Transcript Slide 1

Media Assignment due date changes
#3—Due 4/6
#4—Due 4/18
#5—Still Due 4/27
Assignment due Thursday, 3/16
From Part 4, answer questions 1, 5, and 6 from pages 315-316. Your
responses should span a total of at least two full pages. Notice #6 requires more
information than either #1 or #5.
Part 5—Poverty, Inequality, and Structural Violence
“20% of the population in the developed nations consume 86% of the world’s goods.
--1998 Human Development Report, UN Development Programme
“A mere 12% of the world’s population uses 85% of its water, and these 12% do not live
in the Third World.”
--Maude Barlow, National Chairperson, Council of Canadians
As of 2000, nearly half the world’s population lived on less than $2 per day.
As of 1997, the wealthiest 20% of the world’s countries had 74 times as much wealth as
the poorest 20% (318).
5.1—“Inequality in the Global Village,” Jan Knippers Black
Are the recent findings of economic progress telling the whole story?
During the 1980s, “70 percent of the world’s ninety-five least developed
countries suffered overall economic decline in the 1980s” (324), thirty six of
the poorest being forced to slash education and health budgets by 25 and
50 percent, respectively.
While the World Bank showed a decline between 1987 and 1993 from 34%
to 32% of people in developing countries living in poverty, estimates
actually show an increase in the number of poverty stricken people by
100,000 million—from 1.2 billion to 1.3 billion total.
Also, “Advances in some areas have come at the expense of decline in
others” (325).
While the 1990s have been hailed as largely representing an economic
boom, the boom in the US commonly came at the expense of the workers,
who made less in real wages in 1997 than they had in 1989.
--But on an aggregate measure, things looked good…
“Between 1990 and 1993, Zambia spent thirty-five times as much on debt
payment as it did on education” (328)
17 million die each year in developing countries of curable infections and
parasitic diseases
HIV/AIDS afflicts 23 million per year.
In the US, over 47 million lack health insurance. This translates to 800 million
worldwide.
“The American Association of State Colleges and Universities reports a five
hundred-dollar-per-student decline between 1980 and 1995 in state
appropriations for public universities and colleges, largely a result of increased
state costs for prisons and health care” (329)
--the US currently incarcerates over 2 million of its citizens
5.2–“Poverty and Inequality in the Global Economy,” Michael D. Yates
Are we really “slouching toward utopia” through capitalism?
What are the trends in poverty?
http://www.census.gov/prod/2005pubs/p60-229.pdf
Who are the poor?
Percentage of population living in poverty—12.7% (37 million)
Percentage of population under 18 living in poverty—17.8% (13 million)
Percentage of Asians in poverty—9.8% (1.2 million)
Percentage of non-Hispanic whites in poverty—8.6% (16.9 million)
Percentage of blacks in poverty—24.7% (9 million)
Percentage of Hispanics in poverty—21.9% (9.1 million)
Percentage of population without health insurance—15.7%
--currently at 45.8 million, up from 45 million in 2003
National unemployment rate—5% (~7.4 million, as of July 2005)
http://www.epi.org/content.cfm/webfeatures_econindicators_jobspict_20050805
Note: According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (www.bls.gov), only those individuals who
are over 16 and who 1) do not currently have a job, 2) have actively sought work in the past
four weeks, and 3) are able to work are included in the ‘unemployed’ numbers.
Poverty Thresholds, 2004
http://www.census.gov/Press-Release/www/releases/archives/income_wealth/005647.html
Four people
$19,307
Three people
$15,067
Two people
$12,334
One person
$9,645
Federal Minimum Wage
$5.15 per hour
So a single mother of one child can work full time (40 hours per week, 52 weeks per
year) while getting paid $5.50 per hour but only make…
$11,440 per year
As of 2003 in the United States….
Top 10% has 71% of the Net Wealth
(Of the 71%, the top 1% holds 47.3% of the Net Wealth)
The Bottom 90% has the other 29%
Income Distribution, 2003
18
18
Percentage of Population
16
15.1
15
13.1
14
11.9
12
11
10
8
6
6.9
5.6
3.4
4
2
0
$100,000 $75000 to $50,000 to $35,000 to $25,000 to $15,000 to $10,000 to $5,000 to
and above 99,999
74,999
49,999
34,999
24,999
14,999
9,999
Under
$5,000
The World Bank examines those individuals who subsist on just over $1 per day,
and through studies using this measurement, the World Bank has determined
that world poverty declined over the 1990s.
--But the World Bank uses and index of prices of all things in a poor
country, not necessarily the prices of things that poor people buy.
--these prices rarely change in significant ways
In India, roughly a third of the population lives in dire poverty. In Calcutta, an estimated
250,000 children sleep on the streets each night (334).
“The income of the richest 25 million Americans is the equivalent of nearly 2 billion of the
world’s poorest persons (2 billion is 80 times 25 million)” (335).
The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita as a measurement of wealth…
Notice that those countries with higher GDPs represent those countries
in which capitalism arose earlier, while the poorest countries are those
countries that were largely colonized.
But if we look at nonmoney measures of living conditions…
Life expectancy for women
US—80
Switzerland—82
Afghanistan—46
Sierra Leone—39
Infant mortality rates per 1,000 births
Norway—3.98
Ethiopia—100
Much of this inequality is directly tied to the relative power of the workers to the owners
(337). It is often seen that more equality exists within countries where the power
differential between these two groups is smaller rather than larger.
“It is no accident that the United States has both the weakest labor movement
and the most unequal income of any rich country” (337).
“Great and growing inequality saps the political power of those at the bottom,
making it more likely that the social welfare programs which help to alleviate the
harmful consequences of poverty will be gutted, while at the same time making it more
likely that policies which further favor the rich will be put in place” (333)
--How might welfare programs be a reflection of this?
What, then, is the ‘free-market’ that capitalists praise?
‘Free’ for whom? Why and how?
5.3–“Is World Poverty Falling?” Angus Deaton
Poverty in India—
Over ¼ of the world’s poor lives in India.
A huge change or no change? Tweak with the instrument and of course you’ll
find a difference…
Does measuring changes in poverty by changes in consumption raise issues?