Transcript Slide 1
Marine Renewable Energy in Scotland
SustainableEngineering@Edinburgh
By: S. Dickson (0679718); J. Knight (0785854); D. Niland (0840777); R. Wallace (0673279)
IMS3 Sustainability Module, March 2009
Introduction: In response to climate change Scotland has set a target to generate 50% of its electricity from renewable sources by 2020.
With the best offshore resource in Europe, generators installed at sea will play a major role in meeting this target.
Wind
Wave
• Shoreline devices e.g. WaveGen, or offshore devices e.g.
Pelamis (pictured)
• The first commercial scale wave farm installed in Portugal
(21 MW) using Scottish technology
• 0.27 MW is already installed, a further 9 MW has been
confirmed. Total potential of 14 GW2
• Two different types; tidal barrage or tidal turbine
• At present there is no generating capacity
• 300 MW tidal barrage proposed for Solway Firth3
• Tidal stream – first installation of commercial device (1.2 MW)
in Strangford Lough (N Ireland); plans to install 50 MW in
Pentland Firth4
• Inherently predictable
• Currently only 10MW of installed power (Beatrice oil field)
• Robin Rigg wind farm (Solway Firth) under construction
60 x 3 MW turbines; 80m hub height, 44m blades
• 6.4 GW of offshore wind farms planned1
• Offshore potential is 25 GW2 – more than Scotland’s entire
projected electricity consumption in 2020
Big challenge
50
public enquiry)
Environmental impact of offshore wind not yet quantified (SEA
due Jan 2010). Tidal – potential collisions between seals,
fish and diving birds with rotating underwater blades
Seabird breeding colonies sensitive to disturbance
during construction; collision risk during operation10
% Electricity generation
from renewables8,9
Other
Wind
40
Hydro
30
Offshore wind 60% more expensive than
Scotland
20
UK
10
2020
2018
2016
2014
2012
2010
2008
2006
0
2004
Less dependence on fuel imports – energy security
Offshore expertise from North Sea oil/gas industry
Leading centres of research at 4 Scottish universities
European Marine Energy Centre based in Orkney
Developing offshore wind power could create up to 40,000 jobs in
the UK (installation & servicing); up to 70,000 jobs if Government
is proactive in supporting R&D, innovation and manufacturing6
Lack of public support for new power lines (e.g. Beauly-Denny
2002
Reduce carbon emissions (& other atmospheric pollutants)
Renewable sources of energy will not be depleted – sustainable!
Reduce visible impact by installing turbines offshore; even less impact
for wave and tidal devices at or below sea-level
No problems with noise
New Marine Bill (Dec 2008) will establish a Marine Management
Organisation, this will help simplify and streamline planning process
Maintenance of offshore wind turbines expensive and weatherdependent – poor availability for first offshore turbines6
Foundations need to be stronger than onshore devices
Lack of specialised installation ships/ rigs
Most sites remote from energy demand – major upgrade to
transmission network required
Intermittency of resource
European
wind atlas7
2000
Technology
The best wind, wave and tidal resources in Europe
Wind energy is a well-established technology and can provide large-scale
generating capacity by 2020 ….beyond 2020 wave and tidal power
likely to be commercially viable
Increased capacity factor for offshore wind turbines due to higher and
more consistent wind speeds
Offshore conditions allow larger wind farms and larger individual turbines
Environment
Big opportunity
Socio-economic
Tidal
onshore6 - electricity prices likely to increase
Cost of offshore wind could reach £75
billion6 - difficult to finance?
Negative impact on fisheries & shipping5
Interference with radar (defence)5
Wind turbines all imported