Transcript Global design template - WV Mine Drainage Task Force
West Virginia Mine Drainage Task Force Symposium
CREATING NATIONAL COAL MINING
GEOSPATIAL
DATA STANDARDS
By
The National Coal Mine Geospatial Committee April 10, 2007
Topics to be covered
Geospatial What does it mean?
Why does it matter?
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining accidents/disasters • Recent • Future Public’s right to know Recent technology improvements making this vision possible Recent Future
Topics to be covered (2)
Voluntary Participation Introduction to the National Coal Mining Geospatial Committee (NCMGC) Background information about NCMGC FY 2006 Significant Activities Highlights of Geospatial Questionnaire Results Sharing Coal Mining Data
What is Geospatial?
Geospatial “pertain[s] to the geographic location and characteristics of natural or constructed features and boundaries on, above, or below the earth’s surface” … term refers especially to data that are geographic and spatial in nature.
Coal mining geospatial data describes the geographic location and characteristics of the features and boundaries of coal mining operations on or below the earth’s surface.
Geospatial Supports SMCRA Business Processes
REGULATORY ACTIVITY BUSINESS PROCESSES DATA REQUIREMENTS WORK PRODUCT
Permit Review Geologic/ hydrologic evaluation Engineering calculation Records of geology, surface water, ground water samples; location of mining operations Engineering drawings, location of mining operations CHIA Bond Calculation Biological review Locations of environmental resources, cultural resources, mining operations FONSI, Decision Documents
Geospatial Supports SMCRA Business Processes (2)
REGULATORY ACTIVITY
Mine Site Inspection
BUSINESS PROCESSES
Inspection
DATA REQUIREMENTS
Location of mining operations
WORK PRODUCT
Inspection Report Enforcement Action Citizen Complaint Investigation Bond Release Request Investigation Locations of citizen and mining operations Report Bond release evaluation Location of mining operations, records of water quality Bond Release Report
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining accidents & disasters Recent • Inez, KY. slurry impoundment failure
Oct. 11, 2000 the nation's largest coal slurry spill occurred at the Martin County Coal Co., Inez, Ky. Far Exxon Valdez spill The 10/17/’01 greater in damage than the 1989 , this event dumped an estimated 306 million gallons of toxic sludge down 100 miles of waterways. MHSA report points to inaccurate mapping as the principal cause.
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining accidents & disasters Recent • Martin County slurry impoundment failure • Quecreek
MHSA's Quecreek accident report
,
July 24 th.
, cited faulty maps as a cause for the Quecreek Mine disaster in June 2002, where nine miners were trapped for 4 days. According to the report,
"The
primary cause of the water inundation was the use of an undated and uncertified mine map of the Harrison No.2 mine.“
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining accidents & disasters Recent • Martin County slurry impoundment failure • Quecreek • Sago
Local Trimble geodetic survey expert called in to survey spot to drill. Hours later drilling begins. The delay … establishing survey control required creating a link to a rover setting on a known point outside the permit boundary
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining accidents & disasters Recent • Martin County slurry impoundment failure • Quecreek • Sago • Aracoma
“Timmy Paul Morgan, who died Apr 9, ‘06 of a heart attack, gave a statement to an attorney representing the widow of Mr. Hatfield. In that statement, Mr. Morgan said rescue team members complained that the map of Aracoma to search for the missing men was inaccurate not exist.” they were given , showing doors and stoppings in places that did
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining accidents & disasters Recent • Martin County slurry impoundment failure • Quecreek • Sago • Aracoma • Black Castle fatality
On Feb. 1, ‘06, a dozer operator at Black Castle strip mine in Drawdy, WV was fatally injured due to ignition of natural gas. As the operator with 15 years experience was developing a drill bench, the blade ruptured a 16” low pressure, high-volume gas line. The MHSA's report stated that “Vira told Moss to stay 100 feet away from the gas line. Neither Vira nor Moss knew the exact location of the gas line .”
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining accidents & disasters Recent • Martin County • Quecreek • Sago • Aracoma • Black Castle • A Google search for
"mining accident" + map
yields 54,100 hits
Unfortunately the importance of accurate maps wasn’t even on the radar!!!
ceremony
That conclusion is based on …
Figure 12: General Spatially Related Terms 0 35 30 25 Word Count 20 15 10 5 0 SMCRA MINER Act Plans Survey Maps Map Map or plan
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets?
Mining disasters Recent Possible future mining emergencies may extending across state boundaries • A common national data structure and map accuracy standard will ………….
– save time trying to combine dissimilar dataset from adjoining states and – eliminate future poor spatial accuracy problems.
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets (2)?
Could allow MANY additional users of this new national information asset • Federal DOE, BLM, MSHA, etc.
• State Emergency response entities • Local County, municipal.
• Others interested in sharing geospatial data assets.
Why create unified national coal mining geospatial datasets (3)?
Could substantially enhance OSM’s e Permitting initiative.
Public’s right to know • Speed up the permit review process • Allow check for mining below properties changing hands (VA House Bill 1562) Subsidence • Proximity of impoundments and valley fills • Proximity to abandoned portals • Mining discharges
Technology improvements making this vision possible
Recent ArcGIS software accommodates data with different projections and/or datums in the same desktop session decided on.
that allows each state to keep data in the projection/datum already ALL mining data can share a core set of tabular attributes of national interest and still have unique tables containing all existing State/Tribe attributes.
Technology improvements making this vision possible (2)
Future ArcGIS 9.2 & Enterprise IT features
NCMG Data
• Database synchronization
State Data
Technology improvements making this vision possible (3)
Future ArcGIS 9.2 & enterprise IT features • Database synchronization • Versioned data replication
In 9.2 for the 1 st time a single logical database can be spread over several network nodes … allows a version of a geodatabase to be replicated to another geodatabase.
Technology improvements making this vision possible (4)
Future ArcGIS 9.2 enterprise features • Database synchronization • Versioned data replication • Nonversioned editing
At ArcGIS 9.2, multiuser editing is possible for the first time without versioning.
Technology improvements making this vision possible (5)
Future ArcGIS 9.2 enterprise features • Database synchronization • Versioned data replication • Nonversioned editing • Web-based services
In version 9.2 ArcGIS Server can provide “services” integrating geodata, globe (3-D), map (2-D), geoprocessing and locator functions.
NCMGC Startup History
OSM’s TIPS Program roots are
Previous OSM Director, Jeff Jarrett, and the Technical Innovation & Professional Services (TIPS) Steering Committee formed the NCMGC May 3-5, 2005 at the St. Louis committee meeting.
Setting members selected late FY 2005.
Supported by TIPS and operates as a partnership between OSM and the states.
Members represent the geospatial technology interests of the states, tribes, and OSM offices.
Representation includes the Interstate Mining Compact Commission (IMCC), National Association of Abandoned Mine Lands Programs (NAAMLP), and the Western Interstate Energy Board (WIEB).
Purpose of NCMGC
Promote development of geospatial technology to support SMCRA National forum to identify geospatial needs of SMCRA organizations Discover best practices Help implement change Help migration to enterprise GIS Improve business processes
NCMGC Members
Member
Bill Card Larry Evans Rick Koehler Len Meier Doug Mullins Alan Wilhelm
State
TN WV NM IL VA CO
* OSM Region States Mining Affiliation
N/A IMCC WIEB N/A NAAMLP N/A
Expertise Title IV &/or V
V IV (support) /V IV/V IV IV/V Vacant DC N/A N/A * Appalachian Region = Red, MCR = Green, WR = blue, HQ= brown
NCMGC’s Charter
Deliberative, advisory body Subject matter experts Represent SMCRA community Identify geospatial technology issues Facilitate sharing of geospatial technology Technical support personnel used to create technical support groups (TSGs) Supported by TIPS Report to Chief, TMD WR
NCMGC’s Technical Support Groups (TSGs)
Subject matter experts Extension of committee Advise committee on technical matters Short term tasking Cooperation among TSG members promotes sharing of technology
NCMGC Accomplishments FY 06
Held first meeting to plan work activities Determined geospatial technology development status of all SMCRA organizations via questionnaire Identified the Geospatial Data Steward (GDS) within each SMCRA organization Held the first National Meeting of SMCRA Geospatial Data Stewards Identified geospatial technology development needs of SMCRA organizations for FY 2007
NCMGC Accomplishments FY 06 (2)
Established a Standards Task Group from the Geospatial Data Stewards (GDSs) that volunteered to help develop national standards Obtained SDE and/or Relational Database Management System (RDBMS) training for a few qualified GDSs to facilitate their moving data to an enterprise environment.
Successfully completed a "proof of concept" project demonstrating exchange of selected coal mining spatial datasets between two networked servers inside OSM's Wide Area Network (WAN)
Highlights of Questionnaire Results
42 responses from SMCRA organizations 38 GSDs identified 38 SMCRA organizations use GIS 13 do not use MS SQL Server or Oracle 28 do not use ArcSDE 29 do not share spatial data by Internet 33 do not have a written GIS implementation plan
Highlights of Questionnaire Results (2)
Category Needs Accomplishments Goals Help from NCMGC Contribute/share Comments 1 Rank 2 3
Infrastructure (12) Using Data (14) Using Data (12) No Response (13) None (17) None (27) Personnel (6) Getting Data (12) Getting Data (10) Tech. Assist. (11) Tech. Assist. (10) Using Data (9) Training (5) None (6) None (8) Funding (9) Data (8) Tech. Assist. (5)
Geospatial Data Stewards
Category
Federal
Geospatial Data Steward Alternate Geospatial Data Steward No Geospatial Data Steward
8 1 1 State 27 3 3 Tribal 3 1 0
Coal Mining Spatial Data Standards ASTM Task Group
Held the first meeting at ASTM International headquarters September 20-21, 2006 Will hold 3 meetings in FY 07 to develop voluntary spatial data standards for the first 2 coal mining spatial data sets of national interest: surface coal mining boundaries and underground coal mining boundaries Standards for additional data sets to be determined later Press release on group and tasks in late 2006
Initial (’07) Coal Mining Datasets
Datasets common to SMCRA workers Surface mining boundaries Underground mining boundaries Quick index to location of other coal mining data Geographic locator of potential impacts
Surface Mining Boundaries
Surface mining boundaries are polygons representing the boundary of the permitted area of a surface coal mining operation as described on the most recent mining operations map contained in a coal mining permit approved by the regulatory authority . Each approved permit has a single record in a spatial database of surface mining boundaries. Each record in the spatial database identifies the of the surface coal mining operation and contains one or more polygons identifying the areas for conducting surface coal mining operations approved by the regulatory authority .
permit number
Surface Mining Boundary
Underground Mining Boundary
Underground mining boundaries are polygons representing the boundary of the underground mine workings of an underground coal mining operation as described on the best available mine workings maps .
Each mine has a single record in a spatial database of underground mining extents. Each record in the spatial database identifies the underground coal mining operation and contains one or more polygons identifying the areas of underground mine workings.
Underground Mining Boundary
Coal Mining Data is a National Information Asset
Executive Order 12906
Public access to geospatial data
Sec. 3(c) OMB Circular No. A-16
Themes of national significance
Appendix E
Applies to all agencies using spatial data Applies to all spatial activities funded with federal funds
Sec 6.
Sec 2.b.(1) and Sec 5.
Agency responsibilities and reporting requirements
Sec 8.a.
Spatial data are subject to Exhibit 300
Sec 8.b.
Applicable Requirements
Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 (SMCRA) Executive Order 12906, Coordinating Geographic Data Acquisition and Access: The National Spatial Data Infrastructure OMB Circular No. A-16, Coordination of Geographic Information and Related Spatial Data Activities OMB Circular No. A-130, Management of Federal Information Resources Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996, formerly the Information Technology Management Reform Act E-Government Act of 2002, Section 216, Common Protocols for Geographic Information Systems Paperwork Reduction Act (P.L. 104-13) Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) President’s Management Agenda Expanded e-Government Government reuse of data Sharing information among government agencies Automate internal processes to reduce cost
NCMGC Plans FY 07
Hold a meeting to review and implement recommendations from the first National Meeting of SMCRA Geospatial Data Stewards Provide briefings to OSM management and SMCRA organizations on the accomplishments and progress of the NCMGC in its activities Send additional qualified personnel to attend vendor software training in managing coal mining geospatial data in an enterprise environment Establish a planning sub-committee to begin preparations for an FY 08 National Meeting of SMCRA Geospatial Data Stewards with a theme of “Integrating GIS into SMCRA Business Processes” Continue development work on a geospatial infrastructure to exchange selected coal mining spatial datasets among networked servers outside OSM's WAN Recruit state regulatory programs to participate in this geospatial infrastructure Conduct an outreach program by giving presentations about NCMGC activities at national meetings of SMCRA organizations; Explore participation with MSHA
Outcomes of the Geospatial Initiative
SAVE
Accurate bond release determinations
LIVES!
Fewer cases of CO Reduced offsite impacts Verifiable annual reports for both states and OSM 2 gas buildup in homes