Transcript The Framework for Teaching

Assessing Effective
Teacher Practices
Charlotte Danielson
[email protected]
www.danielsongroup.org
The Complexity of Teaching
“After 30 years of doing such work, I have concluded
that classroom teaching … is perhaps the most
complex, most challenging, and most demanding,
subtle, nuanced, and frightening activity that our
species has ever invented. ..The only time a
physician could possibly encounter a situation of
comparable complexity would be in the emergency
room of a hospital during or after a natural disaster”
Lee Shulman, The Wisdom of Practice
Why Assess Teacher Effectiveness?
 Quality Assurance
 Professional Learning
The Framework for Teaching Charlotte Danielson
Lake Wobegon
A Question of Fairness
Performance Evaluation in Los Angeles Unified 2008
Teacher Hiring, Transfer and Evaluation in Los Angeles Unified School
District, The New Teacher Project, November 2009
Teacher Evaluation System Design
High Rigor
Low ←---------------------------------------
Level of Stakes -------------------→High
Low Rigor
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Teacher Evaluation System Design
High Rigor
Structured Mentoring Programs,
e.g. New Teacher Center
Low ←---------------------------------------
National Board Certification
Praxis III
Level of Stakes -------------------→High
Informal Mentoring Programs
Traditional Evaluation Systems
DANGER!!
Assessing
Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Low
Rigor
Danielson
Teacher Evaluation System
How
What
 Evaluative Criteria
 Procedures
 Levels of Performance
 Instruments
 Weighting
 Personnel
 Score Combining
 Timelines
 Standard Setting
 Due Process
Process for Deciding
Training for Evaluators
Professional Development for Teachers
Making the Most of Teacher Evaluation, Charlotte
Danielson
8
Defining Effective Teaching
Two basic approaches:
 Teacher practices, that is, what teachers do,
how well they do the work of teaching
 Results, that is, what teachers accomplish,
typically how well their students learn
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Defining What Teachers Do
Two basic approaches:
 As judged by internal assessors, within the
school or district, based on specific criteria
 As judged by external assessors, for example
National Board Certification
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
The Wisdom of Practice
If you were to walk into a classroom, what might you
see or hear there (from the students as well as the
teacher) that would cause you to think that you were
in the presence of an expert?
What would make you think: “Oh, this is good; if I had
a child this age, this is the class I would hope for.”
The Framework for Teaching Charlotte Danielson
Defining What Teachers Do
The Four Domains
Domain 1: Planning and Preparation
Domain 2: The Classroom Environment
Domain 3: Instruction
Domain 4: Professional Responsibilities
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
The Framework for Teaching
Second Edition
Domain 1: Planning and Preparation
•Demonstrating Knowledge of Content
and Pedagogy
•Demonstrating Knowledge of Students
•Setting Instructional Outcomes
•Demonstrating Knowledge of Resources
•Designing Coherent Instruction
•Designing Student Assessments
Domain 2: The Classroom
Environment
•Creating an Environment of Respect
and Rapport
•Establishing a Culture for Learning
•Managing Classroom Procedures
•Managing Student Behavior
•Organizing Physical Space
Domain 3: Instruction
•Communicating With Students
•Using Questioning and Discussion
Techniques
•Engaging Students in Learning
•Using Assessment in Instruction
•Demonstrating Flexibility and
Responsiveness
Domain 4: Professional
Responsibilities
•Reflecting on Teaching
•Maintaining Accurate Records
•Communicating with Families
•Participating in a Professional Community
•Growing and Developing Professionally
•Showing Professionalism
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Common Themes
 Equity
 Cultural sensitivity
 High expectations
 Developmental appropriateness
 Accommodating individual needs
 Appropriate use of technology
 Student Assumption of responsibility
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Domain 2:The Classroom Environment
2a: Creating an Environment of Respect and Rapport
Figure 4.2b
DOMAIN 2: THE CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENT
COMPONENT 2A: CREATING AN ENVIRONMENT OF RESPECT AND RAPPORT
Elements:
Teacher interaction with students Student interaction with one another
L
E V E L
O F
P
ELEMENT
UNSATISFACTORY
BASIC
Teacher
Interaction
with Students
Teacher interaction with at least
some students is negative,
demeaning, sarcastic, or
inappropriate to the age or culture
of the students. Students exhibit
disrespect for the teacher.
Student
Interactions
with one
another
Student interactions are
characterized by conflict,
sarcasm, or put-downs.
Teacher-student interactions are
generally appropriate but may
reflect occasional inconsistencies,
favoritism, or disregard for
students’ cultures. Students exhibit
only minimal respect for the
teacher.
Students do not demonstrate
disrespect for one another.
E R F O R M A N C E
PROFICIENT
Teacher-student interactions are
friendly and demonstrate general
caring and respect. Such
interactions are appropriate to the
age and cultures of the students.
Students exhibit respect for the
teacher.
Student interactions are generally
polite and respectful.
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
DISTINGUISHED
Teacher’s interactions with
students reflect genuine respect
and caring, for individuals as well
as groups of students. Students
appear to trust the teacher with
sensitive information.
Students demonstrate genuine
caring for one another and monitor
one another’s treatment of peers,
correcting classmates respectfully
when needed.
Features of
The Framework for Teaching
 Comprehensive
 Grounded in research
 Public
 Generic
 Coherent in structure
 Independent of any particular teaching
methodology
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
The Nature of Professional Learning
 Trust
 Self-assessment
 Reflection on practice
 Professional conversation
 A community of learners
The Framework for Teaching Charlotte Danielson
Questioning and
Discussion
What is the evidence?
Respect
and
Rapport
Evidence
•Accurate and unbiased
•Relevant
•Representative of the total
Interpretation
Judgment
The Framework for Teaching Charlotte Danielson
The Classroom Environment
Figure 6.7
DOMAIN 2: THE CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENT
COMPONENT 2A: CREATING AN ENVIRONMENT OF RESPECT AND RAPPORT
Elements:
Teacher interaction with students Student interaction
L
E V E L
O F
P
E R F O R M A N C E
ELEMENT
UNSATISFACTORY
BASIC
PROFICIENT
DISTINGUISHED
Teacher
Interaction
with Students
Teacher interaction with at least
some students is negative,
demeaning, sarcastic, or
inappropriate to the age or
culture of the students. Students
exhibit disrespect for teacher.
Teacher-student interactions are
generally appropriate but may
reflect occasional inconsistencies,
favoritism, or disregard for
students’ cultures. Students
exhibit only minimal respect for
teacher.
Teacher-student interactions are
friendly and demonstrate general
warmth, caring, and respect.
Such interactions are appropriate
to developmental and cultural
norms. Students exhibit respect
for teacher.
Teacher demonstrates genuine
caring and respect for individual
students. Students exhibit respect
for teacher as an individual,
beyond that for the role.
Student
Interaction
Student interactions are
characterized by conflict,
sarcasm, or put-downs.
Students do not demonstrate
negative behavior toward one
another.
Student interactions are generally
polite and respectful.
Students demonstrate genuine
caring for one another as
individuals and as students.
The Framework for Teaching Charlotte Danielson
Generating a Summative Evaluation of
Teacher Practices
A several-step process:
 Assess performance using the levels of
performance for each observation or set of
artifacts
 Combine assessments from different “data points”
into a single assessment for each component of
the framework for teaching
 Apply the “decision rules” to arrive at an
assessment of practice for each domain
 Apply “decision rules” to translate the domain
ratings into an overall rating
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Sample “Decision Rules” for Translating
Component Ratings into Domain Ratings
Domain Ratings
 Distinguished - Distinguished ratings in at least half of
the components of the domain, with the remaining
components rated no lower than Proficient.
 Proficient – No more than one component rated
Basic, with the remaining components rated at
Proficient or higher.
 Basic – More than one component rated Basic, with
the remaining components rated as Proficient or
higher.
 Unsatisfactory - Any component rated as
Unsatisfactory.
:
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Sample “Decision Rules” for Translating
Domain Ratings into an Overall Judgment
Overall Ratings
 Distinguished - Distinguished rating in at least two or
more of the domains, with the remaining domains
rated as Proficient.
 Proficient – No more than one domain rated Needs
Improvement, with the remaining domains rated at
Proficient or higher.
 Basic – More than one domain rated Basic, with the
remaining domains rated as Proficient or higher.
 Unsatisfactory - Any domain rated Unsatisfactory.
:
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Sample “Decision Rules” for Evaluating
Non-Tenured Teachers
Non-tenured teachers in years 1 and 2 may
receive a final summative rating of Basic as
they are emerging towards proficiency.
After receiving mentoring and coaching
supports during years 1 and 2, non-tenured
teachers in year 3 are expected to maintain a
final summative rating of proficient or higher.
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Sample “Decision Rules” for Evaluating
Tenured Teachers
Tenured Teachers are expected to maintain an overall
Summative Rating of Proficient or higher. If a Tenured
Teacher receives an overall Summative Rating of
Basic, a Professional Development Plan (PDP) will be
developed.
If a Tenured Teacher exhibits evidence of
Unsatisfactory practice, an overall Summative
Evaluation may be conducted during the contractual
school year. An overall Summative Rating of
Unsatisfactory will result in the development of a
Remediation Plan in accordance with the law.
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Uses of
The Framework for Teaching
 Teacher preparation
 Supervising student teachers
 Teacher recruitment and hiring
 Mentoring beginning teachers
 Structuring professional development
 Evaluating teacher performance
The Framework for Teaching Charlotte Danielson
Benefits of
Any Framework for Teaching
 Common language
 Development of shared understandings
 Self-assessment and reflection on practice
 Structured professional conversation
The Framework for Teaching Charlotte Danielson
General Evaluation Procedures
 Observations of practice
 Conferences
 Samples of student work, with analysis
 Teacher artifacts
Making the Most of Teacher Evaluation, Charlotte
Danielson
27
Challenges in Implementing Robust
Teacher Evaluation Systems
 Clearly defining good teaching
 Building understanding and consensus on the
description of good teaching
 Developing instruments and procedures to
capture evidence of practice
 Training (and certifying?) evaluators
 Structuring schedules to permit time for
professional conversation
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Summary
 Both teacher practices and results of teaching
are important indicators of teacher
effectiveness
 Both approaches pose formidable technical
and psychometric challenges
 Both must be highly evolved before they are
used for high-stakes personnel decisions
 When done well, both can yield significant
benefits in enhancing capacity
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson
Training Resources
 The Danielson Group




www.danielsongroup.org
Teachscape
http://www.teachscape.com/html/ts/nps/index.html
Educational Impact
http://www.educationalimpact.com/index.shtml
ASCD/LSI
http://ascd.org/professional-development/teachereffectiveness-suite.aspx
Knowledge Delivery Systems
http://www.kdsi.org/CL-Framework-for-Teaching.aspx
Assessing Teacher Effectiveness, Charlotte
Danielson