Transcript Slide 1
Integrating Religion and
Spirituality into Clinical Practice
Objectives
To become familiar with empirical
data that connects religion and
spirituality in clinical practice
To gain understanding on how
people grow and develop from a
religious and spiritual perspective
Book Information
Marsha Wiggins Frame (2003).
Integrating Religion and Spirituality
into Counseling: A Comprehensive
Approach. Pacific Grove, CA:
Brooks/Cole
Objectives
To develop skills on specific
strategies for working with patients’
religious and spiritual issues
To acquire expertise in using
spiritual interventions that promote
healing and transformation
Objectives
To refine skills in applying religious
and spiritual counseling strategies
with families
To explore ethical concerns related
to religious and spiritual
interventions in clinical practice
Definitions: Spirituality
and Religion
Spirituality involves:
Animating life force
Images: wind, breath, vigor,
courage
Innate capacity that moves people
toward love, meaning, hope
transcendence, connectedness &
compassion
Definitions: Spirituality
and Religion
Capacity for growth, creativity, values
Encompasses religion
May or may not involve God or a
Higher Power
Less a method than an attitude
Definitions: Spirituality
and Religion
Religion
Set of beliefs and practices of
an organized institution
Denominational
External
Public
Definitions: Spirituality
and Religion
Cognitive
Behavioral
Ritualistic
Doctrine and dogma
Community
Polity
Relationships Between
Spirituality and Religion
Spiritual, but not religious
Religious, but not spiritual
Spiritual and religious
Neither religious nor spiritual
Pelikan’s Paradigm: Spirit
vs. Structure
Pelikan (1968) used paradigm to
describe Luther’s role in the Protestant
Reformation
Institutional structures squelching God’
spirit
Free-floating spirituality needs
structure to mediate its power
Clinical Implications
Avoid making assumptions about
patients’ worldviews, spirituality, or
religion
Inquire about how patients’ make
meaning in their lives—especially the
meaning about illness, trauma and
death
Clinical Implications
Ask how you may best serve patients’
religious or spiritual needs given your
professional role
Actively invest in learning about
patients’ religious or spiritual
perspectives
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality & Health
Extensive empirical studies reveal that
acitvely religious people have lower
rates of many physical disorders
ranging from cancer to heart disease.
Mortality rates are lower.
Coping with death and other stressors
is better
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality & Health
Recovery rates from almost
everything, including surgery are
better for religiously active individuals
(Larson & Larson, 1994)
A TIME survey in 1996 revealed that
over 70% of patients polled believed
that spiritual faith and prayer help in
illness recover
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality & Health
64% of those surveyed believed
physicians should talk to patients
about spiritual issues as part of their
care and pray with patients if they
request it
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality & Health
One of the strongest predictors of
survival after heart surgery is the
degree to which patients draw
strength from religion or spirituality,
and the more religious they are the
greater their protection from death
(Oxman, Freeman, & Manheimer,
1995).
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality & Health
Weekly church attendees have been
found to have 50% fewer deaths from
coronary artery disease, 56% fewer
deaths from emphysema, 74% fewer
deaths from cirrhosis and 53% fewer
suicides (Comstock, & Partridge, 1972)
Why?
Levin (1995) suggested:
Religiously affiliated people have a
secure sense of identity which lowers
their anxiety level and facilitates
resiliency under stress
Religion & spirituality provide meaning
and purpose that allow for rational
interpretations of life problems
Why?
Positive emotions of hope, faith,
optmism, and catharsis emerge from
beliefs and ritualis, including the
process of forgiveness and the hope of
healing and redemption.
Religious people experience social
support through community
Why?
Religion and spirituality that offer
prayer, ritual, worship provide
experiences of communion between
the individual and the Higher Power
Many beliefs lead to a healthy and
responsible lifestyle
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality and Mental
Health
There is a favorable association
between religiousness and suicide risk,
drug use, alcohol abuse, delinquent
behavior, and criminal behavior
(Gartner, Larson & Allen, 1991)
Couples who attend church regularly
as less likely to divorce—of course
they may stay unhappily married!
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality and Mental
Health
However, further research revealed
religious folk were more satisfied in
their marriages than were the less
religious. (Gartner, et. al, 1991)
In fact, church attendance predicted
marital satisfaction better than any of
8 other variables (Glen & Weaver,
1978)
Empirical Data on Religion,
Spirituality and Mental
Health
There is a positive relationship
between religion & spirituality and
overall well-being.
Religious persons reported lower levels
of depression than did those who were
not so religious (Gartner, et. al, 1991)
Conclusion: Religion & spirituality are
integral to clinical work
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Why they are useful:
Provide framework for
understanding how patients
incorporate their faith
Assist in assessing patients’
religious and spiritual growth
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Why they are useful
Externalize religious and
spiritual perspectives and
reduce practitioner reactivity
Provide tools for practitioners to
make sense of their own
religious and spiritual journeys
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Make practitioners more open to a
variety of religious and spiritual
beliefs and expressions
May be useful in helping patients or
clients understand their own
perspectives vis a vis these
frameworks
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
CAVEATS:
These models are linear and
hierarchical. As such they imply
that higher stages are “better.”
They do not allow for circularity
or movement between stages
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
These models are all based on
western world views. That is,
they are more focused on
individualism rather than
collectivism. As such, they are
not particularly useful with
patients who hold eastern
worldviews.
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
GORDON ALLPORT: The
development of religious sentiments
(1950)
Three stages: Raw Credulity, Satisfying
Rationalism, Religious Maturity
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 1: RAW CREDULITY
Children believe everything they
hear about religion and spirituality
Children cling to their beliefs
because of the bond with their
parents
“Authority based” approach
Sometimes continues to adulthood
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 2: SATISFYING RATIONALISM
Begins in adolescence
Questioning previously held beliefs
Rebellion/rejection of parental
values
Some youth retain their childhood
values & beliefs
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 3: RELIGIOUS MATURITY
Occurs after adolescence
Ability to remain connected to a
tradition but approach it critically
Keep meaningful beliefs; reject
those that do not make sense
Religion & spirituality are positive
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Some adults retain childhood faith
Other adults have more faith than
doubt
Other adults have equal amounts of
doubt and faith
Some never reach “religious maturity”
Some have meaningful life without
religion or spirituality
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
JAMES FOWLER: Faith Development
Influenced by Piaget’s theory of
cognitive development
Influenced by Kohlberg’s theory of
moral development
Also influenced by Erik Erickson and
John Dewey
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Based on an empirical study of 359
individuals
For Fowler faith has more to do with
a dynamic, trusting orientation toward
life, others, and God, than with the
more static notion of faith as believing
beliefs
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
About the stages:
There are 7
They are invariant, sequential,
hierarchical
It is not possible to skip stages
Some people stay in one stage
for long period of their lives
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
About the stages:
Sometimes they overlap as people
transition to the next stage
They are not content specific
Fowler claims that lower stages are
not inferior, but he has been
challenged on this point
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 1: PRIMAL FAITH (Infancy)
Trust in caregivers is developed
in infancy
They learn that caregivers are
reliable
Corresponds to Erikson’s stage
of trust vs. mistrust
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 2: INTUITIVE PROJECTIVE
FAITH (Early Childhood)
Images of God and faith are
reflections of children’s relationships
with parents and other significant
adults
Children in this stage do not have
the capacity for logical thinking
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 3: MYTHIC-LITERAL (Middle
Childhood and Beyond)
Concrete thinking
People appropriate the myths,
stories, beliefs, symbols of their
traditions
God’s characteristics are
anthropomorphic
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Stage 3: Mythic-Literal continued…
God rewards good, punishes evil
Many people in this stage get
disillusions when they discover that
“bad things happen to good people.”
Adults can also remain in this stage
Some entire congregations (often
fundamentalist) are in this stage
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 4: SYNTHETIC-CONVENTIONAL
(Puberty to Adulthood)
Ability to think abstractly
Faith is constructed in terms of
conformity to a set of values and
beliefs with deference to authority
Faith stabilizes identity & worldview
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Synthetic Conventional continued…
Beliefs and values are typically
unexamined
Yearning for a personal relationship
with God or Higher Power
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 5:
INDIVIDUATIVE=REFLECTIVE Faith
(Young Adulthood)
Critical examination of faith
Take responsibility for their
worldview
Commit through conscious choice
rather than unexamined acceptance
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 6: CONJUNCTIVE FAITH
Usually emerges in midlife and
beyond
People acknowledge multiple
perspectives as valid
Integrate polarities
Openness to difference while
grounded in own worldview & belief
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Conjunctive faith continued…
Most adults do not reach this stage
God is experienced as both personal
and abstract
Life is considered both rational and
mysterious
Second naivete—reclaiming past
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Conjunctive faith continued…
Develop a passion for justice
It is rare that one moves beyond
this stage
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 7: UNIVERSALIZING FAITH
Only a few people in this category
(2-3 people/1000)
People are “grounded in oneness
with the power of being or God”
(Fowler, 1991).
Activists for justice
Examples: MLK, Jr. Mother Teresa
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
VICKY GENIA’S THEORY
Based on psychoanalytic theory
Acknowledges that development is
not always linear or smooth
Peaks and plateaus
Emotional problems may cause
people to adopt unhealthy faith
forms
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 1: Egocentric Faith
Religion is rooted in fear and needs
for comfort
People here reenact their
relationships with their parents in
their relationship with God
Self deprecation or perfectionistic
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 2: Dogmatic faith
Devotion to earning God’s love and
approval
Gravitate toward groups that focus
on self-denial
Allegiance to religious authority
Often intolerant of diversity and
ambiguity
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 3: Transitional Faith
Examine tenets of faith
Open to exploring new spiritual
paths
Might switch affiliations
Doubt leads to spiritual growth
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 4: Reconstructed Faith
People at this stage choose a faith
that meets their needs
They are aware of human
limitations
Strong sense of internalized morals
and ideals
Conform to religious behavior codes
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Reconstructed Faith continued…
They relate to God as a caring,
reliable parent who is an ally and
source of sustenance
They may still have trouble with
ambiguity and multifaceted
dimensions of spirituality
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
STAGE 5: Transcendent Faith
Committed to universal ideals and
experience community with others
of diverse faiths
This stage is rare
Lifestyle consistent with values
Integration of reason & emotion
Models of Religious and
Spiritual Development
Transcendent faith continued…
They are committed without
absolute certainty
Eliminated egocentricity, magical
thinking and anthropomorphisms
Acknowledge the reality of evil and
suffering
CASE STUDY
Betty is a 42 year old White female
who has been hospitalized because of
a blood clot in her leg. The hospital
chaplain visited Betty and they spoke
about her faith. Betty indicated she
wasn’t sure anymore about her belief
in God. Although she was raised in a
strict Presbyterian home, she said she
CASE STUDY
Had doubts about whether God really
hears prayer. She also wonders if
Christianity is really the only “true”
religion. She admits that her illness
has caused her to think about things
she has previously accepted “on faith.”
CASE STUDY
Which of Fowler’s stages seems to
best fit for Betty?
Which of Genia’s stages seems to best
represent Betty’s story?
How would you suggest the chaplain
talk with Betty about her faith?
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Refrain from assuming that you do not
have the ability or experience to talk
with patients’ about religion or
spirituality
Be careful not to impose your own
belief system on patients
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
View the patient as a whole person.
Avoid splitting religious and spiritual
issues from health or psychological
concerns.
Accept patients’ religious or spiritual
stories as just that without attempting
to reframe them as psychological
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
A Social Contructionist Perspective
Holds that our thoughts and images
about reality are subjective creations
rather than objective
representations (Luken & Lukens,
1988)
Allows multiple points of view about
a single issue or problem
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
People construct their worldview as a
result of interactions with others in a
social context and the belief systems,
values, fears, prejudices, hopes and
disappointments of the constructor.
It involves working within the patients’
own belief systems and values
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Three umpires are sitting around and
one says, “There’s balls and there’s
strikes and I call ‘em the way they
are.” Another says, “There’s balls and
there’s strikes and I call ’em the way I
see’ em.” The third says, “There’s balls
and there’s strikes and they ain’t
nothing until I call ‘em.” (Anderson,
1990)
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
CHALLENGES:
Should I disclose anything about my
religious/spiritual beliefs?
What about patients’ religious
authorities?
What about my own issues?
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
SHOULD I DISCLOSE?
Patients often ask about caregivers’
personal beliefs. Why?
Interest
Fear of being devalued
Testing trust
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Other reasons:
Nonreligious patients may worry
that caregivers will judge them
negatively
They may worry that nonreligious
caregivers may not understand or
respond to their belief systems
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Another reason…
Some patients fear that religious
caregivers may use their situation as
an opportunity to convert them
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
SHOULD I SELF-DISCLOSE?
Some experts believe that caregivers’
self-disclosure interferes with patients’
own self-exploration
Others believe exposing one’s beliefs
build rapport and offers clarity
Kelly (1995) suggests deflection of direct
questions may be helpful:
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Example 1:
“I value your question, especially
because it suggests something of
importance to you. Rather than
respond directly, I think it might be
helpful if you were to talk more about
your belief and how it is helpful to
you.”
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Example 2:
“ It sounds like you are concerned that
if my beliefs are different form yours
that I might try to convince you to
change them and that would not be
acceptable to you.”
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Example 3:
“Maybe you are worried that I won’t
take your religious or spiritual
concerns seriously or that it isn’t safe
to raise these topics with me. I want
you to know you can trust me to
respect your beliefs.”
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
WHAT ABOUT PATIENTS’ RELIGIOUS
AUTHORITIES?
Definition: the power to influence or
command thought, opinion, or
behavior
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
WHAT ABOUT PATIENTS’ RELIGIOUS
AUTHORITIES?
Parents
Bible
Doctrine
Clergy/ Bishops/Pope
Catechism
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
The more significant the authority, the
less power I have in client’s life (unless
I happen to be an authoritative person
such as clergy)
Be careful about direct challenges to
patient authorities because you may
not be taken seriously
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Talk openly with patients about their
religious/spiritual authorities so you
can learn about how they function
Use religious/spiritual authorities as
tools in clinical practice.
Example: Talk with patients’ about
Biblical texts that are important to
them
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Consult with religious or spiritual
authorities themselves. It may be
helpful to invite them to participate in
your work with a particular patient
Some patients will respond only to
religious authorities whom they trust.
Referral can be in order
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
WHAT ABOUT MY OWN ISSUES?
It is imperative to become aware of
one’s own issues as a clinical
practitioner
Clients issues may become “clinical
triggers” for caregivers
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
When patients have issues that are
similar to the caregivers’ issues the the
caregivers are more vulnerable to
being pulled into their patient’s system
Countertransference reactions are
common
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Examples:
Nonreligious practitioners
Rejection of family religion/values
Being in a similar stage as patient
Loss and trauma
Social and/or political difference
Clergy abuse
Working with Patients’
Religious and Spiritual
Issues
Addressing one’s own issues:
Seek peer consultation
Embrace supervision
Enter personal therapy
Refer patient
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
GENERAL GUIDELINES
Address personal issues first
Avoid imposing your values
Establish a trusting relationship
Know the norms of your setting
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
GUIDELINES CONT’D…
Be gentle with confrontation
Seek consultation with peers and
experts
Uncover patients’ sources of support
Keep patients’ best interest at heart
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
SPIRITUAL JOURNALING
1. Tool for self-discovery
2. Safety valve for emotions
3. Mirror for the spirit
4. Some patients may write prayers
5. Some may want to share contents
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
SPIRITUAL BIBLIOTHERAPY
Allows patients to express concerns
that may be outside awareness
Compare own thoughts to those of
others
Problem-solving information
Promotes anxiety reduction
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
GUIDELINES FOR SPIRITUAL
BIBLIOTHERAPY
Read the books you recommend!
Be sure the book is a good fit for
the patient
Avoid books that present “band-aid”
solutions to complex problems
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
GUIDELINES CONT’D…
Select books that support patients’
emotional and spiritual health
Seek recommendations for
colleagues, clergy, mental health
professionals
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
SCRIPTURE & SACRED TEXTS
Work within patients’ belief systems
Avoid power struggles & debates
Be prepared to refer
Make use of metaphor and narrative
(Richards & Bergin, 1997)
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Jonathan is a 34-year-old Jewish attorney
and local politician. He came to counseling
because he was "torn apart by guilt over an
affair he had had with a colleague."
Although he and his wife, Patti, are currently
involved in couples therapy with another
counselor, Jonathan sought out Joshua, a
Jewish chaplain, to help him address his
guilt and self-loathing.
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Because Jonathan specifically asked for a
religious dimension to be included in the
counseling, Joshua consulted with his rabbi
for a text that might be instructive for
Jonathan. Rabbi Rosen suggested using the
text from 2 Samuel 5-12:7 that includes the
stories of David's kingship, his victories, and
his adultery with Bathsheba.
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
First, Joshua asked Jonathan to read the
text the rabbi had recommended. Next, he
asked Jonathan, "How is your life like that
of King David?"
Immediately, Jonathan saw the connection.
He said, "I am a successful businessman
and a leader in my community, but I am
also human.
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Just because I am capable and contributing
doesn't mean I am without my faults. And,
just because I made a lousy mess of my
relationship with Patti by having an affair
doesn't mean that I am worthless garbage
either." Joshua then asked, "Based on your
understanding of the David story, what do
you think God would have you do in your
life?"
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Jonathan responded, "There will have
to be consequences. I won't be able to
weasel out of this one easily. I will
have to demonstrate to Patti my
remorse and I'll have to figure out
some way to make amends. And, I will
need to start trusting God more for
guidance, rather than relying solely on
myself."
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
PRAYER AND MEDITATION
90% of Americans say they pray
86% believe prayer makes them
better people
97% believe prayers are heard
(Gallup Organization, 1993)
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
PRAYER AND MEDITATION
Who prays the most?
Women
African Americans
Older persons
(Gallup Organization, 1993)
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
PRAYER AND MEDITATION
Types of Prayer:
Contemplative
Ritualistic
Petitionary
Intercessory
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
PRAYER AND MEDITATION
Prayer used by patients
Prayer by practitioner for patient
Prayer with patient
Consider the setting and purpose
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
MEDITATION
Concentrative—focus on something—
mandala, candle, breath
Mindfulness—open self; await insight
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
MEDITATION
Helps in stress management and
relaxation
Aids with health problems
Assists in managing depression &
anxiety
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
VISUALIZATION AND IMAGERY
Used in a meditative posture
Patients imagine scenes or
images that call up issues or
concerns
Some imagery is guided
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Meditation on Matt. 13:45-46
Here is a picture of of the Kingdom
of Heaven. A merchant looking out
for fine pearls found one of very
special value; so he went and sold
everything he had and bought it.”
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
… You become aware that you are
searching for something of great
value…Following your intuition and
God's guidance, choose your path and
do whatever is necessary in order to
find that for which you are
searching…Let yourself experience any
struggles or barriers along the way
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Also, bring in any help or assistance
that you want…Finally you find this
thing of great value for which you
have been searching…You discover
that you must sell or get rid of
everything else in your life if you are
to obtain this one thing…Become
aware of your inner experience as you
make this discovery…( Stahl, 1977).
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
FORGIVENESS & REPENTANCE
To give up or give away anger and
the actions associated with it,
retribution and revenge (Sanderson
& Linehan, 1999)
A willingness to abandon one’s right
to resentment
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
FORGIVENESS results in
Patients experiencing positive affect
Improved mental health
More personal power
Freedom to grow
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Process of Forgiveness:
Shock & denial
Awareness of hurt
Acknowledgement of grief & anger
Validation of feelings
Justice and restitution if possible
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Process of Forgiveness cont…
Prevention of further offenses
Forgiveness and moving on
Short-cutting process can result in
depression & anxiety
(Richards & Bergin, 1997)
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Forgiveness does not require
reconciliation
An apology may be necessary for
reconciliation, but not for forgiveness
Forgiveness can occur without the
offender’s knowledge or involvement
(Freedman, 1998)
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Four patient choices:
1. Forgive and reconcile
2. Forgive and not reconcile
3. Not forgive and interact
4. Not forgive and not reconcile
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
SURRENDER
First attempt to change
circumstances
Next, willingness to change self and
to accept the direction life takes us
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Patient approaches to life’s difficulties:
Deferring
Pleading
Self-direction
Spiritual surrender
(Pargament, Smith, Koenig, & Perez,
1998)
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
When patients are faced with
situations in which there is little
personal control such as chronic or
terminal illness, death or accidents,
surrender might be appropriate for
them to consider…
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
SURRENDER
involves not only a cognitive shift,
but an experiential one as well in
which one is in touch with selftranscendence that leads to serenity
(Cole & Pargament, 1999).
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Guidelines for using Surrender as a
strategy:
Assess patient’s situation
Avoid using surrender as a means of
control
Distinguish between surrender and
learned helplessness
Strategies for Addressing
Religion & Spirituality
Explore patients’ religious and spiritual
beliefs to determine if surrender is
appropriate in their context
Explore patients’ receptivity by asking,
“What would it be like for you to
surrender to God?” (Cole &
Pargament, 1999).
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
For most Americans, the interface
between family life and religion or
spirituality is very important.
Religious/spiritual beliefs are critical
aspects of healthy family functioning
(Beavers & Hampson, 1990)
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
In a Gallup Poll (1996) 75% of those
surveyed said that religion has been a
positive, strengthening force in family
life.
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Life Cycle Transitions as Opportunities
Marriage/Coupling
Birth of Children
Adolescence
Young adulthood
Midlife
Death & Dying
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
A Family Systems Approach
Problems or difficulties are
understood to be located BETWEEN
people instead of WITHIN
individuals.
In a family, the whole is greater
than its parts
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
A Family Systems Approach:
An emphasis on what, rather than
why
Reciprocal causality rather than
linear cause and effect
Subjective rather than objective
Patterns and context
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
SPIRITUAL GENOGRAM
Map of multiple generations
Used to identify religious/spiritual
issues in the extended family
View of tradition & heritage as well
as current practice
Four Steps:
1. Construct the genogram
2. Questions for reflection
3. Connect with family of origin
4. Integrate into the clinical endeavor
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Procedure:
Map the family and record
significant events
Color-code the religious/spiritual
traditions
Note important religious/spiritual
events
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Procedure cont…
Indicate if family members left a
church or other religious
institution/organization
Indicate closeness or distance or
conflict
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Genogram-Related Questions:
1. What role, if any did
religion/spirituality play in your family
of origin?
What specific religious/spiritual beliefs
are most important for you now? How
are they a source of connection or
conflict between you and other family
members?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
How is gender viewed in your
religious/spiritual tradition?
Ethnicity? Sexual orientation? How
have these beliefs affected you and
your extended family?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
What patterns emerge for you as you
study your genogram? How are you
currently maintaining or diverting
from those patterns?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
How does your religious/spiritual
history connect with your current
distress, or with the problem you
presented for counseling? What new
insights or solutions may occur to you
based on the discoveries made
through the genogram? (Frame,
2000).
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
God as a Member of the Family
Using Circular Questions (Griffith,
1986):
When Dad stops working and
attends to Mom, what happens to
Tyler’s relationship with God?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
More circular questions:
Does Tyler move closer to God or
farther away?
If Tyler moves away from God, who
else makes a similar move?
Who would be the most upset if the
family did not stay close to God?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
More Circular Questions:
About which relationship in the
family do you think God would
express the most satisfaction?
The least satisfaction?
If you worked out your sexual
relationship with your partner
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
so that you both found it to be
satisfying, would you feel closer or
farther away from God?
To whom in the family can you talk
about God?
With whom would you feel it
awkward?
(Griffith & Griffith, 1992)
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Using a Spiritual Framework
Example: A 25 year old son was
overly enmeshed with his mother.
He could not work without her
supervision and she wasn’t able to
travel because she needed him to
protect her.
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Intervention: (Griffith, 1986)
Reframe the son’s obsession with
his mother as a sin because he
lacked faith the God would protect
her.
To son: “By protecting your mother,
you are trying to be her God”
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
TRIANGLES
The notion that a 2 person
relationship is unstable.
To manage the anxiety generated
by emotional reactivity, one person
brings in a 3rd to moderate or
reduce anxiety (Papero, 2000)
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Sometimes one partner in a couple
brings in God to create a triangle and
diffuse conflict and balance the
relationship
Types:
Coalition—each partner competes
for the allegiance of God but neither
is sure they have it
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Types, cont…
Displacement: Couple unites against
a common enemy. God is blamed for
the adversity in the marriage and
the couple may be connected by
their mutual anger at God
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Types contd…
Substitutive: God is brought in to
the partnership to minimize conflict
by diverting attention and intimacy
to God rather than to the partner.
Case Examples (pp. 219-220)
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
RITUALS
Common to both religion and
spirituality
Identify a patient’s experience
Find significant symbols
Create symbolic acts
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
RITUALS cont…
Possible uses:
Healing from abuse
Grief and loss
New relationships
Coming out process
Transitions
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
NARRATIVE APPROACHES
Religious/spiritual language to invite
conversations between self and God.
Build on work of Karl Tomm (1987)
and Michael White (1986)
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
NARRATIVE APPROACHES cont…
Sample Questions:
Had you possessed the
relationship you now have with
God when you first married, how
do you suppose your different
behavior might have altered the
way the relationship evolved?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
If God were to restructure this
interaction, how do you think it
would go?
If you were to discover that God
had in fact been present and active
in this situation all along, where
might that have been? (Griffith &
Griffith, 1992, p. 73).
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
Has there ever been even a brief
moment when, contrary to your
expectations, you did sense approval
coming from God?
Can you recall a time when your
husband might have criticized your
relationship with God but didn’t?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
In view of all the betrayals you
experienced in your life growing up,
are you surprised to discover that you
have learned to trust God? (Griffith &
Griffith, 1992, p. 73-74).
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
What difference will your having
learned how to trust God make in
your learning how to trust your wife?
If you see yourself as the person God
sees, what new possibilities might
you imagine for this relationship?
Spiritual Strategies with
Families
If you were to agree with the outcome
you believe God wants for this
relationship, what might be the next
step in getting there? (Griffith &
Griffith, 1992, p. 74).
Ethical Issues
ETHICS
Our beliefs about what constitutes
right behavior
How practitioners’ behavior affects
patient welfare, social networks, and
the helping profession
Ethical Issues
Four Dimensions:
having sufficient knowledge, skill,
and judgment of use efficacious
interventions
respecting human dignity and
freedom of the client
Ethical Issues
using the power inherent in the
counselor's role responsibly
acting in ways that promote public
confidence in the profession of
counseling
(Welfel, 1998)
Ethical Issues
WELFARE OF THE PATIENT
Address religious/spiritual issues
when the arise
Become familiar with religious
language and concepts
Work within patient belief systems
Ethical Issues
INFORMED CONSENT
Patients’ right to know what will
transpire during a procedure or
helping moment
Let patients’ know about religious
affiliations
Ethical Issues
Protect patients’ rights to decline
the use of spiritual interventions
Provide referrals to other persons
for religious/spiritual guidance and
support
Ethical Issues
COMPETENCE AND TRAINING
Do not practice beyond the level of
competence and training
Get supervision at the beginning of
this work
Consult, consult, consult!
Ethical Issues
PERSONAL ISSUES
Address own religious/spiritual
issues
Get therapy if needed
Seek spiritual guidance, if
appropriate
Ethical Issues
PERSONAL ISSUES cont
Be careful not to place your own
needs above those of the patient
Practice self-evaluation
Clarify your values
Ethical Issues
IMPOSITION OF VALUES
Imposing or exposing?
When exposing becomes imposing
Evaluation one’s interventions for
possible value imposition
Avoid passing judgment on patient
values
Ethical Issues
DUAL RELATIONSHIPS
When practitioners have other
types of relationships with
patients besides their professional
one
Potential for conflict of interest
Ethical Issues
Reduction in objectivity
Possible impairment to clinical
judgment
Possible harm
Ethical Issues
Examples:
Blurred social and professional
boundaries—role confusion
Counselor as priest, rabbi
Chaplain as parishioner or friend
Ethical Issues
Guidelines (Geyer, 1994)
Give notice if clinician is providing
consultation or supervision—
likelihood of confidentiality breaches
Collaboration between religious
organizations to provide mental
health services to each other’s staffs
Ethical Issues
Clinicians in leadership roles in
churches could reserve the right not
to comment when they have
information that would jeopardize
client confidentiality
Avoid dual relationships where
possible
Ethical Issues
Establish personal boundaries
Define financial arrangements (if
any) clearly
Maintain regular supervision and
consultation
Ethical Issues
WORK-SETTING BOUNDARIES
1. Public, govt funded agencies
may have policies that prohibit
religious/spiritual interventions
2. Obtain informed consent
3. Be careful not to usurp or
displace religious leaders
Ethical Issues
4. Take care not to denigrate or
criticize religious leaders’ values or
belief systems
Ethical Issues
CONSULTATION AND REFERRAL
Know your limits of effectiveness
Develop a network of “friendly
clergy”
Become cross-culturally
knowledgeable