogram
Non-stationary signal
with freguency
occure in different intervals time
100Hz 0-270ms ; 10Hz 270-500ms;
25Hz 0.25s
500-760ms; 50Hz 760-100ms
Hamming, width
2001
1000
 (t ) 
-0.2
80
-0.4
60
-0.6
40
1
 2
e (t
2
/ 2 2 )
, 
k
f
-0.8
20
-1
0
0
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.3
0.4
0.4
0.5
0.5
time
Time [s]
0.6
0.6
0.7
0.7
0.8
0.8
0.9
0.9
1
1
S Transform
• The width of analysis window is the
f time plane
2
Resolution of time-frequency
 twhen
)2 f 2 the
/ 2 ksignal
)  i 2 ft
inverse of the frequency = frequency- S ( , f )  is viewed
x  t in the S-Transform
e ((representation,
e
dt
having frequency dependent resolution
dependent resolution
k 2


200
180
160
• S transform performs multi-resolution
analysis on the signal, gives high time
resolution at high frequencies and
high frequency resolution at low
frequencies
Frequency [Hz]
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Time [s]
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Mathematical backgrounds – Cohen’s
Class
TFC x  t ,  
  
  


j t  j  j u
x
u

x
u

    2   2  t  ,  e e e dud d
instantaneous
autocorrelation function
kernel
function
Legend:
TFC x  t ,  
 t  , 
x t 
t

u
- time-frequency representation belonging to Cohen’s class
- kernel function of chosen time-frequency representation
- investigated signal
- time variable
- time shift
- additional integral time variable
 - angular frequency
 - angular frequency shift
General comments:
The equation leads to two-dimensional time-varying spectrum which represents
the energy changes of frequency components, here called auto-terms (a-t).
Unfortunately, bilinear nature of discussed transformations manifests itself in
existing of undesirable oscilating components, called cross-terms (c-t).
Mathematical backgrounds – Cohen’s
Class
Basic level of adaptation for signal analysis –selection of the kernel
function:
WIGNER-VILLE
WVD x  t ,  
t  ,   1
(constant kernel)
t  ,   e

 2

 
sin   
2 
 t  ,   h   

2

CHOI-WILLIAMS
(Gaussian kernel)
ZHAO-ATLAS-MARKS
(cone-shaped kernel)
CWD x  t ,  
ZAMD x  t ,  
Additional level of adaptation for signal analysis – applying smoothing
function:
Signal
x t 
h  
Pseudo-time-frequency
representation
PTFC x  t , 
smoothing effect along frequency axis
g t 
Smoothed pseudo-time-frequency
representation
SPTFC x  t , 
smoothing effect along time axis
Investigated phenomena – switching
of capacitor banks
a)
x10 3
10
measurement
switching on
900kVar
8
switching on
1200kVar
6
Line
0.2km
4
Line
1.0km
current (A)
HV Transformer MV
DY 110/15kV
25MVA
2
0
-2
-4
1200kVar
-6
Load
900kVar
0.09s
-8
0
b)
3
•
One-phase diagram of simulated
distribution system
0.16
0.2
5
x 10
2.5
2
1.5
1
x 10 4
Zoom
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
200
300
400
500
frequency (Hz)
600
0.5
0
0
•
0.08
0.12
time (s)
4
energy density spectrum (J)
T – transformer HV/MV, Δ-Y connected,25 MVA,
110kV/15kV
First capacitor: 900kVar, 0.2km from the station,
switching on at 0.03s
Second capacitor: 1200kVar, 1.2km from the station,
switching on at 0.09s
0.04
energy density spectrum (J)
0.03s
100
200
300
400
500
frequency (Hz)
600
700
Fragment of current waveform at
MV busbar (a) and its spectrum (b)
Time-frequency analysis of investigated
phenomena – switching on the capacitor banks
•
Short-Time Fourier Transform vs S-Transform
700
|Short-Time Fourier Transform|- Spectrogram
h   - Hamming, width - 0.04s
b)a)
5
x 10
700
5
Dynamism of tracking
the energy changes |S-transform|
475Hz component
t=0.03s
600
475Hz
|energy| (J)
frequency (Hz)
frequency (Hz)
475Hz
4
500
3.5
500
400
270Hz
3
400
270Hz
Short-Time Fourier
Transform with Hamming
window, width 0.04s
2.5
300
2
300
200
200
1.5
50Hz
100
0
0
S-Transform
switching on
4.5
600 900kVar
0.05
0.10
time (s)
0.15
1
100
0.5
0.20
Fig. 1. Time-varying spectrum of switching on
the capacitor banks phenomena obtained
using STFT.
0
0 0
0
50Hz
0.02
0.05
0.10
0.04 time (s)
0.06
time (s)
0.15
0.08
0.20
0.1
Fig. 2b.
Comparison ofspectrum
STFT with
S-Transform
for
2a. Time-varying
of switching
on the
tracking
capability.
capacitor banks phenomena obtained using STransform.
Time-frequency analysis of investigated
phenomena – switching on the capacitor banks
•
Short-Time Fourier Transform vs Cohen’s class of transformation
700
|Short-Time Fourier Transform|- Spectrogram
h   - Hamming, width - 0.04s
|Zhao-Atlas-Marks Distribution| - Cone-Shaped kernel
c)
a)
b)
|Choi-Williams
- Gaussian
kernel
function,   0.05
|Wigner-Ville
Distribution|
functionDistribution|
based on Hamming,
width
- 0.04s
700
700
700
(a-t): auto-terms
auto-terms
auto-terms
(a-t):
(c-t): cross-terms
cross-terms
cross-terms
(c-t):
600
600
600
600
475Hz(a-t)
475Hz(a-t)
475Hz(a-t)
475Hz
500
500
500
400
270Hz
300
300
300
300
200
200
200
50Hz
100
0
0
400
400
400
0.05
0.10
time (s)
0.15
100
100
100
0.20
Fig. 3. Time-varying spectrum of switching on
the capacitor banks phenomena obtained
using STFT.
000
000
suppression effect
of the (c-t)
regarding to kernel
function
frequency
frequency (Hz)
(Hz)
frequency (Hz)
500
372.5Hz(c-t)
270Hz(a-t)
270Hz(a-t)
270Hz(a-t)
262.5Hz(c-t)
50Hz(a-t)
50Hz(a-t)
50Hz(a-t)
160Hz(c-t)
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.10
0.10
0.10
time (s)
(s)
time
(s)
time
0.15
0.15
0.15
0.20
0.20
0.20
Fig.
Fig.
4a.
4b.Time-varying
Time-varying
Time-varying
spectrum
spectrum
switching
switching
on
the
the
Fig.
4c.
spectrum
ofofof
switching
ofon
the
capacitor
capacitor
banks
banks
phenomena
phenomena
obtained
obtained
using
using
capacitor
banks
phenomena
obtained
using
Wigner-Ville
transformation
Distribution.
with
Gaussian
kernel.
transformation with cone-shaped kernel.
Time-frequency analysis of investigated
phenomena – switching on the capacitor banks
•
Short-Time Fourier Transform vs Cohen’s class of transformation
5
a)
x 10
4
3.5
Dynamism of tracking the energy changes 475Hz component
t=0.03s
switching on
900kVar
3.5
Short-Time Fourier Transform with
Hamming window, width 0.04s
2.5
x 10
3
Zhao-Atlas-Marks Distribution with
cone-shaped kernel function based
on Hamming window, width 0.04s
3
5
Dynamism of tracking the energy changes 50Hz component
t=0.03s
switching on
900kVar
t=0.09s
switching on
1200kVar
2.5
Choi-Williams Distribution with
Gaussian kernel function,  0.05
|energy| (J)
|energy| (J)
b)
2
2
1.5
Choi-Williams Distribution with
Gaussian kernel function,   0.05
1
1
Short-Time Fourier Transform with
Hamming window, width 0.04s
0.5
0.5
1.5
0
0
0.02
0.04
time (s)
0.06
0.08
0.1
0
0
Zhao-Atlas-Marks Distribution with
cone-shaped kernel function based
on Hamming window, width 0.04s
0.05
0.1
time (s)
0.15
0.2
Fig. 5. Comparison of STFT with Cohen’s class on account of tracking ability, when transient 475Hz
component (a) and basic 50Hz component (b) are detected.
General comment: Selection of appropriate kernel function allows to
achieve sharp detection of the beginning of transient states.
Time-frequency analysis of investigated
phenomena – switching on the capacitor banks
•
7
x 10
5
Influence of the window width on dynamism of ShortTime Fourier Transform
x 10
5
t=0.09s
switching on
1200kVar
6
4.5
270Hz
3
Short-Time Fourier
Transform with Hamming
window, width 0.1s
2
Influence of the window width on dynamism of
Smoothed Choi-Williams Distribution
t=0.09s
switching on
1200kVar
Smoothed Pseudo-Choi-Williams
Distribution with Gaussian kernel
function,  0.05
h   - Hamming, width 0.04s
g  t  - Hamming, width 0.04s
3.5
Short-Time Fourier
Transform with Hamming
window, width 0.04s
4
5
270Hz
4
5
|energy| (J)
b)
|energy| (J)
a)
Short-Time Fourier Transform vs Smoothed version of Cohen’s class of
transformation
Smoothed Pseudo-Choi-Williams
Distribution with Gaussian kernel
function,  0.05
h   - Hamming, width 0.1s
g  t  - Hamming, width 0.04s
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
1
0
0.5
0
0.05
0.1
time (s)
0.15
0.2
0
0
0.05
0.1
time (s)
0.15
0.2
Fig. 6. Comparison of STFT (a) with smoothed version of Cohen’s class of transformation (b), on account
of tracking tracking ability, when different width of smoothing window are applied.
General comment: Applying additional smoothing windows in Cohen’s equation
allows to control time and frequency resolution separately. In STFT the
relationship between window width and time-frequency resolution is
inseparable
Conclusions
•
Time-frequency representations can be treated as a comprehensive
tool for analysis of transient states. Simultaneous representation of
two dimensions delivers much more information about character of
investigated phenomena than known tools.
• Proposed S-Transform and transformation from Cohen’s family have
adaptability to investigated phenomena:
 in case of S-Transform, moving and scalable Gaussian window
uniquely combines frequency dependent resolution with desirable
information about time-varying spectrum,
 referring to Cohen’s generalization, selection of appropriate kernel
function enables adaptation of the representation method to
investigated non-stationarity.
 Undesirable cross-term components, characteristic for bilinear
nature of Cohen’s family, can be successfully reduced through the
selection of appropriate kernel function as well as application of
additional smoothing functions.
Conclusions
•
In comparison with classical spectrogram, proposed methods break of
the inherent relation between time-frequency resolution and width
of the window.
 Smoothed version of Cohen’s transformation allows to control the
time and frequency resolution independently.
 In case of S-Transform, achieved time-frequency resolution comes
from combination of scalable localizing Gaussian function and width
of spectrum.
•
Allows detection of the begging of distortion with better precision
than classical spectrogram.