Multinational strategy, industrial policy and local
Download
Report
Transcript Multinational strategy, industrial policy and local
Multinational strategy, industrial policy and
local capability: A comparison of automotive
industry development in South Africa and
Thailand
Justin Barnes, School of Development Studies, University of
KwaZulu-Natal, and
Anthony Black, School of Economics, University of Cape Town
Faculty of Economics, Thammasat
University, 28th May 2013
Presentation outline
• Introduction: Global developments and their
impact on emerging markets
• The development of the South African and
Thai industries
• Micro level competitiveness factors:
– Factor costs
– Operational capabilities
• Conclusions
Introduction
• Importance of the automotive industry to
developing economies
• Successful development policy (Humphrey and
Oeter, 2000; Lung and van Tulder, 2004) requires:
– Viable “automotive space”
– Firm-level competitiveness
• Paper explores interplay of these two dynamics in
two competing middle income economies – SA and
Thailand
• Perspective is in relation to SA’s development
challenges
Global developments and their
impact on emerging markets
• Share of emerging markets has grown enormously
both with regard to global production and
automotive exports
• Regionalism rather than globalism may be a more
appropriate descriptor of the forces shaping the
location of the industry internationally (Sturgeon
and Van Biesebroeck, 2010)
• Growing concentration of developing country
production locations in a relatively small number
of favoured locations – “viable automotive spaces”
The development of the South African
and Thai industries
Common features
• Long history of government support: high levels of protection,
including tariffs and local content programmes led initially to
proliferation of models being produced in low volumes
• Influx of FDI into both countries in the 1990s and 2000s, and shift to
export orientation
• Toyota largest producer in both markets
• Important competitors in relation to the assembly of light commercial
vehicles (LCVs)
• Hold dominant positions within their respective regions
• Thailand centrally located in large dynamic market region
• SA’s neighbours are poor and, even collectively, comprise a tiny market
Production volumes for car models, 1995
Production volumes (000s)
Country
100+
50-100
20-50
0-20
China
1
1
2
7
India
1
1
1
9
Malaysia
1
1
1
14
Mexico
3
3
5
1
Argentina
0
1
6
4
Brazil
5
3
4
3
Indonesia
0
0
1
13
Thailand
0
1
3
7
S. Africa
0
0
4
17
The development of the South African industry
• Production dates back to the 1920s. From 1950 to early 1980s, sales increased
tenfold but the market then stagnated to the mid 1990s. Annual domestic sales
reached a peak of 714,000 units in 2006, before declining to 395,000 units in 2009
• Problems of high protection were apparent by the late 1980s. SA’s automotive
industry was inefficient and highly inward oriented. Major shift in 1995 – Motor
Industry Development Programme (MIDP) - began a steady process of tariff
reductions. Minimum local content levels were abolished and import duties on
components and CBUs could be offset by auto exports
• Since 1995, auto imports and exports have increased rapidly.
• This had major implications for ownership as OEM and component manufacturer
MNCs acquired local operations or established new plants
• Seven light vehicle OEMs have a total production capacity of 700,000 units
• Local content levels have been range bound between 50% and 60%, even in high
volume models
South African passenger and light commercial vehicle exports:
1995 to 2010 actual, 2011 projections
300,000
250,000
Passenger
LCV
Units
200,000
150,000
100,000
50,000
0
95
96
97
98
99
00
01
02
03 04
Year
Source: NAAMSA
05
06
07
08
09
10 11*
South African passenger and light commercial vehicle imports:
1995 to 2009 actual, plus 2010 and 2011 projection
Units
350,000
300,000
LCV
250,000
Passenger
200,000
150,000
100,000
50,000
0
95
96
97
98
99
00
01
02
03
Year
Source: NAAMSA
04
05
06
07
08
09
10* 11*
The development of the Thai industry
• Significant industrialization in the early 1960s but by 2007 a total of 14
OEMs, predominantly Japanese and American owned, had installed capacity
of 1.7 million units. Production of cars and commercial vehicles reached 1.4
million units in 2008, over double that of SA
• Like SA, Thailand has made use of high tariffs and local content
requirements as well as trade balancing mechanisms to grow the sector
• Local content requirements were removed in 1998 by which time the large
OEMs were initiating plans to increase local content beyond minimum
requirements. Export support was also given in the form of tax and import
duty exemptions
• Since the mid 1990s, the industry has become highly export oriented with
exports increasing from 14,000 units in 1996 to 152,800 in 2000 and
838,600 units in 2008. Over the period 2000-2008 vehicle exports
accounted for 41% of production
• Approximately 70% of Thai production comprises LCVs. Passenger vehicle
production primarily consists of smaller vehicle types, as a result of lower
taxes
Automotive products exports in SA and Thailand
Constant 2009 prices
18
16
14
$ billiion
12
10
SA Exports
8
Thailand Exports
6
4
2
0
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
Developing an ‘automotive space’: Managing
demand and achieving scale
Excise tax structure and duty rates in Thailand and RSA - 2008
Thailand
Type
Excise Tax
Import Duty
30%
80%
10-30%
30%
80%
Powered by blended
fuels (>20% ethanol)
25%
30%
Eco-cars
17%
3%
Electric & Hybrid cars
Pickup trucks (LCVs)
CKD
Excise Tax
Based on
value
1-20%
Passenger vehicles
Based on
engine size
30-50%
RSA
CBU
Import Duty
CKD
CBU
24%
29%
1-20%
24%
29%
80%
1-20%
24%
29%
30%
80%
1-20%
24%
29%
40%
40%
1-20%
24%
29%
Automotive demand side taxes in Thailand relative to
South Africa – 2008 (all figures in South African Rands)
One ton LCV (private use)
Thailand
Passenger vehicle (2000-2500cc)
SA
Thailand
SA
OEM selling price
200,000
200,000
200,000
200,000
CBU import tariff
40%
29%
80%
29%
Excise tax
3%
35%
VAT
7%
5.39% import,
4.05% local
14%
7%
5.39% import,
4.05% local
14%
0.3%
0%
3.5%
0%
221,081
237,234
299,012
237,234
309,514
309,973
538,221
309,973
Interior tax
Local production vehicle
market price (all taxes
included)
Imported vehicle market
price (tariff + taxes included)
Implications of trade policy differentials?
• Market demand profile narrower in Thailand than in SA due to
differential tariff and excise tax structure
• Thai market more open to trade in areas where local scale
economies realised – SA no differentiation
• SA tariffs lower with much higher import penetration in vehicle
market
• Thailand more likely to secure investment based on trade
conditions than SA
– Based on creation of viable automotive space
• But what of firm-level competitiveness factors?
– “Waste” levels?
– Factor costs?
Micro level competitiveness factors: factor
costs and operational capabilities
Cost of sales profile of four matching Thai and SA automotive
component manufacturers – when holding materials costs
consistent between both sets of firms
Waste elements at the four pair-matched component
manufacturers (as % of sales)
Thai Firms (n=4)
Inventory Costs (1)
Quality Costs (2)
Flexibility Costs (3)
Reliability Costs (4)
HRD Costs (5)
Total Costs
2.31%
1.28%
2.38%
0.86%
0.05%
6.88%
SA Firms (n=4)
3.89%
1.46%
9.00%
4.69%
0.40%
19.43%
Additional SA
costs
1.58%
0.18%
6.62%
3.83%
0.35%
12.56%
Source: South African Automotive Benchmarking Club
Based on comparative (1) inventory levels, (2) customer return rates and
materials scrap levels, (3) production downtime due to machine/line
changeovers, (4) production downtime due to machine/tool breakdowns,
and (5) attendance levels,
Average profile of three South African-based auto
component manufacturers
Average
Sales
R214.8 million
% Exports
11.0%
Value added as % sales
45.0%
Materials purchased
R116.5 million
-
Local materials
R44.3 million
-
Imported materials
R77.2 million
Employment
Source: SAABC database, accessed 2009
769
Labour and employment profile of 3 SA firms, and a comparison
of their costs in SA versus a model of costs in Thailand
Employment
category
Avg. cost per
employee in South
Africa
Avg. number of
employees
Avg. cost per
employee in
Thailand
Management
18
R 428 500
R 158 148
Professional
17
R 275 500
R 47 520
Supervisors
44
R 122 000
R 29 946
Artisan
40
R 267 000
R 22 080
Production
613
R 53 334
R 19 320
Apprentices
37
R 38 448
R 16 560
Total
769
Source: SAABC database, 2009; DAC Remuneration and Retention Survey, 2009. Annual median Total
TCTC wage data from the MIBCO database http://www.mibco.org.za/forms/MI_Wages2008_3.pdf;
Thailand Board of Investment (BOI): www.boi.go.th/english/how/labor_costs.asp
Modelling of Thailand and SA employee costs for transplanted SA
automotive component manufacturer
Management
R 7 855 833
R 2 899 380
Thailand as %
SA cost
36.9
Professional
R 4 683 500
R 807 840
17.2
R 3 875 660
Supervisors
R 5 327 333
R 1 307 642
24.5
R 4 019 691
Artisan
R 10 769 000
R 890 560
8.3
R 9 878 440
Production
R 32 675 964
R 11 836 720
36.2
R 20 839 244
R 1 422 576
R 612 720
43.1
R 809 856
R 62 734 207
R 18 354 862
29.3
R 44 379 345
Employment
category
Apprentices
Employee cost
total
South African
cost
Thailand cost
Thailand cost
advantage
R 4 956 453
Summary of labour and overhead input
cost differentials
SA avg. COS
breakdown
Thailand avg. is
cheaper by...
Thailand advantage
(% COS)
22.7
8.0%
1.81
- electricity
1.0
3.0%
0.03
- water
0.2
66.0%
0.16
- management
4.3
63.1%
2.71
- factory rentals
3.2
(34.0%)
(1.09)
Labour
18.3
63.8%
11.68
Materials
Total labour/
overheads
59.0
Overheads
41.0
.....................Held constant......................
33.1%
13.49
Re-cap of our evidence
• Thailand has a significant competitiveness advantage
over SA:
– Concentrated light vehicle ownership - major incentive for the local
assembly of such vehicles
– Supported localization of production through a suite of Greenfield
investment incentives
– Low cost infrastructure
– Supply of low cost skilled and semi-skilled employees
– Implementation of advanced lean production methodologies
• SA competitive advantage relates only to government
export/production incentives
Conclusions
1. Benefits of market concentration – forced by tariff and tax structure – creates
scale economies and opportunities for localisation
2. Liberal tariff structures work against the more open economy when investment
decisions are free of political economy factors and based on production
benefits in the two economies, e.g. for an average R200,000 LCV, the tariff and
tax benefit of Thailand over SA was 2.9% in 2008, whilst for a 2,000-2,500cc
passenger vehicle, the advantage was calculated at a far more substantial
21.5%
3. High input costs into manufacturing, particularly for (skilled) labour and
management, are potentially crippling to competitiveness, whilst also ensuring
that operational performance is impaired. Cost disadvantage in SA is severe,
with operational waste factors suggestive of a 12.6% cost differential with Thai
producers, and factor cost comparisons a 13.5% disadvantage (but figures not
cumulative)
Conclusions
4. SA auto industry leans heavily on tariff rebates support equivalent to ±8% of
OEM sales. This is more generous than the highest support levels possible for
Greenfield investments in Thailand (5.4% of sales). BUT such support measures
do not effectively compensate for lower tariffs and basic competitiveness
attributes (e.g. cost, skills, infrastructure). SA’s regional location and limited
cost advantages have led to a pattern of limited investment, hence lower
volume operations and limited supplier development
5. Thailand represents a genuine export platform; SA does not. BUT SA’s growing
market, combined with a fast growing SSA, will constitute a significant regional
market in the medium term. If the SA industry can reduce its manufacturing
costs, it will be well positioned to take advantage of this
6. Thailand has established itself as the regional hub within ASEAN, although it is
likely to face much greater competition in the future - from other members of
ASEAN in its domestic market – and from China and others in third country
markets
Thank you