Transcript Document

SECTION C—International Issues
STUDY THEME 3B: THE PEOPLE’S
REPUBLIC OF CHINA
4_Economic Issues, improvements
and impact
How much time do you think has elapsed between these two pics?
Learning Intentions:
• Understand and explain what economic
changes has occurred in China
• And explain and give examples of the impact
of this change
From SQA Course Descriptor
• Progress towards a market economy: the decline of state ownership; the
growth of private companies; foreign investment; agricultural reform; the
impact on the environment; changing role in the world economy.
• Social and economic issues: the nature and extent of social and economic
inequalities and their consequences, government responses, the
effectiveness of these responses in relation to:
♦ urban/rural differences
♦ employment and unemployment
♦ housing and urban overcrowding
♦ health
♦ crime and the law education
♦ Human rights: women, population control, law and order.
Minorities.
Economic Situation
Themes: the nature and extent of economic inequalities and change and the
effectiveness of government responses and the consequences affecting people in
China. You will also be expected to link social and economic progress/lack of progress
and the impact of change.
China has one of the fastest growing economies in the world. China has overtaken the
USA as the largest economy in the world. Due to the ‘open door’ policy now adopted
by China it has an increasingly westernised lifestyle. Rising incomes have created a
bigger demand for western fashion, cars and fast food, as well as movies and sport on
satellite TV. In 2010 China had over 900 branches of McDonald’s and 2000 KFC.
Between 2004-2010 the number of internet users went from 94 million to over 420
million! New car registrations have trebled and 80% of people in urban areas own
their own homes.
However, not all parts of China have benefited from these changes. There is inequality
between rural and urban areas and a widening gap between the rich and the poor.
What evidence of change in the economic situation can you identify?
iron rice bowl
The iron rice bowl is an expression which refers to an employment programme
started by the Chinese Communist Government in the 1950s.The programme
guaranteed job security for life for employees of state-run businesses and also
provided food, education, healthcare and housing. This guarantee had obvious
benefits but it also created problems, with guaranteed job security it didn’t matter
if you were good at your job or like what you did. So the economy became weak,
and China was falling behind other world powers.
Market Economy
China was a traditionally a closed economy – the government owned and controlled
all businesses and industries. However, since the 1970s, China has changed the way
it runs its economy and now has an open door policy with the rest of the world.
The traditional state owned economy was failing to meet the needs of the growing
population in China, with a large number of people living in poverty. In 1981 it was
estimated that over half the population was living in poverty.
The economy was put through a number of progressive reforms. In 1978-9 China
witnessed the end of the iron rice bowl when Deng Xiaoping introduced the
Household Responsibility System. This reform allowed farmers to grow and sell
surplus food on the open market and removed restrictions on what they were
allowed to produce. Rules for the production industry were also relaxed allowing
factories to produce goods to supply market demand, rather than to meet
government quotas.
Many State Owned Enterprises (SOEs) were inefficient and failed to produce profits.
Under the iron rice bowl, millions of Chinese citizens relied on SOEs for employment
and social support, such as housing and healthcare. However, as a result of their
inefficiency, many state owned enterprises closed down after the introduction of
the economic reforms causing high levels of unemployment and poverty.
Explain in your own words what was the Household Responsibility system
and what was the significance of SOEs?
Special Economic Zones
In 1992 Deng Xiaoping introduced Special Economic Zones (SEZs) to open up China
to the world and encourage foreign businesses to invest in China. SEZs were set up
around coastal areas of China to make it easier to export goods produced there.
Businesses setting up inside SEZs enjoyed tax incentives and cheap labour,
encouraging the economy to boom. The main business sectors that invested in
SEZs were: banking, technology industries, electronic manufacturing and textiles.
The first SEZ was Shenzhen which has grown from a small fishing village in south
China’s Guangdong province into a booming metropolis, home to a number of
high-tech firms and manufacturing industries.
Comparison of Gansu and Guangdong
Population
26 million; 73% rural
93 million, 34% migrants
Life Expectancy
67 years
73 years
Literacy
75%
91%
Industries
Mining,
electricity Electrical
goods,
generation,
garments, toys, shoes,
petrochemicals, tobacco. construction.
Agriculture
42% of land area is
mountain and desert;
main
crops:
grain,
vegetables,
melons,
medicinal herbs.
10%
of
land
area
intensively
cultivated:
main crops; rice, livestock,
tea, tropical fruits.
GDP
£15.8bn
£180.4 bn
Foreign investment
£9.8m
£6 bn – Special Economic
Zone
Spot the difference between Gansu and Guangdong.
Gansu is a long, thin strip of land that connects the upper reaches of the Yellow River with
the deserts of Xinjiang. Much of the industry in Gansu is mining and processing of
minerals and metals. Gansu is the center of China's nuclear industry.
The province of Guangdong - economically the fastest growing region in China, has
an external trade volume of one trillion dollars in 2013 with a gross domestic
product totalling to over one trillion dollars. The province has a population of 106
million inhabitants.
2001 World Trade Organisation
This resulted in foreign trade doubling in China and allowed Chinese
companies to invest abroad and many more foreign companies to invest in
China. These companies range from banking and the finance industry to
manufacturing and service industries. China has been nicknamed the
‘workshop of the world.’ It manufactures two-thirds of the world’s
microwave ovens, DVD players, shoes and toys. Many huge multinational
companies have set up in China. Starbucks, for example, now has over 400
coffee bars in China and IKEA has Chinese stores. Walmart, the biggest
corporation in the world, is the largest importer of Chinese products to the
United States.
The Communist Party of China outlined development objectives for the
country for the next eight years at the recently concluded 18th National
Congress of the Communist Party of China. It vowed to double China's 2010
gross domestic product and per capita income for both of urban and rural
residents by 2020. China has to maintain an average annual growth rate of
at least 7.5 per cent in the coming years in order to achieve the goal set by
the government, Yuan said.
Video: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/8320665.stm
Video: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/davos/7856636.stm
Special Economic Zones & Slave Labour
Li Chun Mei a 19-year-old had collapsed and died last November at the end of a 16hour shift. Like many of the staff, she often had to work past midnight, especially in
the run-up to Christmas. One out of every three pairs of shoes in the world is made
here. But this global workshop runs on cheap labour and low safety standards.
Under Chinese law, employees cannot be forced to work more than eight hours a
day and overtime must not exceed 40 hours a month.
There's a local minimum monthly wage too of $66. But every single worker we
spoke to from many different factories around Shenzhen had at some point either
been overworked or underpaid. Like Li Chun Mei, Zhou Shien Pin came from a
remote corner of the Sichuan province. He got a job in a paint factory and was
hoping to save enough to build his family a house. But then he touched a highvoltage wire. The accident has scarred his face and chest and his toes have melted
away like wax, leaving just his ankles and heels. The boss paid £2,500 ($4,000)
compensation, but that money was quickly used up in medical fees. He's fighting
for more compensation but has little chance.
Workers are dispensable in a place where there are four or five applicants for
every job. China has 16 out of 20 most polluted cities. 300,000 a year die from
respiratory diseases. 70% of China's energy needs are supplied by Coal fired
power stations. Prime Minister said, "If I worked in Beijing I would shorten my life
by at least 5 years." SEZs were established to encourage foreign investment,
bringing jobs, technical knowledge and future tax revenues.
In your own words, describe what happened to Li Chun Mei?
Special Economic Zones were established in the following areas:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Shenzhen
Zhuhai
Shantou
Xiamen
Province of Hainan
Plus 14 Costal cities – including Shanghai
Shenzhen
is located in the south of Guangdong Province with Hong Kong to its south. It
is a coastal city with beautiful scenery. In 1970 Shenzhen was established as a
city, and in 1980 was designated as a Special Economic Zone (SEZ). Its total
coastal line is 230 km. Over the past dozen years, Shenzhen has developed
economically and socially, turning itself from a frontier town into a modern
city. It was a former fishing village which in little more than 30 years has
grown into a sprawling metropolis.
Shenzhen
This is where China's economic revolution started and where we may see its next stage as
companies try to compete at the highest level with innovation, as well as low-cost
manufacturing. Within Shenzhen is the Taiwanese-owned Foxconn plant, one of the world's
biggest factories and the place where Apple's iPhone is made. Foxconn has been at the
centre of concerns about working conditions in Chinese plants, although as manufacturing
wages in Shenzhen soar, the company is moving many jobs to inland China.
On the back of the iPhone, it says: "Designed by Apple in California. Assembled in China." The
people who assemble most of these iPhones and other bestselling Apple products like the
iPad work for Foxconn, a manufacturer owned by the Taiwanese group Hon Hai Precision. For
years, Foxconn has remained low-key despite employing 800,000 workers worldwide.
Foxconn counts itself as one of a number of "hidden dragons" - huge but often obscure
companies that manufacture goods, largely in China, for the world's biggest brands in
electronics, clothing, toys and home appliances. But scandals over working conditions and
the growing visibility of the products it makes have thrust it into the spotlight.
Foxconn is famous for its industrial revolution approach to manufacturing; the workers eat,
sleep and live in huge dormitories adjacent to the factories where they work round-the-clock
shifts. The company even provides doctors. The plant in Shenzhen, which includes bakeries,
banks and acupuncture clinics, for example, employs over 400,000 people. Workers live in a
dorm with seven strangers, performing the same task six days a week.
Create a spider diagram detailing information about Foxconn.
Suicide deaths
But the gulf between the beauty of the products Foxconn makes and the conditions it takes to
make them were exposed quite brutally when a spate of deaths hit the firm. Protestors have
been vocal about Foxconn working conditions. Thirteen Chinese employees committed
suicide at Foxconn or related plants in 2010, shining a spotlight on working conditions in China
and drawing attention to growing labour strikes. And in May 2011, two people were killed
after an explosion at a Foxconn plant in Chengdu.
Foxconn said its working conditions were not responsible for the death, and was initially
dismissive of the suicides. But it soon responded to the worldwide media attention by raising
wages, shortened working hours and installed counsellors on site. It also installed suicide nets
to factory living-quarters at its Shenzhen factory. And Apple sent independent inspectors
from the US Fair Labor Association to audit their facilities, who found "significant issues"
among working practices there.
Apple said it "fully accepted" the report's conclusions. Despite being a lightning rod for
criticism, Foxconn is regarded as one of China's better employers by many Chinese labour
rights groups, paying workers on time and for all the overtime. The starting salary at its
Shenzhen plant - which employs the bulk of its workers - is 1,800 yuan, compared with a
minimum wage of 1,500 yuan in the city
Workers have a limited ability to stand up for their rights; the All China Federation of Trade
Unions (ACFTU) is only legally recognised trade union in China.
Explain why Foxconn was a PR disaster for a US based company.
Impact
By now there has been two decades of growth. The Shenzhen SEZ recorded 16% of
the whole of China’s total imports and exports, but unfortunately, not all SEZ’s have
been so successful. Hainan SEZs success has lagged behind other areas. It has had
to re-think policies to suit the fact that it is traditionally an agricultural area; the
aim is now to transform it into a tourist resort. Encouragement has been given to
private companies to set up, particularly in rural areas where unemployment is
high.
Private Enterprise
Encouraging Private Enterprise has created the “New Rich”; only 1/3
of the economy is now state controlled. For decades being rich in
China was a crime punishable by imprisonment or death. Managers
in enterprises are being allowed greater freedom to take decisions
on economic grounds and not just follow government directives.
Now, being wealthy is a cause for celebration, prompting thousands
of Chinese millionaires to come out of the closet.
Two years ago a Chinese individual bought a Chinese vase for $43m
at a London Auction. These wealthy entrepreneurs make up 10% of
the population and own 45% of the wealth. Private Enterprise is
encouraged to such an extent, that it is now enshrined in the
constitution. The Gini Co-efficient, measurement indicates that
China is more unequal than the USA. The Gini coefficient - a
commonly used measure of inequality of wealth - has reached 0.47
in China, overtaking the recognized warning level of 0.4, and it is
0.45 in the USA.
Summarise the impact of allowing
private enterprise.
INEQUALITY
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3F5Qvls798w
China's rapid economic progress has transformed its cities and coastal areas. But life
for many millions of Chinese in the country's, rural areas is in some ways the same
as it always was. Two of China's poorest inland provinces are, Ningxia and Guizhou.
Wang Ran says, "The agricultural tax is high. Government officials say they are going
to reduce the rural taxes, but they haven't and we don't know when they will. If
they did reduce our taxes, that would really change our lives. We are so poor
because there is no development here. The government does give aid but for some
reason there is hardly any allocated to this area. I have no way to buy fertilizer. We
need economic help."
Yao Min says, "Both our children have left the village to work in the cities. The
central government leaders just care about themselves - not about the masses, not
about the people. The local officials only pay attention to the one child policy, so
that they can collect fines from those who have more than one child. If families
don't have enough money to pay, they take things from their houses. If we become
sick this will be a disaster for the family."
Describe some of the issues that citizen’s in rural China face.
Agricultural Modernisation
A clash over the forced seizure of farmland on 2010 that resulted in the
death of one farmer brought renewed attention to the problem of illegal
land requisition in rural China. The Pizhou's impressive economic
performance is based on the practice of seizing land from local farmers for
minimal compensation and then selling it off to speculators who expect
land prices to continue to rise. As the city's land area increased, its
government moved into fancy offices ten times larger than what had been
approved.
In the early days of the CPC, farming was organised under the commune
system, where Chinese farmers worked land given to them by the state,
under the control of the state. This proved very inefficient and the
household Responsibility System was introduced. This meant farmers
were likely to get more money the more they grew. This was like the
development of a market economy in agriculture. There are over 300
million Chinese farmers, just over half the workforce and they have
succeeded in making China self-sufficient in food production. However,
there are only a few successful farmers and may have been forced by
poverty to leave their land to look for work in the more prosperous urban
areas.
What is Pizhou’s economic success atributed to?
Rural Poverty
Capitalism has created many winners, but there are many
losers. Poor people, those who make less than $1 a day make
up 10% of the population. According to World Bank figures
there are 130m poor people in China. Average agricultural
income has grown, but 90% rural tax burdens jumped by
800%. Farmers can make more money selling their blood
than from growing crops.
Because of this inequality between Urban and Rural areas
150-200 million rural workers who have moved to China’s
cities in search of work. Their average monthly wage is $50.
Half the rural population have no money for a doctor even if
they could find one. There are significant opportunities for
migrant workers in SEZs.
Economic Inequalities
The past 10 years have seen the emergence of China as a major global economic
power, but the gap between rich and poor is one of the largest in the world.
·Unemployment benefit is low at about £25 a month. The urban population is
expected to jump by 65% or 500 million people by 2025. The rapid economic
progress has transformed cities and coastal areas. But for those in China's
underdeveloped rural interior life remains difficult, there is an increasing gap in
wages and living standards.
The government is trying to reduce the gap between Urban and rural areas. It has
connected more areas to electricity. Farmers are encouraged to work in cities,
increasing farmer incomes and improving living conditions. There are plans to
remove the hukou, to try and reduce discrimination against rural people.
Unemployed migrant workers
gather near job ads at a labour
market in Qingdao city, eastern
China.
Hukou
Video: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/video/2010/mar/15/china-migrantworkers?INTCMP=SRCH
The Hukou is a residency permit that was introduced by the Government to identify a person as officially a
resident of a particular area. People needed this registration to get jobs, benefits, schooling and medical
care. With large numbers of farmers unable to make a living in the countryside and moving to other areas to
look for work, the system has largely broken down.
China has experienced the largest migration within a country in history; the people moving around the
country for work are known as the ‘floating population’ of migrant workers. There are an estimated 150
million Chinese living outside their officially designated area. Reforming the residency system has become a
very controversial area for the Government. On the one hand, the economic reforms have encouraged
migration from the interior to the coastal cities, and officials have turned a blind eye to Hukou
transgressions, though some are still subject to poor treatment. Migrant workers provide cheap labour for
both multinational companies and state-owned enterprises in China. Migrant workers, desperate for
employment, often work very long hours in factories for very little pay. Many factories will provide basic
food and accommodation for their workers. As a result of the low pay these migrant workers receive,
factories and businesses can make huge profits on their products.
On the other hand, there is a fear that this massive influx of people to the coast will put too big a strain on
government services and cause more damage to the rural economy. In 2005, the Government announced
plans to scrap the Hukou in 11 of the 23 provinces, though they might still not be implemented once city
governments realise the strain that a fresh influx of migrants might put on local resources. Guangdong
province cancelled the system in 2010 and replaced it with a residence permit system. This means that
migrant workers in Guangdong cannot enjoy more benefits, such as free vaccinations for children and some
social security benefits. However, such changes are not uniform across China. In Beijing, the Hukou
restrictions are still strict. Migrant workers in Beijing face charges for health care and secondary education
and have not access to social security.
Investigation:
1.
2.
3.
What is a hukou?
What impact does it have on people (in terms of health, education,
wealth, family circumstances)? Include an example of impact on an
individual if you can.
What is the government response to this?
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/31/chi
na-reform-hukou-migrant-workers
The hukou system, introduced in the 1950s, ties people's access to services to their
residential status. When controls on movement were relaxed, tens of millions of migrant
workers left the fields to work in factories, toil on building sites, serve in restaurants or
clean homes, contributing to China's spectacular economic growth. But while they have
built new cities and boosted their incomes, they have not enjoyed the same benefits in
healthcare, pensions and other social welfare as city residents. Their children often
struggle to access education; tens of millions have been left in the countryside to be
raised by grandparents.
China is to overhaul the system that migrant workers say has made them second-class
citizens, easing the settlement of 100 million people in cities over the next six years. The
plan from the state council will remove the distinction between urban and rural
residents, a decision welcomed for its symbolic value at least. It should help migrant
workers to access services and social welfare.
BUT the reforms include exemptions for major cities, and analysts say key measures are
not enforceable by the centre. Even if 100 million gain new rights, there are more than
that already living in cities without official status. "Hukou is basically apartheid –
apartheid against domestic servants," said Lynette Ong, associate professor of political
science at the University of Toronto. "One [question] is whether this makes a difference
at the material level, in terms of entitlements and access to education. The second is
[how it affects] some of the 'softer' discrimination against people with a rural hukou, with
people in cities looking down on them.“
China wants 60% of its almost 1.4 billion population to be urbanised by 2020, hoping that
their increased consumption as city dwellers will boost the economy.
Link to next lesson - Social Unrest
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-14122256
A Chinese court has jailed six people for their involvement in riots last month in a southern
industrial area. The court in Guangdong province handed out prison sentences ranging from
nine months to three-and-a-half years. Thousands of migrant workers rioted for several days
in a garment manufacturing zone near the city of Guangzhou. They threw stones at police,
burned cars and ransacked government buildings after a confrontation between street
vendors and security officials.
A pregnant street trader was reportedly shoved to the ground by security guards after being
told to move her stall. But the workers - many of whom were from Sichuan province - then
turned against the government, with long-held grievances about corruption and abuse of
power coming to the surface. Migrant workers are often paid meagre wages, and China's
tight control of internal migration means they are not given the same rights as full residents of
the cities where they work.
Workers in China are increasingly aware of and demanding their rights, according to a new
report by the China Labour Bulletin. There were 1,171 strikes and protests in China recorded
by the Hong Kong-based labour advocacy group from June 2011 until the end of last year. Of
those, 40 percent occurred among factory workers, as China’s exports suffered a slowdown
and its overall economy cooled. “Many manufacturers in China sought to offset their reduced
profits by cheating workers out of overtime and cutting back on bonuses and benefits, etc.