Seminario na FEUP - Marco 2000 (Parte 1)
Download
Report
Transcript Seminario na FEUP - Marco 2000 (Parte 1)
New Organisational Forms
and CSCW (part 1)
M. Baptista Nunes
14/03/2000
1
Aims of this lecture
to investigate the impacts of the explosive developments
of ICT on organisational Structure and Design;
to provide an overview and discuss new emergent forms
of organisation:
• Networked Organisation;
• Boundary-less Organisation;
• Virtual Organisation.
To provide an overview of CSCW and its role and
importance in the new organisation.
2
Organisation Structure
“Structure is a means for attaining the objectives and goals of
an organisation”
(Drucker, 1974)
“Organisation Structure is the system of arrangements, the
pattern or network of relations, between the various
positions and their holders.”
(Buchanan and Huczynski, 1997:297)
“Organisation structure is more than boxes on a chart; it is a
pattern of interactions and co-ordination that links the
technology, tasks and human components of the
organisation to ensure that the organisation accomplishes
its purpose”
(Duncan, 1979:59)
3
Organisation Structure
Organisation Structure is a framework for dividing,
assigning and co-ordinating work.
Key elements of structure:
• Work specialisation and definition;
• Departmentalisation;
• Type and Levels of authority (hierarchy and chain of
command);
• Concentration of authority and span-of-control.
4
Organisation Structure
Expression of structure:
• Organisation Chart;
• Job Descriptions;
• Hierarchy;
• Rules, Policies and Procedures;
• Culture and Behaviour.
5
Organisational Form
“The design of an organisation is an exercise in matching
structures, systems and style of management, and the
people employed, to the various activities of the
organisation.”
(Mullins, 1997:566)
Organisational
Design
Organisational
Form
6
Traditional Organisational
Forms
Self-contained, integrated structures operating in
stable environments.
• Physically located in office buildings and production
plants, in which the organisation’s members work
and where the required machines, equipment,
materials and information can be found;
• Functional Structure;
• Boundaries defined by the physical structures and
contractual relations;
• Rigidly centralised bureaucracy;
• Traditional pyramidal span-of-control.
7
Challenges for the Organisation
Changes in the
Competitive
Situation
Innovation
Potential of
ICT
Value Changes
with Labour, in
Markets, and
Society
Challenges for the Firm
New Organisational Forms
8
Changes in the Competitive
Situation
Internationalisation of Markets;
Innovation Dynamics with Products and
Processes;
Globalisation Buyer Markets;
Globalisation of Purchasing;
Demographic Developments;
Resource Decreases.
9
Value Changes with Labour,
in Markets, and Society
Attitude toward Environment;
Age Demographics of Employees;
Quality Demands on the Work Place;
Market Behaviour;
Globalisation of Standards;
Globalisation of Legislation;
Internationalisation of Customer, Buyer and
Supplier awareness.
10
Information Technology
Falling costs of SW and HW and the advent of the PC Most
knowledge, data and service workers (see last week) and
managers now a have a PC on their desks;
Availability of user-friendly SW that allows easy, fast and
efficient use of the IT infra-structures;
Increasing availability of of business information from both
internal and external databases providing information essential to
maintain a competitive market position;
The explosive development in communication technology and the
increasing convergence of telecommunications and computing
(ICT) which led to the Information Society.
11
Innovation Potential of ICT
gradual elimination of:
• bureaucracy and manual processing of information;
• individual functions;
• layers of middle management;
internal integration of departments;
diluting of organisational boundaries:
• Removal of geographical barriers and time limitations;
• external integration with suppliers and customers;
• creation and strengthening external links with
12
complementary organisations.
Innovation Potential of ICT
gradual elimination of:
• bureaucracy and manual processing of information;
Centralised
Decentralised
• individual functions;
• layers of middle management;
“Tall”
“Flat” hierarchies
internal integration of departments;
Functional
Networked structures
13
Innovation Potential of ICT
diluting of organisational boundaries:
• Removal of geographical barriers and time limitations;
Physical
Virtual organisation
• external integration with suppliers and customers;
• creation and strengthening external links with
complementary organisations.
Strict Boundary
Boundary-less
Organisation
14
Decentralised Organisation
Centralisation - refers to the concentration of authority
and responsibility for decision making in the hands of
managers at the top of an organisation.
Decentralisation - refers to authority and responsibility
for decision making being dispersed more widely
downwards and given the to operating units, branches and
lower-level managers.
Decentralisation
Empowering, Democratisation
15
Decentralised Organisation
Centralised
• greater uniformity in
decisions;
• more control;
• fewer skilled
managers required;
• Less extensive plan
and reporting
procedures;
• Faster decision
process.
Decentralised
• Lower-level decisions are
easier;
• Lower-level management
problems can be dealt on
the spot;
• Greater motivation and
better opportunities for
lower-level managers;
• Top-level managers have
more time for strategic
planning.
16
“Flat” Hierarchies
The combination of span of control and chain of command
determines the overall pyramid shape and whether the
hierarchical structure is “flat” or “tall” (Mullins, 1997:536).
“Flat” hierarchies broader span of control, few levels of
authority.
“Tall” hierarchies narrower span of control, more levels
17
of authority.
“Flat” Hierarchies
Advantages
• Savings on managerial
costs;
• Improved
communication;
• More participative
styles of management;
• Greater involvement
of staff;
• Improved
organisational
efficiency.
Disadvantages
• Inhibit the flow of
effective communications
between top management
and the workforce;
• Reduce commitment and
motivation levels;
• Lower-level managers
face increased load;
• Deterioration of
productivity;
• More vulnerable to fraud.
18
Networked Structure
Networked organisation is a combination of:
• functional departments provide stable base for specialised
activities;
• project teams that form and disband as required and are set up
as temporary units for the attainment of a particular task.
• reliance on links between individuals, sub-units and outside
organisations;
• “command-and-control”
“information-based”
19
Networked Structure
Advantages
sharing of resources;
more than one critical
orientation to the operations of
the organisation;
organisational systems &
processes capable of rapid
response to changing
conditions
integration and effective
utilisation of diverse cultures,
people, and talents
organisational involvement
across organisational boundary
Disadvantages
• Results in more complex
organisational structure;
• Problems of co-ordination;
• Political and authority
problems;
• Functional groups may tend to
neglect their duties;
• Reduce commitment and
motivation levels;
• Loss of accountability;
• Increased working load for
designated staff;
• Deterioration of productivity.
20
Boundary-less Organisations
Boundary-less Organisations represent “the dissolution of
traditional organisational structures and boundaries in
favour of the establishment of symbiotic arrangements with
external partners” (Wigand et al., 1998:209).
Initially employees joined teams to work on specific projects regardless
of their physical location or organisational membership - once the
project is over, the team disbands.
Nowadays ...
21
Boundary-less Organisations
Advantages
sharing of resources is more
open, accurate and timely;
strong leadership by shared
vision, collaboration and
commitment.
organisational systems &
processes capable of rapid
response to changing
conditions
integration and effective
utilisation of diverse cultures,
people, and talents;
Disadvantages
• Results in more complex
organisational structure;
• Problems of co-ordination;
• Political and authority
problems;
• Difficult to define boundaries
resulting in security risks to the
firm;
• Dissolution of organisational
culture and sense of
community;
• Reduce commitment and
motivation levels;
22
• Loss of accountability.
Virtual Organisations
“Virtual Organisations represent a task and competence
oriented approach in the design of an organisation”
(Wigand et al., 1998:364).
Static and long-term
boundaries of:
responsibility
physical location
functional allocation
Task specific and
contingency
allocation of
Competence.
23
Virtual Organisations
Advantages
location independent
organisations;
sharing of resources is more
open, accurate and timely;
changing the time and spatial
dimensions of performance;
increasing speed of
performance;
rapid response to changing
conditions;
integration and effective
utilisation of diverse cultures,
people, and talents;
Disadvantages
• Results in more complex
organisational structure;
• Problems of management and
co-ordination;
• Political and authority
problems;
• Difficult to define boundaries
resulting in security risks to the
firm;
• Dissolution of organisational
culture and sense of
community;
• Reduce commitment and
24
motivation levels.
Worth thinking about … :-)))
“All this constant talk about technology is so boring. It is
only another tool and besides it is the management and
performance of people that really matters.”
YES, but ...
Technology is the tool which enables people to perform and
managers must have the skills and understanding to know how to
make the best of technology within organisations.”
Different technologies determine different organisational structures
and behaviours
Technological determinism.
This course follows a moderate technological determinism view , but
… this is not the only approach !
25
In Sum . . .
Organisations are complex systems ...
Environment
Structure
Objectives
Technology
People
26