Transcript Document

Excavation,
Trenching, and
Soil Mechanics
Subpart P
Jim Howry
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
1
Points To Be Covered:
7/17/2015

1926.650: Scope and Application

1926.651: Specific Excavation Requirements

1926.652: Requirements for Protective
Systems

1926 Subpart P Appendix A: Soil
Classification

Other Appendix and Tabulated Data!
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
2
DANGER!
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
3
Most Frequently Cited Serious Violations
in Construction – FY00
Standard & Subpart - 1926.
Fall protection - Unprotected sides & edges
1468
5 0 1 (b )(1 ) - M
Head protection
994
1 0 0 (a ) - E
Scaffolds - Fall protection
948
4 5 1 (g )(1 ) - L
Excavations - Protection of employees
785
2 1 (b )(2 ) - C
Scaffolds - Safe access
783
4 5 1 (e )(1 ) - L
Employee training
755
6 5 2 (a )(1 )- P
Scaffolds - Platform construction
660
4 5 1 (b )(1 ) - L
Fall hazards training program
5 0 3 (a )1 )- M
2 0 (b )(2 ) - C
1 0 5 3 (b )(1 ) - X
609
Inspections by competent persons 5 9 5
Portable ladder 3 feet above landing
surface
522
Number of Serious Violations - FY 00
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
2
4
Subpart P - Excavations
(1926.650 - 652)
Employee protection in excavations - Protective system use
6 5 2 (a )(1 )
755
Standard - 1926.
Egress from trench excavations
6 5 1 (c )(2 )
351
Inspections by competent person
6 5 1 (k )(1 )
345
Protection from falling/rolling materials/equipment
6 5 1 (j)(2 )
263
Competent person inspection - Employees removed from hazard
6 5 1 (k )(2 )
83
Number of Serious Violations - FY 00
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
16
5
Fatal Facts!

7/17/2015
An employee was installing a small
diameter pipe in a trench 3’ wide, 1215’ deep and 90 feel long. The trench
was not sloped or shored nor was
there a box or shield to protect the
employee. Further, there was
evidence of a previous cave-in. The
employee apparently reentered the
trench, and a second cave-in
occurred, burying him. He was found
face down in the bottom of the trench.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
6

7/17/2015
Four employees of a mechanical
contractor were laying a lateral
sewer line at a building site. The
foreman, a plumber by trade, and
a laborer were laying an eightinch, 20-foot long plastic sewer
pipe in the bottom of a trench 36
inches wide, nine feet deep, and
approximately 50 feet long. The
trench was neither sloped nor
shored, and there was water
entering it along a shale seam
near the bottom. The west side of
the trench caved in near the
bottom, burying one employee to
his chest and completely covering
the other. Rescue operations took
two and five hours - too late to
save the men.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
7
1926.650
Scope and Application

7/17/2015
“This subpart applies to all open
excavations made in the earth’s
surface. Excavations are defined
to include trenches.”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
8
What Is Soil?
7/17/2015

A soil is a mixture of rock, water,
air and a variety of other
substances.

Soil is made up of rock in the form
of small particles and spaces
called voids. Normally some part
of these voids is filled with water.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
9
Weighing in on Soil…
Solid Rock weighs about 167 lbs.
Per cubic foot. Since a cubic foot
of soil is about ½ rock it will
weigh about 83 lbs. Add in water
and the weight begins to rise to
around 114 lbs. (if saturated).
Do the math and a simple cubic
yard of soil can weigh over 3000
lbs! That is a ton and a ½!
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
10
Mechanics of a Cave-In

7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
11
Diagram of a cave in
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
12
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
13
Protecting Employees in
Excavations




7/17/2015
1926.652 (a)(1)
“Each employee in an excavation shall be
protected from a cave-ins by an adequate
protective system designed in
accordance with paragraph (b) or (c) of
this section except when:
(I) Excavations are made in entirely stable
rock; or
(ii) Excavations are less than 5’ in depth
and examination of the ground by a
competent person provides no indication
of a potential cave-in.”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
14
Protective Systems

7/17/2015
“a method of protecting employees
from cave-ins, from material that
could fall or roll from an excavation
face or into and excavation, or
from the collapse of adjacent
structures. Protective systems
include support systems, sloping
and benching systems, shield
systems, and other systems that
provide the necessary protection”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
15
So…We have Options:





7/17/2015
Slope, or Bench according to allowable
configurations…
Use a Registered Professional Engineer
to design a sloping or benching system.
Use support systems in accordance with
requirements set forth in the standard.
Purchase an engineered system,
(example..a trench box or shield.)
Have a PE design a shielding or shoring
system specific to your task.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
16
29 CFR 1926.652(b)(4)(i)



7/17/2015
Design by a registered
professional engineer…
Any system not found within the
guidelines set forth in the standard,
or within the tabulated data tables
in the standard requires use of a
Professional Engineer.
*No where in the standard or
tabulated data does it allow for
excavations deeper than 20 feet.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
17
Competent Person


7/17/2015
“one who is capable of identifying
existing and predictable hazards in
the surroundings, or working
conditions which are unsanitary,
hazardous, or dangerous to
employees, and who has the
authorization to take prompt
corrective measures to eliminate
them”
(Knowledge & Authority)
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
18
1926.651(k)(1)
Inspections
•Daily Inspection of excavations shall be
conducted by a ‘competent person’ prior
to the start of work and as needed
throughout the shift.
•Inspections shall also be conducted after
every rainstorm or other hazard increasing
occurrence.
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
19
Access and Egress
1926.651 (c)(2)

7/17/2015
“A stairway, ladder, ramp or other
safe means of egress shall be
located in a trench excavations
that are 4’ or more in depth so at to
require no more than 25’ of lateral
travel for employees.”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
20
Soil Tests


7/17/2015
1926 Subpart P appendix A, Soil
Classification (c)(3)
In order to classify a soil A, B, or C
at least one visual and one manual
test must be performed by a
competent person.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
21
Visual Test

7/17/2015
“Visual analysis is conducted to
determine the qualitative
information regarding the
excavation site in general, the soil
adjacent to the excavation, the soil
forming the sides of the open
excavation, and the soil taken as
samples from the excavated
materials.”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
22
Manual Tests


7/17/2015
“Manual analysis of soil samples is
conducted to determine
quantitative as well as qualitative
properties of soil to provide more
information in order to classify soil
properly.”
Examples: Thumb penetration,
Pocket penetrometers, Drying
tests, Sedimentation…
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
23
Thumb Penetration Test


7/17/2015
1926 Subpart P Appendix A(2)(iii)
…type A soils with an unconfined
compressive strength of 1.5 tsf can be
readily indented by the
thumb;however they can only be
penetrated by the thumb only with
great effort…Type C soils with an
unconfined compressive strength of
.5 tsf can be easily penetrated several
inches by the thumb, and can be
molded by light finger pressure.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
24
SOLID ROCK

7/17/2015
“Natural solid mineral matter that
can be excavated with vertical
sides and remain intact while
exposed”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
25
Type A Soil


7/17/2015
Cohesive soil with an
unconfined, compressive
strength of 1.5 Tsf
Examples of this type of soil
are: Clays, silty clay, sandy
clays, and clay loam.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
26
A Soil is NOT type ‘A’ IF:





7/17/2015
The soil is fissured
The soil is subject to vibration
The soil has been previously
disturbed
The material is subject to other
factors that would require it to
be classified as a less stable
material.
Water is present
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
27
Sources of Vibration






7/17/2015
Traffic
Railroad Operations
Heavy Equipment Operations
Jack Hammer Operations
Tamping Machine Operations
Thumping Car Stereos that make
you want to pull your hair out and
to…never mind…
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
28
Type B Soil



7/17/2015
Cohesive soil with an unconfined
compressive strength greater than
.5 Tsf
Granular cohesionless soils
including; silt, silt loam, sandy
loam, and some sandy clay loam
Previously disturbed soils except
those which would otherwise be
classified as Type ‘C’ soil
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
29
Type ‘C’ Soil



7/17/2015
Cohesive soils with an unconfined
compressive strength of 0.5 Tsf or
less
Granular soils including gravel,
sand, and loamy sand
Submerged soil, or soil from which
water is freely seeping
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
30
Sloping Requirements
by Soil Type
Stable Rock
Maximum
Allowable Slope for
Excavations less
than 20’
Vertical (90 Deg.)
Type A
¾ to 1 (53 Deg.)
Type B
1 to 1 (45 Deg.)
Type C
1 ½ to 1 (34 Deg.)
Soil or Rock Type
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
31
Sloping in Type ‘A’ Soil
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
32
Sloping in Type ‘B’ Soil
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
33
Sloping in Type ‘C’ Soil
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
34
Trench Boxes or
Shield Systems:

7/17/2015
“A structure that is able to
withstand the forces imposed on it
by a cave-in and thereby protect
employees.”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
35
Trench Boxes or Shield
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
36
Is this allowable?
7/17/2015
YES! If the Trench boxes are designed to
be stacked and are used in accordance
with their tabulated
data.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
37
Trench Boxes and
Sloping or Benching

7/17/2015
Trench boxes are generally
used in open areas, but they
may also be used in
combination with sloping and
benching. The box should
extend at least 18 inches
above the surrounding area if
there is sloping toward the
excavation.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
38
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
39
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
40
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
41
Shoring
(Shoring System)

7/17/2015
“A structure such as metal
hydraulic, mechanical or timber
shoring system that supports the
sides of an excavation and which
is designed to prevent cave-ins.”
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
42
Hydraulic Shoring
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
43
Stacked Hydraulic
Shores
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
44
Whaler System
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
45
Surface Encumbrances


7/17/2015
1926.651 (a)
“All surface
encumbrances that are
located so as to create
a hazard to employees
shall be removed or
supported as
necessary to
safeguard employees”






Adjacent
Structures
Roads and/ or
Sidewalks
Curb and Gutter
Light poles
Utilities
Mailboxes
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
46
Utilities


7/17/2015
1926.651(b)
The estimated location of utility
installations, such as sewer,
telephone, fuel, electric, …that
reasonably may be expected to be
encountered during excavation
work, shall be determined prior to
opening an excavation…
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
47
Locates

Red = Power
Blue = Water
Orange = Communications
Yellow = Gas
7/17/2015
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
48
Can an Excavation be a
Confined Space…?




7/17/2015
Oxygen deficient atmospheres:
less than 19.5% oxygen.
Potential for other gasses to be
present include but not be limited
to:
Natural Gas from potential leaks or
cut lines.
Methane from decayed matter.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
49

Call before you dig.

Use at least one
visual and one
manual soil test to
determine soil type.
Summary



A Ladder is
required for access
and egress at 4’


7/17/2015
The ladder must be
within 25’ lateral
travel at all times.

At 5’ depth some type of
‘protective system is
required’.
Treat all soil as Type ‘C’ and
slope at 1 ½ : 1 and you are
covered.
If not: Use some type of
shoring or shielding to
protect your employees.
Excavations over 20’ require
the use of a P.E.
www.oshainfo.gatech.edu
50