Spring Market Assessment 2002
Download
Report
Transcript Spring Market Assessment 2002
Spring Market Update
2002
Chris Smith & Les Deman
May 2002
If I Only Had One Slide
2001 Storage Levels Relative to Historical (Total US)
Source: EIA
3,500
3,000
May 24, 2002 at 1,796 Bcf
2,500
Bcf
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
J
F
M
A
94-01 Historical Max-Min
M
J
Series2
J
2000
A
2001
S
O
2002
N
D
Is It Deja Vu All Over Again?
The 1999-2001 Cycle
Gas inventories reached an all-time peak in March 1999
NYMEX gas prices troughed in February 1999 at $1.63
NYMEX oil prices troughed in February 1999 at $11.68/B
The US rig count troughed in April 1999 at 488
WTI hit $37.20 in September 2000
Henry Hub gas approached $10 in December 2000
Gas inventories plunged to 627 Bcf in March 2001
The US rig count peaked at 1293 in July 2001
Spring 2002
Gas inventories surpassed the 1999 peak
Gas and oil prices are strong
The rig count dropped to 738 in early April
Economic growth seems to be ramping upwards
Will the next 18 months repeat the 1999-01 experience?
US Gas Demand Better in 02, 03 Maybe
No Winter = No Demand
WINTER RESIDENTIAL-COMMERCIAL DEMAND
42
40
38
Bcfd
1st quarter 2002 was 9% warmer
than normal
If rest of 2002 is normal GWHDDs 1.4%, but up 1.3% in 2003
Residential/Commercial flat in 2002,
but up 4.2% in 2003
Power generation down 4% in Q-I,
but gas took share from oil
36
34
32
30
1999-00
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
Generation Comes First in Q-II & III
US POWER GENERATION GROWTH
2001-2003
E
R
H
T
A
L
O
A
S
O
C
2003
+
IL
O
N
U
C
LE
A
R
Y
D
H
RISKS: EL NINO BEGINNING IN
SECOND HALF OF 2002
2002
R
2001
G
100
80
60
40
20
0
-20
-40
-60
-80
O
Cheap baseload units get chosen
first--hydro, coal, nucs
Generation growth goes to hydro &
gas in 2002
In 2003 growth goes to coal, oil and
gas
Bil Kwh
Source: EIA, NOAA and Coral estimates
Industry Comes Last
Industry=f(Price, HDDs, GWIP)
BASE INDUSTRIAL GAS USE
(Yr over Yr Change)
01 II
-Q
01 III
-Q
-IV
02
Q
-I
02
Q
-I
02 I
Q
02 III
Q
-IV
03
-Q
-I
03
Q
-I
03 I
Q
-I
03 II
Q
-IV
-I
US economic growth accelerated in QI, but Q-II signs are more subdued
Gas-intensive mfg. remains well below
the mid 2000 peak
Efficient new gas units & a return of
hydro & coal might limit gas upside
Higher gas prices through rest of 2002
impacts 2003 demand growth
01
Q
01
Q
How Fast a Rebound?
4
3
2
1
0
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5
US GAS CONSUMPTION - 12 MO. AVE.
63
62
61
Bcfd
The key variables were mostly
negative in 2001
Weather was a drag in 01Q-IV & 02QI, but key industries are raising
production
Gas prices were attractive in Jan-Feb,
but a negative factor in Mar-Apr
Bcfd
60
59
58
57
RISKS: HIGHER INTEREST RATES
PLUS HIGHER OIL AND GAS PRICES
PUT A BREAK ON THE RECOVERY
56
Jan- May- Sep- Jan- May- Sep- Jan- May- Sep- Jan- May- Sep00
00
00
01
01
01
02
02
02
03
03
03
Source: EIA and Coral estimates
Gotta Drill To Find Gas
Gotta Have Money to Drill
GAS RIG COUNT vs GAS PRICE* 1991-2002
1200
Gas Rig Count
About 85% of all US wells
are drilled by independents
Spending is highly
correlated with prices
Low price = less drilling
A Lot of Wells to Keep Even
1000
800
600
200
0
$0
RISKS: THE PRICE NEEDED TO RAISE
PRODUCTION DEPRESSES DEMAND
$2
$4
$6
$8
GAS DISCOVERIES vs RIG COUNT 1990-2000
Gas Discoveries - Tcf
Dry gas production reached
53 Bcfd in 2001 (19.3 Tcf)
Max gas discoveries* past
10 yrs was 19.1 Tcf (2000)
Well half-life is down to 24
months, from 40 in 1990
Need about 800 gas rigs to
get 20 Tcf
*Wellhead Price 6
mos earlier
400
20
15
10
5
0
300
400
500
600
Gas Rig Count
Source: EIA and Baker-Hughes
*Excludes revisions and adjustments
700
800
If Not in 2002, When?
2002 Supply - A Downer
ESTIMATED QUARTERLY PRODUCTION CHANGES
(Yr-Over-Yr)
US gas production peaked in mid
2001
Declines likely through most of 2002
Gas rigs hit 1070 in 7/01, but supply
growth trailed off quickly in Q-III & IV
Gas rigs are down 1/3, but may have
turned a corner
Bcfd
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5
01
Gas Imports Help Some
I
I
I
II
II
II
II
II
II
Q- 1Q- -Q-I Q-IV 2Q- 2Q- Q- I Q- IV 3-Q- 3Q- Q- I Q- IV
2
3
0
1
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
03
01
ESTIMATED GAS IMPORT CHANGES
(Yr-Over-Yr)
2.0
PIPELINE
1.5
LNG
1.0
Bcfd
Canadian and LNG imports are trailing
last year
LNG import growth is lagging, but may
rebound with gas prices $3.50+
Unless WCSB declines, pipe imports
should trend higher because of high
Canadian gas storage
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-Q
01 -III
-Q
-IV
02
Q
-I
02
Q
02 II
Q
02 III
Q
-IV
03
-Q
03 I
Q
-I
03 I
Q
03 III
Q
-IV
Q
-II
01
01
Q
-I
-2.0
01
RISKS: E&P INVESTMENT LAGS AS
PRODUCERS CLEAN-UP BALANCESHEETS
Source: EIA and Coral estimates
A US Trial Balance: 2002-2003
So Far, So Good. But....
US SUPPLY-DEMAND BALANCES
65.0
APPARENT DEMAND
63.0
62.0
61.0
60.0
2001
Going From Feast To Famine
2003
3500
2001
3000
2002
Bcf
2500
2003
2000
1500
2000
1000
500
1996
Source: EIA, AGA and Coral estimates
O
ct
N
ov
D
ec
ep
S
l
ug
A
Ju
Ju
n
M
ay
pr
A
M
ar
Fe
b
0
Ja
n
RISKS: ANTICIPATORY MARKET
REACTION LOWERS DEMAND &
RAISES SUPPLY
2002
END OF MONTH STORAGE 1995-2003
Record storage levels likely
until fall 2002
2003 could see record lows
over much of the year--below
1996 & 2000-01
Has the market reacted too
early or is it too late?
TOTAL SUPPLY
64.0
Bcfd
US demand growth should
exceed supply in 2002 & 03
High 2002 storage should
mitigate availability concerns
The balance gets more dicey
in 2003
Supply 2005: Through a Looking Glass
It’s A Tall Order
US ANNUAL SUPPLY GROWTH 2000-05
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
-2
Mexico
Canada
Source: EIA (12-2001) and Coral estimates
2005
W
es
t
es
Ro
ck
i
LNG
2000
RISKS: TRADITIONAL NA GAS
SUPPLY BASINS HAVE PEAKED
SW
M
id
Co
n
S
NET IMPORTS
Bcfd
Imports need to grow at least
0.5 Bcfd per yr.
Will Canadian exports grow
from East & West basins?
LNG import capacity grows to
3.5 Bcfd by 2005, but worldwide
supply lags
O
C
G
ul
f
Can Imports Balance S&D?
O
ns
ho
re
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
-0.05
NE
Forecasts call for production to
grow nearly 1.0 Bcfd per year
All regions expected to increase
except southwest
Gas rigs may need to average
1000+ between 2002-05
Bcfd
What If the Forecasts are Wrong?
The Physical Issues
Smaller gas supply squeezes
industrials
Price sensitive sectors close
first--ammonia, methanol, etc.
Foreign sources gain share-metal products, chemicals, etc
0
-2
-4
Bcfd
POTENTIAL DEFICITS 2005
-6
-8
Higher supply encourages
more gas-for-oil fuel switching
The Financial Issues
-10
-12
Flat Production
Flat Productuin +
High Generation
KEY OIL-GAS PRICE RELATIONSHIPS (HUB GAS*)
$7.00
USGC Propane
NYC Distillate
NYC 0.3% No 6
$6.00
$5.00
$/MMBtu
If supply lags, gas prices move
up to clean oil products on a
sustained basis--No. 2, LPGs,
etc. Hub prices might range
from $3.50-$6.00/MMBtu
Higher supply pits gas against
No.6. Hub prices in the $2.75$4.25/MMBtu range.
Higher Generation
$4.00
$3.00
$2.00
$1.00
RISKS: BOOM-BUST CYCLES LIMIT
INVESTMENTS IN BOTH THE SUPPLY
AND DEMAND SECTORS
$-
$20 WTI
ASSUMES $0.50 HUB-NYC BASIS
Source: Coral estimates
$25 WTI
$30 WTI
New Generation, No Place to Go
WSCC GENERATION ADDITIONS - GW
Build and they Will Come
72 Gw slated from 2000 to
2005, 37% in CA
Peak demand growing at 34 Gw per year
Need aluminum and silicon
valley to return to 2000
growth rate
25
Many plants facing limited
operation at variable cost
Merge, sell or mothball?
Consumers in some
western states see flat-tolower bills. Not in CA.
OTHER
2001
2002
20
15
10
5
0
The Good, Bad & ….
CA
2003
2004
2005
WSCC RESERVE MARGIN FORECAST - %
30
25
20
COMFORT RANGE
15
10
5
CA
0
2000
2001
OTHER
2002
Source: RDI and Coral estimates
2003
2004
2005
Gas Gets Generation Growth, But…
WECC LOAD ESTIMATES - Bil KWh
Limited, Low Cost Sources
Hydro can do 200+ in wet
year, but no upside
Nuclear, operating near
capacity now. Tomorrow?
Coal’s cheap, but minimal
new capacity slated
Load growth goes to gas
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
GAS
COAL
NUCLEAR
HYDRO
*Other includes
purchases & imports
2000
Declining Heat Rates
Dampen Gas Growth
2001
2005
ESTIMATED GAS USE FOR GENERATION - WECC
4.6
4.4
4.2
Bcfd
Gas generation growth
exceeds 5%/yr.
66% of new plants are ccgas
Heat rates could easily
decline by 10% in 2005
OTHER*
4.0
3.8
3.6
3.4
2000
Source: EIA and Coral estimates
2001
2005
Gas & Electricity Values
Yesterday, Tomorrow (& Last Year)
20.00
$/MMBtu
$/MWH
200.00
SP 15 On Peak
17.50
SP 15 On Peak - (Last Yr)
175.00
SoCal Border
15.00
SoCal Brdr - (Last Yr)
150.00
12.50
125.00
10.00
100.00
7.50
75.00
5.00
50.00
2.50
25.00
You were here
You are here
0.00
Jan-95
Jul-95
Jan-96
Jul-96
Jan-97
Jul-97
Jan-98
Jul-98
Jan-99
Jul-99
Jan-00
Jul-00
Jan-01
Jul-01
Jan-02
Jul-02
Jan-03
Jul-03
Jan-04
Jul-04
Jan-05
Jul-05
Jan-06
Jul-06
Jan-07
Jul-07
Jan-08
Jul-08
Jan-09
Jul-09
Jan-10
Jul-10
0.00
Tying It All Together
Despite a 1st quarter GDP surge, a U-shaped US economic recovery
in 2002 seems likely as capital investment expenditures lag
Gas increases marketshare from oil (lost in 2000-01) and in power
generation, but mild winter moderated demand growth
A large inventory overhang hinders gas markets, but farsighted
players provide upward momentum
Accelerating economic growth (US and R-O-W) moves energy
demand up sharply in 2003
US gas demand could see record growth in 2003
Quicker market reaction sends early signals to producers and
consumers, reducing the likelihood of price spikes
RISKS: ESCALATING OIL AND GAS PRICES LOWER ECONOMIC GROWTH AND
DEPRESS GAS & OIL DEMAND BY LATE 2002-EARLY 2003. PRICES FALL AND
THE NEXT CYCLE BEGINS.