MANAGING WORKPLACE DISCIPLINE & INCAPACITY

Download Report

Transcript MANAGING WORKPLACE DISCIPLINE & INCAPACITY

CODE OF GOOD PRACTICE ON THE HANDLING
OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT CASES IN THE
WORKPLACE(2005)
@ CCMA
Zola Madotyeni
18 November 2014
INTRODUCTION

Recent amendments to the provisions of the EEA,
particularly those that for the fist time empower CCMA to
adjudicate sexual harassment cases(which we all know is
a form of discrimination) informed this presentation.

In the past all discrimination cases were adjudicated in
the LC after unsuccessful conciliation.

Now section 10 of EEA gives CCMA jurisdiction
@ CCMA
INTERNATIONAL LAW
Constitutional obligations

section 39 to consider international law when interpreting
the rights in chapter 2.

Section 231-RSA to respect international law

Section 233- courts to adopt an interpretation that is
consistent with international law
@ CCMA
INTERNATIONAL LAW INTRUMENTS

ILO COMMITTEE OF EXPERTS

CEDAW-1979-(articles 7-16)- states to eliminate all forms
of discrimination in all aspects of life including
employment.

BEIJING PLATFORM FOR ACTION: (art112-113b)- defines
sexual violence to include sexual harassment

PROTOCOL TO THE AFRICAN CHARTER(12-13) outlaws
sexual harassment; laws & programmes
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
CONSTITUTIONAL CONTEXT
(Constitution of RSA 108 of 1996)

Section 9: Equality, eradication of discrimination on (un)
listed grounds; (positive obligations- the state to enact
legislation-EEA)

Section 10: right to human dignity

Section 12: freedom & security of person

Section14: Right to privacy

Section 23: right to fair labour practice

Section7(2): state to promote, protect & fulfill the rights
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
NATIONAL LEGISLATION
( LRA & EEA are constitutionally inspired laws)
Labour Relations Act
•
Section 5(1) protection exercising rights conferred by LRA
•
Resolution of disputes at CCMA-sections 133-134; 135;
136; 137 & 138-142(powers)
•
Section 185: no unfair dismissal/ or ULP
•
Section 186: definition of dismissal & ULP
•
Section 187(10(f): automatically unfair dismissal
•
Section 188: ordinary dismissal
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
EMPLOYMENT EQUITY ACT

Sec2- Purpose: elimination of unfair discrimination

Sec3- interpretation: the Code; intl law

Sec4 applies to all employers/employees

Sec6: prohibits unfair discrimination: harassment of an employee is a form unfair
discrimination is prohibited on any listed ground-

Sec10(6)(aA)(i) CCMA arbitrates sexual harassment

Sec10(8) appeal CCMA arbitration to LC within 14 days

Sec11: onus of proof 11(b) defenses- it did not take place or rational

Sec54(1) empowers minister to issue Codes

Sec 60(1) duty of employee to report as soon as possible

Section 60(2) employer to consult all affected parties & to act

Section 60(3) vicarious liability on employers who fail to act

Section 60(4) defense to employers: it did what it could in a given case
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
SEXUAL HARASSMENT

Section 6(3): harassment of an employee is a form of
discrimination and is prohibited on any listed grounds

Common type in the workplace is sexual harassment.

Unlike the 1998 Code, Sexual harassment not defined in
2005 Code, elements thereof are explained in clauses 4
and 5 to include unwanted conduct of a sexual nature that
violates the employee’s rights & create a barrier to equity
in the workplace with examples.

Can be persistent or once off. Mokoena v Garden Art at
paragraph 40 to 42
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
THE CODE OF GOOD PRACTICE
The obligation to consider the Code of good
Practice when dealing with sexual
harassment is peremptory

Sec 3(c) of EEA: code must be considered

Sec 138(6) of LRA- Code must be considered

Sec203(3) of LRA- Code to be considered

So the Code of Good practice is an important
interpretation tool- failure to consider it is reviewable:

SA Metal Group v CCMA & Another at paragraphs 10;11 &
25
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
THE NATURE OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT

Forms of Sexual Harassment
(1) Sexual harassment may include unwelcome physical, verbal or non-verbal
conduct, but is not limited to the following examples:

(a) Physical conduct of a sexual nature includes all unwanted physical contact,
ranging from touching to sexual assault and rape, and includes a strip search by
or in the presence of the opposite sex.

(b) Verbal forms of sexual harassment include unwelcome innuendoes
suggestions and hints, sexual advances, comments with sexual overtones, sexrelated jokes or insults or unwelcome graphic comments about a person's body
made in their presence or to them, unwelcome and inappropriate enquiries about
a person's sex life, and unwelcome whistling at a person or group of persons.

(c) Non-verbal forms of sexual harassment include unwelcome gestures,
indecent exposure, and the unwelcome display of sexually explicit pictures and
objects.

(d) Quid pro quo harassment occurs where an owner, employer, supervisor,
member of management or co-employee undertakes or attempts to influence or
influences the process of employment, promotion, training, discipline, dismissal,
salary increments or other benefits of an employee or job applicant in exchange
for sexual favours.”
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
The Code enacted in terms of Section
54(1) of the EEA

Clause 1

The objectives of the Code is to eliminate sexual harassment in the

workplace.

provides appropriate procedures to deal with sexual

harassment and prevent its recurrence.

The code encourages and promotes the development and

implementation of policies and procedures that will lead to the
creation of workplaces that are free of sexual harassment, where
employers and employees respect one another’s integrity and dignity,
their privacy, and their right to equity in the workplace. SA Metal
Group (Pty) v CCMA
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
APPLICATION OF THE CODE



The Code applies to employers, managers, job applicants,
employees, contractors, clients, applicant’s for position
others having dealings with the employer.
non-employee victim of sexual harassment may file a
grievance with the employer of the harasser, where the
harassment has taken place in the workplace or in the
course of the harasser’s employment. Adrian Simmers v
Campbell South Africa & others (employee charged with
harassment of a consultant off premises)
However, employer can’t charge an outsider
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
SEXUAL HARASSMENT IS A FORM OF
DISCRIMINATION (CLAUSE3)

Clause 3 is the restatement of section 6(3)

Makoti v Jesuit “The obverse of granting employment benefits in
exchange for sexual favours, is when an employee is disadvantaged
for not granting them. Clearly this is an impermissible criterion for
differentiating in the treatment of employees and will constitute
unfair discrimination. An employee dismissed on such basis is clearly
dismissed for an impermissible reason and one that is unfairly
discriminatory within the meaning of section 187(1)(f) of the LRA
read with section 6(3) of the EEA (at paragraph 54).
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
TEST FOR SEXUAL HARASSMENT
(CLAUSE 4)
Sexual harassment is unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature that violates
the
•
rights of an employee and constitutes a barrier to equity in the
workplace,
•
taking into account all of the following factors:
•
whether the harassment is on the prohibited grounds of sex and/or
gender and/or sexual orientation;

whether the sexual conduct was unwelcome;

the nature and extent of the sexual conduct; and

the impact of the sexual conduct on the employee.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
TEST FOR SEXUAL
HARASSMENT(CONTINUED)
Simmers v Campbell “The commissioner properly had regard to the Code of Good
Practice on the Handling of Sexual Harassment Cases. But there was no evidence at
the arbitration that Simmers’s conduct crossed the line where sexual attention
becomes sexual harassment. The Code specifies that that is the case when -•
the behaviour is persisted in, although a single incident of harassment can
constitute sexual harassment;
•
the complainant made it clear that she considers the behaviour offensive; and/or
•
the alleged perpetrator should have known that his behaviour was unacceptable.

The Code makes it clear that a person may indicate that sexual conduct is
unwelcome by walking away. That is what M. did in this case. Simmers did not
pursue her. Verbal conduct includes sexual advances – but it must be unwelcome,
and the alleged perpetrator should have known that or the recipient of the
advance should have made it clear.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
TEST FOR SEXUAL HARASSMENT
Simmers v Campbell (paragraph 27)

It is true that a single incident of unwelcome sexual conduct can
constitute sexual harassment. But it is trite that such an incident
must be serious. It should constitute an impairment of the
complainant’s dignity, taking into account her circumstances and
the respective positions of the parties in the workplace. This
nearly always involves an infringement of bodily integrity such as
touching, groping, or some other form of sexual assault; or quid
pro quo harassment. In this case, it is common cause that the
Commissioner dealt with a single incident. He found so. Once M.
made it plain to Simmers that it was not welcome, he backed off.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
THE TEST FOR SEXUAL
HARASSMENT(CONTINUED)
Onus in terms of amended , Section 11 now provides:

‘(1) If unfair discrimination is alleged on a ground listed in section 6
(1), the employer against whom the allegation is made must prove, on
a balance of probabilities, that such discrimination-

(a) did not take place as alleged; or

(b) is rational and not unfair, or is otherwise justifiable.’
Bandat v De Kok and others: “What is clear is that following the
amendment of section 11 of the EEA, all the employee party has to do is
to allege that discrimination exists on one of the grounds specified in
section 6(1), and the onus would squarely be on the employer party to
prove that it does not exist.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
THE TEST FOR SEXUAL
HARASSMENT(CONTINUED)
Onus in terms of amended , Section 11 now provides:

‘(1) If unfair discrimination is alleged on a ground listed in section 6
(1), the employer against whom the allegation is made must prove, on
a balance of probabilities, that such discrimination-

(a) did not take place as alleged; or

(b) is rational and not unfair, or is otherwise justifiable.’
Bandat v De Kok and others: “What is clear is that following the
amendment of section 11 of the EEA, all the employee party has to do is
to allege that discrimination exists on one of the grounds specified in
section 6(1), and the onus would squarely be on the employer party to
prove that it does not exist.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
FACTORS TO ESTABLISH SEXUAL
HARASSMENT (CLAUSE 5)
Clause 5 codifies decisions of courts & writings
•
On prohibited grounds(e.g. sexual orientation)
•
Conduct is unwanted persisted
•
Is of a sexual nature
•
Nature & extent: favours; victimization
•
A single act may amount to sexual harassment
•
Position of perpetrator & victim
•
Impact: impairment of dignity
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
HARASSMENT ON PROHIBITED GROUNDS
(sex, gender & sexual orientation: same sex qualifiesVodacom Services Provider v CCMA (para5-6)

G v Minister of Police: “The EEA does not define
“harassment” but treats it as discrimination. It also does
not define “sexual harassment”. The Code also treats
sexual harassment as discrimination. It sets the test as
“unwanted conduct of a sexual nature that violates the
rights of an employee and constitutes a barrier to equity
in the workplace, taking into account certain factors.
Conversely, behaviour that is desired, welcome, mutual or
reciprocal is excluded from the definition”.(paragraph1112) Vodacom Services Provider v the CCMA and another at
paragraph 4-5
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
UNWELCOME CONDUCT: a desired, welcome,
mutual or reciprocal conduct excluded:
•
the victim has a duty to show that the conduct is
unwelcome, depending on circumstances.
Sec61 of the EEA requires immediate reporting to employer:
"in instances of sexual harassment, the word “ immediately"
shall mean, as soon as is reasonably possible in the
circumstances and with out undue delay, taking into account
the nature of sexual harassment, including that it is a
sensitive issue, that the complainant may fear reprisals and
the relative positions of the complainant and the alleged
perpetrator in the workplace.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
UNWELCOME CONDUCT TO BE
COMMUNICATED

Bandat v Kok: “Anderson advised the applicant that she
had to call on the first respondent to stop this conduct
immediately. Anderson recommended that this be done in
writing. Anderson advised the applicant that if the first
respondent would then not stop, he would be liable for
sexual harassment. Despite this clear advice, the
applicant did nothing. She did not confront the first
respondent, or tell him what conduct she found
unacceptable. She did not call on him to stop anything.
She raised nothing in writing (paragraph32).
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
However duty to reject unwelcome
conduct depends on circumstances

Gaga v Anglo Platinum: “The rule against sexual harassment targets,
amongst other things, reprehensible expressions of misplaced
authority by superiors towards their subordinates. The fact that the
subordinate may present as ambivalent, or even momentarily be
flattered by the attention, is no excuse; particularly where at some
stage in an ongoing situation she signals her discomfort. If not the
initial behaviour, then, at the very least, the persistence therein is
unacceptable. By applying too narrow a definition of sexual
harassment, the commissioner overlooked these considerations and
made a material error that denied the first respondent a full and fair
determination of the issues; thereby committing an irregularity or
misconduct (paragraph 41).
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
COPING MECHANISM SHOULD NOT
REGARDED AS RECIPROCITY

Gaga v Anglo Platinum: There is accordingly no rational
basis justifying the commissioner’s conclusion that there
was no sexual harassment on the limited ground that the
remarks and behaviour caused no offence or discomfort.
The evidence established that the remarks and behaviour
were unwelcome and inappropriately repeated despite
being declined(Paragraph43)

See G v Minister of Police (para111-121& comments on
paragraphs 126-128 on wards)
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
REASONS FOR NOT COMPLAINING OR
VOICING REJECTION TO BE UNPACKED
Makoti v Jesuit Refugee Service SA: “The applicant's
testimony of the specific acts of sexually aggressive
behaviour of the director aimed at her was relatively
detailed, plausible and could not be directly contradicted
by the respondent. Understandably, the respondent sought
to suggest that her account ought not to be believed
because she never raised any grievance about it at the time.
It is true that the applicant's failure to make an issue of a
deeply felt grievance at the time when it was suffered calls
for a plausible explanation, which must be carefully
assessed”(at para 44).
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
NATURE OF THE CONDUCT

Serious verbal and physical: Vodacom Service Provider v
CCMA (words, touching, photos, exposure)

Gaga v Anglo Platinum- comments

Jesuit v Makoti- obverse of quid pro quo/ denial of
benefits, para54

SA Metal Group: hugging, kissing, comments

Potgieter v Minister of Police: touching

G v Minister of Police: longstanding sexual relationship
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
A SINGLE INCIDENT MAY CONSTITUTE
SEXUAL HARASSMENT

Mokoena and Another v Garden Art Ltd and Another:
‘Sexual attention becomes sexual harassment if the
behaviour is persisted in, although a single incident of
harassment may constitute sexual harassment, the
recipient has made it clear that the behaviour is
considered offensive and the perpetrator should have
known that the behaviour would be regarded as
unacceptable.’ at paragraph 47.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
GUIDING PRINCIPLES (CLAUSE6): GIVING
ONTENT ON THE EMPLOYER OBLIGATIONS IN
SECTION 60 OF EEA
Employer and management obliged:
•
Create & maintain environment where dignity of employee is respected;
•
To refrain from sexually harassing employees;
•
Protect its employees/customers from sexual harassment
•
To take appropriate action in cases of sexual harassment: Potgieter v Minister
of Police
•
Mokoena v Garden Art Ltd
•
Makoti v Jesuit (failure to take action exposes employer to liability in terms
of sec60 of EEA
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
OBLIGATION TO ADOPT SEXUAL
HARASSMENT POLICIES(CLAUSE7)
Places an obligation on employer’s subject to existing
collective agreements to adopt sexual harassment policy
covering all topics in the Code: Policies subject to the
Code
 Policies to make sexual harassment an offence
 In the absence of Policy, provisions of the Code apply:
Simmers v Campbell “CSA does not have a policy on
sexual harassment. The commissioner properly had regard
to the Code of Good Practice on the Handling of Sexual
Harassment Cases.”(paragraph 26)

@ CCMA
2015/07/20
OBLIGATORY PROCEDURES IN SEXUAL
HARASSMENT POLICIES

Policy to be accommodative and ensure privacy & dignity for any
reporting;

To have both formal and informal procedures(restorative and penal
contents)

The contents and procedures publicized;

The right to refer to CCMA to be publicized should internal grievance
process fail;

Perpetrator’s right to refer to CCMA publicized

Retaliation/ victimization after legitimate reporting to be penalized
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
IMPORTANT CASES ON THE APPLICATION
OF THE CODE

SA METAL GROUP: failure to apply the (correct) code is a
reviewable irregularity. Correct legal approach is to
consider the Code, evidence in totality and the relative
position of the parties. (verbal/written banter, kissing &
hugging).

Vodacom v CCMA: Female superior exposed herself to
juniors, sexual comments and touching;

Gaga: suggestive talk to a junior, revealed at exit
interview: similar fact evidence used.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
IMPORTANT CASES

Makoti v Jesuit: deprivation of benefits. Failure to renew
a contract of employment

Potgieter v National Commissioner: a colleague tried to
kiss her & superior called her liefie when she reported:
fine & warning to those involved, employer not liable.

Mokoena v Garden Art: (peeping Tom) male supervisor
entering female change room: apology & warning.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
IMPORTANT CASES

Simmers v Campbell: “ do you want a lover tonight?” an
employee to a consultant outside the premises, in a lodge
in Botswana. Court held comments not serious enough.

G v Minister: sordid affair between a Senior SAPS member
& junior happening over years, then ended in bitterness:
harassment not proven- no proof that conduct unwanted.

Bandat v Kok: constructive dismissal not proven, no proof
that the conduct was unwanted
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
IMPORTANT CASES

Media 24 v Grobler: damages for sexual harassment by
manager: “It is well settled that an employer owes a
common law duty to its employees to take reasonable
care for their safety. This duty cannot in my view be
confined to an obligation to take reasonable steps to
protect them from physical harm caused by what may be
called physical hazards. It must also in appropriate
circumstances include a duty to protect them from
psychological harm caused, for example, by sexual
harassment by co-employees.”(para 65 &68)
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
IMPORTANT CASES

News 24 v Grobler: The mere fact the incident happened
outside the workplace is of no consequence, the
perpetrator will still be liable: (sexual harassment
happening during flat incident was held to be the cause of
trauma)

Simmers v Campbell (the offending utterances took place
in a lodge in Botswana)

G v Minister of Police( Most of the incidents happened in
the house of the perpetrator and in cheap and dirty
lodges.
@ CCMA
2015/07/20
THANK YOU
@ CCMA
2015/07/20