Transcript EERE Programs Briefing

NASCSP 2011 Mid-Winter Training Conference
Weatherization Assistance Program:
The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
1 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
March 3, 2011
Jean Diggs and Christine
Platt Patrick
eere.energy.gov
W EATHERIZATION GRANT GUIDANCE
The Difference of 10-1 and 11-1
Presenter: Jean Diggs
2 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 NATIONAL EVALUATION: Grantees and subgrantees can track the
progress of the national evaluation and see early results through
regular postings at:
http://weatherization.ornl.gov/evaluation_nr.shtml.
 PROGRAM OVERSIGHT:
-
Enhanced monitoring by POs and IG
Increased oversight surfaced several areas of concern.
Result is DOE will place special emphasis on several key areas
3 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 CONTINUING RESOLUTION (H.R. 3082):
-
Until March 4, 2011
-
DOE will send out WPN-11-2 Allocations
-
Grantees and subgrantees will be notified via a specific program
notice if final appropriations allow for Sustainable Energy Resource
and Consumer Grants in 2011.
4 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 HISTORIC PRESERVATION.
– Prototype Programmatic Agreement established.
– This streamlined process will continue to be used under the annual
program award.
– Additional information can be found in Weatherization Program Notice
10-12.
 VOLUNTARY NATIONAL STANDARDS FOR WEATHERIZATION
– Suite of voluntary national guidelines and a companion set of
Knowledge, Skills and Attributes for workforce involved in residential
energy efficiency
– Strategy to support employment and entrepreneurial opportunities for
WAP and other workers for the future
5 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 BEST PRACTICE GUIDES FOR WEATHERIZATION:
– Keen interest in best practices for every aspect of the Program
– WAP has posted and will continue to post best practices on WAPTAC at
www.waptac.org
6 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 TABLE OF CONTENTS
5.13 – Incidental Repairs
5.23 – Eligible Dwelling Units
5.24 – Use of WAP Funds for Add-on/Call-back
 1.3 ADJUSTED AVERAGE:
– The adjusted average expenditure limit for Program Year 2011 is $6,572
– The adjusted average for renewable energy measures increased from
$3,243 in 2010 to $3,279 for 2011
7 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 4.0 GRANTEE PROGRAM OVERSIGHT (Program Monitoring)
– DOE has increased its monitoring efforts
– Project Officers perform weekly, monthly, and quarterly desktop reviews
as well as site visits.
– Minimum Frequency of On-Site Monitoring visits per Year include (more
visits may be required based on specific situations or needs):
 Grants over $90 Million (Quarterly)
 Grants between $90 Million - $40 Million (Three visits)
 Grants under $40 Million (Semi-Annual)
8 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 4.0 GRANTEE PROGRAM OVERSIGHT (Program Monitoring)
(cont’d)
– DOE oversight also includes Quality Assurance visits.
– The Institute of Building Technology and Safety (IBTS).
– IBTS will perform a minimum of 30,000 quality assurance visits.
– The Grantee is the responsible entity for DOE grant
– DOE recommends that Grantees make at least quarterly visits
– Five percent of work at each subgrantee
– More frequently if justified
9 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.2 MULTI-FAMILY ELIGIBILITY: Questions on whether a building
meets the criteria should be directed to the DOE Project Officer.
 DOE issued the following Program Notices on multi-family
related issues:
– WPN 10-15, Final Rule on Amending Eligibility Provisions to MultiFamily Buildings for the Weatherization Assistance Program;
– WPN 10-15A, Guidance Regarding Accrual of Benefits to Low-Income
Tenants in Multi-Family Buildings under the Weatherization Assistance
Program;
– WPN 10-17, Guidance on Using Non-Federal Resources as a BuyDown for Meeting the Savings-to-Investment Ratio for Materials Used in
the Weatherization Assistance Program.
10 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.5 ENERGY AUDIT CRITERIA: WPN 01-4: (cont’d)
Note: Many Grantees are currently delinquent in submitting
their energy audit procedures for revalidation.
 DOE will take more aggressive steps to ensure Grantees meet
this requirement
 Manufactured Home Audits: Grantees may elect to use alternative
energy audits provided they are approved by DOE.
 Multi-Family Audits:
 Where multi-family dwelling units represent more than 20% of
building type, must submit multi-family audit and procedures in
accordance with WPN 01-4
11 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 Multi-family audits – cont’d.
 Less than 20 and do not have DOE approved audit, the Grantee
must take two actions
 Describe in State Plan approach
 Submit to DOE necessary material to approve the multi-family
building PRIOR to beginning work
12 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 Deleted the Energy Crisis which was the old 5.8
 5.8 DETERMINING ELIGIBILITY LEVELS:
– Added the definitions of low-income
 5.9 DEFINING INCOME:
– DOE issued WPN 10-18, 2010 Poverty Income Guidelines and
Definition of Income issued September 20, 2010.
– Revised definition of income.
– Also clarified cash receipts, exclusions, proving eligibility, child support,
annualizing income, and re-certification.
Note: Grantees and subgrantees are reminded that the supporting
documentation for applicants applying for weatherization that may be
on a waiting list or for other reasons must have their eligibility
documentation updated at least annually.
13 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.10 DETERMINING PRIORITY SERVICE:
– Lists out five priority groups
– Reminded everyone that housing type is not a recognized priority, and
– That you cannot discriminate due to the type of home
14 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.12 ENERGY-RELATED HEALTH AND SAFETY:
– The primary goal of the WAP is energy efficiency.
– Goal endures even with the program changes that allow the DOE funds
to be used for health and safety risk mitigation.
– DOE encourages Grantees to be prudent in their oversight of the
percentage of funds approved for health and safety mitigation on homes
weatherized
– WPN 11-6 has been issued
15 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.12 ENERGY-RELATED HEALTH AND SAFETY: (cont’d)
Note: DOE issued Health and Safety Guidance in Weatherization
Program Notice 02-5 on July 12, 2002. DOE issued revised Health and
Safety Guidance in Weatherization Program Notice 11-6 in early
January 2011. Grantees should use the revised guidance in
developing their health and safety plans.
 5.13 INCIDENTAL REPAIRS:
– Grantees and subgrantees are reminded that the WAP is not a
rehabilitation or general repairs program.
– Provides definition of Incidental Repairs in Section 440.3 Definitions
– Repair to a roof to protect the insulation installed is allowable
– Expanding this definition to include roof replacement or for other nonenergy related repairs is not a permissible with DOE funds
16 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.15 ENERGY-RELATED MOLD AND MOISTURE IMPACTS:
[Deleted Mold-Related Weatherization Procedures Paragraph]
 5.16 REWEATHERIZATION:
September 30, 1994
Note: The term “Reweatherization” applies only to those units
which fall into the category of time indicated above and
described under 10 CFR 440.18(e)(2)(iii).
17 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.22 HISTORIC PRESERVATION:
– Mentioned previously
– DOE did receive the ACHP Chairman’s award recognizing both the
DOE and National Conference of State Historic Preservation Officers.
– The award was given to recognize everyone’s contributions to creating
a workable solution to the number of transactions that needed to be
completed in order to allow ARRA money to be sent.
– New Program Manager accepted the award for DOE
The weatherization of non-stationary campers and trailers that do
not have a mailing address associated with the eligible applicants is
not allowed. The use of a post office box for non-stationary campers
or trailers does not meet this requirement.
18 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.23 ELIGIBLE DWELLING UNITS:
– Subgrantees should exercise caution in dealing with non-traditional type
dwelling
 Shelters
 Apartments over businesses, etc.
– Consideration on weatherizing these types of units should be
coordinated with the Grantee or if necessary approved by the DOE
Project Officer prior to weatherization.
19 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 5.24 USE OF WAP FUNDS FOR ADD-ON/CALL-BACK WORK:
As a general rule, Grantees and subgrantees may not charge the
WAP for additional work on homes that have already been reported
to DOE as completed, weatherized units. WPN 11-03 provides
specific guidance on this type of activity.
Note: Under no circumstances can any of these activities be
covered under the reweatherization provisions of 10 CFR
440.18(e)(2)(iii).
20 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
WAP GRANT GUIDANCE 11-1
 6.2 REPORTING DOE COMPLETED UNITS:
– DOE recommends that final inspections be conducted by a person
not associated with actual work
21 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO Reports:
Inspector General and General Accountability Office
A Review of Findings and Next Steps
Presenter: Christine Platt Patrick, DOE Policy Advisor
22 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
Overview
 Introduction
 The IG/GAO
 Findings and Trends
 Next Steps
23 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – The Process
 The Inspector General (IG) Mission - To help the Department and
the American taxpayer by identifying opportunities for cost savings
and operational efficiencies in Department programs; and returning
hard dollars to the Department and the U.S. Treasury as a result of
Office of Inspector General civil and criminal investigations.
 The General Accountability Office (GAO) - GAO exists to support the
Congress in meeting its constitutional responsibilities and to help
improve the performance and ensure the accountability of the
Federal government for the benefit of the American people.
24 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – The Process
 The audit process commences upon receipt of the incoming
notification letter from IG or GAO of their intent to conduct a review
with EERE.
Information contained in the notification letter includes:
 Job title, job code and a brief description of the assignment;
 Indication of whether the audit is the result of a Congressional
request or a IG/GAO initiative;
 Proposed entrance conference dates;
 Locations and specific program offices where work will be
performed, and
 Identification of the performing division, and the name and telephone
number of the appropriate IG/GAO contact for the audit.
25 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – The Process
 Attend entrance conference
 Respond to requests for information and documentation
 Statement of Facts/Coordination Copy
 Draft Report
 Respond with management decision letter with corrective actions and
estimated completion dates
 Exit Conference
 Final Report
26 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – Findings and Trends
 General IG/GAO Findings:
– Substandard performance in weatherization workmanship
– Substandard performance in initial home assessments
 Assessments that called for inappropriate weatherization measures
 Assessments overlooked key measures to make homes more energy
efficient
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Inadequate oversight of contractors
Inaccurate documentation for contractor billing
Homes failing final inspection
Inadequate recordkeeping
Inadequate payroll systems to track employee’s time on projects
Incomplete client files
Fraud, waste and abuse of funds
27 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – Next Steps
Investigations Are Changing Focus
– Prior Focus: Department level
– New Focus: CAA level
28 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – Next Steps
What CAAs Can Do
29 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – Next Steps
 Procure contractor weatherization services through a competitive
process as required by Federal regulations and perform cost
analyses in the selection of contractors to ensure price
competiveness.
 Obtain and/or review supporting documentation for contractors'
invoices to ensure that materials and labor costs incurred on
projects are associated with allowable weatherization services and
materials.
 Ensure that employees charging payroll costs to the Weatherization
Program Recovery Act grants are actually providing such services to
the Program.
30 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – Next Steps
 Develop written policies and/or procedures for ensuring cost
reasonableness and supportability.
 Develop/ensure payroll systems are structured to track employee's
time incurred on projects.
 Ensure payments for expenditures are appropriately documented
and accounted for.
 Ensure contractors are billed for labor charges that have been
incurred and for materials that have been installed.
31 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
IG/GAO – Next Steps
 Initial assessments that called for inappropriate weatherization
measures or the assessments overlooked key measures needed to
make the homes more energy efficient.
 Ensure that income eligibility source documentation be a part of
every client’s file.
 Ensure the eligibility documentation, whether stored electronically or
hard copy (off site is ok), be readily available at the request of an
outside reviewer.
32 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
Inspector General
IG Hotline Complaints
33 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov
Questions?
34 | Weatherization Assistance Program: The Federal Perspective (Part 1)
eere.energy.gov