Transcript FIRST NATION FINANCIAL CODE TOOLBOX TRAINING SEMINAR
AFOA Canada National Conference Calgary, AB February 27, 2004
Session 6 – Improving Financial Management and Accountability with the Financial Management Toolbox
Points to Ponder #1
Ham and Eggs: Just a day’s work for a chicken but a lifetime commitment for a pig.
Why do toasters always have a setting that burns the toast to a horrible crisp, which no decent human being would eat?
Why is there a light in the fridge and not in the freezer?
Presented by ABORIGINAL FINANCIAL OFFICERS ASSOCIATION OF BC
Welcome & Overview of Seminar
Facilitators Clay Harmon, Director Mike Mearns, General Manager Moderator Susan E. Wood, President – AFOA-BC
Welcome & Overview of Seminar
This seminar will overview the five toolbox chapters:
First Nations Governance Concepts Financial Management By-Law Financial Management Manuals Strategic Planning Capacity Building
How did the Financial Code Project begin?
In the development of the First Nations Financial Code Toolbox, the Financial Management and Accountability Project committee members realized the importance of “beginning at the beginning”.
Who are the Committee Members?
AFOABC Board Members
Susan E. Wood, President Chris Bolton, Vice-President Clay Harmon, Director Carol Kelly, Interim Vice-President Lynn Anderson, Secretary-Treasurer Mike Mearns, General Manager
AFOABC Members
Chad Mason, Gitwangak Band Council Jay Norton, DeGruchy, Norton and Company Margaret White, Nanaimo First Nation Myrna Jacobson, Old Massett First Nation Sharlene Wilson, Nil/Tu Child and Family Services Trevor Morrison, Gitksan Watershed Authorities
How did the Financial Code Project begin?
WHAT DOES EACH TOOL BOX CHAPTER COMPRISE OF?
The committees recommendations of successful applications developed throughout the country. Most have been developed by the Aboriginal Financial Officers Association of BC Others have been used by permission by the authors.
What is the definition of “CODE”?
A systematic body of laws A set of rules or conventions (an agreement between nations, a treaty; established usage, social custom)
What is AFOABC’s interpretation of a Financial Code?
WHAT IS A FINANCIAL CODE?
The first task of the committee was to define what a Financial Code is and what it means.
Through a brainstorming session the committee agreed that the following defined their thoughts of a First Nations Financial Code.
What is AFOABC’s interpretation of a Financial Code?
A FIRST NATION FINANCIAL CODES IS A SET OF PRINCIPLES THAT: Respects the culture, traditions and history of a First Nation.
Protects, maintains and increases the resources of a First Nation through effective planning and control.
Defines and implements the “Best Practices” for the preparation and communication of quality reporting.
Provides high standards and ethical leadership for the equal and confidential treatment for all.
What is the First Nations Governance Toolbox?
WHAT DOES A FINANCIAL CODE TOOLBOX COMPRISE OF?
The second task of the committee was to outline the toolbox “chapters”. This step was important to the creation of the toolbox since it would eventually lead a First Nation into adapting a governance structure that encompassed the First Nation Financial Code principles. It was also important that an order of evolution was outlined. This would guarantee the success of the toolbox application for a First Nation.
What is the First Nations Governance Toolbox?
The committee agreed the following chapters would be:
First Nations Governance Concepts Financial Management Bylaw Financial and Human Resource Policy and Procedures Manuals Strategic Management and Planning Capacity Building
COMMUNITY DIRECTION
Vision Mission Values
GOVERNANCE MODEL
CONSTITUTION
Founding Provisions Rights and Freedoms
Government Structure
INSTITUTIONS Government Organization Core Branches Programs & Services BYLAWS
Financial Management
Human Resources
Administration POLICIES & PROCEDURES
Financial Human Resources Operations
Chapter One: First Nation Governance Concepts
A constitution is a solid foundation for First Nation’s with a strong community vision to move ahead in:
Treaty
Self-government
Other Nation building initiatives.
First Nation Governance Concepts
Part 1 – First Nations Constitution Development
This section includes information that relates to importance of having a constitution that provides a solid foundation for: codes, by-laws and policies development.
First Nation Governance Concepts
Some of the standard components of a First Nations constitution include the following: Founding Provisions Rights and Freedoms of Citizens First Nation Government Structure Government Officials Roles and Responsibilities Financial Management and Accountability Lands and Resources General Provisions
First Nation Governance Concepts
The constitution would be specific for their community needs and would serve the purpose of:
who you are
how you are governed
how the membership has input into governance
key positions for governance
SAMPLE ORGANIZATIONAL CHART
COMMUNITY MEMBERS CHIEF AND COUNCIL BAND ADMINISTRATOR ADMINISTRATION SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT EDUCATION HOUSING RESOURCES HUMAN RESOURCES FINANCE SKILLS TRAINING K - 12
- 12
LANDS FISHERIES FORESTRY
First Nation Governance Concepts
Part 2 – Government Organization
This section provides information about First Nation government organizational structure that supports the development of: various laws policies procedures administration guidelines necessary for good government
First Nation Governance Concepts
Government organization in broad terms is a constitution. The structure is developed to create: structure departments committees reporting and accountability systems
First Nation Governance Concepts
Financial management systems are an integral part of organization structure and are required for: budget planning allocation audit requirements
First Nation Governance Concepts
Some examples of government organization components are: Government Organization Council size, committee structure Core Branches or Departments Administration, Finance and HR Programs and Services Health, SA, Education, Resource Mngt
First Nation Governance Concepts
Financial Accountability Policy Sample
Is a solid basis for developing and adopting a policy to your own First Nation. The success of any policy is to give “life” to the document by ensuring that all members, staff and council is fully trained and understands the basis of the policy. As with all other policies that are adopted, it becomes a living document that all abide by.
First Nation Governance Concepts
The policy provides sample wording for: Compliance with Policy Financial Decision-Making Process Conflict of Interest Guidelines Procedures for Financial Information Disclosure Dispute Resolution.
First Nation Governance Concepts
Appendix A – Building a Community Constitution
This Appendix is used by permission by the Institute on Governance. The handbook was developed in collaboration with the Samagok Anishnawbek First Nation and Canadian Executive Services Organization, Aboriginal Services in January 2001.
First Nation Governance Concepts
The handbook was born out of the Samagok workshop, and is meant as a guide for others First Nations during their constitution-building process. The handbook summarizes both international and Sagamok experiences, and outlines the basic process of developing a constitution.
First Nation Governance Concepts
It is organized around the four questions that formed the basis of the Sagamok workshop: What is a constitution?
Why have a constitution?
What should a constitution contain?
How can a community develop its constitution?
Points to Ponder #2
If the professor on Gilligan’s Island could make a radio out of coconut, why can’t he fix a hole in a boat?
Gargling is a good way to see if your throat leaks.
If a thing is worth doing, wouldn’t it have been done already?
Failure is not an option. It’s bundled with your software.
He who dies with the most toys is still dead.
Chapter Two: Financial Management By-Law
WHAT IS A FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT BYLAW?
A key component of the First Nations Financial Code Toolbox is the ability for First Nations to make laws and enforce them.
Financial Management By-Law
Section 83 of the Indian Act provides for the development of laws in variety of areas. Some First Nations have undertaken the development of a financial management by-law, in particular those that entering into the area of taxation, claims management and economic development.
Financial Management By-Law
Key components of the Financial Management Bylaw includes: 1.
Council Responsibilities
planning and budgeting for service and capital projects hiring of competent financial management staff council responsibilities in the areas of annual budgeting, expenditures, information on contracts and tenders, financial statements and audit requirements is covered.
Financial Management By-Law
2. Conflict of Interest Guidelines
In the development of financial management by laws conflict of interest guidelines are needed to ensure transparency in financial management procedures.
Financial Management By-Law
3.
Financial Information Disclosure
This relates to the need for accountability to membership and access to financial information. Disclosure also deals with Council member's requirement to provide information about potential financial benefits through Council decisions.
Financial Management By-Law
4. Dispute Resolution
This section of the by-law ensures there is a process for redress where a band member feels they would be adversely affected by a Council or administrative decision. This area also includes a process for mediation or arbitration.
Financial Management By-Law
This toolbox chapter includes sample policies that your First Nation can adopt. The policies are: Conflict of Interest Disclosure Contracts and Tenders Optional Committees and Boards
Financial Management By-Law
In conclusion, law making is an important part of First Nations governance and will requires sound
judgment
in their creation. Provided laws are based on a shared vision and constitutional provisions that will meet the needs of the community. This will in turn provide a solid base for health, social and economic development.
Chapter Three: Financial and Human Resource Policy and Procedures Manual
The focus of this First Nations Financial Code Toolbox chapter is on policy and procedure development and its role in helping your First Nation achieve its desired administrative goals. Included are sample policies and procedures for financial management and human resources that your organization may use as a template in the creation of your own.
Financial/HR Management Manual
WHAT ARE POLICIES?
Policies and procedures help ensure that behaviours in the workplace conform to the expectations of the organization and to legal requirements. Different policies and procedures relate to general governance, function, strategic decisions or the administration of specific programs or activities.
Financial/HR Management Manual
The development of your own effective policies should support the vision, mission and values of your organization. It is important to consider these issues in your development: input from all affected stakeholders relevant, complete and understandable content effective communication to all stakeholders
Financial/HR Management Manual
all policies documented in a consistent format appropriate authorization and accountability for administering the policy a periodic review process to validate appropriateness and completeness
Financial/HR Management Manual
Policies should contribute to the growth and development of a high performance organization. Key components of effective policies contain: purpose/objective scope authority policy content They may also contain an effective date and consequences of non-compliance/redress.
Financial/HR Management Manual
WHAT ARE PROCEDURES?
is a step-by-step list of activities required to conduct a certain task. ensure that routine tasks are carried out in an effective and efficient fashion, and in accordance with policy. should contain the following key components: the purpose of the procedure and the policy to which it relates.
Financial/HR Management Manual
step-by-step instruction on performing the given task.
illustrations of any form involved and specific instructions regarding their use. any requirements related to review, approvals and signatures.
any requirement relates to the communication of information.
the position or person with primary responsibility.
Financial/HR Management Manual
In conclusion, it is important to remember that this process is irrelevant if all users do not receive and apply your published policy and procedures to their daily practice. Your new manual will be well received by all users if they are easy to understand, develops effective solutions and if there is a communication or training plan in place.
Financial/HR Management Manual
WHAT SAMPLES DOES THIS TOOLBOX CONTAIN?
This toolbox chapter contains a sample Financial Procedures Manual a sample Human Resource Manual which includes samples of Codes of Conduct. Each sample includes samples of various forms, terms of reference for auditors, performance evaluation charts, grievance steps and oath of confidentiality forms.
Financial Procedures Manual
SAMPLE FINANCIAL PROCEDURES MANUAL
This sample contains procedures for administration staff and council on the correct and approved methods of financial control from the recording receipts, depositing funds, disbursement procedures capital assets annual year-end audits.
Sample Accounts Payable Process Good or Service Invoiced to First Nation
Financial Procedures Manual
Yes Is the good or service amount exceeding cost limits set by Chief and Council?
Is there a BCR approving the expenditure?
No Ensure that expense is brought to Chief and Council for approval Yes Notify vendor that invoice is not approved for payment.
Attach a copy of signed BCR to invoice No Approval Granted?
Yes No Yes Attach a copy of purchase order to invoice Release Cheques Yes Are all the cheques signed?
No Forward invoice to accounts payable Yes Does the invoice reference a purchase order?
No Forward invoice to department head or purchasing staff for verification and approval.
Approval Granted ?
No On scheduled cheque- run days, process cheques for invoices and forward for bank account signatories Data enter invoice into computer accounting program Accounts Payable Attach all packing slips, work orders, waybills, purchase orders, etc to invoice Code expense to appropriate department and forward to department head for approval Invoices returned to accounts payable for proper documentation or coding Notify vendor that invoice is not approved for payment.
Yes Approval Granted?
No
Human Resource Manual
SAMPLE HUMAN RESOURCE MANUAL
This sample contains policies for managing staff. It defines: the conditions of employment benefit entitlement reporting performance evaluations and redress
Human Resource Manual
It complies with the Canadian Labour Code and would work in cooperation with an Operations Manual. This is the single important document that would provide your First Nation with a healthy workplace. The First Nation that regularly reviews and amends their Human Resource Manual seldom has recruitment or retention problems.
Points to Ponder #3
If Wile E. Coyote had enough money to buy all that ACME equipment, why didn’t he just buy dinner?
If corn oil is made from corn, and vegetable oil is made from vegetables, then what is baby oil made from?
Did you ever notice that when you blow in a dog’s face, he gets mad at you, but when you take him on a car ride, he sticks his head out of the window?
Chapter Four: Strategic Management & Planning
The focus is strategic planning for First Nations The information contained in this chapter was written by Jim Pealow, MBA, CMA, CAFM and being used by permission It is also course content reading for AFM4 – Strategy and Decision Making of the Certified Aboriginal Financial Manager program of the Aboriginal Financial Officers Association of Canada
Strategic Management & Planning
This publication will inform those in First Nations leadership positions about strategic management and accountability Highlight some practices that will assist in improving the quality of First Nations’ activities in planning and accountability.
Strategic Management & Planning
Information is presented in five sections First an introduction and addresses the current situation.
The second is information on strategic management.
The third looks at accountability and related issues.
Strategic Management & Planning
The fourth is a section of examples and best practices are presented to allow the reader to measure against and consider potential improvements. The last section includes sources of information to provide additional knowledge for those wishing to examine topics further.
Strategic Management & Planning
Learning Objectives
By using the information in this publication, you will be able to: Gain a better understanding of accountability and how it benefits an organization.
Develop an accountability program.
Strategic Management & Planning
Understand the relationship between accountability and strategic management.
Gain a better understanding of strategic management and how it benefits an organization.
Assess strategic management activities in an organization.
Strategic Management & Planning
What is Strategic Management?
Strategic management can be defined as the art and science of formulating, implementing, and evaluating cross-functional decisions that enable an organization to achieve its objectives.
Strategic Management & Planning
Other definitions bring in different elements integral to a strategic management process. This definition, however, clearly describes the heart of strategic management. Strategic management focuses on integrating all organizational activity for the purpose of achieving organizational success. Strategic management can be viewed as a formal planning process that allows a First Nation to pursue proactive rather than reactive strategies.
Strategic Management & Planning
Feedback Internal Audit Establish Vision, Mission, & Values Establish Goals & Critical Success Factors External Audit Strategy Formulation Generate & Select Strategies & Performance Measures Establish Policies, Action & Budgets Allocate Resources & Do It!
Measure and Evaluate Performance Strategy Implementation Strategy Evaluation
Strategic Management & Planning
How Do You Implement Strategic Management?
Strategy implementation requires: policy support for the selected strategies related tactics objectives the necessary resources.
Strategic Management & Planning
First Nations are able to formulate strategy but run into implementation problems because of financial capacity, lack of supportive policy or employee/volunteer motivation problems. Strategy implementation usually requires a supportive culture, appropriate organizational structure, and readjustment of current activities.
Strategic Management & Planning
Strategy implementation is the action stage and is sometimes referred to as “Where the rubber hits the road.” Everyone needs to be committed and understand the role they play in the success of the organization. Commitment will be achieved more easily if everyone participates in developing and understanding the strategy, what they must do to implement the strategy and get the job done.
Strategic Management & Planning
Key elements in strategy implementation are: flexibility training continuous improvement, policy decision making problem solving
Strategic Management & Planning
The best way to support implementation of strategy is to develop a business/work plan.
The business plan is: a consolidation of all programs and activities outline the strategies, related assumptions and activities to support the strategies performance indicators financial information such as budgets indicates who will do what and when.
Strategic Management & Planning
If your process is easy to follow, and not overly prescriptive, you can be
flexible
It takes more time and effort to amend a 200 page business plan than one with 24 pages. Keeping it brief can be helpful. Size can impact perception. Some people would rather hold off on new innovative tactics than go through the tedious process of submitting a revision to a long document.
Strategic Management & Planning
What is Strategy Evaluation?
Strategy evaluation is the stage of the strategic management process that is often neglected.
This stage provides the opportunity to assess how well strategies are doing. and is important in terms of supporting accountability.
Measuring performance to the goals that were set beforehand allows the assessment of progress.
Strategic Management & Planning
It also identifies areas where corrective action is necessary. Trends upon which the original strategies were developed change and, therefore, evaluations are required on a regular basis to assess impacts. There may be a need for abandonment, adjustment or new strategies.
Strategic Management & Planning
First Nations need to undertake a formal process to evaluate strategy. Since strategic direction is usually long term, a bad strategy can seriously influence a First Nation’s health and can be difficult to change.
Therefore, timely and effective evaluations to identify problems or potential problems are critical.
Strategic Management & Planning
What is Accountability?
Put simply, accountability is the same thing as responsibility – responsibility to a person or group of people. Accountability is used to make sure people do the things they should, and don’t do the things they shouldn’t.
Strategic Management & Planning
Types of Accountability: Political/Managerial Program or Administrative Fiscal Individual Stakeholder or Member
Strategic Management & Planning
Major Components of an Accountability Program: Planning and Performance Reporting Policies and Procedures Roles and Responsibilities
Strategic Management & Planning
Link Between Accountability and Strategic Management: To meet the accountability needs of an organization strong planning knowledge and skills are necessary The better conceived an organization’s strategy and the more competently executed with accountability and measurement, the more likelihood of success
Strategic Management & Planning
What Tools, Examples and Best Practices does the Toolbox Chapter contain?
Strategic Management Questionnaire Strategic Management Policy Example Strategic Plan Example – Ucluelet First Nation Accountability Best Practices Strategic Management Best Practices Problem Solving and Decision Making Tool Priority Setting Tool Activity Plans
Chapter Five: Capacity Building
Once the key elements of governance are in place and function efficiently, attention to maintaining high standards becomes important.
This chapter was designed specifically to assist financial managers become aware of the need for capacity building in their work with First Nations
Capacity Building
What is capacity building?
Simply put... it is building competencies, relationships and models.
Why do we need capacity building?
To improve job performance and efficiencies.
Capacity Building
The competencies capture the shift from the financial manager being primarily a scorekeeper to an expanded role of providing advice and leadership on all financial activities. This becomes important as financial management of First Nations becomes more complex due to self-government initiatives, economic development and new partnerships.
Capacity Building
Provincial Level
AFOABC exists to provide support to its membership in capacity building in a number of ways:
1.
Training and Development Conferences
AFOABC hosts 3-4 training conferences or events per year that serve to inform and train members in matters related to administrative and financial management. In conference planning, core competencies are used as guide to develop workshops and training sessions.
Capacity Building
2.
Aboriginal Financial Manager Certificate Program
The Aboriginal Financial Management Certificate Program is an innovative part-time 18-credit program offered by Capilano College on behalf of AFOABC. This program offers students working in the finances offices of First Nations an opportunity to improve their skills in financial management and administration.
Capacity Building
Students are trained in basic and intermediate accounting, computer applications, Aboriginal and business law, strategic management and leadership and communications. This program is offered when student demand and sufficient funds are available.
Capacity Building
National Level
At national level, AFO Canada is the professional organization in Canada responsible for certification of First Nations financial managers and setting high standards for Aboriginal financial management. Competency Standards for Aboriginal financial management have been established.
Capacity Building
These standards are the basis for development of curriculum used in granting credits towards the Aboriginal Financial Manager Program certificate, diploma, and the professional designation. They are also used in assessment of practical experience and the professional CAFM exam.
Capacity Building
What is Competency Modeling?
Competency modeling is the process of identifying the key responsibilities in a specific job function and the observable outcomes and behaviours that can be expected at the learning, full performance and superior performance levels. Competency modeling enables practitioners, peers, clients and supervisors to reach consensus on skills, motives, attitudes or other personal characteristic that differentiates superior from average performers.
Capacity Building
The Need for Modeling
The development of a validated model would add a much-needed visual dimension to the current listing of Financial Manager competencies. Most importantly, the process would enable Aboriginal Financial Officers Association members to reach consensus on the observable outcomes and behaviours associated with superior level performance by Financial Managers.
Capacity Building
Consensus on this subject will be vital in establishing a course of action to improve the financial management capacity in every First Nations community. The modeling process would also identify and document ‘best practices’ in the role of the Financial Manager that could then be shared with all First Nations communities.
Capacity Building
Applications and Benefits
A Financial Manager competency model would provide a visual reference of the specific attributes at three distinct levels of performance and would be used in a variety of applications including: Serving as a base for curriculum development.
Identifying and measuring work experience requirements.
Developing continuing professional development services.
Capacity Building
Conducting guided assessments to identify professional development needs Recruitment and selection.
Providing a source of best practices to support governance initiatives and sound financial management.
Conducting performance appraisals.
Compensation Analysis.
Capacity Building
The Core Competency Domains for a Certified Aboriginal Financial Manager are: Aboriginal History and Cultures Management Information Systems Communications & Personal Skills Economics Financial Accounting Management Accounting Computer Applications Law Quantitative Methods Strategy and Decision Making Financial Management Aboriginal Human and Fiscal Issues
Capacity Building
This toolbox chapter includes the Financial Officer Competency Model Workbook The model was developed by Aboriginal Financial Officers Association BC members The model illustrates the different outcomes and behaviours that can be observed at the learning stage, full performance and superior performance levels
Participant Feedback & Wrap-Up
Please take this time to ask questions and provide feedback to the facilitators regarding the Financial Code Toolbox
Participant Feedback & Wrap-Up
Please take a few moments to complete the training session’s evaluation form.
Your comments and suggestions assist AFOABC in planning future events
Participant Feedback & Wrap-Up
Thank-you for attending the Aboriginal Financial Officers Association of BC’s
Improving Financial Management and Accountability with the Financial
Management Toolbox Session and have a safe trip home!