Transcript Document
PBS and Transition to
Adulthood
Vincent Winterling, Ed.D.
Statewide Director, Delaware Autism Program
Director, Vincent Winterling, Ed.D., LLC Consultants
Objectives
Define and describe Positive Behavior Support (PBS)
Define and describe the Lifestyle Planning Process
Review essential elements of the FBA process
Review essential elements of Behavior Intervention Plans
Review (if time permits) why plans fail
Define and Describe Positive
Behavior Support
What is PBS?
Applied science
Use of educational methods
Expand individual’s repertoire
Systems change methods
Redesign and individual’s living (or learning) environment
Achieve quality of life
Minimize problem behavior
PBS: Foundational Considerations
Teach skills to increase likelihood of success in important
domains
Teach, strengthen, expand positive behavior
Utilize systems change to increase opportunities for the
display of positive behavior
PBS: Overarching Goals
Assist individual’s lifestyle to evolve such that all in the
student’s world have experience of change
Render problem behavior irrelevant, inefficient, and
ineffective by helping individual achieve goals in socially
appropriate manner.
Positive Behavior Support
Differs from traditional approaches to behavior
support
Function rather than form
Proactive rather than reactive
Functional Skills
Positive
Individualized
Long-term goals
Multi-component / comprehensive
PBS: Underlying Assumptions
Challenging behaviors need to be understood within the
contexts in which they occur.
Challenging behaviors serve a function or purpose for the
individual.
Effective interventions are based on a understanding of the
individual, the social contexts in which they participate, and
the purpose/function of their challenging behavior.
PBS emphasizes person-centered planning and values that
respect the dignity, preferences, diversity, and goals of each
individual.
PBS: Defining Characteristics
PBS is assessment based. Interventions are directly linked
to environmental influences and hypotheses concerning the
function of challenging behavior.
PBS plans are comprehensive, usually involving multiple
interventions.
PBS is proactive, involving teaching alternative skills and
adapting the environment.
PBS emphasizes carrying out assessment and intervention
practices in typical settings that are inclusive in order to
promote lifestyle enhancements.
PBS: Defining Charactertics
PBS considers the values, beliefs, and goals of family
members in the assessment and treatment planning
process.
PBS is sensitive to the resources available to families and
the constraints they face.
PBS looks to build on the strengths of family members and
address areas of need.
PBS has a broad view of success that includes (a)
increasing the use of alternative skills, decreasing the
incidence of challenging behaviors, and making
improvements in quality of life.
Define and Describe Lifestyle
Planning Process
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
School Age (3 to 12 Years)
Family Issues
Educational Focus
Adjusting to educational
Communication
systems (IEPs; placement;
Social Skills
support services)
Play
Developing advocacy skills
Self-care
Dealing with reactions from
School-based and
peers groups and
Academics
community
Domestic
Locating community
Community
resources
Maintaining a healthy
family process
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
Adolescence (13 to 17 Years)
Family Issues
Addressing emerging
sexuality
Dealing with peer rejection
and isolation
Addressing more serious
behavioral issues
Estate/Trust planning
Redefining parental roles
and expectations
Learning about post-21
services
Educational Focus
Vocational
Domestic
Self-care
Community
Communication
Social Skills
Recreation
Functional Academics
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
Launching (17 to 21 Years)
Family Issues
Adjusting emotionally to
having an adult
son/daughter with special
needs
Residential issues
Financial and guardianship
planning
Developing advocacy skills
for adults
Educational Focus
Vocational
Domestic
Self-care
Community
Communication
Social Skills
Recreation
Functional Academics
Transition Planning
Carefully planned process
Initiated by any team member
To establish a plan for either additional training or
employment
At least 3-5 years prior to the transition target date
Must involve the majority of IDT members and an
employer or service providers, as needed
Transition Planning Best Practices:
Needs of Individuals with
Disabilities
Transition planning must be comprehensive to meet the
individual’s total life needs.
Criterion of Ultimate Functioning (historical)
Quality of Life
Case Conceptualization:
Treatment Considerations
What are the goals we should be pursuing for our group of
learners?
How much of what we do could be considered current
within the field of special education and ABA?
With respect to Behavior Intervention Planning should we
be positively focused, assessment driven, and governed by
EBP?
How much of what we do could be labeled as Positive
Behavior Support?
If we can’t be more exclusively positive what barriers prevent
it?
Case Conceptualization: What are
the priorities?
What are the priorities for the Support Plan?
Who determines them?
What is the process for that determination?
What is a reasonable (i.e., balanced) program of skill
enhancement and behavior intervention?
How is that determination made?
Are there children for whom our model is ineffective?
How do we make that determination?
How do we resolve that?
Do we track them in any way?
Case Conceptualization:
Assessment
What is our assessment protocol?
For whom is it provided? When?
How do we link the findings of assessment to an active plan
of skill enhancement (i.e., teaching) to behavior intervention?
How is it used specifically for program planning?
Is it proceduralized? And / or systematized in any way?
Case Conceptualization:
Treatment Considerations
How much of what we do includes providing either negative
consequences / coercion / punishment to the children /
youth in our care?
To what extent does the professional literature guide
intervention planning / implementation for our students?
Do we follow any specific guidelines?
Should we have guidelines for practice within our
system?
How much does the analysis of the results of formative data
collection processes impact on our intervention process?
Is there a system level process for managing these
data?
Case Conceptualization: Additional
Treatment Considerations
Context for intervention – positive, organized milieu (e.g.,
classroom management)?
Presence of supervision, monitoring, and quality
management systems
Orientation to collaborative teaming
Mediator analysis
Lifestyle Interventions
Considerations (Turnbull & Turnbull, 1996):
Interdependence
Inclusion
Contribution
Lifestyle Interventions
Long-range outcomes (Risley, 1996):
How is the person doing overall over time?
Is she or he happy, satisfied, and safe?
Does the person have a stable home and family
and friends on which to base her or his life and
future, and after whom to model her or his ways?
Is she or he practicing independence,
productivity, and integration?
Is the person continuing to develop new
interests, new friends, and new skills?
Lifestyle Intervention Components
(Hedeen, Ayers, Meyer & Waite, 1996)
Relationships with others
Ecological factors and setting variables
Communication and understanding
Activity preferences
Meaningful curriculum
Choice and self-determination
User-friendly evaluation strategies
Best Practices
Focus Upon Quality of Life Indicators
Choices and control
Opportunities to participate in preferred activities
Community inclusion
Peer relationships
Relationships with family members
Increased independence across settings
Expressive and receptive communication
Are they happy most of the time?
Person-Centered
Planning
The Philosophy
Person-Centered Planning is build on a philosophy that does
the following
Takes a capacity-based perspective of the individual
Uses natural resources to fulfill a vision
Builds a circle of support for the individual that includes friends,
family and service providers
What is Person-Centered
Planning?
Person-Centered Planning allows a diverse group of people
who share a common goal or need to align their”
Vision, Purposes and goals
Understanding of the focus person’s past, present and
future; and
Actions for change, mutual support, personal and team
development, and learning.
Person-Centered Planning is a planning process
But PCP can also be seen as an assessment tool in that it
evaluates where the person has been, what their
environment is like now, and where they would like to go in
the future.
What is Person-Centered
Planning?
PCP can also be an intervention.
PCP has the potential to create and build a strong and
effective team dedicated to supporting the individual with
problem behavior, and well as each other.
What Person-Centered Planning is
NOT:
An easy, one-shot process
The answer to all problems
The replacement for an IEP
A quick fix solution to complex human and/or organizational
problems
Something to be done and forgotten
A guarantee
5 Essential Goals of PCP
Being present and participating in community (school) life
Gaining and maintaining satisfying relationships
Expressing preferences and making choices in everyday life
Having opportunities to fulfill respected roles and live in
dignity
Continuing to develop personal competencies
Different Approaches
Different Approaches
A Sample Person-Centered Plan
Britney
Sample MAP Pages
Sample Relationship Map
Relationship maps are used to find out who is currently
involved with the focus person's life and in what capacity. By
mapping relationships in this way, it allows conscious changes
and developments to be planned and made to the benefit of the
focus person
Sample PATH - Planning Alternative Tomorrows
with Hope
Using the focus person's dreams as a starting point, a PATH is used to help plan the
steps necessary to achieve those dreams and aspirations. The PATH helps to make
clear who's help is needed, how to go back enrolling appropriate assistance, who
will help with what, the first steps to be taken, 6 monthly goals, and so on.
Sample page from an
Independent Living proposal
Sample pages from a kitchen
guide/cookbook
Essential FBA Components
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
Design and Delivery of PBS Plans
Step 1:
Step 2:
Step 3:
Step 4:
Step 5:
Conduct an FBA
Develop a hypothesis statement
Design PBS plan
Evaluate plan effectiveness
Modify plan as needed
Steps for Conducting a Functional
Assessment and Developing a BIP
Identify and operationally define target
behavior
Purpose: To identify (and prioritize
behaviors that interfere with learning,
productivity, and general well-being
and agree on exact topography
Strategies: Group consensus
FBA: Pre-intervention Assessment
Identify contextual variables that evolve and maintain
adaptive behavior.
Identify functional relations that maintain challenging
behaviors (environment and challenging behaviors), both
proximal and distal.
Steps for Conducting a Functional
Assessment and Developing a BIP
Assess the student’s behavior
Purpose: To identify activities and events
associated with occurrences and
nonoccurrences of the problem behavior
Strategies: Questionnaires, checklists,
conversations, structured interviews,
direct observations
Understanding the Individual with
Problem Behavior
Gather Broad Information
Individuals strengths and skill limitations (communication,
social skills, self-help skills, play, recreation and leisure).
Daily Routines and Activities
Preferences and Goals for the Future
Medical/Health related Issues
Quality of Life Considerations: (opportunities for choice,
exercising control, experiencing social relationships,
participating in inclusive settings)
Understanding the Individual with
Problem Behavior
Gather Specific Information
When is the individual most and least likely to engage in
challenging behaviors?
What specific events appear to be contributing to the
challenging behavior?
What functions do the challenging behavior serve for the
individual (i.e., what are they communicating)?
Steps for Conducting a Functional
Assessment and Developing a BIP
Develop hypotheses
Purpose: To formulate data-based (based on assessment
information) hypotheses about why behavior occurs
Strategies: Review all assessment information; Develop
hypothesis statements that identify variables that can be
manipulated to formulate an intervention
Developing Hypotheses
Strategy:
Review assessment information
Develop hypotheses statements about why behavior is occurring
Steps for Conducting a Functional
Assessment and Developing a BIP
Assess the accuracy of the
hypotheses (optional step)
Purpose: To evaluate whether
hypotheses are accurate prior to
formulating an intervention
Strategies: Brief reversals
Summary Statements
Purpose: to offer and explanation of the problem behavior in
terms of antecedent and setting events and possible function
Content of Summary Statements
Description of antecedent and/or setting events
Description of problem behavior
Identification of presumed function
Examples of Summary Statements
When Amy is given difficult work (antecedent) she
engages in property destruction (behavior) to escape
the task (function).
When Rob has a cold (setting event) and is asked to
perform a difficult task (antecedent) he engages in selfinjury (behavior) to escape the task (function).
When Sally is left alone without anything to do
(antecedent) she engages in hand mouthing (behavior)
to gain sensory stimulation (function).
When Tommy is in large groups (antecedent) he
engages in aggression (behavior) to obtain attention
(function)
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
All Behavior
Serves a Purpose or
“Function”
Behavior
Gain Access to a
Desirable
Stimulus or Event
Escape/Avoid
an Undesirable
Stimulus or Event
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
Escape or Avoid...
Non-Preferred
Object or Activity
(Task)
Social
Interaction
Adults
Peers
Sensory
Stimulation
Steps for Conducting a Functional
Assessment and Developing a BIP
Design an intervention/support
plan
Purpose: To formulate an intervention
that is directly linked to the hypotheses
Strategies: Consider contextual fit
Steps for Conducting a Functional
Assessment and Developing a BIP
Collect data on effectiveness of
intervention/support plan
Purpose: To assure plan effectively
reduces problem behavior and increases
desirable behavior
Strategies: Direct observation; Review
permanent products, natural documents
Essential Plan Components
Developing Behavior Intervention
Plans
Based on hypotheses established in the assessment
process.
Person Centered in that goals and intervention strategies
preserve the individuals’ dignity, and reflect their preferences.
Individualized to reflect a good fit between the person’s
needs and corresponding intervention strategies.
Best Practices
Among other components, the written PBSP contains
a description of antecedent modifications, functionally
equivalent alternative responses (and teaching
strategies), differential reinforcement systems, and
consequences designed to eliminate or minimize
reinforcement after undesirable responses
Objective data is used to determine program
effectiveness and to guide modifications in the PBSP
Outline of a Behavior Support Plan
Set Up (description, strengths, vision)
Assessment
Operational Descriptions, Routines, FA Hypotheses
Foundations (if needed)
Prevention
Teaching/Education
Consequence Procedures
Minimize reward for problem behavior
Ensure regular, clear reward for positive behavior
Punishers (if needed)
Define safety/emergency procedures (if needed)
Evaluation and Monitoring for Improvement
Steps for implementation
Why Should a Support Plan be
Multicomponent?
Many variables usually influence whether problem behavior
will occur; therefore effective support most often involves
manipulation of several of these variables
Long-term reduction in problem behavior usually requires
intervention in several areas
Best Practices
Comprehensive Staff Training and Support
Pre-service and in-service training and workshops
Performance checklists
Ongoing supervisory feedback and support (structured classroom
observations, supervision meetings, and so on)
Weekly classroom team meetings
Best Practices
Family Inclusion and Support
Participate fully in planning
Updated routinely on child’s progress
Frequent opportunities to communicate with staff
Access to informational seminars and training on interventions
and strategies
Futures planning
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
Common Elements of Good Interventions
A comprehensive assessment of skills is completed
Targeted skills are meaningful to the student and will facilitate
independence
Lessons are designed to enhance student motivation
Spontaneity is taught early on
Communication training occurs across environments and across
the student day
Communicative responses that are taught can be understood by
all members of the community
Change Behavior Successfully
Prioritize and work with only 1 or 2 behaviors at a time
Require only gradual improvement in behavior
Use procedures that are easily implemented and inexpensive
(to the extent possible)
Use immediate consequences whenever possible
Change Behavior Successfully
Teach the behaviors you want to see the individuals exhibit
Use and fade prompts to increase the likelihood of
appropriate behavior
Pair social reinforcers with tangible or activity reinforcers
Thoroughly organize and precisely introduce the program to
the individual
Steps for Changing Behavior
Decide on which behavior to change
Operationally define the behavior
Collect data for a baseline on the behavior
Intervene on the behavior
Graph and evaluate the ongoing process
Revise the program if needed
Interventionists To-do List
Consider the use of program-wide rules
Limit to no more than 5 sspecific, observable, and
positively stated
Post rules in prominent places
Develop a plan for providing frequent positive feedback for
following rules and routines.
Develop consequences for common rule infractions
(consequence should fit the violation and be as mild as
possible)
Develop an attention signal
Design routines for most common procedures in the
setting
Interventionists To-do List
Analyze the physical setting and modify if needed and
possible
Develop lessons and provide regular review of rules and
routines
Design activities to maximize engagement in meaningful
tasks
Set and plan to achieve goals to improve instructional
delivery
Things to Remember!
Let the data drive your hypothesis development
Individuals may engage in problem behavior for a variety of
reasons
A single problem behavior may serve more than one function
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
PBSP
Components of a PBSP
Antecedent Strategies
Functional Equivalence Training
Differential Reinforcement
Consequence Strategies
Evaluation and Modification
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
Characteristics of PBSP
Based on assessment results and hypothesis driven
Emphasizes skill building
Comprehensive, usually involving multiple intervention
components
Focus on long-term solutions, not quick fixes
Team approach
Function rather than form
Categories of Intervention
Establishing
Operations
Ameliorate
Eliminate
Immediately
Before
Behavior
Relative to
Function
Antecedent
Manipulations
General Skills
Training
Equivalence
Training
Self-Regulation
Training
After
Behavior
Instructional
Consequence
Reduction
Oriented
Consequence
What are Antecedent
Interventions?
Environmental modifications that are made to reduce the
likelihood that problem behavior will occur
Antecedent interventions are arranged before the problem
behavior occurs
What are Antecedent
Interventions?
Environmental modifications that are made to reduce the
likelihood that problem behavior will occur
Antecedent interventions are arranged before the problem
behavior occurs
Replacement Behavior
Behavior that serves the same function as the problem
behavior but is socially appropriate
How Can We Assure Appropriate Behavior
Will Replace Problem Behavior?
Make it effective:
Reinforcement should always be
provided at first
Make it efficient:
Response should be less effortful than
problem behavior
Reinforcement should occur
frequently and quickly
Rationale for Alternative Skills
Instruction
Individuals do not have the general skills to cope with
everyday demands; therefore, problem behaviors occur
Categories of Alternative Skills
General skills
Self-management skills
Coping and tolerance skills
Purpose of Consequences
To teach alternative responses to problematic situations
To respond to problem behavior in a way that is least likely to
reinforce it
Consequence Approaches
Feedback
Problem Solving
Response Cost
Time Out
Restitution
Extinction (Ignore)
Natural Consequences
Advantages/Disadvantages
Copyrighted Material of Devereux
CARES
PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER
Design intervention that
Look at behaviors,
teaches child more
assess, identify function
acceptable behaviors
Why Plans Fail
Failure is not an
option…
(but does happen)
Failure is not inescapable BUT its
impact can be minimized
You cannot strive to serve the most challenging students
and escape failure
Failure per se is less of a problem than the refusal to
acknowledge and act upon it
At every Devereux Center, at any given time, every
Psychologist and school has a failed BMP
The center has a student whose failed BMP
leaves someone open to injury or other risk
management issue.
Why are plans for high risk
students more likely to fail?
Behaviors can result from a broad range of biopsychosocial
factors and / or skill deficits
Student’s cognitive / skill level
Variable mood / affect
Psychiatric issues
Abuse / victimization history
May have more limited range of education / interests / positive
influences
Poor case conceptualization / training / implementation of plan
What did we miss?
Plan is not proactive
We missed something in the data?
Staff not trained sufficiently to implement plan successfully
Plan is not positive
Plan does not teach new skills (new skills take time to learn)
Plan was not given sufficient time to work
Plan contains unintended aversives that cause behavior
deterioration
Team is not a team